Infant's death at hospital linked to circumcision followed by oral suction

Joined
Jan 25, 2010
Messages
799
Apparently the Rabbi was performing an old ritual after circumcision called metzitzah b'peh which involves applying suction to the fresh wound with the mouth. The baby got Herpes and died.

His Holy Book says he has to do the metzitzah b'peh but there is debate about the definition of the ritual. I tend to think the mention of spitting out the blood clears that up ;) -- smacks of the old "Oh it doesn't say anything bad at all, you're just misinterpreting it" routine.

Links in article here, explaining why he had Herpes, officials' condemnation of the ritual, previous cases causing brain damage, and a modern Jewish view of it.
 
We could argue about circumcision for months, again... so let's avoid that.

I had never heard of "metzitzah b'peh" before. What could possibly make anyone think that's a good idea?
 
We could argue about circumcision for months, again... so let's avoid that.

I had never heard of "metzitzah b'peh" before. What could possibly make anyone think that's a good idea?

Perhaps it was necessary back in the day when mechanical suction was unavailable.

Illustrates the problem of hanging on to a practice via the justification of tradition when it can be performed more safely with modern methods.
 
We could argue about circumcision for months, again... so let's avoid that.

I had never heard of "metzitzah b'peh" before. What could possibly make anyone think that's a good idea?


Well, he is a priest.

You don't think the catholic priests came up with their proclivities from scratch, did you?
 
Alas in the US alone a child dies every 2-3 days due to circumcision.
:mad:
 
"My client is known internationally as a caring, skilled and conscientious mohel," Kurzmann said. He suggested the babies could have contracted herpes elsewhere.
http://www.nydailynews.com/archives...y-circumcision-article-1.586889#ixzz1oBHwUfeq

I'm sure the baby boys actually picked up herpes from the cheap girls they were picking up in bars.....
​
 
Here is some more detail about this practice, listing more deaths.

It's pretty grisly, not for the faint of heart.:eye-poppi

Alas in the US alone a child dies every 2-3 days due to circumcision. :mad:
Believe me, I am no fan of circumcision, but this baby died of Herpes from the Rabbi's mouth infecting his penis, which apparently is a legal religious ritual and has been throughout Jewish history.
 
Last edited:
Wait what?
There are a number of statistics on infant deaths directly related to circumcision in the USA, suggesting approximately 120-200 deaths per annum.
From a previous thread:
The Thymos study (2010) suggests 117. More coverage here. This study covered only the neonatal period and would exclude deaths from complications, such as infections, which would be likely to manifest later.
Baker's study (1979, available in part here) suggested 229
Gellis (American Journal of Diseases of Children DEC1978, available here) suggested that deaths form complications from circumcision outnumbered those from penile cancer.
John Brunetti (NY City Child Services) estimated 200 deaths pa in the US. [presentation at the 'Early Head Start' annual conference 2001]
Bollinger (in 'Death and the New Penis') examines a number of sources and suggests ~100 deaths pa.

Non-USA.
Gairdnder (BMJ DEC1949, available here) suggested 16-19 deaths pa in the UK in the late 1940s. Extrapolation would support 120-150pa in the US today.


ETA: apologies for the slight derail. FYI this particular death wouldn't appear in these stats, suggesting the death rate is higher then believed.
 
Last edited:
Let's be clear here. This is absolutely NOT a practice of mainstream Jews. Even orthodox Jews.

Mohels who perform circumcisions for non-fantical Jews in 2012 use gauze for this, not their mouths.
 
Wow, thanks.

I think it's wrong, but didn't realize that it actually killed infants.
I didn´t realize this either.

I have been throwing moral dirt against circumcision for years, in threads thousands of posts long, without anyone ever mentioning that there are more serious aspects to it than whether you like the esthetical shape or not.
 
Let's be clear here. This is absolutely NOT a practice of mainstream Jews. Even orthodox Jews.

Mohels who perform circumcisions for non-fantical Jews in 2012 use gauze for this, not their mouths.


http://www.ou.org/jewish_action/article/8987


What is Metzitzah?
The original technique for the performance of metzitzah employs the human mouth. The mohel brings the baby’s organ into his mouth immediately after the excision of the foreskin and sucks blood from it vigorously. This action lowers the internal pressure in the tissues of the organ, in the blood vessels of the head of the organ and in the exposed ends of the arterioles that have just been cut. Thus, the difference between the pressure in the blood vessels in the base of the organ and the pressure in the blood vessels at its tip is increased. This requirement has deep religious significance as well as medical benefits.

Metzitzah as a religious obligation is mentioned in the mystical portions of the Torah.12 In the last two centuries, as well, a number of famous posekim have declared that an attack on the tradition of metzitzah is tantamount to an attack on the mitzvah of brit milah itself.13 Nevertheless, many posekim, including the Chatam Sofer, the Ketzot Hachoshen, the Netziv of Volozhin,14 the Avnei Nezer15 and more recently, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach and the Tzitz Eliezer, have ruled that the purpose of metzitzah is solely medical.

Some have pointed out that even the posekim who maintain that metzitzah is a religious obligation (that is, that metzizah is part of the mitzvah of brit milah) may not have based their statements purely on halachic reasoning, but to a large extent were responding to attacks against brit milah. Those who make this claim are supported by the halachic literature on metzitzah, which indicates rather clearly that metzitzah is a medical requirement instituted by Chazal because of the risk involved in neglecting to perform it. In addition, one cannot ignore the difficulty of defending a medical guideline imposed by Chazal in the absence of sufficient medical knowledge to explain it. Furthermore, proclaiming that metzitzah is an inseparable part of the commandment of brit milah is an effectual means today, as in the past, of fending off attacks against the Divine covenant of circumcision.16

The Gemara states that the requirement of metzitzah stems from medical considerations; it is meant to minimize risk to the infant’s life and health17:
Rav Pappa said, “A mohel who does not perform metzitzah endangers the baby and is dismissed.”
 
The Gemara states that the requirement of metzitzah stems from medical considerations; it is meant to minimize risk to the infant’s life and health17:
Rav Pappa said, “A mohel who does not perform metzitzah endangers the baby and is dismissed.”

There is something essentially demented about this: the practice is intended to minimize risk to the infant's life, and probably does, given the situation.
But if the infant had not just had a piece of his penis amputated, there would be no risk to minimize.
 
I agree, it is barbaric to say the least.

The insane things done in the name of religion.:confused:
 
I didn´t realize this either.

I have been throwing moral dirt against circumcision for years, in threads thousands of posts long, without anyone ever mentioning that there are more serious aspects to it than whether you like the esthetical shape or not.
Try the three previous threads here; there are a lot of links/citations for various studies on the physical, emotional and sexual problems related to circumcision, as well as the lack of support for the purported health benefits.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom