Iranian President Denies Existence Of Homosexuality In Iran

It seems to me that if they remain in a closet, the bulldozer has a relatively easy job of dozing the entire house, and thus being assured of killing whoever is in the house, of which the closet is a subset.

The law seems to be a self licking ice cream cone, if your take on it is accurate, and all homosexuals in Iran must stay in the closet AND will be bulldozed. :cool:

DR


Looking into it, does anyone have a reference for the bulldozers in Iran? I have only heard of hanging of homosexuals there and this

Reason Magazine said:
There's since been a return to the seventh century, when sodomites were executed by having a wall pushed over on them. The Taliban reinstituted that practice, using bulldozers to push over the walls
It does not seem to be referenceing Iran but Afganistan.

Link
 
I don't think that much considering the tenacity with which he repeated it. He said: "In Iran we don't have homosexuals like in your country" and "In Iran we do not have this phenomenon, I don't know who has told you that we have it."

If he would have left it at "We don't have homosexuals" I could have understood the translation argument. But to repeat it the way he did leaves little room for translation error.

Actually, it is the repetition that makes me wonder. I mean, he sounds so incredulous, it makes me wonder if the interpreter accidentally said "anal rape squads" or something. :confused:
 
So Ahmadinejad was really saying "Any homosexuals are kept in the closet lest they be killed under bulldozers"? (Which is what they do to homosexuals in Iran.)

Yes.

I'm not sure how this contextualization improves Ahmadinejad's response.

That's doesn't improve his response, but I'm not trying to improve anything, just trying to understand why he said what he said. Besides, it should be obvious that he knows homosexuals exist in Iran. After all, he's executing them, isn't he?
 
That was my bad. I confused Iran's method of executing homosexuals with the Taliban's method of executing homosexuals. My larger point still stands.

Oh I agree, but as I had seen video from some exicutions of homosexuals in Iran, and they where hung, the continued references to bulldozers confused me.

So let it be clear, Iran kills homosexuals by hanging them with cranes in town squares.
 
That's doesn't improve his response, but I'm not trying to improve anything, just trying to understand why he said what he said. Besides, it should be obvious that he knows homosexuals exist in Iran. After all, he's executing them, isn't he?

I think you have made a crucial point with your analysis of what he meant:

I would say it is more of an idiom than a translation error. I used to work with a fellow who was from Iran. He had escaped in 1979 and hadn't been back since. One day, I was talking to him about my electric guitars and he said, "In Iran, there aren't any electric guitars." But then he stopped himself and said, "Well, there are, but people keep them hidden." He went on to explain how they were a sign of Western culture, therefore, they were banned in Iran. People still had them but they had to be careful.

When I heard about the speech where gays were said not to exist, I remembered this and thought it was a figure of speech. Ahmadinejad might as well have said, "We don't electric guitars in Iran", or alcohol, or Beatles CD's, etc. The way I understand it Iran has everything we do, they just keep it hidden, and in their culture, things that are hidden 'do not exist'.

QFE

That's the problem with denial, or denialism, it's a form of self delusion that makes you accept two completely different and opposing ideas at the same time. If it doesn't exist, then it's OK to eliminate it...

We see that everyday with truthers (when they don't acknowledge the errors in their arguments) and even the White House (when they persist in not acknowledging the problems in Iraq). If you ignore the problem, then it doesn't exist (I'm not saying homosexuality is a problem, but it is obviously to Ahmadinejad).
 
Oh I agree, but as I had seen video from some exicutions of homosexuals in Iran, and they where hung, the continued references to bulldozers confused me.

So let it be clear, Iran kills homosexuals by hanging them with cranes in town squares.

High tech gallows.

Joy. :(

DR
 
High tech gallows.

Joy. :(

DR

Not really. I don't think they employ a drop method that breaks the neck, so it is slow strangulation.

So the effect is very basic hanging, and so is not very sophisticated.

But it does make the spectacle that they want.

Now for real fun, there is the case where Iranian officials executed a young woman(16 I think) for being raped. This was after the supreme court there said that there could not be capital punishments for minors. Basically the judge was corrupt but as he was a judge well connected to the revolution he was very safe, even if he killed a young girl for being raped.(legally I think the max penalty for that would have been 80 lashes)
 
Last edited:
When it involves human rights that should be universal, yes.

That's where it all falls down though, isn't it? What are our universal rights? I think killing someone for being gay is pure insanity, but appearantly that's not how people feel in Iran. Do I think it's wrong that they do it? Yes, but I am hardly an international coalition that can set down ground rules for basic human rights. If only such an organization existed, some kind of union of nations...
 
That's where it all falls down though, isn't it? What are our universal rights?
But that's a different analysis. On the Politics Forum we debate all the time as to what should be a "universal right". Free speech? Health Care? Six Weeks Vacation?

But that means we presume there is a bundle of things that should be universal rights. Deciding that there are no universal rights only means that any government can do anything it wants to anybody and condemnation from outsiders would be inappropriate.

South Africans decide to ignore AIDS medicine in favor of the "have sex with a virgin" method of curing AIDS?? Well, that's just "alternative medicine." Who are we to judge?

Myanmar cracks down on opposition parties? Well, who are we to say that the right to dissent should be recognized in Myanmar?

America invades Iraq? Feh. That's just Americans expressing their culture of invasion. And if Iraqis then begin killing each other in a civil war, well, maybe that's not what we would do in our part of the world, but who are we to judge?

Cultural relativism gives a free pass to tyrants. Just because we don't agree on what is right and wrong does not mean we cannot agree that there is a right or wrong and that we should strive to determine what that is.

I think killing someone for being gay is pure insanity, but appearantly that's not how people feel in Iran. Do I think it's wrong that they do it? Yes, but I am hardly an international coalition that can set down ground rules for basic human rights. If only such an organization existed, some kind of union of nations...
The United Nations is hardly a legitimate voice for determining what is right on that score, since most of the world's governments are homophobic. Just because very few countries in the world recognize homosexual unions with the benefits and protections of heterosexual unions does not mean I should abdicate my own preferences and judgment.
 
I've had people in Japan tell me there are no homosexuals here.

Of course, I laughed at them, too.

But I'm still trying to decide which is more ignorant: denial of homosexuality or denial of the Holocaust.
 
Last edited:
I've had people in Japan tell me there are no homosexuals here.

Of course, I laughed at them, too.

But I'm still trying to decide which is more ignorant: denial of homosexuality or denial of the Holocaust.

Is it worse to deny the existence of a natural expression of sexuality that harms no one, or to deny the existence of the brutal murder of 12 million people just because of who they were?

Denial should not exist of either, but for different reasons.
 
I've had people in Japan tell me there are no homosexuals here.

Of course, I laughed at them, too.

But I'm still trying to decide which is more ignorant: denial of homosexuality or denial of the Holocaust.

The Japanese example is relatively benign, but the Iranian example in the OP is worse than Holocaust denial.

Because in Japan there is no penalty for being gay, but in Iran it's a death penalty.

So the Iranian president is denying the crimes of his own regime.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom