Ed Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu will be indicted on charges of bribery, fraud...

...What do you think of Netanyahu’s recent problems?

Tempest in a teacup.
Many Israelis are simply scratching their heads and wondering "Huh?!"

And the 'problems' he faces are not recent --- The Israel Police began investigating Netanyahu starting in December 2016.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigations_involving_Benjamin_Netanyahu

Being charged by the attorney general is certainly recent.......I’m sure his corrupt behaviour may be longer term. Possibly going back to childhood?
 
His prior legal troubles are certainly a matter of record (you could have easily searched this information) --- Mr. Netanyahu came under scrutiny during his first term as Prime Minister in the 1990s.

https://www.law.columbia.edu/sites/default/files/microsites/public-integrity/netanyahu_finalpdf.pdf

and https://apnews.com/42d795e65dc14376ad6301aa99275987

At that time, although investigations resulted in the Israeli Police recommending two charges, neither case was pursued by the Attorney General.

Bibi has also appeared on television, admitting to adultery.
 
Last edited:
Well, I started looking at this forum a few years before I joined. Didn't spot any 'Likud apologists' accusing anyone of anti-semitism when they were merely giving valid criticism that could apply to anyone- but memory can be fallible.
If you have any examples of this, it would be interesting.
Either way, that's obviously not the case now, so you can put your mind at rest.

LOL....let me guess. It would be you that judges what is “valid criticism”?

I wont be spending any time providing examples for you to apply your pre prepared excuse to.
I would encourage you to take advantage of the forums excellent search system if you are interested in reviewing any of the posts you previously didn’t spot.....

What a peculiar thing to say.
No, of course not. That's why I posted a commonly-accepted definition of anti-semitism, so it could be used as a framework to decide if the criticism was valid, or actually anti-semitic.
Then we could discuss it. I know I joined this forum after you, so maybe I'm wrong, but I was under the impression that that was the point of this forum: to discuss things.
How you got from what I said to the idea that I'm somehow appointing myself as sole arbiter, or that I would automatically come down against you, is a mystery to me.


In other words, you can't actually cite any examples, and instead are resorting to accusing me of doing something I have not actually done, nor would I actually do.
Very poor.



Again, I newer here than you, but I'm fairly sure that the burden of proof lies with the one making the claim, which in this case would be you.
That, and Hitchens' Razor: "That which is asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence". Pretty sure that's been mentioned here before too.

Sorry but you seem to not be paying attention one is asking for examples of fact....have people claimed two specific claims........the other is asking for examples that Require a judgement call if something is “valid criticism”

Your are not very good at this are you.....maybe Mycroft can coach you?

I've quoted most of the conversation here for the context.
You said people on this forum were accusing you of anti-semitism, when all you were doing was voicing what you thought was valid criticism.
I asked you for examples. You refused to provide them.
The only judgement call needed is your own. All you had to do was post something you thought was an attempt to use the accusation of anti-semitism to try to silence you. If you haven't already made that judgement, then I am left wondering why you would claim this has been happening, and apparently happening for years?
As for 'specific claims', perhaps you could suggest a search term I could use? I doubt that anything like 'Comments The Fool thinks are unfair' will give me any useful results.
 
Speaking as someone who is strongly pro Israel, I say GOOD. About bloody time.
 
Speaking as someone who is strongly pro Israel, I say GOOD. About bloody time.

Agreed.
Netanyahu has been an obstacle to peace for years. Expanding settlements, assuming sovereignty over the Golan Heights, the laws about the Jewish nature of Israel etc., have all served to widen the divide between the two sides.
I can only hope that he is removed from office, so a more moderate and less obstructionist government can take power.
 
Agreed.
Netanyahu has been an obstacle to peace for years. Expanding settlements, assuming sovereignty over the Golan Heights, the laws about the Jewish nature of Israel etc., have all served to widen the divide between the two sides.
I can only hope that he is removed from office, so a more moderate and less obstructionist government can take power.

Absolutely correct....well said.


And also...my apologies for ragging on you in this thread. I got out of Israel threads some time ago because I gat sick of the bickering so I don’t know why the hell I started doing it again.

Anyway.....my apologies.
 
Last edited:
...I got out of Israel threads some time ago because I got sick of the bickering so I don’t know why the hell I started doing it again.

I kinda like to think that I've had something to do with your return!

As for 'bickering' --- In the MidEast, bickering is a 'hobby' of sorts, and sometimes it becomes fairly intense.
 
I kinda like to think that I've had something to do with your return!

As for 'bickering' --- In the MidEast, bickering is a 'hobby' of sorts, and sometimes it becomes fairly intense.

Normally if you sacrifice a chicken I will appear.....at least that’s what my voodoo witch told me.
 
Absolutely correct....well said.


And also...my apologies for ragging on you in this thread. I got out of Israel threads some time ago because I gat sick of the bickering so I don’t know why the hell I started doing it again.

Anyway.....my apologies.

Claiming people are being called anti-Semites "just because" they criticized Netenyahu or Likud, then refusing to show any examples for rather paranoid reasons.

Dismissing examples of people who went deep into conspiritard territory for...reasons?

Taunting/trolling behavior, Your are not very good at this are you.....maybe Mycroft can coach you?

You were a pretty major contributor to the bickering behavior, not just in doing it yourself but actively working to draw it out in others. If you want bickering free discussions, I suggest you concentrate on reviewing evidence other present to you in support of their opinions and presenting evidence of your own to support your opinions, and learn to refrain from making it personal.
 
Claiming people are being called anti-Semites "just because" they criticized Netenyahu or Likud, then refusing to show any examples for rather paranoid reasons.

Dismissing examples of people who went deep into conspiritard territory for...reasons?

Taunting/trolling behavior, Your are not very good at this are you.....maybe Mycroft can coach you?

You were a pretty major contributor to the bickering behavior, not just in doing it yourself but actively working to draw it out in others. If you want bickering free discussions, I suggest you concentrate on reviewing evidence other present to you in support of their opinions and presenting evidence of your own to support your opinions, and learn to refrain from making it personal.
Sorry Mycroft you must have me confused with someone who is interested in Your opinions.....unless, of course, if you have any opinions on the topic of the thread....Netanyahu??
 
Israel's SUPREME COURT is being petitioned to 'fire' Bibi.

https://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/D...cials-ask-High-Court-to-fire-Netanyahu-610286

What is unique about the latest petition, besides that it involves a group of generally apolitical hi-tech officials, is that they specifically have attacked the "theoretical argument" of the Attorney General.
They say that the issue is concrete today, and not theoretical, because voters (in March, when the third elections will be held) should know whether Netanyahu has the legal capacity to form a new government before they decide how to vote.
 
Israel's SUPREME COURT is being petitioned to 'fire' Bibi.

https://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/D...cials-ask-High-Court-to-fire-Netanyahu-610286

What is unique about the latest petition, besides that it involves a group of generally apolitical hi-tech officials, is that they specifically have attacked the "theoretical argument" of the Attorney General.
They say that the issue is concrete today, and not theoretical, because voters (in March, when the third elections will be held) should know whether Netanyahu has the legal capacity to form a new government before they decide how to vote.

There must be a real shortage of choice if someone in Netanyahu’s position is still a viable alternative. The main reason people like him can still be in the frame is Israel’s bizzare electoral system where people can only vote for parties and the parties provide a list of who becomes elected......any old hack can be put on the list you then get a government full of influence paddlers and unrepresentative political hacks.

Australia has this system in its upper house (senate) and you would be amazed at the band of clowns it produces.
 
There must be a real shortage of choice if someone in Netanyahu’s position is still a viable alternative. The main reason people like him can still be in the frame is Israel’s bizzare electoral system where people can only vote for parties and the parties provide a list of who becomes elected......any old hack can be put on the list you then get a government full of influence paddlers and unrepresentative political hacks.

Australia has this system in its upper house (senate) and you would be amazed at the band of clowns it produces.

At least they have that choice: it's more than the Palestinian Arabs have.
It doesn't look like Hamas is going to the polls any time soon.

Anyway, I'm British. Don't talk to me about poor electoral choices. Johnson or Corbyn. Sheesh. :mad:
 
At least they have that choice: it's more than the Palestinian Arabs have.
It doesn't look like Hamas is going to the polls any time soon.

Anyway, I'm British. Don't talk to me about poor electoral choices. Johnson or Corbyn. Sheesh. :mad:
They have elections in the West Bank but I think it would be easier to pull teeth out than get Hamas to have elections in gaza. I despair about Gaza. Which is why I find it strange that the plan Webfusion refers to would shunt the election running West Bank Palestinians into the Hamas sphere....
 
Agreed.
Netanyahu has been an obstacle to peace for years. Expanding settlements, assuming sovereignty over the Golan Heights, the laws about the Jewish nature of Israel etc., have all served to widen the divide between the two sides.

He enacts popular policies why is that a bad thing? He is giving the voters what they want.
 
There must be a real shortage of choice if someone in Netanyahu’s position is still a viable alternative.<snip>

It's a little bit more than that.
A big part of the issue here is that in Israel, the right has 100% loyalty to the leader while the left has 100% loyalty to the party but 0% loyalty to the leader.

Now that Netanyahu has a challenger from within - Saar has officially decalred he wants to challenge Netanyahu for leadership of the party - he is instantly classified as a "traitor" against the party.

So the right won't kick him out so easily. He's even expected to win against his challenger.


For the left, as I said, it's the opposite problem. Their loyalty is to the party only. Not the leader. So the backstabs are deadly with high frequency. Last year, they didn't even wait until the end of the election, they started during the election.

This is part of the problem of why BB wins the election almost blindly every single time. The opposition throws constant mud at themselves, it eventually backfires.

Even now, the current pointless name that's running against BB is a guy who nobody knew anything about him other than he was the head of the army (sorry, don't know the English term).

Literally, they showed a survey asking people who they would vote for if he was in the race. People didn't know anything about the guy. Not his stance on national issues, church and state, economy etc.

The guy didn't even said he was running, and the polls showed him as getting 16 sits (out of 120) which was bigger than any other source of opposition.

They seriously just ranodmly picked a guy out of a hat.


Add on top of that that the left doesn't offer any platform whatsoever and it becomes even more absurd.

The left claims to be against religious opression, but they run begging for the extreme religious for a coalition that it's known they have 0 credibility in that department.

The left claims that they are anti corruption, but again, they offer deals to both religious extreme parties - one is run by a convicted fellon who has a new indictment regarding tax fraud. The other one is run by a guy who has an indictment about (surprise surprise) faking a medical report in order to prevent a pedophile from serving her sentence.


So while Netanyahu is hardly a saint to say it mildly, yes, in many cases the opposition is pretty much the same if not worse.


Heck, all 3 former heads of opposition to Netanyahu (Gabai, Hertzog and Peretz) had an election campaign that was nothing but "Bibi is bad, so vote for us so we can kick him out and don't believe all the others that will tell you that cause they'll join his coalition"

All 3 of them crawled on their hands and knees into his coalition...

So even in that regard their word is pretty worthless.
 
They have elections in the West Bank but I think it would be easier to pull teeth out than get Hamas to have elections in gaza. I despair about Gaza. Which is why I find it strange that the plan Webfusion refers to would shunt the election running West Bank Palestinians into the Hamas sphere....

https://www.ynetnews.com/article/HkXplr3TH -- BREAKING NEWS, Elections to go forward, although no date was set and there's one vital caveat: Jerusalem residents must also vote.
(That is unlikely to be approved by Israel --- http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/272933)

The NewState proposal does depend on shunting Hamas aside (by force, including decimating the leadership) and also to eviscerate the Jihadists & ISIL in North Sinai.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom