If God Exists is it likely that one religion has teachings closer to his true nature

DOC

Philosopher
Joined
Jan 20, 2007
Messages
7,959
Yes, I posed this question in my thread "Evidence for why we know the New Testament writers told the truth" which is located in the History, Literature Forum section. One person implied it was off topic, one person said I was playing a guessing game, one person changed the premise of the question and said I need to prove the existence of God. So I thought I'd bring the question in here. It is probably more related to religion than history anyway.

I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?
 
I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?

I do. As the actual fate of the universe (death through ice) seems to be more accurately predicted in the Norse religion than any of our contemporary religions (Who predict it will end in fire). That seems closer to His nature.
 
I do. As the actual fate of the universe (death through ice) seems to be more accurately predicted in the Norse religion than any of our contemporary religions (Who predict it will end in fire). That seems closer to His nature.

Well Christ did say "Heaven {the heavens} and earth will pass away but my words will never pass away...

But overall then you do agree with me in that if God exists then "one" religion will be closer to the truth than the others. You just don't believe that that religion still exists.
 
If a god exists, I see no reason why any religion should have a stronger idea of its capabilities than any other. If no-one has had contact with such an entity, then they are merely guessing. If they have, then they were not necessarily enlightened; They could have been intentionally misled, meaning that those who were making guesses had a greater chance of being correct.

While I can see the possibility that one religion might be closer than the others, either through chance, or through a truthful god, I cannot see that the proposition must be true.
 
Yes, I posed this question in my thread "Evidence for why we know the New Testament writers told the truth" which is located in the History, Literature Forum section. One person implied it was off topic, one person said I was playing a guessing game, one person changed the premise of the question and said I need to prove the existence of God. So I thought I'd bring the question in here. It is probably more related to religion than history anyway.

I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?
Doc, I answered this more fully in the other thread. If the Christian God exists then Christianity is the most likely. If the Islamic God exists then Islam is the most likely.

If we assume a random God exists then there is no reason why any religion should describe the true nature of that God better than any other. If we look at the world today and assume there is a God we can only conclude that he is random or he does not intervene in life on earth and no religions get anywhere near his true nature.
 
Last edited:
Doc, I answered this more fully in the other thread. If the Christian God exists then Christianity is the most likely. If the Islamic God exists then Islam is the most likely...

(boldness added)

If the Christian God exists then Christianity is "true" (the wording "most likely" would be inappropriate).

If the Islamic God exists than Islam is "true" (the wording "most likely" would be inappropriate).
 
Last edited:
(boldness added)

If the Christian God exists then Christianity is "true" (the wording most likely would be inappropriate).

If the Islamic God exists than Islam is "true" (the wording most likely would be inappropriate).
Given there are different versions of Christianity and Islam and their are violent differences between them I would suggest that any single sect is not necessarily wholly preaching the truth.
 
Why do you assume a current religion?
There have been plenty others.
 
If a god exists, I see no reason why any religion should have a stronger idea of its capabilities than any other. If no-one has had contact with such an entity, then they are merely guessing...

But what if God came in the flesh (e.g. Christianity) and told certain people what his capabilities and nature and laws were -- then they wouldn't be guessing.
 
Last edited:
So you are asking. If you assume that the Christian God described in the Christian bible is real which religion is most likely to be true?

No that is what you are asking, I'm asking what's in the title of the thread.
 
Well Christ did say "Heaven {the heavens} and earth will pass away but my words will never pass away...

Yet appears to have incorrectly predicted the eventual fate of the Universe. I don't get what you mean by this.

You could go by the Hindu religion, which appears to have predicted the age of the universe far more accurately than Christianity.
 
Last edited:
Sure, what if.

But then Islam believes that the Koran is the direct word of god written through the profit Mohamed, and that Jesus was mearly a prophet.
Have you any evidence that this is not the truth and Christianity is?

If Islam is wrong, then it is obviously a construct by deluded or self serving people, yet has a following in the billions. The same can be said for every other religion EXCEPT for the one that happens to be the truth.

Now, I bet you were just lucky enough to choose to believe (having been raised in it)the one religion (and I bet the one demonination of that religion) that happens to not be the work of mass delusion.

Lucky you....:cool:
 
I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?

How does one define "closer to the truth" if one does not know the truth?
 
Why do you assume a current religion?
There have been plenty others.

Any current religion or even past religions.

My contention is that if God exists "one" of them is closest to his true nature. I don't really understand why that is so hard for some people to accept. It seems a logical assertion.
 
How does one define "closer to the truth" if one does not know the truth?

If God exists his nature is what it is regardless of whether or not people have knowledge or it.

And one religion will be closer to his true nature whether or not people have exact knowledge of which one is closer. Truth is what it is, it is not dependent on people's beliefs.
 

As I said, Christianity predicts the Universe will end in fire, the Norse predicted it will end in ice. The latter is more accurate and the former highly incorrect.

The lesson is that you can always find something in your scripture that will make it appear the closest religion there is to that of the true nature of the Universe.
 
Last edited:
I contend that if you assume an intelligent God exists (for argument sake) then it is absolutely true that the teachings of "one" religion, that exists now, (whether it be Christianity or Islam or Judaism etc.) will be closer to the truth about the "true" nature of God than the other religions. Does anyone disagree with my contention and why?

I disagree with your contention as posed in the text of the post ("it is absolutely true"), as explained in the other thread. As expressed in the title of this thread ("is it likely that"), then the claim is true but trivial; it fails to pass the slood test. If I ask two people to describe slood, it is likely that one of the descriptions of slood will be closer to the real nature of slood than the other, despite the fact that neither I nor either of the people I have asked knows what slood is. This inequality does not imply that the two descriptions are in any way correlated to the actual nature of slood.

Dave
 
No that is what you are asking, I'm asking what's in the title of the thread.
No you have changed the question. The original question is one where are asked to assume that a God exists then judge the veracity of different religions.

Now you have asked us to judge the veracity of different religions assuming that the assumed god exists and also that God came in the flesh (e.g. Christianity) and told certain people what his capabilities and nature and laws were.

Perhaps you need to give us a list of the nature, properties and achievements of the assumed God before we make a judgement on the religions.

For example did this assumed God send his only son to earth to die for our sins?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom