imminent merger of supermassive black holes?

Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.

That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?

I think the quote is wrong. What's gone from 1 year to 1 month is the period of the oscillation, which is effectively the time it takes to make 1 full orbit. It's still moving hella fast though. They are thought to be orbiting each other at about the distance of Pluto, and completing that orbit in 1 month so one of them is moving ~3000X as fast as Pluto (~15 000Km/s or about 5% the speed of light) and accelerating rapidly


That's if this really is 2 supermassive black holes about to collide, the paper isn't done peer review yet and it could wrong even if it survives peer review. If correct seeing such a merger this close is a 1/10 000 year event.
 
Let’s see… Pluto’s orbit is very eccentric between ~30 and ~50AU. Say the black holes are 40AU (~6x10^12 m) from each other orbiting a barycenter directly between them. Assuming a circular orbit to make it easy, they travel pi*40AU every orbit, which only takes one month = 30*24*60*60 = 2.6x10^6 seconds. So they’re moving 6x10^12*pi / 2.6*10^6 = ~7500 km/s = 2.5% of light speed. Now that’s scootin!
Strange... I thought of the difference in distance and the time until merger and guessed about 1/36th the speed of light... 2.77%.
Because I'm lazy and uneducated in teh maths.

Took me 8 seconds. :D
 
Last edited:
Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.



That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?
Aww, look at that... I was even sorta ninja'd.
Figures. :D
 
Has either of the black holes made any statements about how they're not going to merge and anyway they're both part of the same black hole historically?
I suspect they're both committed at this point, no diplomatic effort will stop it (or could have, 1.2 bya).
I'd have suggested arming the neighboring systems against future expansion of this new merged entity.
 
Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.

That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?

I don't know, I was only copying what I read. And now I don't know how I posted light "month" because I don't remember reading that. It looks like that whole sentence is wrong and while I remember reading one light year because I thought is was odd, I don't see it now.

Tick-Tock: The Imminent Merger of a Supermassive Black Hole Binary (the Yang et al paper)
In this work, we report on the first system with rapid decaying periods revealed by its optical and X-ray light curves, which has decreased from about one year to one month in three years.

Sorry about that.
 
I do not understand why we would not be able to observe the gravitational waves using LIGO. They would need to detect that the measured length is changing over a period of seconds or hours.
One possibility is that the amplitude is too small. Cannot think of any others.
 
This is an earlier video from Dr Becky, made last October.

The title is "Why can't LIGO detect mergers of supermassive black holes?"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqUnEObH94

Excellent discussion of why larger waves are not detectable with the current LIGO instrument. You need the whole wave which the LIGO instrument can measure if the wave is small. But if the wave is large, LIGO only sees a fraction of the wave.

By all means someone correct me if I misunderstood Dr Becky's explanation.
 
Excellent discussion of why larger waves are not detectable with the current LIGO instrument. You need the whole wave which the LIGO instrument can measure if the wave is small. But if the wave is large, LIGO only sees a fraction of the wave.

By all means someone correct me if I misunderstood Dr Becky's explanation.

That is what she said. Not sure I fully understand it.
 
Honestly, after watching the video I still don't totally understand it. At about 5:20 in the video is where she explains it. She says that the distance down those L-shaped tunnels in the detector needs to be around the same length as the length of the gravitational wave that you are trying to detect. She doesn't really explain why exactly that is. There's probably some 5-head physics reason that would be pointless to try to explain to laypeople. Or maybe it's just like trying to measure a large distance with a short meter stick. You need a longer measuring tape, or something like that.

Possibly it is because once the event horizons of the black holes merge, even gravitational waves cannot escape. So even though the waves do get shorter as they spiral into each other, the waves that can escape never get short enough because the event horizon (or the Schwarzschild radius) of the black hole is too large.
 
I don't know, I was only copying what I read. And now I don't know how I posted light "month" because I don't remember reading that. It looks like that whole sentence is wrong and while I remember reading one light year because I thought is was odd, I don't see it now.

Tick-Tock: The Imminent Merger of a Supermassive Black Hole Binary (the Yang et al paper)


Sorry about that.

I didn't check the source for accuracy either :)

So it's their orbital period that reduced, not the distance between them. Still, they are (probably, if the paper survives peer review) going to travel 5-ish Billion Kilometers in 300 days (30 million seconds), which puts their (average) closing speed at ~150Km/s. If I haven't screwed the maths up again.

Speeds are only going to increase as the two objects get closer to each other - angular momentum is a bitch. I can't wait for the light show!
 
What would an event like this mean in the local area?
I mean in the galaxy in question?

Would it be able to sterilize the entire galaxy of life (should it be present there)? Only in the center of the galaxy? Or not even that?
As I understand it supernovae can have an immediate effect, capable of harming life for several tens of lightyears (possibly more?), but those fling a lot of different kinds of energy all around.

What happens with these supermassive blackholes during merging? Only gravity waves, or something more?

In other words. How powerful is all of this?
(he asks with about the most open ended question possible).
 
What would an event like this mean in the local area?
I mean in the galaxy in question?

Would it be able to sterilize the entire galaxy of life (should it be present there)? Only in the center of the galaxy? Or not even that?
As I understand it supernovae can have an immediate effect, capable of harming life for several tens of lightyears (possibly more?), but those fling a lot of different kinds of energy all around.

What happens with these supermassive blackholes during merging? Only gravity waves, or something more?

In other words. How powerful is all of this?
(he asks with about the most open ended question possible).

By far most of the energy involved will be gravitational waves, and it will be a monumental amount of energy. We’re talking a significant fraction of the mass of these black holes, which are quite massive. But gravitational waves don’t dump that energy into surrounding matter very quickly, they mostly just pass through stuff, so probably little effect on life in the galaxy directly from that. The potentially more deadly effects might come from anything happening to the accretion disks. If they flare up, then I’m not sure what that might do to nearby life, or what counts as “nearby”.
 
...
So it's their orbital period that reduced, not the distance between them.
It's both. Which you noticed:

...Speeds are only going to increase as the two objects get closer to each other - angular momentum is a bitch. I can't wait for the light show!
Sadly, I expect all us lay people will see is a short lived new star, if that. This is in a nearby galaxy, not within the Milky Way. That's probably a good thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom