Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

I will be interested to see if any construction engineers address this.

I notice, for example, that Hulsey is claiming that A2001 cannot walk of its seat because it would be trapped by the flange on Col 79.

The NIST report talks of it being pushed off by the expanding floor girders and in this case it seems likely that there would be rotation of Col 79 and bending of A2001 which would make it unlikely that that flange would be enough to trap it.

However I am far from an expert so I will wait for any engineers to chip in. (I could ask my brother but I imagine he would simply mock me for paying any attention to this).

The walk-off is not important. The strain energy builds up until the high strength bolts rip thru the bottom support plate. This whole connection comes apart like a small bomb. The girder is not pushed off the bearing seat, because there is no support left.
 
I don't understand what is supposed to be the motive for demolishing WTC7.

Do truthers suppose that the Powerful Secret Cabal didn't think people would be outraged enough by the two big towers being dropped, but that WTC7 would be one tower two many for the public?
 
The collapse of 7WTC appears to be an unforeseen and unintended consequence of the collapse of 1 WTC. It's not clear at all that the hijackers had any engineering expertise to know that hitting the towers with a jumbo would make them collapse.

For sure the main shock they wanted to cause was to hijack planes and use them as weapons... killing all on board and people in the buildings hit.

To this date there seems to be debate as to how the plane strike led to the building collapse. And there are some (truthers) who suggest that they towers were "too strong" to collapse without placed devices.

The runaways collapse phase... dubbed ROOSD seems to be the best fit explanation of that phase. There remains some fog about about the "ROOSD mass" was "freed" to drive the floor collapses, and then the toppling of the facade and core axial systems.

These towers depended in integrity of the structural system to remain standing. As the integrity was lost the structural failures rapidly raced through and undid the structural matrix and the buildings came down driven by gravity.

++++

Truthers need to come up with an explanation why and how the towers were taken down. They posit the main objective was to be the excuse to invade the ME... the so called "false flag", yet there was evidence that AQ was planning some sort of huge terrorist attack on US soil. This was included in a daily briefing to the POTUS in August. However the US had not way to prevent such an attack nor stop in in progress. The intel was not specific enough to prevent it. We had no policy to shot down commercial planes which were hijacked. Low tech trumped high tech... and our "security" was "defeated".

++++

Steel framed structures without effective fire fighting will likely fail after several hours. This was the case for the 3 buildings.

There were lessons learned from 9/11:
better Security at at airports and high profile terrorist targets
more robust fire protection systems for steel framed buildings
better systems for emergency egress of occupants in high rise buildings
redundant structural systems not (less) prone to runaway structural failures
better intel for/on non state actors
 
I don't understand what is supposed to be the motive for demolishing WTC7.

Do truthers suppose that the Powerful Secret Cabal didn't think people would be outraged enough by the two big towers being dropped, but that WTC7 would be one tower two many for the public?

They claim the CIA had a field office in WTC7 and they destroyed the building to get rid of files or whatever.

Yes, it gets stupider as they explain it.

I guarantee that in 9-10-2001 the CIA could have moved all of the files out of WTC7 with a marching band and cheerleaders and NOBODY would have cared. Most Truthers have never been to, let alone lived in NYC, New Yorkers and those who worked in the Twin Towers were always on the clock and if you got in their way they'd walk right over you to get to the office. They were almost all college educated and since most of the businesses in the WTC complex were financial based they were under a lot of pressure, and this means that any prep-work (i.e. jack hammers, the stench of cutting steel) would not only have been reported, they would have raised holy hell about it. They would still be talking about it today, how it interfered with their jobs.

To date there has yet to be any survivors of the WTC to come forward with tales of mysterious work crews or seeing anything out of the ordinary.

Every CT will gain steam with an anomaly, or perceived anomaly, or a collection of anomalies which can be used to create doubt even though none of the anomalies have anything to do with the actual event.

In the case of 911 this was a one-time spectacular event with a combination of moving parts. The problem is perceived reality verses reality.

Reception: Fire cannot bring down a high rise building.

Reality: Yes it can. WTC7 burned for almost 8 hours and there was undefined damage to the building from WTC1.

Perception: There's no way four hijacked airliners could fly unchallenged by the mighty USAF.

Reality: Ask anyone who's ever served in the military, especially in the Clinton era, about the USAF's capabilities to defend against an external attack, and then ask about an internal attack. The F-16's which launched out of D.C. were unarmed and the pilots planned to ram the jetliners.

Perception: The collapses of the Twin Towers and WTC7 looked like CD.

Reality: No they did not. There were no loud blasts and none of the buildings fell evenly as they would have under controlled demo.

Perception: Bush needed to fake 911 to invade Afghanistan and Iraq.

Reality: NOBODY wanted to invade Afghanistan in 2001. Everything that has happened since our invasion has not been a surprise to anyone with basic military history knowledge, or just reads Kipling. In the end the US joins a prestigious list of failures that starts with Alexander the Great. Iraq was a different matter. Saddam was an idiot and the sad fact was it was only a matter of time before he pulled something that would have justified invasion - but we couldn't wait for some reason.

I can't speak to the engineering side of WTC7 but I've read the NIST report, and while most of it is over my head the answers are there in their recommendations for building code changes. Truthers are not but on subtext because if they were the NIST spells out the many issues with WTC7 and the Twin Towers which helped doom them after the attack.
 
"Not only that, it will inform tens of thousands of engineers about the UAF report by sending postcards to a whopping 50,000 engineers, funding two dozen engineering presentations between now and August, and more."

How does AE 9/11 pick the engineers it will target?
 
From page iii:
EXTERNAL PEER REVIEWERS

Gregory Szuladzinski, Ph.D
Chartered Consulting Engineer
Analytical Service Company

Robert Korol, Ph.D
Emeritus Professor of Civil Engineering
McMaster University
​
​
Colour me surprised :rolleyes:

Many key mistakes of the draft have been replicated in the final report:
  • It does not really rebut Weidlinger's collapse initiation hypothesis, it merely talks about it with incredulity using pretty much the same wording as in the first version. That alone suffices to debunk one of the central claims of the report (that fire did not cause the collapse), as incredulity is not a strong enough reason to reject a report that proves otherwise.
  • They've kept this claim (section 4.3, p.95; PDF p.108):
    Based on these analyses, we found that Columns 79, 80, and 81 did not fail at the lower floors of the building (e.g., from Floor 6 to 13 or Floor 13 to 21). We found that the failure of Columns 79, 80, and 81 at the lower floors of the building would cause the building to tilt dramatically to the east[1], which would have been observed in the videos but was not[2], and that it would not cause the east penthouse to collapse, because the intact portions of Columns 79, 80, and 81 above where the columns failed would still support the penthouse.​
    As for [1], how dramatically is dramatically? Figure 4.2 shows a deflection of almost 10 inches to the east, the biggest of them. Figure 4.3 shows a deflection of 7.2 inches. In a video where 300 pixels represent 330 feet, 10 inches are about 0.9 pixels.

    Would a deflection of 0.9 pixels be visible in the videos? Not so much to the naked eye, unless you use some reference, but NIST came up with a method for sub-pixel measurement of displacement. They elaborate in appendix C of NCSTAR 1.9. The deflection they obtain is in the order of 6 inches to the east. Therefore [2] is false because this "dramatic" displacement was in fact observed in the videos. The question that remains is why did Hulsey's penthouse not collapse, and everyone else's (Weidlinger's, NIST's, ARUP's) collapse.
  • Figure 4.17(c) is still that joke of a simulation, where the penthouse cracks like an egg, pivoting on the top right instead of the bottom right. The Metabunk guys found that the animation was specifically crafted to produce the collapse seen in the videos, by means of manipulating certain parameters, and was NOT the result of the removal of all columns as the report seems to imply. They did NOT obtain an animation of the global collapse from an accurate physics simulation. Therefore this point (p.110, PDF p.123) is a lie:
    4. The simultaneous failure of all core columns over 8 stories followed 1.3 seconds later by the simultaneous failure of all exterior columns over 8 stories produces almost exactly the behavior observed in videos of the collapse. The collapse could have started at various floors starting at Floor 16 and below and produced the same behavior.​
They seem to have removed the ANSYS figure from the NIST report that they confused with the LS-DYNA analysis and patched the text accordingly. EDIT: My bad, the figure is still there and the text is essentially unchanged.

These are my findings on a first read.
 
Last edited:
Find the Final Report as well as the Draft Report and the Public Comments linked to from the UAF's project page:
http://ine.uaf.edu/projects/wtc7/

I submitted my comments on the Draft (13 pages!) to the intended email address [email protected] on November 14th, 21:31 UTC (that's Nov 14th in the day for all of the USA) - and yet they do not show up in the Public Comments published yesterday! :mad:

I emailed Hulsey and the interim Director of the Institute of Northern Engineering (INE), David Barnes, directly and separately to inquire about the whereabouts of my comments.

I find it curious that these comments were to be directed to an anonymous email address controlled by the sponsor of the study, giving them the means to censor comments they don't like. Even if Hulsey chose to ignore such criticism, they should at least now be part of the public record.


Did anyone else here submit comments? Are they included?
 
I don't understand what is supposed to be the motive for demolishing WTC7.

Do truthers suppose that the Powerful Secret Cabal didn't think people would be outraged enough by the two big towers being dropped, but that WTC7 would be one tower two many for the public?

I never understood this reasoning myself, or why they had too blow up the buildings. Its not like the Government would not declare war with just the buildings on fire, and still killing thousands of people. But reasoning is hard for truthers I guess.
 
I never understood this reasoning myself, or why they had too blow up the buildings. Its not like the Government would not declare war with just the buildings on fire, and still killing thousands of people. But reasoning is hard for truthers I guess.

I believe it is the distrust of the evil Government that lies most of the time and when investigating something no one had ever envisioned or believed could happen that the CTs went wild with their planes couldn't have done all the damage it HAD to be something else. Therein lies the connection towards the Government.
 
Truthers basically "think" everything from the media and the USG is a lie... The lies are meant to conceal some ugly truth... and in service to that they can essentially do and say anything... including controlling hundred and thousands of people to join in their fantasy.

Then come along a handful of false prophets who try to make scientific or engineering "sounding" arguments... write papers, books, lecture, do videos. None of it is based on facts. These guys are "cashing out" on the sheep who follow them.
 
Same as with the northwoods file, they say only an evil man could come up with this, but I Guess they never read a book, or wacthed a movie. because authors can write a lot more disturbing stuff.
 
Hi, is there a decent rebuttal/debunking summary published out there to this report?

Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom