Iranian President Denies Existence Of Homosexuality In Iran

I feel as you do: Invade Iran for the sake of intolerance. :boggled:

Oliver, please be reasonable. Answer my question.


A better question for Oliver: Do free people have the right to free the gay people in Iran? Not should they, irrespective of practical concerns. But do they have such a right, philosophically?
 
A better question for Oliver: Do free people have the right to free the gay people in Iran? Not should they, irrespective of practical concerns. But do they have such a right, philosophically?


No - and I say this because (A) they don't want us interfering
in Iran for the surprising reason that we interfered in the Past.

(B) Because it's a sovereign country which can decide for itself.

(C) Because we, the west has problems with Gay-Rights as well.

(D) Because killing Saddam = X00,000 innocent casualties. I'm
sorry but I prefer 1000 dead people (in your case gays) over
hundred-thousands of dead people. (Which should make sense for
everyone who has at least a small amount of brain/morality)

However, I would agree if we start to stop the murder of Gays with
our Friends like the ones in the UAE, for example. And I feel save to
say this because this will never happen anyway - thanks to all the
mendacious Hypocrites complaining about Iran while dismissing the
Saudis with exactly the same punishment for Gays -PLUS- a pretty
much real dictatorship.
 
Know what would be funny? Ahmadinajad getting caught in a JFK mensroom tapping his foot in a stall...
 
That's a good approach.

Just make up whatever number that proves your point the best.


I'm sure you know very well what I meant. But nice that
you picked this point (which we don't have the actual
numbers yet) to comment on it while skipping the rest.

Nice.
 
No - and I say this because (A) they don't want us interfering
in Iran for the surprising reason that we interfered in the Past.

(B) Because it's a sovereign country which can decide for itself.

(C) Because we, the west has problems with Gay-Rights as well.

(D) Because killing Saddam = X00,000 innocent casualties. I'm
sorry but I prefer 1000 dead people (in your case gays) over
hundred-thousands of dead people. (Which should make sense for
everyone who has at least a small amount of brain/morality)

However, I would agree if we start to stop the murder of Gays with
our Friends like the ones in the UAE, for example. And I feel save to
say this because this will never happen anyway - thanks to all the
mendacious Hypocrites complaining about Iran while dismissing the
Saudis with exactly the same punishment for Gays -PLUS- a pretty
much real dictatorship.

So, you excuse Iran on the principle of "Better them than us" then go on about how we allow our allies to do it as a reason not to.
:jaw-dropp
 
Oliver, how can you equate the Iraqi civilian casualties (who are mostly due to the sectarian conflict and terrorist bombings, and when they are the result of American action, they were not the ones targeted), to people being deliberately and systematically killed for who they are, because of a nation's intolerant policy towards them?
 
So, you excuse Iran on the principle of "Better them than us" then go on about how we allow our allies to do it as a reason not to.
:jaw-dropp


I listed 4 reasons why I personally disagree with a violent
solution. Feel free to address my whole post to give me the
chance to understand your point of view.
 
Oliver, how can you equate the Iraqi civilian casualties (who are mostly due to the sectarian conflict and terrorist bombings, and when they are the result of American action, they were not the ones targeted), to people being deliberately and systematically killed for who they are, because of a nation's intolerant policy towards them?


I can't. Can you - concerning the murdered Gays in Saudi Arabia? No, you
can't as well. What's your point?
 
Please re-read my post, you didn't understand it.


You asked a question and my answer to that is: "I can't".
What didn't I understand about your post?

And concerning the civilians: It doesn't matter who killed
them. What matters to me is that they were killed as a
result of replacing Saddam who had, and no matter what
kind of ugly ******* he was, things under control.
 
You asked a question and my answer to that is: "I can't". What didn't I understand about your post?

And concerning the civilians: It doesn't matter who killed
them. What matters to me is that they were killed as a
result of replacing Saddam who had, and no matter what
kind of ugly ******* he was, things under control.


The problem is that this thread is not about the war in Iraq. You are the one who brought the large number of Iraqi civilian casualties to minimize the fate of the homosexuals being executed in Iran.

I say that one is a result of a very dirty war, and not the result of a systematic intolerant policy, the other is the result of a very oppressive policy, not a war. Both are absolutely different and unrelated topics.

I am asking you again, why do you equate the two?
 
The problem is that this thread is not about the war in Iraq. You are the one who brought the large number of Iraqi civilian casualties to minimize the fate of the homosexuals being executed in Iran.

I say that one is a result of a very dirty war, and not the result of a systematic intolerant policy, the other is the result of a very oppressive policy. Both are absolutely different and unrelated topics.

I am asking you again, why do you equate the two?


I'm arguing this way because I don't see the point of discussing
Iran's Gay rights at this moment - because we all agree that it's
wrong, don't we? Of course we do.

And from my experience about the Iran-Issue I sensed that you're
very opposed to Iran's Leadership - even if they don't pose a threat.
So of course I try to set you straight.
 
I'm arguing this way because I don't see the point of discussing Iran's Gay rights at this moment

Then don't post in this thread then.

And from my experience about the Iran-Issue I sensed that you're
very opposed to Iran's Leadership - even if they don't pose a threat.

Which has nothing to do with this thread.

So of course I try to set you straight.

I am straight.
 
Then don't post in this thread then.

Which has nothing to do with this thread.

I am straight.


Okay - I rest my case in this thread unless someone
replies to anything I posted in here.

And if you're straight, this might not be the right thread
for you as well... :p:D
 
Oliver, are you at least aware that equating the number of dead people in Iraq to the number of gays being executed in Iran is illogical?

ETA: I'm not trying to attack you, I'm just curious to know if you are aware of your own process in which you construct your arguments.
 
Last edited:
A better question for Oliver: Do free people have the right to free the gay people in Iran? Not should they, irrespective of practical concerns. But do they have such a right, philosophically?

Oliver, are you at least aware that equating the number of dead people in Iraq to the number of gays being executed in Iran is illogical?


No, it isn't illogical if you followed my answer to Beerina. I argued
that the same as in Iraq could happen in Iran, so I wouldn't support
to "free people" from outside - because we also supposedly "Freed"
the people of Iraq. So the comparison is legitimate in this context.
 
No, it isn't illogical if you followed my answer to Beerina. I argued that the same as in Iraq could happen in Iran, so I wouldn't support to "free people" from outside - because we also supposedly "Freed" the people of Iraq. So the comparison is legitimate in this context.

I see, it all started with your strawman that we were advocating an invasion of Iran because of their treatment of gays.

See what strawmen can lead to?

Nobody mentioned an invasion of Iran.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom