I do believe I've found something more extreme than Rapture Ready

Troy is either getting close to finding his 12 apostles, or he's managed to get rid of almost everyone, and scare off any new members.

Erm, I choose B.

He's down to 15 folks, now.
 
That's not my question:

Do you believe that everything you can dream up or imagine is true ?
The fact that we are able to dream or, imagine anything at all must somehow be supported in reality. Even an illusion must have its basis in reality, otherwise we wouldn't be able to see it. Now, what do I say in my signature? ...

Even lies need something real to back them up, so in that sense delusion and fantasy don't really exist ... only the monsters from the id that sustain them.
 
Last edited:
The fact that we are able to dream or, imagine anything at all must somehow be supported in reality. Even an illusion must have its basis in reality, otherwise we wouldn't be able to see it. Now, what do I say in my signature?
This is true - events in our daily lives are no different than a dream, a dream alas, with seemingly immutable rules governing it. Both the upper and lower (where effect can preceed cause) worlds though are states of unbalance, and aren't ultimately desirable or interesting, either personally or intellectually. This is why it is no good to have an attachment to the idea that events in daily life are ultimately an illusion - because here they are two qualities in opposing balance, not one. You already live in conditions where nature is really graspable, form and function can be understood, and self-directed purpose achieved.
 
The fact that we are able to dream or, imagine anything at all must somehow be supported in reality. Even an illusion must have its basis in reality, otherwise we wouldn't be able to see it. Now, what do I say in my signature? ...

That doesn't mean that the THING you're imagining is real. Please answer my question.
 
You're not answering the question again. Is everything you imagine real, one way or another ? No ifs, no buts.
Yes, it is, if you view the imagination in terms of a "living process." Think of it this way, do rocks imagine things?
 
Yes, it is, if you view the imagination in terms of a "living process." Think of it this way, do rocks imagine things?

I think it unlikely that rocks imagine things, but I don't see what that has to do with the question.

Things that I imagine are "real imaginary things," or to put it more succiently but less exactly, "real stories." Not true stories, but they exist at least. As a rock thinks about nothing, the stories created by a rock are at the very least, dull, and at the worst, not real.
 
I think it unlikely that rocks imagine things, but I don't see what that has to do with the question.

Things that I imagine are "real imaginary things," or to put it more succiently but less exactly, "real stories." Not true stories, but they exist at least. As a rock thinks about nothing, the stories created by a rock are at the very least, dull, and at the worst, not real.
The imagination is part of real system (you) which is alive. So, in what way is the imagination unreal or, not alive?
 
Is a painting of a tree a tree? Nope.
So? Don't both of these have to already exist inside of you -- where, in other words? -- in order for you to speak of them? You don't claim that this is part of a "living process?" You know it's the relationship between these images in our minds that determine who we are don't you? ... Which, in fact is why we have different religions and schools of thought.
 
Last edited:
The real reason is that I wanted to see whether I would be let in with my (former) Christian beliefs. He's very secure in his beliefs, but some of his beliefs are unusual even among fundamentalists.
Actually, his actions all indicate that he is very insecure in his beliefs. Needing to call his proof "perfect", banning anyone who puts up a counterargument, and so forth. He is doing the Web equivalent of shouting from the rooftops with his fingers in his ears so that he can't hear anything contrary to what he believes. And the most usual reason people have for doing that is if they know that their belief cannot withstand the pressure their own sense of reason will put on it if it is exposed to a differing viewpoint.

No, his belief is tenuous at best, but he is so blinded by fear of what might happen to him by the possibility that his belief is true that he won't dare let it be challenged. He lives his life in that kind of Hell, and I pity him.
 
So? Don't both of these have to already exist inside of you --

ARGH! There's a tree inside me! Get it out!

Honestly, Iacchus. My intentional object of a tree (that's a pschology term, please look it up BEFORE you appropriate it) is not a tree.
 
Apparently, Troy has a stalker.

Troy said:
We are living in a very sick world! Satan is the god of this world. And this stalker is a very sick person who needs to be regenerated by the Holy Spirit. His accent sounds utterly evil as well as the inflections he uses. His voice swirl sounded a bit like Robert Deniro's in "Cape Fear." If you would like a copy of the mp3's to verify this person's voice if you suspect someone, you may request the audios.

Yes. He sounds EEeeevil!

Damn, this guy (troy) writes a whole lot of lines of text, considering how little he has to say.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom