If I Was An Evil Genius... Refuting Conspiracy Theories via Motive

I didn't say I had no evidence; I said I wouldn't marshal it for you folks. You all have access to the same information that I do.

One problem you have is that you are unable to accept verifiable evidence that shows your beliefs to be wrong. Therefore you live in a fantasy world. Am I wrong? Then answer this question, which I ask for the sixth time:

What did Larry Silverstein hope to "get away with," when his insurance and loan contracts were in writing and were legally enforceable?

You brought it up. If you don't live in a fantasy world, you'll either support your claim with evidence or accept that your claim is baseless and thank me for the for all the information about WTC insurance and financing that I provided.

What are you afraid of, GB? Answer the question.
 
Anyone else think that his nick(sock?) was specifically chosen to annoy(mock?) Gravy?.

And @Gravy - surely you don't believe this. Golden Bear was chosen after one of my sports idols: Jack Nicklaus, The Golden Bear.
 
What did Larry Silverstein hope to "get away with," when his insurance and loan contracts were in writing and were legally enforceable?

Did you not see me say let's assume you are right and I don't know enough to debate you on the subject? Can we please move on to the points I made specifically about the WTC?
 
Ok. I'll just spend my time arguing cases to a judge and jury. I won the very first summary judgment motion I ever drafted, and that was while I was still in law school. Where did you go to law school again, Gravy? I don't need some smug a**hole telling me I'm "immature". Can we please keep this discussion at a little bit higher level?
It goes to show no matter how much college some people have, they are still unable to understand facts and evidence or present the same. So far you seem to be just another no fact CTer. Fact less and clue less on 9/11. Better get your team of lemming truthers to drag out some lies to support your truther ideas.

You may be a lawyer, but then we have insane PhD econ majors with no planes, PhD idiot with a Beam Weapons, and now a Lawyer. What would make a lawyer able to do physics better than the Physics PhD Dr Thermite Jones who seem insane too. The dolts and insane PhDs may only demonstrate this level of ignorance on 9/11, or it may permeate their entire lives. Actually Dr Thermite Jones is very personable but very dirt dumb on 9/11. I think he has a political bias which has clouded his judgment to the point of insanity. You should read his papers.

I imagine a lawyer could mess up 9/11 and lie better than the best truther have.
 
Last edited:
Did you not see me say let's assume you are right and I don't know enough to debate you on the subject? Can we please move on to the points I made specifically about the WTC?

But GB, I gave you the information. Why do you not know enough?
 
You are now a self-proclaimed lawyer with a Stundie nomination.

Way to answer the question, Gravy. You are now just as good as the rest of the "critical thinkers" here that offer ZERO substantive rebuttal to the points I have raised.

Do you mean to tell me you don't have form responses ready for anything except the Silverstein insurance idea? Come on critical thinkers. Give me something substantive to work with.

Is a Stundie nomination a showing of disrespect around here? Well, if so, it really hurts, Gravy. Man, you are good.
 
The data is the same, the evidence is the same. It's just how you interpret it that matters.



I'd like to get an idea of where our interpretations deviate, if I may.

Here is a graphic I produced presenting the sequence for collapse in simplified form, as supported by evidence.

(Click on it to enlarge)



My sequence is as follows:

1) intact structure, showing exterior columns, core columns, and floor trusses.

2) Post impact - aircraft impact spreads Jet-A fuel through multiple impact floors, starting fires (red). Smoke begins to spread into upper floors.

3) Fire spreads upwards through building causing localised floor collapses. Floor trusses in impact zone begin to sag, pulling exterior columns inwards.

4) Moment of collapse - Bowed exterior columns fail, sending impact zone floor trusses falling downwards. This also draws collapsed exterior columns inwards. Meanwhile conditions in upper part of building have deteriorated due to spreading fire and continued structural failures.

5) Moment after collapse initiation (I would amend this graphic now to show the core failure at this point, causing fall of upper section) - failed floor trusses and exterior columns impact lower intact floor trusses, causing continued collapse which jetisons debris out lower windows.

6) Above-collapse section comes in contact with below-collapse section. Floor trusses continued to collapse downwards ahead of the upper section, collecting additional floors and burning debris as they go. Intact exterior columns act like a chute, directing all materials inwards onto intact floor trusses.

7) Intact below-collapse core section shatters descending upper section, causing it to start to break apart. Upper section pushes exterior columns of intact below-collapse section outwards in a "peeling" motion. Advanced floor truss collapses continue, accelerating with gravity.

8) Collapsing floor trusses have almost reached the ground, and the intact below-impact core has completely shredded the upper section. Exterior columns continue to peel outwards, impacting surrounding buildings. Meanwhile most of floor contents and upper section debris falls within the "chute" created by the failing floor trusses.

9) Collapse in nearly complete. Floor trusses have completely collapsed, burying tonnes of combustible material and fires, which will continue to burn for weeks. Last of exterior columns fall to ground. All that remains standing is severly damaged below-impact core section.

10) Core section begins to collapse due to severe damage and not being designed to stand on its own.

11) Collapse is complete.

At which point (1-11) would your account of what happened deviate from mine?

-Gumboot
 
But GB, I gave you the information. Why do you not know enough?

Fine, you're right. He didn't benefit personally. Now can we move on?

I hoped you wouldn't assume my nickname was chosen to mock you, just checking to make sure you didn't believe the odd suggestion that it was.
 
@William Rea - I appreciate your comments. I wasn't trying to bash civil engineers or structural engineers, just trying to bring them back down here with the rest of us. A little hyperbole was necessary to check the undeserved angelic halo attributed to them by most here.
More gibberish. Please cut the crap, GB. Got an argument to make? Make it, back it up, and be prepared to defend it.

You can't b.s. us. We're not the substitute teachers.
 
Allow me to refer you to posts 91, 95, and 111. Do you disagree with them? If so, present your evidence.
 
Way to answer the question, Gravy. You are now just as good as the rest of the "critical thinkers" here that offer ZERO substantive rebuttal to the points I have raised.

Do you mean to tell me you don't have form responses ready for anything except the Silverstein insurance idea? Come on critical thinkers. Give me something substantive to work with.

Is a Stundie nomination a showing of disrespect around here? Well, if so, it really hurts, Gravy. Man, you are good.
I now know what pdoh can do with his life! He can be a scientist like GB, or is it a lawyer. Or is it a scientist/lawyer/FBI guy who is about to loose his job?

Anyway pdoh/Docker/JessicaRabbit, if you are watching you could be a lawyer, this guy is just like you! He claims to make big buck making money but it was veiled proclamation as he discussed Gravy's 6000 posts being more than he writes in a year. He could be a slow typist like JDX, so maybe he does no make the big bucks.

Pdoh, take those night classes and be a lawyer, if this guy can do it anyone can. He is a scientist too; or was that scientologist?
 
That would be difficult, since I don't care a fig about the team. I just wear the hat because it fits and isn't filthy. :)

Aww c'mon Gravy, don't be a fair weather fan. My team didn't make the tourney either. Things'll turn around...:p

I know what you mean though, a good hat is hard to find.
 
At which point (1-11) would your account of what happened deviate from mine?

I think the point of deviation would occur between points 6 and 7, with the tilted upper floor block not "bouncing" (for lack of better term) off to the side because it encounters asymetric resistance to its fall. Given the choice of (A) falling downwards through the intact structure below and (B) continuing to tilt through the air and falling off to the side through the path of least resistance - I think the upper floors would choose B.

How could the trusses pull the outer columns inwards, initiating collapse, but then somehow leave the outer columns in place to act as a "chute" as you have called it, to initially direct the motion of the upper floors in a straight downward direction. Either the outer columns were pulled inwards or they weren't. In any case, the outer columns, even if left intact, could not have offered any resistance outside the original building cross-sectional area. The tilted area outside the outer columns would still be resisted by air alone, which would be the path of least resistance. Therefore, I still think the building would continue to tilt towards the path of least resistance.

I also take issue with point 8. It looks to me like there isn't much mass or energy left to continue the progressive collapse. Energy is being consumed "shredding" the upper floors, which means this energy isn't going into deformation of the lower floors. Once the upper floors have been mostly shredded, there isn't much potential energy left to finish the job. The sudden last-minute collapse of the single remaining core section seen in the video footage is interesting. It seems to give-way with little justification (except perhaps a late-detonating explosive charge). If all of the upper floors have shredded and have little remaining energy to contribute, what caused this section of the core to suddenly fail? It is an interesting question.
 
I
I also take issue with point 8. It looks to me like there isn't much mass or energy left to continue the progressive collapse.

At point 8:

How much energy left does it look like there is? (Joules or TNT tons equivalent please)

How much energy would there have to be to continue the progressive collapse? (Show your work)
 
take those night classes and be a lawyer, if this guy can do it anyone can.

Yes. You have clearly proved anyone can become a lawyer. Care to support this bald assertion/attack on me with any substance?

Thank you gumboot for providing a substantive response with zero ad hominems. What a rare treat around here.

The rest of you really need to think before you type. What possible evidence have I given you that I'm not a lawyer (aside from the ridiculous assumption that a lawyer could never believe the "conspiracy theories")? Is my writing too clear?
 
How much energy left does it look like there is? (Joules or TNT tons equivalent please)

How much energy would there have to be to continue the progressive collapse? (Show your work)

Respectfully, gumboot didn't provide any calculations to support his analysis, so I don't see why I should be required to do so. It just seems to me that energy being used up shredding the upper stories cannot be used to continue the progressive collapse. Although many seem to think I am lying about having a degree in engineering, I am not and I do understand the principle of conservation of energy. Gumboot's analysis was fairly abstract, and I think my rebuttal was of the same vein conceptually.
 
I think the point of deviation would occur between points 6 and 7, with the tilted upper floor block not "bouncing" (for lack of better term) off to the side because it encounters asymetric resistance to its fall. Given the choice of (A) falling downwards through the intact structure below and (B) continuing to tilt through the air and falling off to the side through the path of least resistance - I think the upper floors would choose B.

How could the trusses pull the outer columns inwards, initiating collapse, but then somehow leave the outer columns in place to act as a "chute" as you have called it, to initially direct the motion of the upper floors in a straight downward direction. Either the outer columns were pulled inwards or they weren't. In any case, the outer columns, even if left intact, could not have offered any resistance outside the original building cross-sectional area. The tilted area outside the outer columns would still be resisted by air alone, which would be the path of least resistance. Therefore, I still think the building would continue to tilt towards the path of least resistance.

I also take issue with point 8. It looks to me like there isn't much mass or energy left to continue the progressive collapse. Energy is being consumed "shredding" the upper floors, which means this energy isn't going into deformation of the lower floors. Once the upper floors have been mostly shredded, there isn't much potential energy left to finish the job. The sudden last-minute collapse of the single remaining core section seen in the video footage is interesting. It seems to give-way with little justification (except perhaps a late-detonating explosive charge). If all of the upper floors have shredded and have little remaining energy to contribute, what caused this section of the core to suddenly fail? It is an interesting question.
With only 248 tons of TNT energy available I guess your last idea was wrong. There was too much energy for global collapse. No explosives needed. Wrong on about 4 or 5 issues, seems if you had take some more physics classes you would understand why many papers explain why you are wrong, and you could be able to explain why the truth papers were wrong.

Proved wrong on your last points 5 years ago. (pdoh, now he has a degree in engineering too! a scientist, lawyer, engineer. ) You must be one real dumb engineer not to come with numbers.

No the core can not stand alone, it needed the outer shell to support it in the lateral. Sorry you are wrong on that point also. Plus, you seem to be lacking in engineering, may be you are a software engineer who does a lot of crack up jobs on buildings. Bit bucket and all. Berkley.
 
Last edited:
Yes. You have clearly proved anyone can become a lawyer. Care to support this bald assertion/attack on me with any substance?

Thank you gumboot for providing a substantive response with zero ad hominems. What a rare treat around here.

The rest of you really need to think before you type. What possible evidence have I given you that I'm not a lawyer (aside from the ridiculous assumption that a lawyer could never believe the "conspiracy theories")? Is my writing too clear?
Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury I present GB's post as evidence anyone can be a lawyer, and back that up with tons of witnesses. Should I bring in mom?

So where are you numbers and how many joules are you short of to bring down the WTC? What was g again?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom