Ed Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu will be indicted on charges of bribery, fraud...

Given that Netanyahu has twice been unable to form a majority government in the recent elections, I think some kind of citation is needed for this claim.

Winning a plurality of the vote of course. Claiming he does not represent the country and its values is like americans trying to claim Trump doesn't represent and show what americans want.

Or I guess we could claim that there is no real democracy in Israel that would remove the populace from endorsing the actions of the dictator in charge.
 
Last edited:

Yes they fail as a democracy, the government in no way represents the will of the people. The claim you make is that the government does not do that so it is not a democracy.

Seems like they could have gotten some benefit from protesting the antidemocratic government in the arab spring and maybe got a government that does represent the people.
 
Winning a plurality of the vote of course. Claiming he does not represent the country and its values is like americans trying to claim Trump doesn't represent and show what americans want.

Or I guess we could claim that there is no real democracy in Israel that would remove the populace from endorsing the actions of the dictator in charge.

I guess it really shouldn't be considered a democracy then as the government in no way answers to the will and votes of the people.

Guess we should be encouraging regime change to finally bring real democracy there.

As with so many of your posts on this thread, it is hard to tell if you are joking or not.
On the assumption that you are being serious here, let me point out that, although I am not an American, I am aware that Trump does not represent the views of all Americans.
In fact, his approval ratings are consistently below 50%.
By your own logic, therefore, the US is not a democracy, and the government should be overthrown by force.
Alternatively, you could try to come to grips with the complexity of the real world. Not everything is as black-and-white as you want it to be. If you can develop an understanding of this, it would make your comments here less ridiculous.
 
I'm guessing that ponderingturtle is American, and that the concept of coalition governments is confusing to them.

The answer is clear government and its leadership bear no resemblance to the will of the people that seems to be the main argument here.
 
As with so many of your posts on this thread, it is hard to tell if you are joking or not.
On the assumption that you are being serious here, let me point out that, although I am not an American, I am aware that Trump does not represent the views of all Americans.
In fact, his approval ratings are consistently below 50%.
By your own logic, therefore, the US is not a democracy, and the government should be overthrown by force.
Alternatively, you could try to come to grips with the complexity of the real world. Not everything is as black-and-white as you want it to be. If you can develop an understanding of this, it would make your comments here less ridiculous.


Got it everyone hates these policies but refuse to stop them, as such they are totally not accountable for them.

The only people who can ever be held accountable for the the actions of their government are the Palestinians that is clear.
 
The answer is clear government and its leadership bear no resemblance to the will of the people that seems to be the main argument here.

What does that even mean -- "The Will of The People" ??? Elections in Israel do not reflect ONE SINGLE will of the people, they reflect a desire to have a Government with MANY representatives from all across the spectrum of political stripes. Israel does not elect a Prime Minister directly (it was tried for a while, and then dropped).

So, the results we've seen over the past year indicate that the plurality of voters are trying to elect Gantz, but Gantz doesn't have enough outside support to reach the 61 seats of a Knesset majority (and that would include Joint List -- i.e.: Arab -- agreeing).

Bibi is unable to form a Government, too. He needed Avigdor ('Yvette') Liberman to come along with his 8 seats, and Liberman said "Nyet" because his demands for Haredi draft legislation were rejected by Bibi, since that would alienate the Haredi (Orthodox religious component of the Jewish population).

So, Liberman was catering to the Will of the People who voted for him (many secular Russians are against religious coercions).
The Haredi (including SHAS) are choosing their guys who represent the Will of the People for them.
The leftists (i.e. - Labor, et al) want to get out of the occupied territories and turn the whole kit and kaboodle over to FATAH/PLO and/or HAMAS.
The rightists want their "Will of the People" to include a greater presence of Jews in the occupied territories, and for the P-A to disappear and Jewish soverignty to replace it.

And you think that there is a "Will of the People" in Israel? Uh, no.

So, another round of elections is scheduled for March 2nd.
Maybe a new thread for that? We'll see.
Gideon Sa'ar might just be able to put forward a campaign within the Likud to change leaders, but that's a long-shot, given Bibi's huge popularity (since Netanyahu does represent the "Will of the People" in his camp).

In the meantime, this topic is about the indictments of Benjamin Netanyahu for accepting bribes and abuse of office. He is presumed innocent until convicted. That is the default position of the law. Yeah, the law, which mirrors the "Will of the People" -- right?
 
"The only people who can ever be held accountable for the the actions of their government are the Palestinians that is clear.

Palestinians have a government which is dysfunctional, at best.
https://mondoweiss.net/2019/10/the-last-lifeline-the-real-reason-behind-abbas-call-for-elections
In Gaza, a mixed group of jihadist thugs run the place. With force of arms. Either you go along with their program, or bad stuff happens (like being dragged through the streets by motorcycles, for example)
In Ramallah, AbuMazen holds sway despite his term of office expiring long ago.
http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/2019-11/10/c_138542863.htm

So, yeah, the average Palestinians are obligated to be held accountable, both in Gaza and Judea&Samaria. Why wouldn't they?
 
Last edited:

I have said before that there seems to be an inviolable Law of the Ponderingturtle, which states that every time you say 'got it', you then proceed to demonstrate that you haven't got it at all.


everyone hates these policies but refuse to stop them, as such they are totally not accountable for them.

The only people who can ever be held accountable for the the actions of their government are the Palestinians that is clear.

Yup. You just did it again. :rolleyes:
 
What does that even mean -- "The Will of The People" ??? Elections in Israel do not reflect ONE SINGLE will of the people, they reflect a desire to have a Government with MANY representatives from all across the spectrum of political stripes.
True and this time around it's even worse and these elections.
The new trend this year was "technical blocks". Most parties running for parliament were groups of several smaller parties that have joined forces solely to reach the bare minimum they need to enter and pretty much declared in advance they'll go their separate ways after the election.


So when you have a single list hosting X and Y, how the heck can you tell if people voted for it because of X or Y?

And yes, X and Y are very different in this case.

This is one election that teaches you absolutely nothing about "the will of the people".


So, another round of elections is scheduled for March 2nd.
Maybe a new thread for that? We'll see.
Gideon Sa'ar might just be able to put forward a campaign within the Likud to change leaders, but that's a long-shot, given Bibi's huge popularity (since Netanyahu does represent the "Will of the People" in his camp).
Bitan claimed that he managed to get the 800 signatures he needed to have the center of the party vote on whether or not there will be a primaries in the first place.

So Saar might lose his chance, though I don't think it will pass and they'll do the internal elections - with Netanyahu still being the favorite to win.
 

Ridiculous is what happens when you adapt a position based on nothing but blind ideology with a "My Mind Is Made Up, Don't Confuse Me With Facts" attitude.
If there is one kind of person I intellcutally despise, it's the blind partisan who automatically adapts a "Party line" and never thinks of wavering from it. I don't trust people who never think for themselves but just parrot whatever the party line is on an issue.
This applies to both Left and Right.
 
Last edited:
It's official, he is requesting immunity.

Though he doesn't have a majority to actually get it.

He'll most likely stall the process until after the election hoping he'll get the votes then.
 
It's official, he is requesting immunity.

Though he doesn't have a majority to actually get it.

He'll most likely stall the process until after the election hoping he'll get the votes then.

Apparently the Israeli police, public prosecutors and judiciary are all taking orders from the left to sabotage his political career.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom