imminent merger of supermassive black holes?

By far most of the energy involved will be gravitational waves, and it will be a monumental amount of energy. We’re talking a significant fraction of the mass of these black holes, which are quite massive. But gravitational waves don’t dump that energy into surrounding matter very quickly, they mostly just pass through stuff, so probably little effect on life in the galaxy directly from that. The potentially more deadly effects might come from anything happening to the accretion disks. If they flare up, then I’m not sure what that might do to nearby life, or what counts as “nearby”.
Great idea for a book: we see a string of huge spaceships (large enough for us to see their propulsion light) fleeing the galaxy. They had time to prepare and launched some time ago, timing the departure from the galaxy to coincide with the predicted merger so they actually left years ago.
 
Last edited:
Great idea for a book: we see a string of huge spaceships (large enough for us to see their propulsion light) fleeing the galaxy. They had time to prepare and launched some time ago, timing the departure from the galaxy to coincide with the predicted merger so they actually left years ago.

Sort of already been done.
 
A lot of story ideas have been done. Look at Star Wars and tell me that plot isn't a well known trope.

It's how you write the story that can make a great new novel. I'm not picturing a Ring World in my plot.

I'm not going to write that story. I already have a finished sci-fi young adult novel that I am beginning the marketing task for. And I have the second novel that goes with it started. After that if I'm still alive I have a non-fiction idea, The Real History of Nursing, in mind.
 
It's both. Which you noticed:

Sadly, I expect all us lay people will see is a short lived new star, if that. This is in a nearby galaxy, not within the Milky Way. That's probably a good thing.

Yeah but I got the speed differences wrong.

I am hoping for lots of good science from the resultant light show, mainly in the gamma/x-ray spectrum.
 
Before anyone gets too excited about this though, don't forget to put on your skeptical hats. The Science article linked in the OP says the following:
But the prediction may be a mirage. It’s not clear that the observed galaxy holds a pair of black holes, let alone a pair that’s about to merge, says Scott Ransom of the National Radio Astronomy Observatory, who finds the presented evidence “pretty circumstantial.”
 
Before anyone gets too excited about this though, don't forget to put on your skeptical hats. The Science article linked in the OP says the following:

What?

First Betelgeuse didn't explode, now this?

The sky is just so disappointing sometimes.
 
Before anyone gets too excited about this though, don't forget to put on your skeptical hats. The Science article linked in the OP says the following:
That might be talking about a different pair of black holes, one assumed to be at the center of two colliding galaxies. I've been getting annoyed my search engines keep turning up colliding galaxy black holes.

These two are midsized black holes not in the center of any colliding galaxies.

I don't understand why the Science article has this mixed up but they do.
 
Last edited:
The Science article speaks of supermassive black holes in the center of two colliding galaxies. And indeed the Yang paper opens with a note about such mergers. In that same paragraph though we find this:
In this work, we report on the first system with rapid decaying periods revealed by its optical and X-ray light curves, which has decreased from about one year to one month in three years. Together with its optical hydrogen line spectroscopy, we propose that the system is an uneven mass-ratio, highly eccentric SMBH binary which will merge within three years, as predicted by the trajectory evolution model.
IOW the merger is between 2 binary stars that collapsed into black holes and are circling each other with one bigger than the other.

Dr Becky explained these were medium range black holes within a galaxy, not in the center of one (or two). That in itself was a new discovery, not that said black holes should exist but evidence they do.

After describing supermassive black holes colliding (just to confuse us ;) ) the Science article goes on:
Then, the researchers found something more: a trend they interpret as a binary pair closing in on a merger. The cycles were getting shorter, going from 1 year to 1 month in the space of 3 years. It is “the first official report of decaying periods which reduced over time,” says Youjun Lu, a theoretical astrophysicist at the National Astronomical Observatories of China, who was not part of the team.
So they have it right, just not the opening bit about supermassive black holes.


Yang et al recorded this binary pair with x-ray, visible light, and infrared light and radio interferometry using different telescopes.

The Science article says this to play the doubting Thomas role:
But Ransom is prepared for disappointment. He and others point out the team is basing its prediction on just a handful of observed cycles. Theorist Daniel D’Orazio of the Niels Bohr Institute in Copenhagen, Denmark, says some aspects of the AGN’s light curve also raise doubts. For example, he says, the ZTF archives show SDSSJ1430+2303 lacked a periodic oscillation in the years before Jiang’s team discovered it; its dim, steady emission then looked more like a standard AGN with a single supermassive black hole. “Why has [the oscillation] just turned on now?” D’Orazio asks. “I’m not sure how that steady emission fits with binary emission models.”
 
Last edited:
Dr Becky explained these were medium range black holes within a galaxy, not in the center of one (or two). That in itself was a new discovery, not that said black holes should exist but evidence they do.

I think you've gotten confused about what Dr Becky said in the video. In post #8, you quoted the list of time stamps on that video. Go back and check. Re-watch that segment of the video if you need to. But this is the time stamp:
16:43 - Imminent supermassive black hole merger

She quite clearly stated that the black holes in question are thought to be supermassive.

Now, she has made lots of YouTube videos about black holes, so maybe you later watched a different video that was about some other black holes?
 
IOW the merger is between 2 binary stars that collapsed into black holes and are circling each other with one bigger than the other.
The merger of those would be eminently detectable by LIGO. That is what LIGO does.


The Science article is about the merger of two supermassive black holes, which is not detectable by LIGO, and doesn't have anything mixed up.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom