Inequality-Indexing of the Tax System

Malerin

Banned
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
3,341
Robert Shiller was on CNN's GPS program and casually mentioned a paper he'd done about indexing income tax to income inequality. It seemed like a very clever way to keep inequality of wealth under control.

http://www.tobinproject.org/welcome/downloads/RP_Inequality-Indexing.pdf

It's a very short paper. Basically, we keep the progressive tax system we currently have in place, but the rates would fluctuate according to the level of income inequality. A system like Shiller proposes would have resulted in marginal top rates of 75%+ in 1979, and probbaly much higher for 2009. Median household income has pretty much stayed flat for the last decade.

Some questions I have:
- Would the govt. have a perverse incentive to pursue policices that would keep income inequlity high in order to bring in more revenue? Could that be avoided by a mandate to invest extra revenue into, say, paying down the debt?
- Would ultra-high rates result in a lot of wealthy people leaving the country for greener (tax) pastures?
- A household with two teachers (or teacher + firefighter, or nurse + police officer, etc.) could easily be in the $100,000+ household income range. That puts them in the top 15%. How much would their rates go up if income inequality is on the rise?
- Is income inequality as big a problem as Shiller assumes it is?
 
I think it's a bad idea.

The premise is that wealth inequality is a bad thing. Why?

I think people forget that capital itself is productive, and that the "inequality of wealth is bad" argument, in order to be valid, must (at the very least) show that the wage rate increases slower than the interest rate on capital.

I think they are both about the same rate, give or take.
 
Would the amount of paperwork generated by a constantly fluctuating tax rate drive everyone batcrap insane?
 
Would the amount of paperwork generated by a constantly fluctuating tax rate drive everyone batcrap insane?

Not really, no. Tax forms and tables are generated yearly anyway, to keep up with changes in tax law. Printing a different tax table to reflect a marginal tax rate of 61% instead of last years 63% would be trivial.
 
I think it's a bad idea.

The premise is that wealth inequality is a bad thing. Why?

Because it correlates with -- and seems to cause, although that's harder to prove -- lots of bad things.

I think people forget that capital itself is productive,

That's right. People tend to forget things that aren't true. I consider this to be a good thing.

Capital itself is not productive. The credit freeze proved that, if nothing else. Capital is only productive when people do things with it, and one of the easiest ways to put in the hands of the people who can do this with it is via wealth equality. One of the issues with the current or just ended recession (depending upon which set of numbers you see) is that the people who HAD the capital weren't the people who needed the capital to create jobs and wealth.
 
I disagree with: "The most essential long-term economic problem of this century is the risk that income inequality will get substantially worse than it is today." A more essential long term problem is—for example—the risk that income fails to rise in the large parts of the world where it has stagnated at subsistence level for the last century.

I also disagree with the part about "merely acknowledging that the progressivity of the tax system is designed to address inequality", because it isn’t. Rather—it is designed to redress arbitrary luck in the allocation of endowments, and to provide a threshold income level that is viewed as a moral requirement by (a wealthy enough) society. I don’t think that is exactly the same as what Shiller writes—which would be why progressive income tax systems don’t already have a responsive link to a Lorenz curve.

If Shiller is calling for a greater level or redistribution than currently exists (in the US) then it would be better to call for that. Otherwise, I think that the argument that inequality per se is adverse needs to be sold more persuasively on ethical and/or economic grounds.
 
Because it correlates with -- and seems to cause, although that's harder to prove -- lots of bad things.



That's right. People tend to forget things that aren't true. I consider this to be a good thing.

Capital itself is not productive. The credit freeze proved that, if nothing else. Capital is only productive when people do things with it, and one of the easiest ways to put in the hands of the people who can do this with it is via wealth equality. One of the issues with the current or just ended recession (depending upon which set of numbers you see) is that the people who HAD the capital weren't the people who needed the capital to create jobs and wealth.

Fair enough. How do you respond to the fact that the capital return rate is relatively consistent with the wage rate?

In other words, the rich get richer, the poor get richer...
 
Also... post hoc ergo propter hoc..

The fact that causation is merely plausible at best for a few of the social ills mentioned in the equality article, is pretty important.

I ate an ice cream cone on september 10th, therefore, my consumption of ice cream cones caused 9/11.

You can't say wealth inequality is bad until it's proven. Someone prove it.
 
Fair enough. How do you respond to the fact that the capital return rate is relatively consistent with the wage rate?

In other words, the rich get richer, the poor get richer...

How are you defining "rich"? From 1965 on, household income levels have been nearly flat for the bottom 20 percent of the country. The top 20% have seen incomes steadily rise, with a very large rise in the top 5% (nearly 100% growth in the last 40 years).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distribution_1967-2003.svg


Also, the share of pre-tax household income has been climbing steadily for the top 1% since 1985 (from around 9% to around 17%). Now, correlation is not casuation, but it's striking that the year where the top 1%'s share was greatest just happened to be 1929. And just as we were approaching those 1929 levels, we just had a near-depression.

Here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Share_top_1%.jpg

Perhaps we have a self-correcting mechanism when income inequality gets too extreme. Too bad depressions and severe recessions disproportianetly affect the poor and middle class. I don't think Gates, Buffet, Ellison, the Walton clan, Soros, etc. worry too much about unemployment or being foreclosed on.


Do you think it's healthy for a society for the slice of "income pie" to grow increasingly larger for an increasingly smaller number of people? As Disco Stu would say, "If these trends continue...".

Let them eat cake?
 
....One of the issues with the current or just ended recession (depending upon which set of numbers you see) is that the people who HAD the capital weren't the people who needed the capital to create jobs and wealth.
Very good point which I feel is over looked by some. An economy which functions without booms and bust is a balance between the two.

I get this feeling that the rich don't want to pay the piper, they want to be the piper.
 
How many revolutions in recent history have occured where economic issues were not a factor?
The cause of revolutions is a complex phenomena that can't be explained merely by economic issues. The economy was one part of the American Revolution, but there were other predominant issues present.
 
The cause of revolutions is a complex phenomena that can't be explained merely by economic issues. The economy was one part of the American Revolution, but there were other predominant issues present.

Sure, but look at some of the major revolutions of the 20th century: China, Russia, Vietnam, Cuba, N. Korea, Cambodia, etc. All predicated on the belief that an egalitarian "worker's paradise" could be achieved and was worth dying for. Would any of those revolutions have happened without an extreme divide between rich and poor?
 
- Would the govt. have a perverse incentive to pursue policices that would keep income inequlity high in order to bring in more revenue?

That doesn't make much sense and doesn't appear to be at all related to how our government works. What kind of policies were you thinking of? I also don't see how paying down the debt would have any related benefit in terms of increasing economic equality.

- Would ultra-high rates result in a lot of wealthy people leaving the country for greener (tax) pastures?

Did that happen to any significant degree in the '60s when the top bracket was around 90%? And if so, so what? Where's the negative effect?

- A household with two teachers (or teacher + firefighter, or nurse + police officer, etc.) could easily be in the $100,000+ household income range. That puts them in the top 15%. How much would their rates go up if income inequality is on the rise?

So, there are still two brackets above them. The top 1% is the problem, not the top 15 or 20% (the middle to upper-middle class).

My main problem with the concept of an inequality index is that I see no reason why the upper brackets should ever go down. Why not just raise them up and keep them there? Assuming that we want to reduce inequality and that higher taxes on the extremely wealthy would help achieve that, then why wouldn't we just find a good rate and stick with it? Is there any danger of too much income equality? I see no evidence that there was any such problem when top rates were at 90%.

The other problem is that, as with so many tax discussions, it focuses on taxing wages and ignores the types of taxes that truly affect the extremely wealthy, like capital gains and the estate tax.
 
How are you defining "rich"? From 1965 on, household income levels have been nearly flat for the bottom 20 percent of the country. The top 20% have seen incomes steadily rise, with a very large rise in the top 5% (nearly 100% growth in the last 40 years).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distribution_1967-2003.svg


Also, the share of pre-tax household income has been climbing steadily for the top 1% since 1985 (from around 9% to around 17%). Now, correlation is not casuation, but it's striking that the year where the top 1%'s share was greatest just happened to be 1929. And just as we were approaching those 1929 levels, we just had a near-depression.

Here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Share_top_1%.jpg

Perhaps we have a self-correcting mechanism when income inequality gets too extreme. Too bad depressions and severe recessions disproportianetly affect the poor and middle class. I don't think Gates, Buffet, Ellison, the Walton clan, Soros, etc. worry too much about unemployment or being foreclosed on.


Do you think it's healthy for a society for the slice of "income pie" to grow increasingly larger for an increasingly smaller number of people? As Disco Stu would say, "If these trends continue...".

Let them eat cake?

You still haven't proven that the impoverishment of the lower 20% or the middle class is absolute as opposed to relative.

ie - "yes i have a 2003 lexus, but my neighbor has a 2009 mercedes e class.."
 
You still haven't proven that the impoverishment of the lower 20% or the middle class is absolute as opposed to relative.

uh...

From 1965 on, household income levels have been nearly flat for the bottom 20 percent of the country. The top 20% have seen incomes steadily rise, with a very large rise in the top 5% (nearly 100% growth in the last 40 years).

The top has seen enormous gains. The bottom is almost flat and it takes nearly twice as much labor to get even that (compare the single income family of 1965 to the two income family of today). Given that there are still people going hungry, living on the street, dying without healthcare, I think it's pretty self evident that there is an income disparity on an absolute level which can be addressed pretty easily by raising taxes on the extremely wealthy.

Now if we were talking about a country which guaranteed everyone food, shelter and health care, and we truly were talking about the difference between a mercedes and a lexus in the driveway then you may have a point. But you don't.
 
The bottom is almost flat and it takes nearly twice as much labor to get even that (compare the single income family of 1965 to the two income family of today).

How many dual income families are in the bottom 20% of households by income?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom