Moderated Inside the latest Clinton pay for play scandal

Huh? Looks to me as if he reached out through official channels and was politely denied. And Huma Abedin is giving a polite excuse for the original denial to Band. After the exchange with Band, Hillary met with the Prince within 48 hours. This looks exactly as I described it.
Not really. It is your interpretation.

How do you know that Huma Abedin "is giving a polite excuse" and not simply telling the truth to Band?
 
Shocking then that he would feel the need to ask Band to intercede on his behalf. What you're implying I guess is that even important people were being denied access until they paid the Clinton Foundation "cover charge." That's even worse actually.

Am I missing something? Is there a timeline somewhere that shows that the man got denied, THEN made a donation, then emailed Clinton and got a meeting? Did Clinton, or any lackey, suggest that they donate? Is there anything other than you tying loose connections? No? Didn't think so.

You and The Big Dog should keep digging up the backyard, maybe you'll find something those bones somewhere.

Edited by zooterkin: 
Edited for rule 0. Do not make fun of other member's names.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not really. It is your interpretation.

How do you know that Huma Abedin "is giving a polite excuse" and not simply telling the truth to Band?

It doesn't really matter. For whatever reason, Hillary didn't accept his request to meet with the Prince, and after Band intervened, she did. If you are speculating that it's just a coincidence and that Hillary felt better or found out that her other plans had changed, than I think it is incumbent on you to provide evidence for that.

My evidence is that "pay to play" is going on because otherwise, the Prince wouldn't think of going through the Clinton Foundation, Band wouldn't think of interceding on his behalf, and Abedin wouldn't have made it sound like Band's request was perfectly acceptable and normal.
 
Am I missing something? Is there a timeline somewhere that shows that the man got denied, THEN made a donation, then emailed Clinton and got a meeting? Did Clinton, or any lackey, suggest that they donate? Is there anything other than you tying loose connections? No? Didn't think so.

The connection is that Band vouched for him. Presumably Band would know if the Prince was in "good standing" with Clinton Foundation or not. I doubt that it would have been necessary for money to have changed hands in the interim. Only that Band and the Prince were on the same page as far as bilateral expectations were concerned.
 
It doesn't really matter. For whatever reason, Hillary didn't accept his request to meet with the Prince, and after Band intervened, she did. If you are speculating that it's just a coincidence and that Hillary felt better or found out that her other plans had changed, than I think it is incumbent on you to provide evidence for that.
I'm not speculating, that is what the emails tell us. You speculate that Huma Abedin "is giving a polite excuse".

My evidence is that "pay to play" is going on because otherwise, the Prince wouldn't think of going through the Clinton Foundation, Band wouldn't think of interceding on his behalf, and Abedin wouldn't have made it sound like Band's request was perfectly acceptable and normal.
Yes, the crown prince of Bahrain has more access than Firestone of Belgium or sunmaster14 of the USA. That he used the Foundation to try and force a meeting is something I couldn't do. These things happen, in every country, under every administration.

But you have no evidence whatsoever that the reason he finally got his appointment is not exactly what Huma Abedin suggests in her email.
 
Shocking then that he would feel the need to ask Band to intercede on his behalf. What you're implying I guess is that even important people were being denied access until they paid the Clinton Foundation "cover charge." That's even worse actually.

The Clinton Foundation is a charity that has saved the lives of many people. Sorry that they're brown, but it is what it is, and rational people don't give 2 ***** what you ODS/HDS sufferers feel. If palms need to get greased to get it done, who cares? It's business as usual.
 
Ok, feel free to explain how Clinton doing it is worse than every other politician doing it, or alternatively how up in arms you've been by anyone other than Clinton doing it.

Or, just keep pretending it only matters because Clinton did it.

This thread, I thought, was created to discuss the admittedly remote possibility that allegations of impropriety could lead to the undoing of Hillary Clinton and her presidential bid.

What I find fascinating is how far some people will go to try to defend her. Make no mistake though, HRC will be elected president and I'm voting for her. I have to. The admittedly remote possibility of a Trump presidency quite frankly scares the living **** out of me.

But that's OK because in the eyes of the majority, Hillary can do no wrong. Hell, it could be disclosed that she has a penis, is a card carrying NAMBLA member and likes to mow down bunnies and kittens with an assault rifle for relaxation and she'll still win in a landslide this November. Why?

1. Bu-but [insert scumbag] does / did it too. The argument of a five year old.

2. Don't care, must stop Trump, even if that means electing a weasel into office.

It's a shame really.
 
"Good friend of ours."

"OURS." I do not think I have ever seen anything that so clearly indicates that Hillary ran a pay for play racket out of the State Department.
 
"Good friend of ours."

"OURS." I do not think I have ever seen anything that so clearly indicates that Hillary ran a pay for play racket out of the State Department.
That's about as reasonable as me taking the four words that I colored blue out of context. Pro tip: stick with the facts.

That doesn't mean I don't find the whole thing sleazy -- it certainly is.
 
"Good friend of ours."

"OURS." I do not think I have ever seen anything that so clearly indicates that Hillary ran a pay for play racket out of the State Department.

Because that could never be interpreted as a "good friend of the United States" what with the longstanding relationship and all that :rolleyes:
 
That's about as reasonable as me taking the four words that I colored blue out of context. Pro tip: stick with the facts.

That doesn't mean I don't find the whole thing sleazy -- it certainly is.

lolz! It is four *********** words, hell the only one that isn't controversial is "of," and I would argue that.
 
Because that could never be interpreted as a "good friend of the United States" what with the longstanding relationship and all that :rolleyes:
Indeed. And despite this stunningly obvious possibility, TBD has never seen anything so clear. Go figure.
 
Because that could never be interpreted as a "good friend of the United States" what with the longstanding relationship and all that :rolleyes:

Didn't think that through did you?

Doug Band was with a private entity that Hillary said she would have nothing to do with while SoS.

As such, where the hell does he get off telling the State Department who and who is not a "good friend" of the United States?

C'mon man...
 
Because that could never be interpreted as a "good friend of the United States" what with the longstanding relationship and all that :rolleyes:

:jaw-dropp That is not a reasonable interpretation in context. I hardly think that one of the most senior people at the Clinton Foundation needs to remind the State Department that the Prince of Bahrain is a good friend of the US (if indeed he is). Band clearly was referring to the fact that the Prince was a good friend of the Foundation.
 
The Clinton Foundation is a charity that has saved the lives of many people. Sorry that they're brown, but it is what it is, and rational people don't give 2 ***** what you ODS/HDS sufferers feel. If palms need to get greased to get it done, who cares? It's business as usual.

This, by the way, is a claim that I do not accept without evidence. I have taken a shallow dive into the Clinton Foundation's work before, and, frankly, it's so-called accomplishments look relatively insubstantial and vague. If indeed it is a poorly run charity and functions more like a political slush fund, then it probably has the effect of killing more people than it saves. Any organization that wastes resources on net has that effect because we live in a world of limited resources.

Let me preempt all the HDS-ers who will point out the "A" rating from charity watch. I read what that rating means, and it means very little. The grade reflects only two metrics: what percent of funds raised are spent for fundraising (the lower the better); and what percent of funds raised are spent on actual programs rather than overhead (the higher the better).

But in the case of the Clinton Foundation, all the former metric indicates is that Bill and Hillary have the clout to get millions of dollars of donations with merely a phone call to rich people, who, likely, couldn't care less about the chartiable work (such as it is) for the Foundation. The latter metric sounds good, but it also is a direct result of the way the Foundation set itself up. It does very little work on its own, but rather forms partnerships with other charities and gives grants for doing charitable work. As such, the real overhead expenses (which the downstream charity has) gets subsumed into the grant itself and looks like charitable spending rather than overhead. The proper way to calculate this number would be to add in the downstream overhead expenses to the numerator. For example, an charity shouldn't be A-rated for this metric if it gives most of its money to B-rated charities. But it looks like the way it is calculated, that definitely would happen.
 
Didn't think that through did you?

Doug Band was with a private entity that Hillary said she would have nothing to do with while SoS.

As such, where the hell does he get off telling the State Department who and who is not a "good friend" of the United States?

C'mon man...

Why not, it never hurts to remind people who the person is - especially if you're asking for an audience and especially if you don't know whether the person in question or a member of their staff is reading the mail.

:jaw-dropp That is not a reasonable interpretation in context. I hardly think that one of the most senior people at the Clinton Foundation needs to remind the State Department that the Prince of Bahrain is a good friend of the US (if indeed he is). Band clearly was referring to the fact that the Prince was a good friend of the Foundation.

You doubt that the Crown Prince of Bahrain is a good friend to the U.S. ?

As to the rest see my answer above.
 
Whatever. Do you really think the SecState decides arm sales and not the President and the Pentagon?

whatever?...

Federal law explicitly designates the secretary of state as responsible for the continuous supervision and general direction of sales of arms. 22 U.S. Code § 2752...

But you said "whatever" which is probably a pretty strong argument!
 
Why not, it never hurts to remind people who the person is - especially if you're asking for an audience and especially if you don't know whether the person in question or a member of their staff is reading the mail..

First of all, let us all remind everyone that you pulled this "interpretation" out of thin air.

Second, Doug Band wasn't asking for a meeting, he using his access to request a meeting on behalf of a donor despite the fact that Hillary signed an ethics agreement that was supposed to set up a wall to prevent just this type of behavior.

Are you really not understanding this?

Wow.
 
This thread, I thought, was created to discuss the admittedly remote possibility that allegations of impropriety could lead to the undoing of Hillary Clinton and her presidential bid.

What I find fascinating is how far some people will go to try to defend her. Make no mistake though, HRC will be elected president and I'm voting for her. I have to. The admittedly remote possibility of a Trump presidency quite frankly scares the living **** out of me.

But that's OK because in the eyes of the majority, Hillary can do no wrong. Hell, it could be disclosed that she has a penis, is a card carrying NAMBLA member and likes to mow down bunnies and kittens with an assault rifle for relaxation and she'll still win in a landslide this November. Why?

1. Bu-but [insert scumbag] does / did it too. The argument of a five year old.

2. Don't care, must stop Trump, even if that means electing a weasel into office.

It's a shame really.

Speculative hyperbolic strawman; demonizing the opposition. Ten points for Hufflepuff.
 
Last edited:
Didn't think that through did you?

Doug Band was with a private entity that Hillary said she would have nothing to do with while SoS.
As such, where the hell does he get off telling the State Department who and who is not a "good friend" of the United States?
C'mon man...

??

I would hope that the base of our entire 5th Fleet could safely be called a "good friend" by pretty much any of the 330 million people who call the US home.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom