Split Thread Is there an underground oligarchy ruling the world?

What kind of hard, linking evidence do you think would exist between the oligarchs and their agents in government? Telephone records? Wire transfers? A few photographs showing them shaking hands at a special event? What? Who has the power to investigate such relationships and on what basis would they bother? Do you really expect a bunch of corrupt politicians - many of which are indebted to these oligarchs for their rise to prominence - to police themselves and those who share their ideology?

Forget it. The machinery of the government has been almost completely hijacked. This is how Washington runs, and it's been running this way for well over a hundred years.

Of course! How blind am I? Why on earth would any reporter, politician, foreign power, wiki-leaker or whistleblower ever reveal corruption! Why would anybody ever feel the need to investigate and gather evidence for any personal, social, ethical or professional reasons!

Lets see how this corruption of yours works, is it like this:

Reporter: My my. This epic phone hacking scandal has revealed a politician was pushing legislation on behalf of a mysterious agent.
Agent: DONT PUBLISH THAT!
Reporter: why?
Agent: I am an agent of the secret rulers.
Reporter: no you are not.
Agent: yes I am.
Reporter: prove it.
Agent; er...
Reporter: so are you going to kill me? Pay me off? Blackmail me?
Agent: no. You just do what I tell you. I don't leave evidence. ANY evidence.
Reporter: And if I don't do as you ask?
Agent: Look, this is really awkward, but would you mind deleting my name from the visitors book in the lobby? Nobody is allowed to know I exist...

So you are really advocating that every arm of the US government at every level is totally in the grip of the conspiracy, from postmen to presidents, and all press bodies, journalists and, well, the rest of the world all keep very quiet about the mechanics of manipulation required on that scale?

When an entire nation needs to be complicate, that is no longer a secret agenda, it is the nation.
 
Openly repressive regimes are not nearly as productive as those who disguise/hide their repression. The Soviet Union was an economic basket case. Cuba was and still is an economic basket case. North Korea is an economic basket case. China was an economic basket case until Beijing loosened its grip on the Chinese people.

The ruling oligarchy in the West understands that it derives its superior power and wealth from the value it can harvest from its citizens.



People rebel against naked force or simply don't produce. The ruling class doesn't want to risk revolt. At least not yet.



Who's going to be manning all those tanks, artillery pieces, and aircraft? Yep, the brothers, sons, and fathers of the people they are going to be told to disarm, round up, and kill. Not enough of the military has been radicalized enough to fire on their own countrymen yet.

But you said the machinery of government was completely hijacked? How can that be so if the machinery of government, the employees are not under their influence?


Is there any risk of your providing evidence or will it be more excuses and wishful thinking? At what point do you expect anybody to believe your speculation? Are you practicing the same jedi mind tricks the overlords use to brainwash the departments of army and navy?
 
I know some people talk of taxes as a form of slavery, but this is laying it on a bit thick, don't you think?

No, not really. A tax on the exchange of one's labor is a form of slavery. If I claim a portion of your labor by placing a tax on the exchange of it, and if you don't pay the tax I can legally detain and imprison you, you are effectively my slave.

That's how the income tax works. The government claims the labor of the American people and taxes the exchange of it. Failure to pay the tax can result in the government putting you in a cage. The U.S. government effectively exercises control over the exchange of the American people's labor the same way a slave owner exercise control over the exchange of his slaves' labor.

In all honesty, though -- yes, there are very real inequities, especially self-perpetuating imbalances of economic power (those who have the money, can adjust the rules to ensure they keep it). And I find this plenty enough concern without having to invent secret cabals.

They don't have to be invented, because they already exist. What do you think became of the 19th Century robber barons of Europe and America and the great fortunes they left to their progeny? I'll tell you. They spent the 20th Century consolidating their wealth and power by buying off control of the government and putting all kinds of regulatory controls in place to prevent anyone from ever amassing enough wealth to compete with them.

What you are doing, really, is replacing the banality of real evil with the most banal of imaginary evils; replacing the very real ability to manipulate politics and to cheat millions of people and only rarely getting punished for it, with some sort of mustache-twirling "We do it because it is EVIL!" from some bad movie.

You're just deluding yourself. You yourself even acknowledge that those with money can adjust the rules (laws) to benefit themselves. Well, how do you think they do that? By buying off politicians and taking control over the machinery of government, that's how.

You must recognize that there are people out there with billions and billions of dollars to play with. They use that money to make even more money, and they do it in all sorts of ways. They buy up control of the media. They buy up influence over the education system through the large tax-exempt foundations. They buy up industries and corporations. They get their friends elected to Congress, who then pay them back with lucrative legislation. They get their friends jobs in regulatory agencies, who then go after their competitors. Etc...
 
Of course! How blind am I? Why on earth would any reporter, politician, foreign power, wiki-leaker or whistleblower ever reveal corruption!

What specific evidence would they have of this corruption?

Why would anybody ever feel the need to investigate and gather evidence for any personal, social, ethical or professional reasons!

Assuming they had full access to anything worth investigating.

Again, what evidence are they going to find?

Lets see how this corruption of yours works, is it like this:

Reporter: My my. This epic phone hacking scandal has revealed a politician was pushing legislation on behalf of a mysterious agent.
Agent: DONT PUBLISH THAT!
Reporter: why?
Agent: I am an agent of the secret rulers.
Reporter: no you are not.
Agent: yes I am.
Reporter: prove it.
Agent; er...
Reporter: so are you going to kill me? Pay me off? Blackmail me?
Agent: no. You just do what I tell you. I don't leave evidence. ANY evidence.
Reporter: And if I don't do as you ask?
Agent: Look, this is really awkward, but would you mind deleting my name from the visitors book in the lobby? Nobody is allowed to know I exist...

Reporters can be silenced, taken off of stories, not have their stories published, threatened, intimidated, and bought off. Most reporters won't trade their life to break a big story that might not even gain any traction in the rest of the controlled media.

So you are really advocating that every arm of the US government at every level is totally in the grip of the conspiracy, from postmen to presidents, and all press bodies, journalists and, well, the rest of the world all keep very quiet about the mechanics of manipulation required on that scale?

The ruling class has the upper hand over government, but the control is loose. Not everyone in government is aware. There are honest and well-intended politicians. Most government workers have no idea of the corruption above them at the higher levels.

When an entire nation needs to be complicate, that is no longer a secret agenda, it is the nation.

To be complicit in something (this conspiracy to subvert the United States) is one thing. To be an innocent bystander without insider knowledge of what's going on is another. Maybe you don't understand the difference.
 
The question is not what evidence would there be. It is what evidence do you have to convince me of your assertion. If the answer is "none", I have no reason to accept your assertion.

If your answer to make excuses, as it has been, then I have good reason to dismiss them.

Threatening journalists? Leaves evidence I'm afraid. We know newspapers and the media have overlooked or dropped stories in the past because there is evidence. There has to be something to threaten journalists with for a start.

And bare in mind you are not claiming individuals are doing this for their own means, you are suggesting a group, a collective, a motivated unified action.


Lets assume you are correct to say there is no evidence. Then what do you base your conclusion upon? Instinct? Assumption? Imagination?
 
"All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident."

Low level humour is common when people point out uncomfortable truths.

Ah, Schopenhauer. I've always liked that quote. It's especially fitting in this thread. Thanks for reminding me of it, as I hadn't seen it referenced in a while.

Here's another quote in keeping with the spirit of the thread, this time from Woodrow Wilson in The New Freedom from 1913:

Since I entered politics, I have chiefly had men's views confided to me privately. Some of the biggest men in the United States, in the field of commerce and manufacture, are afraid of somebody, are afraid of something. They know that there is a power somewhere so organized, so subtle, so watchful, so interlocked, so complete, so pervasive, that they had better not speak above their breath when they speak in condemnation of it.

Imagine that. All the way back then, a hundred years ago, there were powerful men of means in America who were frightened by a mysterious, organized power operating in and around the United States. This power was so watchful, so pervasive, and so great, that it made even powerful men hold their tongues.

Who were these men that had Wilson's ear referring to? Could it have been the same power that president Franklin Delano Roosevelt referenced in a personal letter to Colonel Edward M. House in 1933:

The real truth of the matter is, as you and I know, that a financial element in the larger centers has owned the Government ever since the days of Andrew Jackson — and I am not wholly excepting the Administration of W. W. The country is going through a repetition of Jackson's fight with the Bank of the United States — only on a far bigger and broader basis.

Why did Roosevelt, a precise and most eloquent communicator, use such a curious phraseology in his letter to House? Why would he talk about the government of the United States being "owned" by an unnamed "financial element"? Our government is not supposed to be owned by anybody, right? Right?

I wonder if Wilson and Roosevelt knew about this hidden ruling oligarchy and were beholden to it during their presidencies.
 
Last edited:
For the same reason you have people who set trends, invent things, and blaze new trails. Some just march to the beat of their own drum and can think outside the box. Most others can't.
Sometime they march off cliffs, and the box is a padded room.
 
Like I already said, the evidence is all around you. It's everywhere. If you haven't put it all together yet there is nothing I can show you that will help you put it together now. You've been conditioned since birth to not see what is plainly right under your nose, and even if you could see it, you wouldn't be able to believe it.

Your problem is that you're not STARTING with the evidence and working your way to a conclusion. You're starting with the conclusion then looking for things that seem to confirm it.

Using this same methodology, I could show you evidence that Tinkerbell is real and is in control of all the world's cadmium supplies.
 
Lets see how this corruption of yours works, is it like this:

Reporter: My my. This epic phone hacking scandal has revealed a politician was pushing legislation on behalf of a mysterious agent.
Agent: DONT PUBLISH THAT!
Reporter: why?
Agent: I am an agent of the secret rulers.
Reporter: no you are not.
Agent: yes I am.
Reporter: prove it.
Agent; er...
Reporter: so are you going to kill me? Pay me off? Blackmail me?
Agent: no. You just do what I tell you. I don't leave evidence. ANY evidence.
Reporter: And if I don't do as you ask?
Agent: Look, this is really awkward, but would you mind deleting my name from the visitors book in the lobby? Nobody is allowed to know I exist...

That's the beauty of the oligarchy...it's SO sooper seekrit, it has no perceptible effect on the world.

It's almost as if it doesn't exist. But we know that can't be right, right?
 
If the oligarchy is underground, how do they breathe? Do they have snorkels or something? And what's so bad about them ruling the world? It's just one less thing I have to do.
 
After numerous puerile threads and posts, it's nice to see our little friend finally commit to articulating his/her beliefs.

"Nice" as in "entertaining as all get-out."
 
Last edited:
Ah, Schopenhauer. I've always liked that quote. It's especially fitting in this thread. Thanks for reminding me of it, as I hadn't seen it referenced in a while.

Here's another quote in keeping with the spirit of the thread, this time from Woodrow Wilson in The New Freedom from 1913:



Imagine that. All the way back then, a hundred years ago, there were powerful men of means in America who were frightened by a mysterious, organized power operating in and around the United States. This power was so watchful, so pervasive, and so great, that it made even powerful men hold their tongues.

Who were these men that had Wilson's ear referring to? Could it have been the same power that president Franklin Delano Roosevelt referenced in a personal letter to Colonel Edward M. House in 1933:



Why did Roosevelt, a precise and most eloquent communicator, use such a curious phraseology in his letter to House? Why would he talk about the government of the United States being "owned" by an unnamed "financial element"? Our government is not supposed to be owned by anybody, right? Right?

I wonder if Wilson and Roosevelt knew about this hidden ruling oligarchy and were beholden to it during their presidencies.

And lets not forget JFK

For we are opposed, around the world, by a monolithic and ruthless conspiracy, that relies primarily on covet means for expanding it's fear of influence

Remember what happened to him guys, he stuck his nose in where it wasn't wanted (federal reserve) and the consequence was death.
 
Reporters can be silenced, taken off of stories, not have their stories published, threatened, intimidated, and bought off. Most reporters won't trade their life to break a big story that might not even gain any traction in the rest of the controlled media.

This lie again? Reporters can, and do, risk their lives and freedom in order to break a hard hitting story. I have difficulty imagining one could ever be threatened, intimidated or bought off.

Of course that's more than a coward like you could ever understand, the drive to be part of something larger than one's self.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom