I do believe I've found something more extreme than Rapture Ready

But how many Christians accept that if you don't believe in the bible/god/whatever then you can't possibly have a moral basis to determine right from wrong. How many of them would turn into mass murderers, thieves and rapists if they didn't have the threat of hell from their god to keep them in line?

I figure it's worthwhile if it gives those who have no real moral compass (other than fear of god) a reason not to become like they claim the non-believers must be.

Hmmmm... I've never read the bible, (willingly) attended a church service and have been a card-carrying agnostic almost my entire life and, well, geeze... I can't ever remember the last time I killed someone!;)

Sorry for the sarcastic opening, Bob... it's not directed at you. I suffer from a terminal case of being a smartarse.:blush:

Seriously, though... although I understand the point you are trying to make, the problem I have is with those of a religious bent who state that believing in <a> god, or following their holy books is the only way to become a moral and upstanding member of society. I had just heard a study on the radio a week or so ago where it showed that the lowest crime rates were in predominantly secular societies... such as in Scandinavia. I also stumbled across a news report that backs up this claim. Since I am unable to post urls until I get 15 posts under my belt, you can find the article by googling "Crime secular countries". It's the 1st result listed for the Timesonline: date Sept. 27th, 2005.

Just one other point... in my opinion, books like the bible and the koran not only condones violent acts against your fellow man (if he/she be one of them unwashed heathens!), but in many instances commands them.

Jen

Oh, and "hi" everybody. I'm new here. Please be gentle. I bruise easily.
 
Hi, Jen.
But how many Christians accept that if you don't believe in the bible/god/whatever then you can't possibly have a moral basis to determine right from wrong.
I don't know... do you?
How many of them would turn into mass murderers, thieves and rapists if they didn't have the threat of hell from their god to keep them in line?
Almost none at all, I would suspect. They may tell themselves God is what prevents them from being bad people, but that doesn't make it true. We don't see any Christian de-converts suddenly turning into homicidal kleptomaniac pedophiles, at least none that I know of.
I figure it's worthwhile if it gives those who have no real moral compass (other than fear of god) a reason not to become like they claim the non-believers must be.
You really don't think much of believers, do you?
However, none of this justifies the sweeping hostility in Zbu's post. They're neither 'idiots' or 'psychotics,' but it sounds to me like he's distancing himself from them as much as possible, so he doesn't have to cope with knowing he could have been a fundie if he'd just grown up in the right environment.
 
You guys who are getting in by answering straight "yes" are just asking to be banned. You can't say you believe in a multi-rapture tribulation and then say you don't know what the tribulation is....
 
Um, I got in and I answered no to everything. of course, I got banned when I PMd Troy to ask him a question clarifying the "challenge." Silly me, actually wanting the money -- I got banned for greed. :boggled:
 
This silly thought just occurred to me. Perhaps religion's role in today's educated and technologically advanced society isn't for the purpose of control or moral guidance, but to increase our fL fraction of the Drake equation.

Maybe sometimes its good to have a critical voice that slows down progress to keep ourselves from blowing each other up, even by accident?
Just for the record, I'm a total atheist, and I hate the way religious dogma slows down research, but maybe its a natural way for societies not to "go too far" without a little resistance?

Just food for thought, I'm now hiding under my desk to dodge all mind bullets. :boxedin:
 
If there was no interaction with the spiritual world, there would be no basis for religion.



horsesh*t.

Surely you admit you can delude yourself? Or are you so arrogant as to think your senses aren't fallable?
 
If there was no interaction with the spiritual world, there would be no basis for religion.

<Doing her best Horshack impersonation> Ooooh! Ooooh! Mr. Kotter! Mr. Kotter! I got a question...

Could you please clarify for me exactly what you mean by "interaction"...? Are you talking about actual contact with the spiritual world, or are you speaking in a metaphorical sense?

If you meant the former, then there would be no religions at all due to the fact that there are no facts nor evidence that even comes close to proving such thing as a "spiritual world". Silly rabbit! Myths are for kids!

Anyway, in my humble opinion, the basis for any religion has always been that a few power-hungry guys had got together over a few beers and thought up of a new way to exert control over the uneducated and superstitious masses through the creation of an invisible boogy man that only they can speak to (god). Next, they come up with a list of "enlightened" rules and regulations that this invisible boogy man had deemed necessary to be followed to ensure a morally upstanding life (such as stoning to death that doubting thomas over there who was cursed with having way too much intelligence to believe the crap he's hearing). Add to that a heathly dose of fear over the repercussions for disobeying your new loving and benign boogy man's commandments (eternal damnation), and voila! You got yourself a religion! Oh! And tithing. Can't forget the tithing.:)

Jen
 
You guys who are getting in by answering straight "yes" are just asking to be banned. You can't say you believe in a multi-rapture tribulation and then say you don't know what the tribulation is....
A sort of big extinct lobster.

Ask me another.
 
So... you're saying that every fantasy ever dreamed up is true ? That's not very useful.
If spirits don't exist, there's no need to discuss them is there? Yet this sort of thing that tends to crop up time after time, regardless of what anyone has to say about it in church.
 
If spirits don't exist, there's no need to discuss them is there?

Quite right.

I expect* you will now shut up about spirits, the spiritual world, etc., until you can prove that they exist.

*By "expect" of course, I mean in this case "don't for a minute think that".
 
Just for the record, I'm a total atheist, and I hate the way religious dogma slows down research, but maybe its a natural way for societies not to "go too far" without a little resistance?

Just food for thought, I'm now hiding under my desk to dodge all mind bullets. :boxedin:

I think of it kind of the other way around... it is better that scientific pace happens slowly to allow time for the fanatics to chill out or self-destruct before getting their hands on its more destructive results.
 
Quite right.

I expect* you will now shut up about spirits, the spiritual world, etc., until you can prove that they exist.

*By "expect" of course, I mean in this case "don't for a minute think that".
Of course, I'll just let others continue to report their experiences then.
 
If spirits don't exist, there's no need to discuss them is there? Yet this sort of thing that tends to crop up time after time, regardless of what anyone has to say about it in church.

That's not my question:

Do you believe that everything you can dream up or imagine is true ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom