If I Was An Evil Genius... Refuting Conspiracy Theories via Motive

I didn't say I had no evidence; I said I wouldn't marshal it for you folks. You all have access to the same information that I do. Like I've said before: if you have looked at the available materials, both for and against the so called conspiracy theories, and you still believe airplane damage plus fire completely destroyed the Twin Towers and Building 7, that's fine by me. Nothing I can refer to outside my own head will change your mind. I can only give you my own take on what happened. The data is the same, the evidence is the same. It's just how you interpret it that matters.

Opinion, what one sees and hears, these are up for intepretation. Scientific Facts, laws of physics, these are not.

TAM:)
 
@Wildcat - My reluctance to discuss anything in detail? Why don't you try responding substantively instead of accusing me of lying about who I am. Yeah, you're right, I flip burgers at McDonald's. Can't you tell.
So why, when pressed for details, do you respond with...

I honestly haven't looked into it enough to try and debate you about it. Can we move on to the WTC please?
Classic CTist detail avoidance right there.
 
OK Golden Bear, you want to discuss, then explain your stance on this:
It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance. Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building?
Now, a real scientist would have some calculations showing that the energy required for 25-odd storys to simply crush through the lower structure is more than the energy required for those 25-odd storys to travel sideways (resisting gravity) a hundred feet to your "path of least resistance". Can you do that?

The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure.
Show your calculations for this also. I'm interested to see how such a large mass is expected to fall in a direction other than straight down.

eta: ironically, I've had CTists also argue that the "lateral ejections" from the collapsing towers proved CD, while others argue exactly the opposite. :rolleyes:
 
That doesn't make you even. If you have no evidence for it, why do you believe the LIHOP hypothesis?
The reason I have not written off LIHOP completely is based on the insider irritations that have been published on the GWB administration's lack of energy in pursuing anti-terrorist measures between January 2001 innauguration and Sept 11, 2001. The split between Sec Def and the Generals in the Pentagon is a symptom of the inner circle's disdain for professionals in their fields, to include State, Intel, Military, and others, and their conviction that "our way is the only way, keep your details to yourself if it doesn't fit our picture." The screening and myopic view on intel regarding Iraq is a striking example of how that mind set perpetuated the inner circle.

One can explain LIHOP away as "stupidity rather than malice," and that a clever and resourceful enemy can exploit one's security loopholes (Occam's Razor) but given the amount of revealed "Hey, we need to do this, boss" followed by "No, not gonna do it" I'd need more detailed policy and prioritization decision evidence to erase a small suspicion that there might have been a perceived value in getting that "new Pearl Harbor" sooner than later.

There's been some interesting writing on FDR's baiting the Japanese into an attack, in an effort to get into the war before England fell. Recall, mobilization began in 1940, and the renewal of the draft. It was easily seen as "when not if" at the policy level. It's not beyond the bounds of probabilty that a similar mind set was in place. As far as plots go, Gulf of Tonkin was a deliberate provocation. That's a matter of record. So, such a course of action is not completely irrational to contemplate.

LIHOP is very, very thin, but it's not beyond consideration. Who in the inner circle would break down and confess? I have no idea. Anyone involved would, I think, take that info to the grave with them.

There is little to go on, other than the after the fact reaction of professionals in CIA, and other government posts, who worked terrorism for a living, and had had their efforts to pursue related security projects rejected.

In defense of Occam's Razor, you can't resource every good idea a field agent or directorate comes up with, and in the international terrorism field, you are constrained by other political issues in freedom of action on others' turf when pursuing terrorists.

The FBI and Intel stovepipe problem is a long standing one, designed by Congress to preclude syping on citizens. It was a key vulnerabiity in the system. Whether this was manipulated (very low probability) or exploited by AL Q and friends (much higher odds) is an open question in my very cynical mind.

DR
 
Last edited:
Golden Bear,

Thanks for your reply.

I think the point of deviation would occur between points 6 and 7, with the tilted upper floor block not "bouncing" (for lack of better term) off to the side because it encounters asymetric resistance to its fall. Given the choice of (A) falling downwards through the intact structure below and (B) continuing to tilt through the air and falling off to the side through the path of least resistance - I think the upper floors would choose B.


I'd like to hear your explanation for this. Remember the buildings are not solid objects, but structures consisting primarily of air. Although the entire structure as a whole is strong, the individual componants are comparatively weak. In a collapse situation, the individual componants end up having to try support a mass that the structure was carefully designed to maintain.

I can't see the upper mass tipping over unless the lower mass componants are strong enough to stop it.



How could the trusses pull the outer columns inwards, initiating collapse, but then somehow leave the outer columns in place to act as a "chute" as you have called it, to initially direct the motion of the upper floors in a straight downward direction.


Only the exterior columns within the collapse zoned bowed inwards. The initial direction of the upper mass will be down because of gravity.

What I was proposing was that the exterior columns acted like a chute for the collapsing FLOOR TRUSSES, keeping the majority of floor contents etc. inside the building footprint.

I actually proposed the upper floor mass forced the exterior columns outwards in a peeling action.



The tilted area outside the outer columns would still be resisted by air alone, which would be the path of least resistance. Therefore, I still think the building would continue to tilt towards the path of least resistance.


The thing is the building doesn't tilt, it rotates. Were it tilting, it would be pivoting off a corner. But it is rotating about the centre of the upper mass, while still falling downwards. Because the centre of mass does not move outside the core-column zone of the lower section, the upper section will not fall outside it.



I also take issue with point 8. It looks to me like there isn't much mass or energy left to continue the progressive collapse. Energy is being consumed "shredding" the upper floors, which means this energy isn't going into deformation of the lower floors. Once the upper floors have been mostly shredded, there isn't much potential energy left to finish the job.


There's two things happening at once. The floor trusses are collapsing on top of each other, while at the same time the lower core is shredding the upper floors. The collapsing floors only need enough energy to break the bolts holding the floor trusses to the inner core and exterior columns.

Once the floor trusses are gone the building integrity is doomed, because it was the floor trusses that kept the building rigid.



The sudden last-minute collapse of the single remaining core section seen in the video footage is interesting. It seems to give-way with little justification (except perhaps a late-detonating explosive charge). If all of the upper floors have shredded and have little remaining energy to contribute, what caused this section of the core to suddenly fail? It is an interesting question.


Not really. The core was very strong, true, but it was never designed to stand on its own. The stripping of the floors around it and the collapsing debris would have damaged it severly.

The fact that it remained standing a few seconds longer than the exterior columns is a testiment to how strong those columns were.

It's quote common in this sort of situation for elements of a structure to remain standing for a few moments after elements around them have collapsed.

-Gumboot
 
Ok, Gravy. What exactly does having one of the trusses fail after 1.5 hours prove, in your mind anyway? And how does 3 or 4 inches of sagging magically become more than 40 inches of sagging?
Because the test was used to indicate baseline performance under design loads, not to simulate load conditions in the towers. A person who had read the NCSTAR would understand this distinction.
I recognize that a longer truss will sag more, but that is a bit extreme.
Perhaps you could provide the mathematics to support that assertion. After all, it's just Newtonian mechanics, right? Nothing abstract about deflection calculations, right?
Also, if you look at the graph showing the sagging truss, most of the sagging occurs very close to one side of the truss, instead of the middle of the truss where you would expect. I'm not suggesting the maximum sag should be right in the middle, but reasonably close to the middle, and certainly not all off to one side.
Perhaps you could provide the mathematics to support that assertion. I can show the FEA showing this, but then again, I'm just a humble civil engineer.
In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.
With all due respect, this is arguably the most pathetic post-hoc rationalization I've ever seen. You think that explosives (whose existence and placement you have failed to prove), were capable of being placed with such accuracy and foresight that an amateur piloting a 767 was able to hit the floor that was wired to go off first?
NIST ignored everything after collapse (again, except for these few conclusory unsupported statements) because they knew they couldn't explain it using fire and damage plus gravity alone.
Once again, as a lawyer, you should have taken the time to familiarize yourself with the National Construction Safety Team Act. Please show me the section where the Congress directs NIST to study events after collapse initiation.
It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance.
Umm, no. Electricity follows the path of least resistance, falling bodies will be acted upon by gravity. A brick falling from a height will not miss the concrete block in order to fall into the water because the water will give less resistance. There is no axiom in physics that supports your statement, and I'm rather disappointed that you've claimed as such.
Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building? The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure.
And yet, no one is claiming that a perfectly symmetric fall happened. It was nearly straight down, and straight enough for most casual observers, but that does not mean that it fell straight down. Perfect symmetry is not at issue here.
The probability that asymetrical damage and asymetrical fire would cause perfectly symetrical downward movement of the upper floors to occur is beyond any rational belief.
Again, your opinion here carries no weight.
In fact, we know it didn't.
Argument from plurality, speculations.
Of course, in reality the upper floors did follow the path of least resistance: The lower intact structure didn't provide any resistance because the columns were being progressively cut using explosives.
Then why did the collapse take longer than the time allowed for free-fall by the force of gravity alone?
 
And how does 3 or 4 inches of sagging magically become more than 40 inches of sagging? I recognize that a longer truss will sag more, but that is a bit extreme. Also, if you look at the graph showing the sagging truss, most of the sagging occurs very close to one side of the truss, instead of the middle of the truss where you would expect. I'm not suggesting the maximum sag should be right in the middle, but reasonably close to the middle, and certainly not all off to one side.
When you are modeling this with pen and paper, or in your head, I think it is important to recall that we cannot accurately analyze the sections and frames as a two dimensional model, since the WTC design (an elegant one that saved on weight and created considerable "empty volume" for inhabitancy) is a three dimensional, generally rectangular, web.

What can be hard for one to visualize from external photographs is the maze of interconnected metal members of varying sizes and strengths. It is these web like inter-connections that both contributed to the "bowing" (thanks to hard point connection) and the relative cohesion of the structure at and after the point of failure.
In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.
As I understand your point, the floor to be aimed at for each building is slightly different (note impact difference of about 10-20 floors between 1 & 2) and so a set of charges is rigged solely on the core columns, and no others, with the intent of forcing the floor to sag and pull.

GB said:
No, actually it's not strange. If I wanted to destroy a building and make it look like an airplane did it, I would probably start the demolition right about where the planes hit the buildings. You know, so it wouldn't be completely obvious it was destroyed using explosives.

Are you thus suggesting that the non uniform impact point was precisely planned with that in mind, so that the buildings would fall at different times, and with the confidence that the hijacker pilots would effectively hit different heights on the building to ensure that outcome?

If this is indeed the idea of WTC 1 & 2, you are presuming a very high level of talent in the amateur pilots (but not impossible), and a layer of complexity that is screwed if either fails to hit the narrow targeted floor.

I am very skeptical of this idea, if I have understood you correctly. I'll explain my basis at the end.

I like this one in particular: "The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that through energy of deformation."
In effect, a twenty or thirty story building was dropped 12 feet onto something.
A few calculations to support this bald assertion would be nice. Maybe even an estimate of the potential energy released or the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb the energy? No? Now that's what I call an authoritative report.
I think there is a thread here somewhere that had an estimate of that, sorry I don't have the link handy.
Here's another good one: "The story immediately below the stories in which the columns failed was not able to arrest this initial movement as evidenced by videos from several vantage points." If I were being paid to investigate this disaster, I would definitely wonder why the intact columns underneath the impact zone, undamaged by fire or impact mind you, "failed to arrest [or even resist] this initial movement". The statement "as evidenced by videos" is superflous and merely tells us what we already knew: what happened. It does nothing to tell us why it happened.
Golden, the failure zone had multiple floors weakened by impact and fire, not a single floor. Have you considered that in your analysis?
NIST ignored everything after collapse (again, except for these few conclusory unsupported statements) because they knew they couldn't explain it using fire and damage plus gravity alone.
I don't think so, I think their intent was to analyze for how to build structures better in the future, in a "lessons learned" methodology.
I do think the modeling of the collapse would be a great senior or masters level project for a team of mechanical or structural engineers. Not sure if any University is doing one.
It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance.
Careful of your model, Golden, it was not a free falling body, it was a mass that was attached by a steel web. The "last resistance" in modified by the tension created by all of those steel members in the "falling body" and beneath it, many parts of which were interconnected.
Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building?
The air was not providing any connective force to hold the body together, the steel was, and steel is 'stronger' than air.

The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure.
Sorry, it is being pulled/guided by the structure itself, since all of the vertical members are connected, one to the other, in tension/compression, and through the web, generally connected in all three dimension by unfailed floors struts.
(Even if this extremely improbable event of perfectly symetrical falling did occur, it is likely that the intact lower structure would provide enough resistance to arrest the downward movement of the upper floors.)
Why? The impact loading in the connections between members is dynamic loading, and remember, from just above, each impact load is transmitted throughout the structure with each of the first few "falling" impact loads. (Yes, I expect nominal amounts of this energy is dampened by absorbtion into the material, steel, with attendant strain and creep, but not all of it. )

What is hard to quantify is whether or not the series of of impact loads from the first few floors failing induced failure in sheer at the joints of lower floors. Since the impact loads were transmitted through the entire structure (steel connected to steel) it is very possible, even likely, that lower floor supports, particularly on the outer vertical members (not as strong as the core members) failed before the floors falling reached them. That would find a few of the lower floors collapsing/settling before the upper mass reached them. No, I am not up to the computer modeling that I can use to show this. It is a limitation of my analysis, but it is a valid scenario given the way the building was constucted, and the nature of energy transfer in basically rigid metals (steel). (Yes, I know that steel is ductile as compared to glass, or other brittle materials.)

Do you see how the dynamic load energy would be transmitted?
(Side note - We can all at least agree that the lower intact structure would provide much more resistance to movement of the upper floors than air would provide, right? Or do I need to provide calculations for that one?)
No, see my point above about the transmission of impact loads, in sheer, on the lower floors. The critical failure would be where the floor meets the vertical, outer, member. Not sure about floor/inner core. Another limitation of my analysis.
The probability that asymetrical damage and asymetrical fire would cause perfectly symetrical downward movement of the upper floors to occur is beyond any rational belief.
Only if you treat the top of the building as a free body, unconnected to the vertical members in tension/compression. The building was not sliced at the point of impact. The failure in the failure zone was not uniform.
In fact, we know it didn't. The upper block of floors on one of the towers started to tilt before or during its fall, which means it certainly could not have fallen straight down, perfectly symetrically onto the lower structure beneath.
And remained connected to the rest of the structure in tension, via the initially unsevered vertical members and the web.
This irregularity in resistance between the lower structure and the air around the upper floors would have expressed itself and the upper block of stories would have continued to tilt, fall off to one side, through the air, which provided the path of least resistance. Think about it - a falling block of floors which is tilted when it impacts the lower structure has part of the floor block hanging out over the edge of the intact structure below at impact.
You are ignoring the steel web structure of the buildings. The floors were not "sliced" and "severed."
This means that air is the only thing resisting the fall of this overhanging portion of the upper floors. The portion of the floor block encountering more resistance from the intact structure will fall slower than the portion of the floor block encountering less resistance from the air, which will cause the floor block to tilt even more, and fall off to the side through the air.
No, you are ignoring the connections of the remaining undamaged vertical members, from the ground up via joint connections, in tension/compression.
Of course, in reality the upper floors did follow the path of least resistance: The lower intact structure didn't provide any resistance
True enough, if you say "enough resistance" as evidenced by the structure's collapse
because the columns were being progressively cut using explosives. It is the only logical explanation as to why the upper floors didn't fall off to the side through the air.
No, it is not the ONLY LOGICAL explanation, but it might have been pulled off by an Evil Genius who had secreted a lot of cutting charges on the core vertical members. How he planned to do that undetected, and in a configuration that the pilots flying the planes could influence by hitting precisely the correct floors to take advantage of the prepositioned charges stretches my skepticism.

My analysis is informed by:

Degree in Mechanical Engineering

Two masters degrees in other fields, but NOT engineering (similar to your furthered education, but I am no lawyer)

Experience in aerodynamics structures and fabrication, to include rotor blades and aircraft tubs and frames

25 years as a pilot, and about 9 as a flight instructor (this regarding my remark on the novice pilots and their aim.)

A thorough examination of what I can find on the web regarding how the structure was built, and where the strength was, and how loads were distributed.

I do not pretend to be enough of an expert to go beyond the coarse analysis that I offer you, Golden, but the core problem with your assumptions is that I find you discount the web structure of the building, and the tendency it gives to hold the structure together, and for the vertical members in tension to act as a guiding force, without having given it proper consideration.

DR
 
Last edited:
I also take issue with point 8. It looks to me like there isn't much mass or energy left to continue the progressive collapse. Energy is being consumed "shredding" the upper floors, which means this energy isn't going into deformation of the lower floors. Once the upper floors have been mostly shredded, there isn't much potential energy left to finish the job. The sudden last-minute collapse of the single remaining core section seen in the video footage is interesting. It seems to give-way with little justification (except perhaps a late-detonating explosive charge). If all of the upper floors have shredded and have little remaining energy to contribute, what caused this section of the core to suddenly fail? It is an interesting question.

Small point but I think you mean Kinetic Energy here. Potential Energy only changes with the height of the object relative to a reference frame.
 
GB is trying to present some stuff but he has no facts on the WTC or energy. Unlike you with no argument at all except when a real nut case comes along you help debunk your own camp, albeit total idiots with no planes, they are only a fraction past your insane claims of explosives.

You are funny, your best post have been to debunk truthers. You are one ironic truther.

What I like about you beachnut is that no matter how many times you get slapped down you still come back like a punch drunk fighter that has run out of ideas and can only flail at his opponent.
 
Respectfully, gumboot didn't provide any calculations to support his analysis, so I don't see why I should be required to do so. It just seems to me that energy being used up shredding the upper stories cannot be used to continue the progressive collapse. Although many seem to think I am lying about having a degree in engineering, I am not and I do understand the principle of conservation of energy. Gumboot's analysis was fairly abstract, and I think my rebuttal was of the same vein conceptually.

These people are absolutists, there is no gap in their world view that allows for uncertainty. Bazant and NIST are their infallible god and their religion is a complete orthodoxy.

They will doubt your qualifications and expect evidence far in excess of what they themselves could understand.

Completing the holy trinity is ad hominem and strawman.

I've already been through this and come out intact, in fact I asked many of the same questions you are but, don't expect to find answers here. The best way is to rip apart their god without proposing an alternative god. Without the alternative god to attack they find it very difficult to defend the absolutist position.
 
Don't retire yet bear. Have you sat down and actually tried to come to an understanding of the potential energy available in just the part of the buildings above the impact sites? Have you thought about how the trade centers would have had to DEFY the first law of motion to have fallen sideways? For the top of the tower to fall sideways off of the rest of the building it would have had to DEFY the first law of motion. PERIOD. Maybe Sir Isaac was mistaken?

No Issac Newton wasn't wrong, you are.

The first law basically states that if everything stays the same then nothing changes. Clearly everything doesn't stay the same so something changed which was the removal of a force beneath one side of the upper floors.

The object could easily fall to the side by not applying a force to one side. Newton didn't say you could only add forces holding an object in equilibrium.
 
I've just noticed something. GB was the latest example that triggered the realization.

It's tempting to say every time, but that's too absolute (ist, for Mr Rea). So, MOST of the time when CTists are asked for calculations, the reply is "you aren't providing any, why should I?"

Oh Zing, that hurts. But it would hurt so much more if they simply provided the calculations, assuming the calculations were both correct and valid.
 
You are the one claming to be an engineer, but failed to know that "Tons of TNT" is a commonly accepted unit of energy measurement.

Strangely, I have never once been asked to answer a question about energy in terms of "Tons of TNT". I'll try that next time I get some Charpy tests back, I'll quote them to my customer in terms of "Tons of TNT". What a hoot that will be.

I think it is more about the dramatic effect of the words than it being a standard unit for energy.
 
I've just noticed something. GB was the latest example that triggered the realization.

It's tempting to say every time, but that's too absolute (ist, for Mr Rea). So, MOST of the time when CTists are asked for calculations, the reply is "you aren't providing any, why should I?"

Oh Zing, that hurts. But it would hurt so much more if they simply provided the calculations, assuming the calculations were both correct and valid.

The irony being that if they were supplied the vast majority of people on here wouldn't understand them anyway.
 
These people are absolutists, there is no gap in their world view that allows for uncertainty. Bazant and NIST are their infallible god and their religion is a complete orthodoxy.

They will doubt your qualifications and expect evidence far in excess of what they themselves could understand.

Completing the holy trinity is ad hominem and strawman.

I've already been through this and come out intact, in fact I asked many of the same questions you are but, don't expect to find answers here. The best way is to rip apart their god without proposing an alternative god. Without the alternative god to attack they find it very difficult to defend the absolutist position.
William, I don't disagree with the character of many on this sub forum to exhibit "True Believer" traits, but I think your analysis of the root of those behaviors is in error.

The catalyst to this entire subforum was the Avery slander job "Loose Change." Following that, a battle was undertaken over the past year, with Gravy's rebuttal to the slander, errors, and lies of Avery.

In the process, some very well argued analysis has come to light to confirm the Occam's Razor initial position: the planes hit the buildings, and the collapse was a direct and indirect effect of that cause, with the agency of damage, fire, and fire coating loss.

The above has become canonical.

Furthermore, the standard MIHOP argument includes some absurdities regarding the Pentagon attack, and the Flight 93 event, while LIHOP at the least does not require any of that.

The premise of the CD canard requires some evidence to back it up, yet no evidence of the CD position can, by process of eliminiation, preclude the KISS principle analysis of the three agency cause and effect I noted above.

To thus assert a CD cause for the effect is to make a case that is not as strong as the case made for the other position.

Do you understand this?

DR
 
I'd like to hear your explanation for this. Remember the buildings are not solid objects, but structures consisting primarily of air. Although the entire structure as a whole is strong, the individual componants are comparatively weak. In a collapse situation, the individual componants end up having to try support a mass that the structure was carefully designed to maintain.

With respect, you can't have it both ways. You can't attack Judy Wood for simplifying the structure into a solid and then say that it acted as a solid to break through the lower floors.

Which one is your model? Is it a hollow structure or a solid one?
 
Last edited:
The irony being that if they were supplied the vast majority of people on here wouldn't understand them anyway.

I've noticed that your last several posts have primarily been gross generalizaiotns against JREF posters. This statement is personally insulting to me and the other engineers on this board who go out of our way to post calculations and mathematics.

These people are absolutists, there is no gap in their world view that allows for uncertainty. Bazant and NIST are their infallible god and their religion is a complete orthodoxy.

For someone who has complained about being pigeon-holed as a conspiracy theorist and being unfairly accused of being as such, you are quite willing to lump all JREF forum members in one group and insult them.
 
William, I don't disagree with the character of many on this sub forum to exhibit "True Believer" traits, but I think your analysis of the root of those behaviors is in error.
The catalyst to this entire subforum was the Avery slander job "Loose Change." Following that, a battle was undertaken over the past year, with Gravy's rebuttal to the slander, errors, and lies of Avery.
In the process, some very well argued analysis has come to light to confirm the Occam's Razor initial position: the planes hit the buildings, and the collapse was a direct and indirect effect of that cause, with the agency of damage, fire, and fire coating loss.
The above has become canonical.
Furthermore, the standard MIHOP argument includes some absurdities regarding the Pentagon attack, and the Flight 93 event, while LIHOP at the least does not require any of that.
The premise of the CD canard requires some evidence to back it up, yet no evidence of the CD position can, by process of eliminiation, preclude the KISS principle analysis of the three agency cause and effect I noted above.
To thus assert a CD cause for the effect is to make a case that is not as strong as the case made for the other position.
Do you understand this?
DR

I understand exactly what you are saying DR.

As long as people understand that there is fallibility.
 
What I said was that I would consider a lawyer who states that no manner of evidence would cause him to rethink the strength or weakness of his case to be an embarrassment to the profession.

Who is misprepresenting whom? I clarified my statement by saying that I didn't think anyone here would cause me to rethink my case. I said this because NIST had several years and millions of dollars at their disposal and failed to convince me. Does anyone here have still more millions available to investigate the collapses?

Congratulations, you and me both are now guilty of ebarrassing our profession by misrepresenting the other. Feel better now?

Also, I have put forth facts and analysis, which you have utterly failed to substantively respond to. Admittedly, I haven't provided much quantitative analysis outside a few references to the NIST report, but neither have any of you. Instead of lobbing the now tired "childish" or "immature" comments back and forth, let's stick to substantive analysis.
 
I've noticed that your last several posts have primarily been gross generalizaiotns against JREF posters. This statement is personally insulting to me and the other engineers on this board who go out of our way to post calculations and mathematics.
For someone who has complained about being pigeon-holed as a conspiracy theorist and being unfairly accused of being as such, you are quite willing to lump all JREF forum members in one group and insult them.

You of course were not included in the "vast majority".

I don't believe the generalisations are out of proportion, you can see that by the way they have rounded on Golden Bear. I'm probably getting "emotional" about this at this point because Golden Bear is going through exactly what I did when I initially came to this forum. It's hard for me to watch it without being defensive for him and feeling like I am also being attacked.

I will pull back from this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom