"I don't believe in coincidences"

As far as "believing in coincidences," yeah, I sure do.

There's an old friend that I've bumped into by accident a few times. Once he was standing at a bar in Cambridge when I stopped in. Another time he and his brother were crossing Kenmore Square when my brother and I were going in the opposite direction. Just last year, he happened to be sitting in the seat literally right next to mine at Fenway Park. As it turns out, he's working for a company owned by the company I work for, and we'll be working in the same building in a few months.

Do I think it's funny? You bet. As far as having a cosmic bond or something? Oh, please.
 
One day I was in a train reading over some papers I'd shoved in an old manila folder to take with me. The folder had previously been used to sort out my father's share portfolio documentation. It was labelled "Clyde Port Authority". Did I mention the train in question was the Gatwick Express - just in case anyone thought I was anywhere near the Clyde at the time.

The woman in the seat opposite, who could not have seen the folder I was working from, took out her mobile phone and started a loud and annoyed phone-round of various people, trying to get the phone number of - the Clyde Port Authority.

Later in the same journey, on a train heading north from King's Cross, I was reading Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell. I came to a passage in the book where one of the passengers was travelling in a coach, and was described as "just approaching Doncaster". I looked up and glanced out the train window to find that it was - just approaching Doncaster.

I remember that couplet because later that day my travelling companion started to praise homoeopathy because some ailment she had had had improved after taking a homoeopathic remedy someone had given her. So I trotted out the meaningless coincidences of the day.

Rolfe.
 
It is strange though. Once the coincidence is seen as meaningful, it's extremely difficult to negotiate an acceptance of it being "just a coincidence" - even with yourself.

One of the problems with figuring out Lockerbie is the number of coincidences. Which of them are "just" coincidences, and which aren't?

There are two that absolutely have to be coincidence, but it's so hard to come to terms with it and everyone keeps looking for some causal connection. One is that of the seven unidentified luggage trays in the Frankfurt automatic baggage transit system, one of them seemed to have come from the airport that was only three miles away from the shop where the clothes in the suitcase with the bomb were purchased. And that was the most suspicious of all the seven trays.

The other is that some months after Megrahi had been fingered as a potential suspect purely on the grounds of his contacts, and the man who sold these clothes had been induced to pick out a picture of him as "resembling" the man who bought these clothes, it was discovered that Megrahi had actually been at the airport at the time the flight heading for Frankfurt was checking in, and he was using a passport in a false name.

Looking at it like that, I'd think he did it. I can totally see why the investigators were convinced. The power of these two coincidences is extraordinarily strong. The only problem is, the bomb didn't travel on the Malta-Frankfurt flight in the first place. The luggage tray was a coincidence.

Rolfe.
 
And goes back to the best Bond movie ever - Goldfinger.

Also a favorite quote of Leroy Jethro Gibbs, who Anthony DiNardo claims got it from "one of the Duke's greatest films".
 
Last edited:
It is strange though. Once the coincidence is seen as meaningful, it's extremely difficult to negotiate an acceptance of it being "just a coincidence" - even with yourself.

One of the problems with figuring out Lockerbie is the number of coincidences. Which of them are "just" coincidences, and which aren't?

There are two that absolutely have to be coincidence, but it's so hard to come to terms with it and everyone keeps looking for some causal connection. One is that of the seven unidentified luggage trays in the Frankfurt automatic baggage transit system, one of them seemed to have come from the airport that was only three miles away from the shop where the clothes in the suitcase with the bomb were purchased. And that was the most suspicious of all the seven trays.

The other is that some months after Megrahi had been fingered as a potential suspect purely on the grounds of his contacts, and the man who sold these clothes had been induced to pick out a picture of him as "resembling" the man who bought these clothes, it was discovered that Megrahi had actually been at the airport at the time the flight heading for Frankfurt was checking in, and he was using a passport in a false name.

Looking at it like that, I'd think he did it. I can totally see why the investigators were convinced. The power of these two coincidences is extraordinarily strong. The only problem is, the bomb didn't travel on the Malta-Frankfurt flight in the first place. The luggage tray was a coincidence.

Rolfe.

Out of curiosity, is there any topic you can't divert to your apparent obsession? :confused:
 
I've seen at least two people who were promoting conspiracy theories say this (two that I can clearly recall right now) and I've probably heard similar sentiments expressed on several other occasions.

It seems like a strange belief to me. It's one thing to argue that a particular set of facts is not merely a coincidence, but to have a general belief that coincidences never happen seems bizarre. Coincidences happen all the time.

Is this a religious-based worldview? I know that some people say that everything that happens is part of some plan by God. Is that the source of this manner of thinking?

You are just over analysing a snappy response to claims that any given bit of evidence or "evidence" is coincidence. It doesn't have any deeper meaning.
 
Out of curiosity, is there any topic you can't divert to your apparent obsession? :confused:

I did a search on Lockerbrie, but I'm not sure what they (Rolfe) are referring to when they mention it...

Never mind, it has to do with Pam Am flight 103, the only result that comes even close.
 
Last edited:
Out of curiosity, is there any topic you can't divert to your apparent obsession? :confused:


Why would you care? It's a perfectly relevant comment. When something appears very significant, it's extremely hard to accept that it's a coincidence, even when you know intellectually that it is.

Rolfe.
 
Most people don't understand how probability and statistics work. Therefore occurrences and facts of reality that are driven by probability are not comprehended and are given some magic causality, all covered under the umbrella statement of "not believing in coincidences". This includes combinatorial and permutation driven statistics, where non-intuitive math is needed, concepts such as Regression to the Mean, the knowledge of normal distributions (bell curves) and their variations, and so on. Combine that in the U.S. at least with a distaste for intellectualism, and you have a witch's brew for woo.
 
Also a favorite quote of Leroy Jethro Gibbs, who Anthony DiNardo claims got it from "one of the Duke's greatest films".

Tony DiNozzo. Tony DiNardo was his identity when he was undercover as *SPOILERS*.
 
...The folder had previously been used to sort out my father's share portfolio documentation. It was labelled "Clyde Port Authority".

<Off-topic> My dad used to have a couple of useful folders marked with that name. Stuck in my mind because he told me they almost called it the "Clyde Unified Navigational Trust".
 
Most people don't understand how probability and statistics work. Therefore occurrences and facts of reality that are driven by probability are not comprehended and are given some magic causality, all covered under the umbrella statement of "not believing in coincidences". This includes combinatorial and permutation driven statistics, where non-intuitive math is needed, concepts such as Regression to the Mean, the knowledge of normal distributions (bell curves) and their variations, and so on. Combine that in the U.S. at least with a distaste for intellectualism, and you have a witch's brew for woo.


I don't think it's necessarily about understanding in an intellectual sense. It's about meaning.

It's easy to laugh about the coincidences I mentioned - the Tristan and Isolde broadcast, the Clyde Port Authority thing and so on. They're so obviously random meaningless chance that nobody with any sense thinks twice about them other than as a talking point for a day or two. The problem starts when the mind attaches meaning to a sequence of events.

It's most obvious in the alternative medicine field, and in fact it's the #1 reason why scams like homoeopathy and so on have such a tenacious hold on the psyche of many people. If you take a particular remedy, and you then get better, it's extraordinarily difficult to shake the conviction that this was cause and effect. (Conversely, if you don't get better, you just shrug it off and forget about it. The mind remembers the hits and forgets the misses.) This is exactly why homoeopathy has so many people insisting absolutely rabidly that "it worked for me!", and disputing vigorously when you point out that it's nothing but sugar pills.

The same thing occurs in the opposite sense in the anti-vax field, among other things. We had a case in England when they were vaccinating all the teenage girls against HPV, and a girl fell ill and died suddenly only a few hours after being given the vaccine. It turned out that she had a tumour on her heart or something like that. It was going to kill her some day that month, and it just so happened it was hours after the vaccine. But many people can't shake the conviction that it must have been the vaccine that killed her, just because of the timing. That has then given rise to a conspiracy theory that the results of the post mortem examination were faked to cover up for the vaccine.

And sorry and all that but someone who knows about 9/11 can find an example within the 9/11 narrative, I know about Lockerbie and that's where I find the examples. The cops were misled, as I said, by two quite big coincidences. First, they found a record of an unidentified item of luggage (one of about seven such records) that appeared to have originated at the airport only three miles from the shop where the clothes packed round the bomb had been purchased. They became convinced that item of luggage must have been the suitcase containing the bomb, even though they never found any evidence to confirm that and in fact quite a lot of evidence suggesting it wasn't.

Then, well over a year later, it also turned out that the suspect they'd settled on for different reasons had been at the airport at the time the flight they believed had carried the bomb was checking in. And he was travelling on a passport in a false name.

I mean, what would you think? I don't really blame the cops, on one level. The significance of the coincidence was extraordinary. I feel it myself. It's very very difficult, even when you know the bomb didn't travel on that flight in the first place, to shake of the overwhelming gut feeling that this must mean something. It's not just the likelihood of the coincidence, it's the meaning attached to it by the mind.

It's hard to shake these convictions off rationally when you're being as rigorous and evidence led as possible. How much harder is it for these truther kids who have no practice in thinking rationally, and are hard-wired to believe all sorts of bizarro-world :rule10?

I think you're on a hiding to nothing.

Rolfe.
 
the fact that the brain takes in massive amounts of information means that on occasssion some of those things will be similar is just the law of averages.

Take the example of randomly thinking about an old friend and then they seem to ring you or turn up.
You only recall the times they ring or turn up and the times they dont we forget.
Isnt that just coincidence?
 
<Off-topic> My dad used to have a couple of useful folders marked with that name. Stuck in my mind because he told me they almost called it the "Clyde Unified Navigational Trust".

Why not the Clyde Regional Authority for Ports?
 
The thingy next to rocket on the launch pad for the Apollo missions was a hair's breadth away from being called the Saturn Launch Umbilical Tower.
 
So they called it a 'thingy' instead, eh?
:boxedin:

My favourite quite about coincidences:
The laws of probability not only allow coincidences, they demand them.
Don't recall where I heard it, though.
 
<Off-topic> My dad used to have a couple of useful folders marked with that name. Stuck in my mind because he told me they almost called it the "Clyde Unified Navigational Trust".
.
The Iraqi war was almost called "Operation Iraqi Liberation"... until someone noticed the faux-pas, and changed it to "Freedom".
 
"I don't believe in coincidences" is an oft repeated mantra of George Noory. And plays into many themes of his show.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom