If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

I would have to say less if they were practicing Mormons who attended temple but I'd bet every penny I had that if everyone in the world was a born again Christian the drop in crime would be tremendous.

So, may I assume that you believe that there is a hierarchy of beliefs and the amount of crime that would be associated?

Would you agree to the following list, in increasing order of civility/decreased criminality:

1.) Atheism
2.) buddhism
3.) animism
3.) Paganism
4.) judaism
5.) Muslim
6.) Mormonism
7.) Christianity
 
DOC this is a question that makes no sense. Let's say every one was an atheist and for that matter me too. And I was the ruler of this atheistc world. Well, I may decide that since there is no after life and no judgement for our actions, there will be fewer laws to follow. My law could be "Thou shalt not kill or harm do do birds." So, everything else would be legal besides this law. And thus, less crime.
On the ohter hand, I could enact a decree that since there is no after life or judgement, we are going to put stricter and more laws in place so that mankind lives and behaves as good as possible since this is the only chance we get. Which one do you prefer?
 
it's funny that DOC's references to Time and New Yorker pronouncements about Peter Singer come not from Time and New Yorker, but from World Magazine and Project Syndicate
 
I would have to say less if they were practicing Mormons who attended temple but I'd bet every penny I had that if everyone in the world was a born again Christian the drop in crime would be tremendous.

Hmm. Statistics suggest that evangelicals are much more likely to be convicted of crimes than atheists are and have higher divorce and abortion rates. 'By their fruits ye shall know them' is good advice.

Lest atheists get too full of themselves, Christians regarded as pious (show signs they take their religion very seriously) do about as well as atheists, statistically.

Ironically, this may indicate that both groups have a high regard for morality, although they arrive there from different starting points. In America at least, that may have something to do with the courage and sacrifice it takes to make a stand at either end of the belief spectrum: on the one hand to really live according to your religous beliefs even when it is inconvenient, and on the other to have the conviction to set aside beliefs that may be comforting because you don't believe they are true, even when it puts you in a small and unpopular minority.

I suspect it doesn't matter what everyone believes. The people who are disposed to commit crimes are unlikely to be pious or atheist, no matter what the dominant religion or opinion is.
 
I make up my own mind about my own morality. Therefore it doesn't actually matter to me if Peter Singer advocates plucking out baby's eyes and using them as party snacks, because i do not derive my morality from Peter singer.
Everyone, except perhaps the severely brainwashed, make up their own minds about their own morality. Atheists can choose at any time that bombing a school is OK, just like theists can. As I rhetorically asked elsewhere, since the Bible is subjectively interpreted, who's to stop DOC from interpreting it in a way that makes him think it's OK to shoot up schools?

All humans follow their own moral compasses.
 
I'm saying that. Do you have any evidence to the contrary, or should I ask Princeton Professor Peter Singer to contact his attorneys about a possible libel suit?

From the World Magazine article "Same-sex marriage? Euthanasia? Child's play issues in the avant-garde philosophy of Peter Singer" Marvin Olasky

"For example, when I asked him {Singer} last month about necrophilia (what if two people make an agreement that whoever lives longest can have sexual relations with the corpse of the person who dies first?), he said, "There's no moral problem with that." Concerning bestiality (should people have sex with animals, seen as willing participants?), he responded, "I would ask, 'What's holding you back from a more fulfilling relationship?' [but] it's not wrong inherently in a moral sense."

If the 21st century becomes a Singer century, we will also see legal infanticide of born children who are ill or who have ill older siblings in need of their body parts. Question: What about parents conceiving and giving birth to a child specifically to kill him, take his organs, and transplant them into their ill older children? Mr. Singer: "It's difficult to warm to parents who can take such a detached view, [but] they're not doing something really wrong in itself." Is there anything wrong with a society in which children are bred for spare parts on a massive scale? "No."

http://www.worldmag.com/articles/9987
 
From the World Magazine article "Same-sex marriage? Euthanasia? Child's play issues in the avant-garde philosophy of Peter Singer" Marvin Olasky

"For example, when I asked him {Singer} last month about necrophilia (what if two people make an agreement that whoever lives longest can have sexual relations with the corpse of the person who dies first?), he said, "There's no moral problem with that." Concerning bestiality (should people have sex with animals, seen as willing participants?), he responded, "I would ask, 'What's holding you back from a more fulfilling relationship?' [but] it's not wrong inherently in a moral sense."

If the 21st century becomes a Singer century, we will also see legal infanticide of born children who are ill or who have ill older siblings in need of their body parts. Question: What about parents conceiving and giving birth to a child specifically to kill him, take his organs, and transplant them into their ill older children? Mr. Singer: "It's difficult to warm to parents who can take such a detached view, [but] they're not doing something really wrong in itself." Is there anything wrong with a society in which children are bred for spare parts on a massive scale? "No."

http://www.worldmag.com/articles/9987
I'm happy that you started a new thread on this topic, as it really does deviate from the question of crime and religion.

So, getting back on track:
may I assume that you believe that there is a hierarchy of beliefs and the amount of crime that would be associated?

Would you agree to the following list, in increasing order of civility/decreased criminality:

1.) Atheism
2.) buddhism
3.) animism
3.) Paganism
4.) judaism
5.) Muslim
6.) Mormonism
7.) Christianity
 
I would have to say less if they were practicing Mormons who attended temple but I'd bet every penny I had that if everyone in the world was a born again Christian the drop in crime would be tremendous.
Not quite as high as if everyone chose to be lobotomized, though.
 
Last edited:
"For example, when I asked him {Singer} last month about necrophilia (what if two people make an agreement that whoever lives longest can have sexual relations with the corpse of the person who dies first?), he said, "There's no moral problem with that." Concerning bestiality (should people have sex with animals, seen as willing participants?), he responded, "I would ask, 'What's holding you back from a more fulfilling relationship?' [but] it's not wrong inherently in a moral sense."
Just as I thought. Atheistic Princeton Professor Peter Singer does not support the right to engage in bestiality and the right to engage in necrophia. He doesn't claim that there is a right to engage in bestiality, and he doesn't claim that there is a right to engage in necrophilia. He doesn't "support" either act. He simply says that the scenarios presented by the interviewer are not immoral.

It's not immoral to smear yourself all over with raw eggs and chocolate sauce before watching movies marathons on TV, but my conceding that doesn't mean I advocate the practice.
 
Just as I thought. Atheistic Princeton Professor Peter Singer does not support the right to engage in bestiality and the right to engage in necrophia. He doesn't claim that there is a right to engage in bestiality, and he doesn't claim that there is a right to engage in necrophilia. He doesn't "support" either act. He simply says that the scenarios presented by the interviewer are not immoral.

It's not immoral to smear yourself all over with raw eggs and chocolate sauce before watching movies marathons on TV, but my conceding that doesn't mean I advocate the practice.
DOC is just lying again. Every time he feels his evil urges rising up, he attacks atheists in order to prop up his fragile ego.
 
it's funny that DOC's references to Time and New Yorker pronouncements about Peter Singer come not from Time and New Yorker, but from World Magazine and Project Syndicate

What are those? - I have not seen them mentioned before.I thought he was quoting the mainstream magazines.
 
Last edited:
Ladewig said:
DOC, you keep posting this stuff while ignoring the responses that show that he does not hold sway over very many atheists and that he was very much misquoted.

And where has he been very much misquoted?


You seem to still believe that it is accurate to say "Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society." If you read the entire Princeton webpage, you would have seen that he was referring to the current situation in which parents request life-saving treatment be withheld from very sick infants. His point was that more suffering arises from withholding treatment from infants that cannot survive without treatment than arises from taking active steps to end the baby’s life swiftly and humanely. He was not referring simply to mentally handicapped infants, he was referring to infants that cannot survive without medical intervention.
 
As long as people keep saying he is irrelevant, I have the right to keep showing evidence that he is relevant.

Yes, DOC, you have that right. My only question is when will you exercise that right because you have not yet done so.

I already addressed this issue back in post 265.

ETA: and other people have addressed it as well.
 
Last edited:
What are those? - I have not seen them mentioned before.I thought he was quoting the mainstream magazines.

DOC has links to World Magazine in his posts to support his assertions. Check them out...World Magazine is a christian web site.

...If you read the entire Princeton webpage.
See, that's the problem. DOC refuses to go to original sources. His only reference is to World Magazine, which can hardly be considered a neutral source given the nature of the topic.
 
Based on the fact that prisons are filled to overflowing with Christians, I'm guessing you'd lose every penny you've got.

As both DOC and others have pointed out, it is possible that the large percentage of Christians is the result of jailhouse conversions to impress parole boards.
 
As both DOC and others have pointed out, it is possible that the large percentage of Christians is the result of jailhouse conversions to impress parole boards.

Actually, the most famous of the prison surveys, AFAIK the one here (scroll down the page to find it), and also here the 1997 Federal Bureau of Prisons survey reflects intake interviews with the convicts in question, rather than queries performed after their incarceration.
 
Last edited:
"Moreover, although a normal newborn baby has no sense of the future, and therefore is not a person, that does not mean that it is all right to kill such a baby. It only means that the wrong done to the infant is not as great as the wrong that would be done to a person who was killed."

Ahem... Why did you add emphasis here?

Why not this emphasis?

"Moreover, although a normal newborn baby has no sense of the future, and therefore is not a person, that does not mean that it is all right to kill such a baby. It only means that the wrong done to the infant is not as great as the wrong that would be done to a person who was killed."

Such emphasis would make it entirely clear that this Professor does not advocate the killing of babies.

Cherry picking someone's words and altering them to give a differing emphasis from what they're clearly trying to say is dishonest. It appears clear that the dishonesty is not just being propagated by you. You're not just a victim, as someone who forms a judgment of a person based solely on the statements of their detractors. Your not just an unwitting perpetrator as someone who repeats these claims. You added to the deceit yourself, fully cognisant of your actions in highlighting Singers assertion that a newborn baby is not a person without reference or context to the highly specialised definition of personhood with which Singer prefixed his argument.

That's not a great example of superior Theistic morals. It appears that the biblical censure against bearing false witness has not sufficiently improved your behaviour.

Shame on you Doc. Shame.
 
Actually, the most famous of the prison surveys, AFAIK the one here (scroll down the page to find it), and also here the 1997 Federal Bureau of Prisons survey reflects intake interviews with the convicts in question, rather than queries performed after their incarceration.

My speculation was incorrect. I did not know that they compiled figures on inmates entering the system. If there were not too many DOC threads at the moment, I would suggest starting a new one to discuss this aspect of the issue.
 
Originally Posted by DOC
As long as people keep saying he is irrelevant, I have the right to keep showing evidence that he is relevant.

Yes, DOC, you have that right. My only question is when will you exercise that right because you have not yet done so.

I already addressed this issue back in post 265.

ETA: and other people have addressed it as well.

Well if you don't like Time and New Yorker magazines maybe you will like the New York Times, and the The New England Journal of Medicine.

For the article "The most influential philosopher alive" by Marvin Olasky

Many readers may be saying, "Peter who?" -- but The New York Times, explaining how his views trickle down through media and academia to the general populace, noted that "No other living philosopher has had this kind of influence." The New England Journal of Medicine said he has had "more success in effecting changes in acceptable behavior" than any philosopher since Bertrand Russell. The New Yorker called him the "most influential" philosopher alive.

http://www.puritanboard.com/f50/most-influential-philosopher-alive-3391/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom