Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

First of all, let us all remind everyone that you pulled this "interpretation" out of thin air.

....and your entire "evidence" trail is nothing more than conjecture and extrapolation......

Second, Doug Band wasn't asking for a meeting, he using his access to request a meeting on behalf of a donor despite the fact that Hillary signed an ethics agreement that was supposed to set up a wall to prevent just this type of behavior.

He can ask all he wants.....

The onus is on you to prove that there was a breach of the ethics agreement, so far you have failed miserably.

Are you really not understanding this?

Wow.

Yes, I am understanding you're so desperate to find some dirt on Hillary you will attempt spin everything towards your version of events.
 
This thread, I thought, was created to discuss the admittedly remote possibility that allegations of impropriety could lead to the undoing of Hillary Clinton and her presidential bid.

No, this thread was created to scare people into thinking that Clinton did something wrong, or something that was different/worse than every other politician/bureaucrat/businessperson/etc. The OP has a history of this.

What I find fascinating is how far some people will go to try to defend her. Make no mistake though, HRC will be elected president and I'm voting for her. I have to. The admittedly remote possibility of a Trump presidency quite frankly scares the living **** out of me.

Do you think that attacking a candidate for things that are not worthy of attack may have the possibility of increasing the chances of a Trump presidency? You do realize that this is an either/or situation, and the OP's (and other Republican's) constant attempts to tear down Clinton would, if successful, leave us with President Trump, don't you?

But that's OK because in the eyes of the majority, Hillary can do no wrong. Hell, it could be disclosed that she has a penis, is a card carrying NAMBLA member and likes to mow down bunnies and kittens with an assault rifle for relaxation and she'll still win in a landslide this November. Why?

Here's the thing, though: if there was any substance to any of the decades long right wing smear job of Clinton, she would have done wrong. The fact that there is no evidence of your scenario, or the OP's scenario, is good enough reason to push back against the constant unsubstantiated allegations. The problem isn't that Clinton can do no wrong, it's that in the eyes of HDS sufferers, everything she does is wrong, even if it's not wrong and a common practice like the instance this thread is about.

1. Bu-but [insert scumbag] does / did it too. The argument of a five year old.

Or, the argument of one who realizes that folks who only complain when Clinton does a common thing are committing the fallacy of selective attention, and trying to hold Clinton to a different standard than they hold everyone else to.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFallacies/159/Selective-Attention2. Don't care, must stop Trump, even if that means electing a weasel into office.

It's a shame really.[/QUOTE]

Hmm, as you admitted that #2 is your reasoning, I'm not clear what you see as a shame.
 
.
He can ask all he wants.....

The onus is on you to prove that there was a breach of the ethics agreement, so far you have failed miserably.

LOLZ! That is actually the first time you have mentioned the "ethics" agreement, which I have posted, quoted and linked several times in this thread.

Yet we get another Black Knight Gainsay! Fantastic.

No, he cannot "ask all he wants." Where the hell did you get that idea?

Clinton pledged to keep her distance from foundation matters as secretary of state. "I will not participate personally and substantially in any particular matter involving specific parties in which The William J. Clinton Foundation (or the Clinton Global Initiative) is a party or represents a party ...," she said.

The Clinton Foundation signed its own, separate memorandum of understanding with the Obama administration, promising to disclose donors annually and report material donation increases to the State Department among other things.

"The parties also seek to ensure that the activities of the Foundation, however beneficial, do not create conflicts or the appearance of conflicts for Senator Clinton as Secretary of State," the memorandum of understanding reads.

Unbelievable the excuses that Hillary fans will make for obvious improper conduct

Sad really.
 
Do you really think that such a post contributes to the discussion or the forum in any positive way? Or is your intent simply to annoy and waste time?
I am providing the only logical explanation for the lack of critical thinking in this thread. For example:
It doesn't really matter. For whatever reason, Hillary didn't accept his request to meet with the Prince, and after Band intervened, she did. If you are speculating that it's just a coincidence and that Hillary felt better or found out that her other plans had changed, than I think it is incumbent on you to provide evidence for that.
You are setting up a straw man just so you can shif the burden of proof. You are claiming foul play. Nothing short of verifiable evidence should be required to assign guit.
My evidence is that "pay to play" is going on because otherwise, the Prince wouldn't think of going through the Clinton Foundation, Band wouldn't think of interceding on his behalf, and Abedin wouldn't have made it sound like Band's request was perfectly acceptable and normal.
You are once again simply making **** up to fit your biased claim.

You are clearly an intelligent poster so I can't blame stupidity. HDS doesn't have an intelligence element so that explanation fits.

Note: If you are wondering, ODS works the same way.
 
...because Hillary does not control him.

Any agreement would relate to her actions, not his. :confused:

face palm... I just explained that Hillary and the CFF signed separate "ethics" agreements.

Doug Band was subject to the CFF agreement.

I do not think I can make this any simpler for you.
 
Other than Donald and the Trumpettes crying 'pay for play' and the news media trying very hard to make a scandal of it, there sure doesn't seem to be any hard evidence for any quid pro quos here. Let's see, the AP played with the numbers and tried to make it look like half the people who had meetings with Clinton were also donors. So we are to believe Clinton had only 154 meetings in her entire tenure as SoS?

Report on the AP report.
The nut fact that the AP uses to lead its coverage is wrong, and Braun and Sullivan’s reporting reveals absolutely no unethical conduct. In fact, they found so little unethical conduct that an enormous amount of space is taken up by a detailed recounting of the time Clinton tried to help a former Nobel Peace Prize winner who’s also the recipient of a Congressional Gold Medal and a Presidential Medal of Freedom....

To generate the 154 figure, the AP excluded from the denominator all employees of any government, whether US or foreign. Then when designing social media collateral, it just left out that part, because the truth is less striking and shareable.

Even so, the number 154 is preposterously low, as Clinton would routinely meet dozens of civil society leaders, journalists, and others on any one of her many foreign trips as secretary of state. In the campaign’s official response to the AP, they argue that the data is "cherry picked" from a "limited subset" of her schedule....ignoring well over 1,000 official meetings with foreign leaders and an unknown number of meetings with domestic US officials.

That is pretty irresponsible journalism for the AP.

Then there's this:
Muhammad Yunus, a Bangladeshi economist who won the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize for pioneering low-interest "microcredit" for poor business owners, met with Clinton three times and talked with her by phone during a period when Bangladeshi government authorities investigated his oversight of a nonprofit bank and ultimately pressured him to resign from the bank's board. Throughout the process, he pleaded for help in messages routed to Clinton, and she ordered aides to find ways to assist him.

Looks like some corrupt guy donates to the Foundation to get help with his country's investigation.

Until you find out
Yunus not only won the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize but has also been honored with a Presidential Medal of Freedom and a Congressional Gold Medal. In 2008 he was No. 2 on Foreign Policy’s list of the "top 100 global thinkers," and Ted Turner put him on the board of the UN Foundation. He’s received the World Food Prize, the International Simon Bolivar Prize, and the Prince of Asturias Award for Concord.

In other words, he’s a renowned and beloved figure throughout the West, not some moneybags getting help from the State Department in exchange for cash.

Isn't that just the kind of person you'd expect the State Department to step in and help?

There's more but I'll let people look at the VOX investigation of the details the AP left out.

What's the real scandal here is the piss-poor investigative journalism.
 
Here is a good article:

The Clinton Foundation’s Global Bribery and Crony Access Scam
Hillary’s hybrid ‘Clinton State-Foundation’ is a national disgrace


Enjoy it!

http://observer.com/2016/08/the-clinton-foundations-global-bribery-and-crony-access-scam/

:rolleyes:


Here's a more accurate article:

http://www.politifact.com/global-ne...n-clinton-foundation-helped-9-million-lower-/

"I'm proud of the work that it has done," Clinton said in the June 8, 2016, interview. "Nine million people have lower-cost HIV/AIDS medicine because of the work of the Clinton Foundation and my husband. We have women across the country, from Latin America and Africa -- across the world, I mean -- getting good jobs, and being able to support themselves for the first time."

I don't think any of those 9 million people give a **** what some vile HDS sufferer thinks.
 
Last edited:
The problem was that he wasn't considered important enough on his own for the Secretary of State to invest the time and prestige in a meeting. He was only considered important enough after it was made clear that he was an important donor to the Clinton Foundation (and would presumably make future donations contingent on getting the meeting). This is precisely what pay to play is. Clinton is selling access to her as Secretary of State (which is the government's property and not hers) in exchange for money for her foundation (which accrues to her benefit, but not the government's).

It's bad enough when a politician does this for campaign donations, but that is a well-understood and regulated activity which has a good measure of transparency. Furthermore, a politician is ultimately answerable to the voters.

It's possibly criminal for a professional bureaucrat to do something similar. Remember that Clinton was not serving as an elected official. She was appointed to her position and therefore was not answerable directly to the voters.

So let's say that's true. Let's even go farther than that. Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him.

My question is "so what?"

Everyone including Republicans agree that the Foundation is an excellent charity that does good work all over the world. What is wrong with the SecState acknowledging this and taking a meeting?

What do you think the Secretary of State does? Isn't it about foreign relations? Here is an opportunity to have a tangible effect. Why the hell not?
 
So let's say that's true. Let's even go farther than that. Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him.

My question is "so what?"

well, she expressly signed an agreement saying that she would not do that.

what is wrong with the Clinton Foundation dictating US Foreign Policy!

Yikes!
 
So let's say that's true. Let's even go farther than that. Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him.

My question is "so what?"

Everyone including Republicans agree that the Foundation is an excellent charity that does good work all over the world. What is wrong with the SecState acknowledging this and taking a meeting?

What do you think the Secretary of State does? Isn't it about foreign relations? Here is an opportunity to have a tangible effect. Why the hell not?

Actually, no, not everyone agrees. I have seen more evidence that it is a scam and a waste of resources than I have seen for your proposition. The Foundation's work in Haiti, for example, has been a failure.
 
well, she expressly signed an agreement saying that she would not do that.

what is wrong with the Clinton Foundation dictating US Foreign Policy!

Yikes!

Taking a meeting is not the same thing. You ran the train right off the rails. What a surprise.
 
So let's say that's true. Let's even go farther than that. Let's say the Prince made a large donation to the Clinton Foundation contingent on meeting the SecState and that was the prima facia reason she met with him.

My question is "so what?"

Everyone including Republicans agree that the Foundation is an excellent charity that does good work all over the world. What is wrong with the SecState acknowledging this and taking a meeting?

What do you think the Secretary of State does? Isn't it about foreign relations? Here is an opportunity to have a tangible effect. Why the hell not?

Taking a meeting is not the same thing. You ran the train right off the rails. What a surprise.

Yes, "taking a meeting" in exchange for money for her foundation is EXACTLY what is proscribed by her "ethics" agreement.

C'mon people, have you not read the agreements yet? Do so.
 
No, this thread was created to scare people into thinking that Clinton did something wrong, or something that was different/worse than every other politician/bureaucrat/businessperson/etc. The OP has a history of this.

You are entitled to your opinion.

Do you think that attacking a candidate for things that are not worthy of attack may have the possibility of increasing the chances of a Trump presidency? You do realize that this is an either/or situation, and the OP's (and other Republican's) constant attempts to tear down Clinton would, if successful, leave us with President Trump, don't you?

And who's saying they're not worthy of attack? Foaming Hillary supporters. I prefer to let the story unfold, thanks.


Here's the thing, though: if there was any substance to any of the decades long right wing smear job of Clinton, she would have done wrong. The fact that there is no evidence of your scenario, or the OP's scenario, is good enough reason to push back against the constant unsubstantiated allegations. The problem isn't that Clinton can do no wrong, it's that in the eyes of HDS sufferers, everything she does is wrong, even if it's not wrong and a common practice like the instance this thread is about.

Oooooh! It's HDS! Thanks, it's all cleared up now.


Or, the argument of one who realizes that folks who only complain when Clinton does a common thing are committing the fallacy of selective attention, and trying to hold Clinton to a different standard than they hold everyone else to.

https://www.logicallyfallacious.com/tools/lp/Bo/LogicalFallacies/159/Selective-Attention2. Don't care, must stop Trump, even if that means electing a weasel into office.

Good thing I'm not making that argument then.
 
Actually, no, not everyone agrees. I have seen more evidence that it is a scam and a waste of resources than I have seen for your proposition. The Foundation's work in Haiti, for example, has been a failure.

I'm not on the ground and personally cannot judge except to say that groups that do watch and rate charity groups give it a high rating. What does seem clear is that some people don't care about that and will do anything and everything to cast aspersions on the Clintons.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom