"It may be too late to stop Ron Paul’s strategy"

If that quote including an endorsement of the constitution's prohibition of a state church is theocratic, then your communist kingdom was until recently a full-blown communist monarchic theocracy.
 
Last edited:
Like TubbaBlubba said, he endorsed the Constitution Party, a right wing, theocratic third party, in 2008. Instead of following the libertarian policy of personal freedoms on, say, abortion, he wants his religious beliefs to be the law of the land..

To be fair, it's a little more complex (and stranger) than how you describe. He initially endorsed all of the third party candidates equally, including Cynthia McKinney and Ralph Nader, but then he and Bob Barr (the LP candidate) got into a pissing contest because Barr refused to go to the press conference. After that, he supported the Constitution Party. He set out his reasons in this announcement, which actually explicitly criticizes the evangelicals. He also talks about how Baldwin has been a "good friend" and an "active supporter" of his campaign. It all sounds more like a decision based on personal vendettas and backdoor squabbling than it does any kind of endorsement of theocracy.
 
Last edited:
They don't sound like the actions of a person who's making the best decisions for the future of our nation.
 
They don't sound like the actions of a person who's making the best decisions for the future of our nation.

Fine, whatever. I just wanted to point out that he doesn't actually advocate for theocracy. His long record as a libertarian would testify to that.

That is, unless you consider an infallible belief in an unregulated free market a religion, which many have argued (including that paragon of progressive liberalism, Pat Buchanan). But I don't think that was what you meant.
 
Fine, whatever. I just wanted to point out that he doesn't actually advocate for theocracy. His long record as a libertarian would testify to that.

That is, unless you consider an infallible belief in an unregulated free market a religion, which many have argued (including that paragon of progressive liberalism, Pat Buchanan). But I don't think that was what you meant.

I don't believe he is nearly as libertarian as he makes himself out to be. Oh, yes, he's quite the free marketer, but there is more to libertarianism than market freedoms. His social freedoms are questionable and the more I've listened to him speak, the more I see that he really, really wants to control what other people do... just not in the most obvious of ways.
 
I don't believe he is nearly as libertarian as he makes himself out to be. Oh, yes, he's quite the free marketer, but there is more to libertarianism than market freedoms. His social freedoms are questionable and the more I've listened to him speak, the more I see that he really, really wants to control what other people do... just not in the most obvious of ways.

Could you explain?
 
Could you explain?

A defining characteristic of Ron Paul's speeches appears to be that if you don't agree with him than you hate freedom. That, coupled with the way this delegate fight is playing out, it presents a very patriarchal attitude that ignores the will and interests of people he doesn't agree with.

In general, on social freedoms he appears to be more of a states rightist than a libertarian. Should so-and-so be legal? To a lib, probably, but to Paul he'll just leave it up to the states to tramp out the rights of it's citizens - something states have been quite good at.

Of course you don't have to agree with my assessment, but again, my problem isn't with libertarianism, it's with Paul.
 
First of all, having theocratic tendencies does not necessarily mean advocating the establishment of a theocratic state. I'm not accusing Ron Paul of being a Dominionist. Second of all, the Republican Party is broader than you seem to think, CE. Seeing as it can contain both the Log Cabin Republicans and, oh, let's say George Bush. We're not all religious, or even social, conservatives.

Ron Paul, however, is. Or, if he isn't, he's more than willing to allow social conservatives to act without check of federal power. His We the People Act would allow states to ban miscegenation, homosexuality, contraception and from what I can tell sex before marriage, too. Hey, if you support that, go right ahead, support Ron Paul.

Even ignoring his grotesquely out of date stance on sexual rights (as hard as that may be, considering how STUPID that stance is, especially in someone who claims to be a 'Libertarian'), sound money is a terrible, terrible, terrible, terrible, terrible idea. I'm not sure this is the thread to go into why it's a terrible idea, but just as an example, inflation, even hyper-inflation, is almost always superior to deflation, and instituting sound money would, besides being (as said), a terrible, terrible (etc.) idea just on the face of it, would be equivalent to massive deflation , because there just isn't enough gold, and certainly isn't enough silver, to run anything like a modern economy on.
 
That's far from a position I would share, but hardly "theocratic".
He endorsed Pastor Chuck Baldwin for POTUS in 2008. Pastor Chuck is a Christian separatist who is attempting to carve out a (not so) little Christopia in the mountain states called The American Redoubt that intends to use "constitutionally and Biblically sound silver currency". And that's just the tip of the iceberg.

Ron Paul, Chuck Baldwin and Christopia

This isn't a vague association. Paul actually endorsed this frothing lunatic for POTUS, favoring him over the Libertarian and Republican nominees.

Is that theocratic enough for you?
 
=Second of all, the Republican Party is broader than you seem to think, CE. Seeing as it can contain both the Log Cabin Republicans and, oh, let's say George Bush. We're not all religious, or even social, conservatives.
That may be. But the current Republican Party has allowed the religious and social conservatives to take over the party platform. Do you think the Log Cabin R's have any influence whatsoever?
 
First of all, having theocratic tendencies does not necessarily mean advocating the establishment of a theocratic state. I'm not accusing Ron Paul of being a Dominionist. Second of all, the Republican Party is broader than you seem to think, CE. Seeing as it can contain both the Log Cabin Republicans and, oh, let's say George Bush. We're not all religious, or even social, conservatives.

Like Mortimer said - you let the religious social conservatives (and by that, I mean raging Jesus Freak nutcases) take over.

You people have no right whatsoever to disassociate yourselves from the freaks running the Republican Party now, until you put your money where your mouth is and leave the freak show altogether. You allowed this to happen, now live with it - or ACT on your claims that you´re not like that.
 
Hmm, i'd like to stick to his own views. Found this on wikipedia which links to this source.
Ron Paul said:
[...] The notion of a rigid separation between church and state has no basis in either the text of the Constitution or the writings of our Founding Fathers. On the contrary, our Founders’ political views were strongly informed by their religious beliefs. Certainly the drafters of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution, both replete with references to God, would be aghast at the federal government’s hostility to religion. The establishment clause of the First Amendment was simply intended to forbid the creation of an official state church like the Church of England, not to drive religion out of public life.

The Founding Fathers envisioned a robustly Christian yet religiously tolerant America, with churches serving as vital institutions that would eclipse the state in importance. Throughout our nation’s history, churches have done what no government can ever do, namely teach morality and civility. Moral and civil individuals are largely governed by their own sense of right and wrong, and hence have little need for external government. This is the real reason the collectivist Left hates religion: Churches as institutions compete with the state for the people’s allegiance, and many devout people put their faith in God before their faith in the state. Knowing this, the secularists wage an ongoing war against religion, chipping away bit by bit at our nation’s Christian heritage. Christmas itself may soon be a casualty of that war.

That's far from a position I would share, but hardly "theocratic".

1) The DoI and the Constitution "replete with references to God"? The DoI mentions a "Creator" once, in a deist sense, not in a Christian-God sense.

2) "government's hostility to religion", "drive religion out of public life": these are just lies, and exactly the same as employed by the Christian theocrats whenever someone complains they're trying to indoctrinate again. The interpretation of the First Amendment is very clear: government cannot endorse a religion. So a teacher at a public school may not call on their class to engage in prayer, or a public school may not hang a "school prayer" or some such on its walls. The students - who are not government aqents - may perfectly fine pray over their lunch in the cafetaria, or even as a valedictorian. And of course, staff and teachers at a religious school can very well do what pleases them - they're no government agents either. So, it's hardly driving religion out of public life, it's just that the government doesn't pay for religious expression and doesn't endorse one either.

To make a parallel with your own country: what do you think of the crucifixes that hang in every Bavarian classroom?

3) I'm not well-versed in the opinions of the Founding Fathers, but many were not Christians but deists and i very much doubt if what he says about them is true, especially the claim "with churches serving as vital institutions that would eclipse the state in importance". His apparent endorsement of that claim is ringing too.

4) He claims that only religion can bring morality.

All in all, while he doesn't outright say the state should be led by a priest, I think "theocratic" is an apt moniker: if it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck...
 
1) The DoI and the Constitution "replete with references to God"? The DoI mentions a "Creator" once, in a deist sense, not in a Christian-God sense.

Not to mention, the most important of those two, the constitution (i.e. The law of the land) has absolutely zero references to God and, in fact, specifically forbids state endorsement religion. When ever so called "constitutional conservatives" mention the 1st amendment's freedom of religion, they tend to forget, or ignore, that it in fact has two parts; the establishment clause and the free exercise clause.

3) I'm not well-versed in the opinions of the Founding Fathers, but many were not Christians but deists and i very much doubt if what he says about them is true, especially the claim "with churches serving as vital institutions that would eclipse the state in importance". His apparent endorsement of that claim is ringing too.

They also love to act as if the "Founding Fathers" are one person with one set of beliefs or one philosophy.
 
Last edited:
How can an advocate for minimal government have "theocratic positions"?
Easy. Just get the court system out of the business of overruling legislatures on social issues. That's less government, since you have removed an entire branch from policy-making.

Federal, state, and local lawmakers can proceed to enact the will of the majority on issues of other people's civil rights and personal conscience, without interference by pesky religious minorities (not to mention women or gays) using the Federal courts to interfere. Even court precedents would be revoked.

As NightStar76 already mentioned, you should read Paul's "We the People Act". Please note how it would reverse about a century of court decisions that have promoted human rights.

The Supreme Court of the United States and each Federal court--
(1) shall not adjudicate--
(A) any claim involving the laws, regulations, or policies of any State or unit of local government relating to the free exercise or establishment of religion;
(B) any claim based upon the right of privacy, including any such claim related to any issue of sexual practices, orientation, or reproduction; or
(C) any claim based upon equal protection of the laws to the extent such claim is based upon the right to marry without regard to sex or sexual orientation; and
(2) shall not rely on any judicial decision involving any issue referred to in paragraph (1).
http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c112:H.R.958.IH:
 
I thought Ron Paul was just stubborn to not officially resign from his candidacy, but it turns out he actually has a strategy:




Politico goes into more details: A Ron Paul Revolution is brewing




His supporters seem to be confident that if they continue with their grass-roots successes in the upcoming big states conventions, they have a realistic chance to "beat the system" through the back-door and nominate Paul.

According to their "real" delegate count, right now it stands 342 Romney : 109 Paul

Bizarre.

I'm quoting the OP since it seems that, as of last night, Romney clinched the nomination by winning the Texas primary, giving him a total of 1169 delegates, 25 more than the magic number of 1144. I don't doubt he will win California's 172 delegates on June 5, giving him 1341 delegates.

In light of this, what do you think of Ron Paul's strategy?
 
According to the "real count" linked in the OP, it now stands 591:186 for Romney, Texas not included yet.

And this is what the "strategists" say:


So, i'd say, nothing was changed by the media announcements according to the strategy. Do I believe the RNC will chose anyone but Romney? No, but I didn't do so when I started this thread either.

As to Paul being "theocratic" - i'll take a look at that "We the people act" on occasion, but from his quote that I posted I am still of the opinion that while it is absurd to claim there's a war on Christmas in the US, referring to him as having "theocratic" positions based on that quote is a mischaracterisation and dodge of his central positions.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom