Inequality-Indexing of the Tax System

How many dual income families are in the bottom 20% of households by income?

Families with two full-time incomes? Presumably none, as two full-time workers making minimum wage would just sneak into the very bottom of the middle 33%. So my statement should have been that the bottom has remained flat, any increases in the middle are due almost entirely to increases in productivity due to women entering the workforce, and meanwhile incomes at the very top have exploded.
 
How many dual income families are in the bottom 20% of households by income?

This doesn't seem relevant, unless you're suggesting that what is needed is a return to the 19th century world of _Pride and Prejudice_ where women need to get married in order to have access to the good things in life.

It's not a question of number of incomes. It's a question of amount of income (and to a lesser extent, of source of income).
 
No, I think gtc had a valid point in the context of my claim that the bottom 20% have flat incomes even with two workers in the family. After I looked at the numbers it was clear that the bottom 20% are either single income families, part time workers, or people who somehow make less than minimum wage.
 
psychictv did raise a good point about the rise of two income families. If two income families today aren't materially better off than single income families were in the past then the family is really worse off due to the opportunity cost of spending time at work.

Obviously it is not as simple as just looking at income but the point he raised was good.
 
It is a good point.

The best way to look at the data would be individual income, not household income.

If people live by themselves more now than in 1965, (I would guess that's got to be true) then the household income becomes a muddy figure.
 
http://www.demos.org/inequality/numbers.cfm

2nd graph from the bottom.

In 1973, hourly wages for the 95th percentile grew from $30.05 to $41.70. Hourly wages for the 50th percentile grew from 12.99 to 14.29.
Hourly wages for the 10th percentile grew from 6.79 to 7.20.

Some other interesting graphs on there.
 
While the income tax is progressive generally it turns regressive at higher income levels. The IRS publishes demographic data on taxes v adjusted gross income. Those with incomes over 1,000,000/yr have seen the percentage of taxes drop. This was not true prior to about 2002.

Didn't Buffett quip that he paid a smaller percentage of taxes than his secretary?

http://www.irs.gov/taxstats/index.html
 
http://www.demos.org/inequality/numbers.cfm

2nd graph from the bottom.

In 1973, hourly wages for the 95th percentile grew from $30.05 to $41.70. Hourly wages for the 50th percentile grew from 12.99 to 14.29.
Hourly wages for the 10th percentile grew from 6.79 to 7.20.

Some other interesting graphs on there.

In all fairness, I'll point out that this is not the best measure in the world. Teachers (and I'm guessing a lot of other professionals) readily make $40+ an hour. My own district tops out at $84,000 a year for 182 days of work (7.25 hours a day): $63 an hour.

Household income is still a useful metric. If you assume a relatively even amount of wage earners per household across income levels, the income inequality is obvious. If you want to argue that households in the top 20% are, say, three times more likely to be dual income households, that would explain why they're making much more than the bottom 20%, but wouldn't explain the increasingly large share of the income pie the top 20% have been getting over the last 30 years. Unlesss you could further argue that the increase in dual income households in the past 30 years has been disproportianately larger in well off households as compared to poor households. I don't know where you would get the stats for that.
 
You still haven't proven that the impoverishment of the lower 20% or the middle class is absolute as opposed to relative.

ie - "yes i have a 2003 lexus, but my neighbor has a 2009 mercedes e class.."

Going back to this for a moment, your car example hints at another factor which is the CPI and the "hedonic" adjustments to inflation statistics that the U.S. has used since the '90s (iirc). For example, a car today might cost twice as much as a car in 1970 but it has airbags, a CD player, and GPS that didn't exist in 1970. Therefore, the way inflation is calculated, the new car is "worth" more and might only reflect a 50% increase in cost (numbers made up for illustration).

So in one sense, the impoverishment is absolute, not relative, because those qualitative changes in consumer goods are supposedly built into U.S. inflation statistics.

But on the other hand, what would the picture look like if we were to discard those arguably meaningless and deceptive adjustments and look at the real inflation numbers? I would imagine that low and middle class incomes have not only stagnated but have dropped.
 
I may have a ridiculously simplistic idea on how income disparity works against the economy, but here it is. Consider both repartition :

repartition 1:
1 person with 1 million
6 persons around 100000
3 persons Around 10000

repartition 2 :
2 persons with 400000
1 persons with 200000
6 persons around 100000
1 persons around 10000

In repartition 1 and 2 you have around the same amount of money but distributed differently.

In repartition 1 a minority with a majority of the capital (66%) can do heavy investment which may or may not have windfall on the one with less income.
But there is so many widget that they can buy, and the 3 lowest will be severely limited.

In repartition 2, invest will be less per persons, but more can invest , and in total for the same amount, but people can buy more expansive widget in greater quantity.

Some argue that repartition 1 is better for the economy due to re-investment, but in reality the re-investment can be anywhere (offshore) or even only in paper money, or in local industry, or in tax haven, or ... anywhere.

Some argue that repartition 2 because you have far more people which can more diversely invest, buy more stuff, and you limit poverty. You limit invest too, but invest will be more diversified between people.

I tend to think repartition 2 would tend to have less invest to be spread on the economy in average, but seem far more stable than repartition 1 which 1) leave the invest into the hand of a few which can do MORE error 2) leave a far higher part of the population in an unstable situation. unstable situation = not very good on the long term for your society either. I tend to favor stability to economic growth...
 
I may have a ridiculously simplistic idea on how income disparity works against the economy, but here it is. Consider both repartition :

repartition 1:
1 person with 1 million
6 persons around 100000
3 persons Around 10000

repartition 2 :
2 persons with 400000
1 persons with 200000
6 persons around 100000
1 persons around 10000

In repartition 1 and 2 you have around the same amount of money but distributed differently.

In repartition 1 a minority with a majority of the capital (66%) can do heavy investment which may or may not have windfall on the one with less income.
But there is so many widget that they can buy, and the 3 lowest will be severely limited.

In repartition 2, invest will be less per persons, but more can invest , and in total for the same amount, but people can buy more expansive widget in greater quantity.

Some argue that repartition 1 is better for the economy due to re-investment, but in reality the re-investment can be anywhere (offshore) or even only in paper money, or in local industry, or in tax haven, or ... anywhere.

Some argue that repartition 2 because you have far more people which can more diversely invest, buy more stuff, and you limit poverty. You limit invest too, but invest will be more diversified between people.

I tend to think repartition 2 would tend to have less invest to be spread on the economy in average, but seem far more stable than repartition 1 which 1) leave the invest into the hand of a few which can do MORE error 2) leave a far higher part of the population in an unstable situation. unstable situation = not very good on the long term for your society either. I tend to favor stability to economic growth...

Let me add another repartition, which is very unstable:

repartition 3:
1 person with 100 million
6 persons around 1000
3 persons around 100

Repartion (1) is a step in the direction of (3). (2) is a step away from
(3). Repartion (1) should be avoided on those grounds alone.
 
One of the issues with the current or just ended recession (depending upon which set of numbers you see) is that the people who HAD the capital weren't the people who needed the capital to create jobs and wealth.
But the much larger issue was that most of the "capital" was not capital at all, but obligations: obligations that could never have conceivably been met.
 
I tend to favor stability to economic growth...
What does this mean? Economic stagnation (non-growth) is pretty highly correlated with instability. Whatever the social ills of income inequality might be, they are considerably less malign than those associated with the absence of growth in income.
 
If people live by themselves more now than in 1965, (I would guess that's got to be true)....

It appears that it is true.

United States:
"In 1950, just 9.3% of U.S. households consisted of people living alone, according to the Census Bureau."
"About 27.2 million Americans lived alone in 2000, accounting for about 26% of all households and about 9.7% of the overall U.S. population"
http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2005-09-02-living-alone_x.htm

This includes women living alone:
"In 2005, 51 percent of women said they were living without a spouse, up from 35 percent in 1950 and 49 percent in 2000."
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/16/us/16census.html

Canada:
"More people were living alone in 2006, according to census data. During the past five years, the number of one-person households increased 11.8%, to 3.3 million. This growth continued the trend found by previous censuses."
http://www12.statcan.ca/census-recensement/2006/as-sa/97-554/p6-eng.cfm

Britain:
"According to the latest statistics, the population has grown by five per cent over the past 30 years, but the number of households with just one occupant is up by 31 per cent."
http://www.esrcsocietytoday.ac.uk/ESRCInfoCentre/PO/releases/2005/January/index01.aspx

Australia:
(hasn't changed much, at least for people in their 20's)
"In both 2001 and 1976, 21% of people in their 20s were living as partners in couples without children, and in both years, 8% of people in this age group were living alone."
http://www.abs.gov.au/Ausstats/[email protected]!OpenDocument
(but also see the next link)

Global Cities:
"The emergence of one-person households is geographically widespread and particularly prevalent in world cities such as London, Paris, Stockholm and New York. As more and more people are living alone either by choice or circumstances, in some cities as many as 50% of people are now living alone, and this number is expected to continue growing."
http://www.adelaide.edu.au/news/news29221.html

FWIW ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom