Robert Shiller was on CNN's GPS program and casually mentioned a paper he'd done about indexing income tax to income inequality. It seemed like a very clever way to keep inequality of wealth under control.
http://www.tobinproject.org/welcome/downloads/RP_Inequality-Indexing.pdf
It's a very short paper. Basically, we keep the progressive tax system we currently have in place, but the rates would fluctuate according to the level of income inequality. A system like Shiller proposes would have resulted in marginal top rates of 75%+ in 1979, and probbaly much higher for 2009. Median household income has pretty much stayed flat for the last decade.
Some questions I have:
- Would the govt. have a perverse incentive to pursue policices that would keep income inequlity high in order to bring in more revenue? Could that be avoided by a mandate to invest extra revenue into, say, paying down the debt?
- Would ultra-high rates result in a lot of wealthy people leaving the country for greener (tax) pastures?
- A household with two teachers (or teacher + firefighter, or nurse + police officer, etc.) could easily be in the $100,000+ household income range. That puts them in the top 15%. How much would their rates go up if income inequality is on the rise?
- Is income inequality as big a problem as Shiller assumes it is?
http://www.tobinproject.org/welcome/downloads/RP_Inequality-Indexing.pdf
It's a very short paper. Basically, we keep the progressive tax system we currently have in place, but the rates would fluctuate according to the level of income inequality. A system like Shiller proposes would have resulted in marginal top rates of 75%+ in 1979, and probbaly much higher for 2009. Median household income has pretty much stayed flat for the last decade.
Some questions I have:
- Would the govt. have a perverse incentive to pursue policices that would keep income inequlity high in order to bring in more revenue? Could that be avoided by a mandate to invest extra revenue into, say, paying down the debt?
- Would ultra-high rates result in a lot of wealthy people leaving the country for greener (tax) pastures?
- A household with two teachers (or teacher + firefighter, or nurse + police officer, etc.) could easily be in the $100,000+ household income range. That puts them in the top 15%. How much would their rates go up if income inequality is on the rise?
- Is income inequality as big a problem as Shiller assumes it is?