"It may be too late to stop Ron Paul’s strategy"

So do you think there is something to Ron Paul's strategy? Is there any reasonable chance that Ron Paul will get the GOP nomination?

Don't tell me--it's "interesting" but you cannot or will not say why, right?


If you're looking for someone to jump through your hoops, better look somewhere else, pal. And learn to read. The answer to your second question is right on this page.
 
If you're looking for someone to jump through your hoops, better look somewhere else, pal. And learn to read.

I read just fine. You've said that you're worried about Ron Paul supporters attempting a "coup d'etat". (I assumed you meant a figurative "coup" and a figurative "etat"--since his supporters are not contemplating or threatening violence and the Republican Party is not a state. So that makes that observation pretty meaningless.)

And instead you continue to repeat unfounded CT claims made by Ron Paul supporters.
 
Yeah, but surely the primaries are merely a political party's way of choosing a candidate to fight a general election? And, if so, why does any outside party such as a state government ( and apart from a legal framework to prevent corruption) have a say in how the party elects it's candidate?

I suspect that the main justification is that the state is often paying much of the cost for those primary elections. If a party wanted to handle the nomination process completely on its own, with no funding from the state, I bet it could get away with an arbitrary nomination process without state regulation.
 

Not really. Since Iowa is one of the few states that have a non-binding caucus system, it really isn't surprising that the hypocrites that follow Ron Paul would work to get themselves elected as delegates.


I predict that the district court will dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction or tell these morons that they don't know WTF they are talking about. The whole definition of the word, "delegate" is a person selected to represent another. If a state or the republican party of a state wants to bind delegates to the results of the primary that is entirely within their purview and it does NOT violate federal election law as it is written in 42 USC 1971.
 
These delegates were first elected on the local level and represent the people who voted for them, that's why they appear on the state level.

That maybe true in non-binding caucus states like Iowa where a primary election is not held. In Iowa, the caucus is where residents are supposed to meet in precinct caucuses and elect delegates to county conventions. Then at the county conventions, delegates are elected to the state convention which then choose national convention delegates that are not bound by the results of the Iowa caucus and the popular vote.

However, in primary states like New Hampshire and most others, the delegates represent the people who voted in the primary and not the people that elected the delegates. In fact, several states require potential delegates to complete an affidavit or statement as to who they support so that delegates can be elected that support the candidates selected by the people. As further proof of Ron Paul supporter hypocrisy, in Arizona, Ron Paul supporters purposely signed an affidavit stating they support Romney in order to get themselves elected as delegates.
 
However, in primary states like New Hampshire and most others, the delegates represent the people who voted in the primary and not the people that elected the delegates. In fact, several states require potential delegates to complete an affidavit or statement as to who they support so that delegates can be elected that support the candidates selected by the people.


Yes, and that's what they are sueing against now. In this case the whole delegate process is moot theatre and you can as well just count the public vote for the state at the national convention. In the other case the public vote is moot. There are definitely contradictions in the system which should be resolved, independent of what one thinks is the better method.
 
Yes, and that's what they are sueing against now. In this case the whole delegate process is moot theatre and you can as well just count the public vote for the state at the national convention. In the other case the public vote is moot. There are definitely contradictions in the system which should be resolved, independent of what one thinks is the better method.

If the popular vote for each state is simply counted at the convention, then you take away the ability of the state to determine HOW their choices for candidates are represented at the national convention. If a state wants to bind their delegates to represent the popular vote either through winner-take-all or proportional allocation, that is the state's decision. If a state wants to leave their delegates unbound, that is also the state's decision. Federal election law has nothing to do with it. The purpose of the federal election law is to ensure that voters IN A PRIMARY, GENERAL, or SPECIAL election are not disenfranchised due to discrimination or intimidation. In fact, the sections concerning federal election law refer to state law several times.

The funny thing is that there is absolutely nothing wrong with the system as it is as long as the rules are followed. However, in their quest for their version of "liberty", the Ron Paul supporters don't want to follow the rules. Ron Paul supporters claim that they are supposed disenfranchised, yet by wanting to unbind delegates, those same Ron Paul supporters want to disenfranchise the other 90% of the Republican voting population. Again, the absolute height of hypocrisy.
 
As I said, you can't have it both ways. The decision about which way to go can be on state level, nothing wrong with that, but then get rid of either the "beauty contest" of a public vote or the "thread mill" of a bottom-up delegate election process inside the state party.
 
Last edited:
As I said, you can't have it both ways. The decision about which way to go can be on state level, nothing wrong with that, but then get rid of either the "beauty contest" of a public vote or the "thread mill" of a bottom-up delegate election process inside the state party.

If conventions were only to select the party's nominee for President or other office, then I might agree with you. However, conventions are often more than that. There are somethings that are decided at party conventions with delegates as representatives of the people that are not presented in primary elections as up for popular vote. It is in those instances that a delegate can "vote his conscience" since the feelings of the majority of the voting populace as a whole is not determined.

There is nothing wrong with the current system as long as elected delegates follow the rules. I have nothing against Ron Paul supporters working to get themselves elected as delegates in order to highlight issues that are important to them at the party conventions. However, I do have a problem with Ron Paul supporters attempting to change the rules, accuse others of not following the rules while they ignore them, or ignoring the will of the people when the laws and rules bind the delegates and say the elected delegates MUST represent the will of the people.
 
There is nothing wrong with the current system as long as elected delegates follow the rules.


Oh, there definitely is, otherwise we wouldn't witness the kind of "hacking" attempt which occures here in a vulnerable, not logically designed system. Who is not following the rules is not clear, and while I appreciate your posts in this thread, I don't think you can determine this with any more certainty than I can (and I know that I can't). These are serious allegations which seem to be backed up by what we saw from how the conventions went:

Courthouse News said:
[...] The Party's Rule 11 prevents changing rules within 30 days of a convention, but Gilbert said that chairmen and organizers often change rules the day before a convention - and sometimes in the middle of one - to deny a quorum or rig an outcome. [...]
 
Oh, there definitely is, otherwise we wouldn't witness the kind of "hacking" attempt which occures here in a vulnerable, not logically designed system. Who is not following the rules is not clear, and while I appreciate your posts in this thread, I don't think you can determine this with any more certainty than I can (and I know that I can't). These are serious allegations which seem to be backed up by what we saw from how the conventions went:

As I stated before, whether what the party considers the actual convention was held in accordance with the rules or not does not legitimize anything that the Ron Paul supporters have done. Regardless of what happened in the convention hall in Oklahoma, what the Ron Paul supporters did in the parking lot was DEFINITELY NOT in accordance with the rules.

In Arizona, potential delegates and their alternates must complete notarized affidavits stating that they belong to the Republican party and what candidate they support. This is in accordance with Arizona State Republican party rules. Ron Paul supporters purposely completed affidavits claiming they support Romney so they would get elected as delegates allegedly for Romney. Tell me, does completing an affidavit with something that is not true seem right to you?

In Louisiana, it is difficult to believe Ron Paul supporters claims that rules were not followed since they don't seem to know what the rules are. Here is an earlier post I made about Louisiana.

ETA: I didn't post this earlier concerning the convention in Louisiana but, since the Chairman of Republican party cannot be ousted at the convention, the Paul "chairman" was chairman of nothing. His attempt to take over the floor and hold a "convention" with just the Paul supporters was met the appropriate response. He was asked to leave because he was disrupting the actual convention and he did not have the floor. When he refused, security was asked to escort him out. When he further refused, they attempted to remove him and he fell. Sorry for his hip, but it is his own fault for being an idiot and not knowing the rules.

As for the "Chairman of the Rules Committee", since he wasn't appointed by the Chairman of the Republican Party of Louisiana, he was officially chairman of nothing. Therefore, it was entirely proper for the actual Chairman to ask him to leave since he was also disrupting the convention since he did not properly have the floor. When he refused, it was again proper for security to be asked to escort him out. Any injuries he sustained are also because he was an idiot.
 
Last edited:
Well the legions of Ron Paul sleeper delegates are no doubt heading to Tampa even as I write this, the Ron Paul Revolution is nigh!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom