Steve
Penultimate Amazing
Now I can help you!
In the video Dr Becky noted we will be able to if we put a LIGO detector in space where the distance between the detectors could be large enough.
Now I can help you!
In the video Dr Becky noted we will be able to if we put a LIGO detector in space where the distance between the detectors could be large enough.
Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.
That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?
Strange... I thought of the difference in distance and the time until merger and guessed about 1/36th the speed of light... 2.77%.Let’s see… Pluto’s orbit is very eccentric between ~30 and ~50AU. Say the black holes are 40AU (~6x10^12 m) from each other orbiting a barycenter directly between them. Assuming a circular orbit to make it easy, they travel pi*40AU every orbit, which only takes one month = 30*24*60*60 = 2.6x10^6 seconds. So they’re moving 6x10^12*pi / 2.6*10^6 = ~7500 km/s = 2.5% of light speed. Now that’s scootin!
Aww, look at that... I was even sorta ninja'd.Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.
That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?
I suspect they're both committed at this point, no diplomatic effort will stop it (or could have, 1.2 bya).Has either of the black holes made any statements about how they're not going to merge and anyway they're both part of the same black hole historically?
Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.
That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?
In this work, we report on the first system with rapid decaying periods revealed by its optical and X-ray light curves, which has decreased from about one year to one month in three years.
Alas... I'm ignorant again.I don't know, I was only copying what I read. And now I don't know how I posted light "month" because I don't remember reading that. It looks like that whole sentence is wrong and while I remember reading one light year because I thought is was odd, I don't see it now.
Tick-Tock: The Imminent Merger of a Supermassive Black Hole Binary (the Yang et al paper)
Sorry about that.
I don't see how my mistaken post or the correction makes your ninja'd the least bit ignorant.Alas... I'm ignorant again.
That didn't last long.![]()
This is an earlier video from Dr Becky, made last October.
The title is "Why can't LIGO detect mergers of supermassive black holes?"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqUnEObH94
Excellent discussion of why larger waves are not detectable with the current LIGO instrument. You need the whole wave which the LIGO instrument can measure if the wave is small. But if the wave is large, LIGO only sees a fraction of the wave.
By all means someone correct me if I misunderstood Dr Becky's explanation.
I don't know, I was only copying what I read. And now I don't know how I posted light "month" because I don't remember reading that. It looks like that whole sentence is wrong and while I remember reading one light year because I thought is was odd, I don't see it now.
Tick-Tock: The Imminent Merger of a Supermassive Black Hole Binary (the Yang et al paper)
Sorry about that.
What would an event like this mean in the local area?
I mean in the galaxy in question?
Would it be able to sterilize the entire galaxy of life (should it be present there)? Only in the center of the galaxy? Or not even that?
As I understand it supernovae can have an immediate effect, capable of harming life for several tens of lightyears (possibly more?), but those fling a lot of different kinds of energy all around.
What happens with these supermassive blackholes during merging? Only gravity waves, or something more?
In other words. How powerful is all of this?
(he asks with about the most open ended question possible).
It's both. Which you noticed:...
So it's their orbital period that reduced, not the distance between them.
Sadly, I expect all us lay people will see is a short lived new star, if that. This is in a nearby galaxy, not within the Milky Way. That's probably a good thing....Speeds are only going to increase as the two objects get closer to each other - angular momentum is a bitch. I can't wait for the light show!