Infant's death at hospital linked to circumcision followed by oral suction

You can post whatever you want, Skwinty, but that doesn't change the fact that Mohels who would use their mouths to do this do not perform circumcisions on the vast majority of Jews.

This practice would be performed in ultra Orthodox communities only. Mainstream Jews would be horrified by this practice, if they even knew it even went on, which the vast majority probably do not.

Though an atheist, I was raised Jewish and both of my sons were circumcised as was my brother, all my cousins, all of their children, etc. I never heard about this nonsense until I read this thread. Both of the Mohels who circumcised my boys were Urologists, and I assure you, they used gauze.
 
Last edited:
You can post whatever you want, Skwinty, but that doesn't change the fact that Mohels who would use their mouths to do this do not perform circumcisions on the vast majority of Jews.

This practice would be performed in ultra Orthodox communities only. Mainstream Jews would be horrified by this practice, if they even knew it even went on, which the vast majority probably do not.

Though an atheist, I was raised Jewish and both of my sons were circumcised as was my brother, all my cousins, all of their children, etc. I never heard about this nonsense until I read this thread. Both of the Mohels who circumcised my boys were Urologists, and I assure you, they used gauze.
Which does not alter in slightest that circumcision is a dangerous, pointless abuse of children.
 
You can post whatever you want, Skwinty, but that doesn't change the fact that Mohels who would use their mouths to do this do not perform circumcisions on the vast majority of Jews.

This practice would be performed in ultra Orthodox communities only. Mainstream Jews would be horrified by this practice, if they even knew it even went on, which the vast majority probably do not.

Though an atheist, I was raised Jewish and both of my sons were circumcised as was my brother, all my cousins, all of their children, etc. I never heard about this nonsense until I read this thread. Both of the Mohels who circumcised my boys were Urologists, and I assure you, they used gauze.

Vic,

I am not Jewish although I am circumcised. However disgusted you may be with respect to this practice, I can assure you that I am equally disgusted.

However, it is quite apparent that this practice still takes place today in acordance with Jewish scriptures. The link that I provided comes from the Jewish Orthodox Union and not the Ultra Orthodox Union.

Of course, once the procedure is complete, the mohel, urologist or not, would dress the wound with gauze and anti-septic.

Now with all due respect, unless you personally witnessed the majority of Jewish circumcisions, your opinion is just that. An unsubstantiated opinion.
 
As a Conservative Jew, I can say that this type of circumcision is never practiced in anything but the most ulta-orthodox hassidic communities, and even then by only a subset of them.

I had both my sons circumcised in religious ceremonies with nothing but the most transient of pain and week of healing.
 
Religion should not be allowed to make legal what would otherwise be illegal.

This man sexually molested a baby, infected it with herpes, and killed it. It doesn't matter what religious traditions anyone has, this is absolutely wrong. He should be in prison and this practice should be outlawed.
 
As a Conservative Jew, I can say that this type of circumcision is never practiced in anything but the most ulta-orthodox hassidic communities, and even then by only a subset of them.

I had both my sons circumcised in religious ceremonies with nothing but the most transient of pain and week of healing.

But it's still only Jews that practice this, am I right? If so am I seeing an advancing "no true Jew" defence?
 
This man sexually molested a baby, infected it with herpes, and killed it.

That's ridiculous, unless you are going to claim that all procedures performed on the genitals are sexual molestation
 
Last edited:
IMO, circumcision is a barbaric measure which should be replaced with personal hygiene education for the child carer and child.
 
You can post whatever you want, Skwinty, but that doesn't change the fact that Mohels who would use their mouths to do this do not perform circumcisions on the vast majority of Jews.

This practice would be performed in ultra Orthodox communities only. Mainstream Jews would be horrified by this practice, if they even knew it even went on, which the vast majority probably do not.

Though an atheist, I was raised Jewish and both of my sons were circumcised as was my brother, all my cousins, all of their children, etc. I never heard about this nonsense until I read this thread. Both of the Mohels who circumcised my boys were Urologists, and I assure you, they used gauze.

So you had your own children mutilated in a slightly nicer fashion than some other people. What do you expect now? A medal?
 
That's ridiculous, unless you are going to claim that all procedures performed on the genitals are sexual molestation

I'm pretty sure that sucking a kid's dick does count as sexual molestation. Also that there is no known surgical procedure that actually requires oral sex, or we'd be lining up at doctor's offices simulating whatever symptoms are needed for that.

If you still need to wrap your mind around why that's sexual molestation, imagine that someone had performed some oral stimulation on some baby girl, even without giving her a lethal VD in the process. I'm sure you can see how nobody would see that as perfectly normal.

Incidentally, even without herpes, the human mouth has a melange of 50-60 species of bacteria, some pretty nasty, and very high concentrations per ml. To the extent that a bite from a human CAN result in septic shock and death even in an adult, especially if their immune system is compromised, and stuff like septic arthritis even in other people, from which only about 10% fully recover and 10-20% even need an amputation.

Source, for example, http://www.onlinejets.org/article.a...me=2;issue=3;spage=186;epage=190;aulast=Patil

At any rate, a human bite is more likely to infect than most other kinds of injury, and is a medical emergency.

"But wait," someone will say, "they're not BITING the kid's dick, are they?"

It doesn't matter. There is nothing about bite vs cut that causes the infection, it's just human saliva contact with an open wound and those bacteria getting into the wound that way. Licking or sucking a cut wound can cause the same problems.

Again, the problems are mostly associated with people with a weak immune system. BUT, that pretty much describes all babies.

Even if this guy didn't have herpes, just putting his mouth on a baby's fresh wound is irresponsible and potentially fatal. It was something just waiting to happen.

There is absolutely no medical justification in getting human saliva on a baby's wound, be it at the genitals or anywhere else. And in fact all the reason in the world NOT to.

Really, if you wouldn't crap on a kid's wound to make it better, keep your mouth off it too.
 
And I just wanted to add, any surgical procedure has a small chance to get infected anyway. That's why people routinely get given antibiotics after surgery.

You can get infected even just from the air, or contact with other stuff, or whatever. The skin does a pretty good job of keeping a lot of bacteria and viruses out. Any wound that broke through the skin, not so much.

And if your immune system is weak, it may well kill you or cause long term problems. Which, again, describes all babies.

I see no reason to do any unneeded surgery on anyone who can't give informed consent. Unless they're old enough to understand the risks, no matter how small, and decide for themselves whether they actually want to take them, just keep the knives away.

Basically if you have to correct some heart malformation that will kill the kid anyway otherwise, fine, get the operating room ready. But inflicting any break in the skin willy nilly, no. Just no.
 
That's ridiculous, unless you are going to claim that all procedures performed on the genitals are sexual molestation

Depends.

Did all those other procedures end with the patient's genitals in the mouth of the person performing the procedure?

Ah, religion.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure that sucking a kid's dick does count as sexual molestation. Also that there is no known surgical procedure that actually requires oral sex, or we'd be lining up at doctor's offices simulating whatever symptoms are needed for that.

If you still need to wrap your mind around why that's sexual molestation, imagine that someone had performed some oral stimulation on some baby girl, even without giving her a lethal VD in the process. I'm sure you can see how nobody would see that as perfectly normal.

Incidentally, even without herpes, the human mouth has a melange of 50-60 species of bacteria, some pretty nasty, and very high concentrations per ml. To the extent that a bite from a human CAN result in septic shock and death even in an adult, especially if their immune system is compromised, and stuff like septic arthritis even in other people, from which only about 10% fully recover and 10-20% even need an amputation.

Source, for example, http://www.onlinejets.org/article.a...me=2;issue=3;spage=186;epage=190;aulast=Patil

At any rate, a human bite is more likely to infect than most other kinds of injury, and is a medical emergency.

"But wait," someone will say, "they're not BITING the kid's dick, are they?"

It doesn't matter. There is nothing about bite vs cut that causes the infection, it's just human saliva contact with an open wound and those bacteria getting into the wound that way. Licking or sucking a cut wound can cause the same problems.

Again, the problems are mostly associated with people with a weak immune system. BUT, that pretty much describes all babies.

Even if this guy didn't have herpes, just putting his mouth on a baby's fresh wound is irresponsible and potentially fatal. It was something just waiting to happen.

There is absolutely no medical justification in getting human saliva on a baby's wound, be it at the genitals or anywhere else. And in fact all the reason in the world NOT to.

Really, if you wouldn't crap on a kid's wound to make it better, keep your mouth off it too.

I only challenged the assertion that it was sexual molestation.
It is a nonsense to say it is, and does nothing to support a reasoned opposition to the practice of non-consensual circumcision
The question of infection is irrelevant to that. Infection could also be introduced by failing to use sterile instruments. You could hardly argue that constituted sexual molestation.
Similarly the sex of the baby is irrelevant. If it were done to a baby girl who had just been mutilated it would not be sexual molestation.
The handling of the genitals during the procedure would also qualify as sexual molestation by your reasoning.
 
I'm pretty sure that sucking a kid's dick does count as sexual molestation. Also that there is no known surgical procedure that actually requires oral sex, or we'd be lining up at doctor's offices simulating whatever symptoms are needed for that.
I think the *intent* is what makes the difference between sexual and not sexual. I'm sure we can think of plenty of good reasons for a doctor to have his hand on a penis or vagina, but we don't say that the doc is giving the kid a handjob. If the mohel is furiously fapping away while he does the mezizah, then it's probably safe to say that there's a sexual component.

I find it problematic when people overreach with their arguments, making weakly supported allegations, when there are already plenty of perfectly good reasons to agree with them on the larger point. That is, this is an antiquated procedure that has absolutely no modern reason to continue. It's reasonable to say that the reason they use their mouths is not because of a sexual component, but because that's how their mud-hut dwelling ancestors did it 3000 years ago, and they couldn't think of a better way to manage suction back then. It's an absolutely stupid reason to continue doing it that way, but for some people, religionists especially, tradition is priority #1. So yeah, stupid idea, but not supportable as "sexual abuse" by any means.

Here where we're mostly skeptics, it's not such a big failing to include crappy points along with the good points that you make. But when we confront the nutters in the world at large, it causes bigger problems, because they can pick out the one weak argument that you've made and make the conversation about that, instead of all the bigger points that they'd lose on.
 
That's ridiculous, unless you are going to claim that all procedures performed on the genitals are sexual molestation

Let's change this around for a minute to show you how insane it is.

A woman goes into a gynecologist's office.

"Well, i could use a speculum, but my religion says i must use a more...appropriate tool **zip**"

Regardless of if the gynecologist in question is doing it for the most pure of reasons, and not to just stick his penis in something, it is still wacky, wrong, and sexual molestation when other less... bat **** crazy options are available.

Only religion would create a scenario in which they want to claim that sucking off a baby , in the modern age, when plenty of contraptions exist that do the job better, and with less... bat **** crazyness , is not child molestation.
 
But it's still only Jews that practice this, am I right? If so am I seeing an advancing "no true Jew" defence?
Circumcision is still commonly inflicted on infants in the USA, regardless of religion/ethnicity; in 2005 the (non-medical) infant circumcision rate was 59%, lower than previously but still needlessly high compared to 3.8% in the UK and <0.1% in Finland.


I had both my sons circumcised in religious ceremonies with nothing but the most transient of pain and week of healing.
There are long term effects, none of them good; for example, from the Frisch, Lindholm and Grønbæk study (IntJouEpid14JUN2011):
Circumcision was associated with frequent orgasm difficulties in Danish men and with a range of frequent sexual difficulties in women, notably orgasm difficulties, dyspareunia and a sense of incomplete sexual needs fulfilment. Thorough examination of these matters in areas where male circumcision is more common is warranted.
picture.php




And I just wanted to add, any surgical procedure has a small chance to get infected anyway. That's why people routinely get given antibiotics after surgery.

You can get infected even just from the air, or contact with other stuff, or whatever. The skin does a pretty good job of keeping a lot of bacteria and viruses out. Any wound that broke through the skin, not so much.

And if your immune system is weak, it may well kill you or cause long term problems. Which, again, describes all babies.

I see no reason to do any unneeded surgery on anyone who can't give informed consent. Unless they're old enough to understand the risks, no matter how small, and decide for themselves whether they actually want to take them, just keep the knives away.

Basically if you have to correct some heart malformation that will kill the kid anyway otherwise, fine, get the operating room ready. But inflicting any break in the skin willy nilly, no. Just no.
Well said. Some risk, no benefits, known problems, suggests not doing it.
Hence the near unanimity amongst Pediatric medical organisations.
 
Let's change this around for a minute to show you how insane it is.

A woman goes into a gynecologist's office.

"Well, i could use a speculum, but my religion says i must use a more...appropriate tool **zip**"

Regardless of if the gynecologist in question is doing it for the most pure of reasons, and not to just stick his penis in something, it is still wacky, wrong, and sexual molestation when other less... bat **** crazy options are available.

Only religion would create a scenario in which they want to claim that sucking off a baby , in the modern age, when plenty of contraptions exist that do the job better, and with less... bat **** crazyness , is not child molestation.
I think you are really torturing that analogy.
That's cruel. Please don't do it.
The fact that you insist in using a sexual term rather than a neutral term indicates a severe and unreasoned bias on your part.
It is not sexual molestation and it is just plain silly to say it is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom