And how does 3 or 4 inches of sagging magically become more than 40 inches of sagging? I recognize that a longer truss will sag more, but that is a bit extreme. Also, if you look at the graph showing the sagging truss, most of the sagging occurs very close to one side of the truss, instead of the middle of the truss where you would expect. I'm not suggesting the maximum sag should be right in the middle, but reasonably close to the middle, and certainly not all off to one side.
When you are modeling this with pen and paper, or in your head, I think it is important to recall that we cannot accurately analyze the sections and frames as a two dimensional model, since the WTC design (an elegant one that saved on weight and created considerable "empty volume" for inhabitancy) is a three dimensional, generally rectangular, web.
What can be hard for one to visualize from external photographs is the maze of interconnected metal members of varying sizes and strengths. It is these web like inter-connections that both contributed to the "bowing" (thanks to hard point connection) and the relative cohesion of the structure at and after the point of failure.
In any event, the inward pulling forces on the exterior columns could just as easily been caused by explosives. If the core columns are cut just below the impact floor, the still attached core structure will no longer have any support underneath it, fall downwards, and pull the outer columns (which it is still attached to via the trusses) inward as seen in the pictures in your post.
As I understand your point, the floor to be aimed at for each building is slightly different (note impact difference of about 10-20 floors between 1 & 2) and so a set of charges is rigged solely on the core columns, and no others, with the intent of forcing the floor to sag and pull.
GB said:
No, actually it's not strange. If I wanted to destroy a building and make it look like an airplane did it, I would probably start the demolition right about where the planes hit the buildings. You know, so it wouldn't be completely obvious it was destroyed using explosives.
Are you thus suggesting that the non uniform impact point was precisely planned with that in mind, so that the buildings would fall at different times, and with the confidence that the hijacker pilots would effectively hit different heights on the building to ensure that outcome?
If this is indeed the idea of WTC 1 & 2, you are presuming a very high level of talent in the amateur pilots (but not impossible), and a layer of complexity that is screwed if either fails to hit the narrow targeted floor.
I am very skeptical of this idea, if I have understood you correctly. I'll explain my basis at the end.
I like this one in particular: "The potential energy released by the downward movement of the large building mass far exceeded the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb that through energy of deformation."
In effect, a twenty or thirty story building was dropped 12 feet onto something.
A few calculations to support this bald assertion would be nice. Maybe even an estimate of the potential energy released or the capacity of the intact structure below to absorb the energy? No? Now that's what I call an authoritative report.
I think there is a thread here somewhere that had an estimate of that, sorry I don't have the link handy.
Here's another good one: "The story immediately below the stories in which the columns failed was not able to arrest this initial movement as evidenced by videos from several vantage points." If I were being paid to investigate this disaster, I would definitely wonder why the intact columns underneath the impact zone, undamaged by fire or impact mind you, "failed to arrest [or even resist] this initial movement". The statement "as evidenced by videos" is superflous and merely tells us what we already knew: what happened. It does nothing to tell us why it happened.
Golden, the failure zone had multiple floors weakened by impact and fire, not a single floor. Have you considered that in your analysis?
NIST ignored everything after collapse (again, except for these few conclusory unsupported statements) because they knew they couldn't explain it using fire and damage plus gravity alone.
I don't think so, I think their intent was to analyze for how to build structures better in the future, in a "lessons learned" methodology.
I do think the modeling of the collapse would be a great senior or masters level project for a team of mechanical or structural engineers. Not sure if any University is doing one.
It is axiomatic in physics that a falling body will follow the path of least resistance.
Careful of your model, Golden, it was not a free falling body, it was a mass that was attached by a steel web. The "last resistance" in modified by the tension created by all of those steel members in the "falling body" and beneath it, many parts of which were interconnected.
Which would resist the falling block of upper stories the most, the intact steel structure beneath the impact zone or the air surrounding the building?
The air was not providing any connective force to hold the body together, the steel was, and steel is 'stronger' than air.
The only possible way the upper block of stories would fall down through any of the lower structure is if it fell perfectly symetrically and straight down on top of the lower structure.
Sorry, it is being pulled/guided by the structure itself, since all of the vertical members are connected, one to the other, in tension/compression, and through the web, generally connected in all three dimension by unfailed floors struts.
(Even if this extremely improbable event of perfectly symetrical falling did occur, it is likely that the intact lower structure would provide enough resistance to arrest the downward movement of the upper floors.)
Why? The impact loading in the connections between members is dynamic loading, and remember, from just above, each impact load is transmitted throughout the structure with each of the first few "falling" impact loads. (Yes, I expect nominal amounts of this energy is dampened by absorbtion into the material, steel, with attendant strain and creep, but not all of it. )
What is hard to quantify is whether or not the series of of impact loads from the first few floors failing induced failure in sheer at the joints of lower floors. Since the impact loads were transmitted through the entire structure (steel connected to steel) it is very possible, even likely, that lower floor supports, particularly on the outer vertical members (not as strong as the core members) failed before the floors falling reached them. That would find a few of the lower floors collapsing/settling before the upper mass reached them. No, I am not up to the computer modeling that I can use to show this. It is a limitation of my analysis, but it is a valid scenario given the way the building was constucted, and the nature of energy transfer in basically rigid metals (steel). (Yes, I know that steel is ductile as compared to glass, or other brittle materials.)
Do you see how the dynamic load energy would be transmitted?
(Side note - We can all at least agree that the lower intact structure would provide much more resistance to movement of the upper floors than air would provide, right? Or do I need to provide calculations for that one?)
No, see my point above about the transmission of impact loads, in sheer, on the lower floors. The critical failure would be where the floor meets the vertical, outer, member. Not sure about floor/inner core. Another limitation of my analysis.
The probability that asymetrical damage and asymetrical fire would cause perfectly symetrical downward movement of the upper floors to occur is beyond any rational belief.
Only if you treat the top of the building as a free body, unconnected to the vertical members in tension/compression. The building was not sliced at the point of impact. The failure in the failure zone was not uniform.
In fact, we know it didn't. The upper block of floors on one of the towers started to tilt before or during its fall, which means it certainly could not have fallen straight down, perfectly symetrically onto the lower structure beneath.
And remained connected to the rest of the structure in tension, via the initially
unsevered vertical members and the web.
This irregularity in resistance between the lower structure and the air around the upper floors would have expressed itself and the upper block of stories would have continued to tilt, fall off to one side, through the air, which provided the path of least resistance. Think about it - a falling block of floors which is tilted when it impacts the lower structure has part of the floor block hanging out over the edge of the intact structure below at impact.
You are ignoring the steel web structure of the buildings. The floors were not "sliced" and "severed."
This means that air is the only thing resisting the fall of this overhanging portion of the upper floors. The portion of the floor block encountering more resistance from the intact structure will fall slower than the portion of the floor block encountering less resistance from the air, which will cause the floor block to tilt even more, and fall off to the side through the air.
No, you are ignoring the connections of the remaining undamaged vertical members, from the ground up via joint connections, in tension/compression.
Of course, in reality the upper floors did follow the path of least resistance: The lower intact structure didn't provide any resistance
True enough, if you say "enough resistance" as evidenced by the structure's collapse
because the columns were being progressively cut using explosives. It is the only logical explanation as to why the upper floors didn't fall off to the side through the air.
No, it is not the ONLY LOGICAL explanation, but it might have been pulled off by an Evil Genius who had secreted a lot of cutting charges on the core vertical members. How he planned to do that undetected, and in a configuration that the pilots flying the planes could influence by hitting precisely the correct floors to take advantage of the prepositioned charges stretches my skepticism.
My analysis is informed by:
Degree in Mechanical Engineering
Two masters degrees in other fields, but NOT engineering (similar to your furthered education, but I am no lawyer)
Experience in aerodynamics structures and fabrication, to include rotor blades and aircraft tubs and frames
25 years as a pilot, and about 9 as a flight instructor (this regarding my remark on the novice pilots and their aim.)
A thorough examination of what I can find on the web regarding
how the structure was built, and where the strength was, and how loads were distributed.
I do not pretend to be enough of an expert to go beyond the coarse analysis that I offer you, Golden, but the core problem with your assumptions is that I find you discount the web structure of the building, and the tendency it gives to hold the structure together, and for the vertical members in tension to act as a guiding force, without having given it proper consideration.
DR