If God Exists is it likely that one religion has teachings closer to his true nature

I must say I have a difficulty seeing the point of the question.

Assuming there is at least one god, then for some definition of "close to", either several religions are as close to the "real" version, or one of them is the closest, for whatever reason. I agree with that, but it mainly depends on what you mean by "closest to", and I don't see any consequences from this fact.
 
Doc, which point on a circle is closest to the centre?

If God exists his nature is what it is regardless of whether or not people have knowledge or it.

And one religion will be closer to his true nature whether or not people have exact knowledge of which one is closer. Truth is what it is, it is not dependent on people's beliefs.

So I now assume God exists, and that His nature is what it is regardless of anyone's knowledge of it.

Fine.

One religion may (not will) be closer to His true nature. Or any old made up thing may be closer to His true nature than any of the extant religions. You've got no way of knowing.

Of course, I don't hold with following any old made up thing. I follow the FSM.
 
Any current religion or even past religions.

My contention is that if God exists "one" of them is closest to his true nature. I don't really understand why that is so hard for some people to accept. It seems a logical assertion.

It isn't hard for us to accept. It's hard for you to see the flaw in the logic, and we're trying to show you:

Yes, a god could exist.

But, it could be a god of a nature we have yet to imagine or conceive.

Therefore, none of us may have come up with a religion that comes anywhere near that god's true nature.

Your argument is posed as a non-sequitur, and so is fallacious.



I think you left a step or two out of your proposition, which is why it isn't functioning logically.

A god, extant, could have revealed itself to a person or persons on this world in some manner.

If that god does exist, then one of our religions, past or present, might reflect that god's true nature.

But to simply postulate the existence of any god, and say that it then follows any of us have or had a clue about it, is poor logic.
 
Doc, which point on a circle is closest to the centre?


So I now assume God exists, and that His nature is what it is regardless of anyone's knowledge of it.

Fine.

One religion may (not will) be closer to His true nature. Or any old made up thing may be closer to His true nature than any of the extant religions. You've got no way of knowing.

Of course, I don't hold with following any old made up thing. I follow the FSM.
But assume a pasta God Exists. Is it likely that one religion has teachings closer to his true flavour?
 
Yes, I posed this question in my thread "Evidence for why we know the New Testament writers told the truth" which is located in the History, Literature Forum section. One person implied it was off topic, one person said I was playing a guessing game, one person changed the premise of the question and said I need to prove the existence of God. So I thought I'd bring the question in here. It is probably more related to religion than history anyway.

I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?

I agree, because it is a conditional statement. It is valid; but not necessarily sound.
 
Last edited:
If God exists his nature is what it is regardless of whether or not people have knowledge or it.

And one religion will be closer to his true nature whether or not people have exact knowledge of which one is closer. Truth is what it is, it is not dependent on people's beliefs.

If the religions are going to be getting different things right and different things wrong all over the place, how would you go about judging which one is closer? If religion 1 says that god's favorite color is red and religion 2 says that god's favorite color is green, but god's favorite color is actually blue, is one of them closer to his true nature then the other?
 
It isn't hard for us to accept. It's hard for you to see the flaw in the logic, and we're trying to show you:

Yes, a god could exist.

But, it could be a god of a nature we have yet to imagine or conceive.

Therefore, none of us may have come up with a religion that comes anywhere near that god's true nature.

Your argument is posed as a non-sequitur, and so is fallacious.

In post #1 I clarified it was an "intelligent" God we would be assuming exists.

No non-sequitur argument, and basically I just asked a question in the title of the thread.
 
Last edited:
If God exists his nature is what it is regardless of whether or not people have knowledge or it.

And one religion will be closer to his true nature whether or not people have exact knowledge of which one is closer. Truth is what it is, it is not dependent on people's beliefs.

What is to prevent two or more belief systems from being equidistant to the truth?
 
Looks like he is talking about the death of heat as heat is lost in an expanding empty universe. He is not talking about the universe setting itself on fire.

I hope you're not implying that Doc has performed a random google search to back up his arguments, misunderstood what he read and ended up making himself look stupid.
 
Not according to this Vatican astronomer. He says "science" predicts it will end in a sudden "heat death".

http://www.physorg.com/news10311.html

From that link:
What's more, the Laws of Thermodynamics predict a sudden "heat death" of the universe, when all stars have died and an ever-expanding empty universe fills with expanding radiation.

Because of the death of the stars, the universe will become unbearably cold, not hot. There will be so little energy a thought may take a trillion years.

But no matter. If you came to the conclusion that the Bible wrongly predicts the eventual fate of the universe, are you saying that you would question your faith? You are demonstrating how you can take your Bible and make it say whatever you want it to say, no matter how ambiguous.
 
Last edited:
In post #1 I clarified it was an "intelligent" God we would be assuming exists.

That doesn't really add anything to the premise.

No non-sequitur argument, and basically I just asked a question in the title of the thread.

Uh, yeah, I know you just asked a question.

It IS a non-sequitur. Your proposed conclusion does not follow from your premise, simple as that.


DOC, what if there is a god, and her name is Sharon. And Sharon is fat, red-headed, and likes truffles. She doesn't want to be worshiped, she has no hell or heaven to send people to, she can't even hear prayers, and she doesn't know we exist.

Which of our religions comes closest to Sharon's true nature?
 
Well, MY god is going to be the closest to his "true Nature" My god teaches that science will tell us all the answers through careful facts and research.

I win.
 
Not according to this Vatican astronomer. He says "science" predicts it will end in a sudden "heat death".

http://www.physorg.com/news10311.html
Oh dear. :nope:

DOC, one of these days you really should try reading your sources, and checking your assumptions before posting. It would help you to avoid these embarrassing situations.

The "heat death of the Universe" refers to the average temperature of the Universe approaching absolute zero, as the stars run out of fusionable matter, and all that's left is cold lumps of gas and dust, and a little radiation floating around in an ever expanding Universe. It doesn't heat up, it cools down.
 
What is to prevent two or more belief systems from being equidistant to the truth?

If the religion that was the closest to God had a founder (like Christianity) who said "I am the truth, the way, and the life, no man comes to the Father {God, the father} but by me". That would prevent 2 or more belief systems from being equidistant to the truth.
 
My contention is that if God exists "one" of them is closest to his true nature. I don't really understand why that is so hard for some people to accept. It seems a logical assertion.
It isn't a logical assertion.

If god is a can of corn, and one religion says he's a toaster, another religion says he's a waffle iron, a third insists he's a blow dryer, a fourth claims he's 4:15 on the afternoon of December 23rd, a fifth says he's the color purple, etc., which one is "closer" to his true nature?

The Christian God, in virtually all versions, is a logical impossibility given the world as we observe it. Omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence just can't be reconciled with widespread suffering.
 
The "heat death of the Universe" refers to the average temperature of the Universe approaching absolute zero, as the stars run out of fusionable matter, and all that's left is cold lumps of gas and dust, and a little radiation floating around in an ever expanding Universe. It doesn't heat up, it cools down.

What may have confused DOC is the use of the word "sudden" in the article. It appears that this was put there, quite inappropriately, by the writer of the article, rather than being a quote from Guy Consolmagno. Indeed, Consolmagno himself is not predicting anything, as he gives two extreme possibilities for the end of the universe and doesn't even bother to justify either. So this isn't simply DOC misunderstanding a source, it's DOC misinterpreting a scientific journalist's misunderstanding of a source. As an appeal to authority filtered through two levels of misunderstanding, it's remarkable that it gives the appearance of containing any information at all.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom