"I don't believe in coincidences"

Your life is a series of nearly infinite events. The occasional "amazing coincidence" is to be expected. Who sees this as suspicious?
 
hmmm,
I went to university in Ottawa and in first year I had a girl friend from Montreal. Years later I happened to be in Kingston visiting friends and planned to fly home (1500 km west) out of Ottawa, though Toronto would have been a equally good choice.
When I got to the security check area who is the person with the metal detector wand? My ex-girlfriend!

Who or what did that to me? I'd like to lodge a complaint.
 
I sat on the train the other day and someone farted, later on in the day I farted and it smelt exactly the same.
Weird eh?
 
hmmm,
I went to university in Ottawa and in first year I had a girl friend from Montreal. Years later I happened to be in Kingston visiting friends and planned to fly home (1500 km west) out of Ottawa, though Toronto would have been a equally good choice.
When I got to the security check area who is the person with the metal detector wand? My ex-girlfriend!

Who or what did that to me? I'd like to lodge a complaint.

Few years ago I was flying from the West Coast to the East Coast. On the same flight was a guy I had served with in the Army 20 years earlier. He was on the return leg of his East Coast to West Coast trip.
:boxedin:
 
hmmm,
I went to university in Ottawa and in first year I had a girl friend from Montreal. Years later I happened to be in Kingston visiting friends and planned to fly home (1500 km west) out of Ottawa, though Toronto would have been a equally good choice.
When I got to the security check area who is the person with the metal detector wand? My ex-girlfriend!

Who or what did that to me? I'd like to lodge a complaint.

where did she put the wand?
 
I was talking to a client who had come in with some lab samples on behalf of her daughter, who was a vet over on the west coast. Turned out the daughter was in practice in a very small town where a friend of mine who is also a vet lives. So I asked the client if her daughter knew my friend.

Apparently not. But the woman herself had been in my friend's class at school in Edinburgh.

Rolfe.
 
I posted a pic of a circuit board fragment (of PT 35b for Lockerbie fans ) on a personal blog some weeks ago ( Rolfe may know the pic as the 'Sunday Herald' close-up )

I then typed a few sentences along the lines of: This is a majorly important fragment, yet no-one knows what it is.

The post got two interesting hits.

One from a chap in Australia who, guessed "...rectifier from a Panasonic radio? "

Another chap from Malta said, " part of my job is designing these things ( PCBs ), looks like a battery to me, but could be anything...dunno "
 
Is this a religious-based worldview? I know that some people say that everything that happens is part of some plan by God. Is that the source of this manner of thinking?
There is a term for people who genuinely think that no coincidences happen in the world. It is "paranoid schizophrenics".

The belief that everything is connected and/or happens for a reason is not consistent with reality and requires unreasonable levels of suspension of disbelief.

With CTers, they mostly don't believe coincidences happened only in connection to the specific event their CT is related to. It is a bit closer to reality, as it is undoubtedly possible to organize an event so that it turns out as one wants it to. The level of planning and basically precognition that is usually assumed, though, is way out of the realm of reason. Sort of a localized schizophrenia, also known as "being thick as a bunker roof".
 
In 1968 I met twins on the beach in Oahu, in 1990 I went to work at a hospital in NY, and one of them worked there, in 2009, I met the other in an airport in Oregon.

I play a lot of poker in one night in Neubrucke Germany I got dealt a royal flush, three hands later I was dealt another, never had one before or after....for non poker people the odds for getting one is 1 out of 650,000
 
Last edited:
where did she put the wand?

I deliberatly left out information along that line.:cool:
Actually she was quite flustered and barely passed the wand over me at all.
It was a somewhat ackward moment and I really wanted to go by and get to my boarding area asap, then she said "I'll call you". This was quite nonsensical since she did not know my new number nor even where I was living.(the plane went to a large city near the town where I was living) However that offhand promise was the scary part.:eek:
 
In 1968 I met twins on the beach in Oahu, in 1990 I went to work at a hospital in NY, and one of them worked there, in 2009, I met the other in an airport in Oregon.

I play a lot of poker in one night in Neubrucke Germany I got dealt a royal flush, three hands later I was dealt another, never had one before or after....for non poker people the odds for getting one is 1 out of 650,000

,, and a quick note on probability that would astound CTists.

The odds of your first royale flush were 1/650,000 and what were the odds of you getting a royale flush three hands later?

Answer: 1 in 650,000
 
I play a lot of poker in one night in Neubrucke Germany I got dealt a royal flush, three hands later I was dealt another, never had one before or after....for non poker people the odds for getting one is 1 out of 650,000

Indeed, gambling is one of the practical examples of the oft-studied phenomenon of just how badly humans typically estimate probability by intuitive means. Pseudo-statistical notions of a "run" of bad luck, or that snake-eyes are "due" because they haven't been rolled in a while, are the psychological basis behind the existence of Las Vegas in all its glitzy glory.

This is why I keep a statistician within communication distance. Lots of engineering decisions are based on probability and prediction of failure (i.e., reasoning through a sea of consequence and coincidence), and my staff is becoming very attuned to the notion that their armchair estimates of probability are not good measurements for what we should actually do. Statistical probability consistently defies even well-informed intuition. Hence "suspicious" coincidence is often predicated on wrong estimates of probability and "normal" outcomes, coupled with a misunderstanding of the law of Large Numbers.

Consider the classic fair coin toss. The probability of heads in any one toss is always p = 0.5, and always p = 0.5 for tails. Always. But intuitively we know that the law of large numbers means that for some long string of recorded coin tosses, the proportion of heads to tails outcome will tend toward 1:1. But if our running count is 453 heads to 472 tails, it is not true that the system will somehow "correct" itself by making heads a more likely outcome on the next toss. Yet this is how many gamblers think, and the basis upon which billion-dollar casino/hotels are funded. But in fact there is no "history" in this sort of statistical process. A coin toss always has evenly split probability -- always.

Considered another way, it's just as likely you'll be dealt a royal flush as any other combination of cards. The difference is solely in how those combinations are scored for poker. It is that imposed significance, not any sort of behavior of the underlying cards, that creates the sense of coincidence.
 
How many of these can be described via the Texas Sharpshooter fallacy? Forensic engineering included...the number of unlikely events that had to happen simultaneously in order for the accident to occur are no more likely, nor less likely, than some other like number of unequally unlikely events that cause no problem that anyone noticed.
 
One night I had a really strange dream, and in the very last segment before I woke up, I switched on my bedroom light and it failed. That afternoon, when I arrived home and went into my bedroom, I hit the switch and the bulb blew out.
A couple of years later I was walking down a very crowded city street and into my head flashed the image of a girl I had not seen in years (in fact she had gone to live in Germany). About two minutes later, she walked right up to me.

Weird coincidence or precognition? More likely, the subconscious mind at work. My brain had registered that the light bulb was failing (very subtle flickering) but the conscious part had not. I had spotted the girl in the distance through the crowds, but again it had not fully registered on the conscious level.
 
Hindsight is 20/80.

You spot relationships that are far away in time, but you forget all the failed matches that happened in the meanwhile.
 
The variant I usually hear from CTers is that everyone who disagrees with them is a "coincidence theorist".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom