Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Now let's revisit the animation that Dr. Hulsey presents to defend his claim that the simultaneous disappearance ("failure", using his words) of ALL core columns for 8 floors is what best reproduces the observed collapse. He gives no explanation as to how these columns would suddenly disappear out of the way. And he offers this animation as a proof that it reproduces the collapse better.

We now know, from the published data, that the acceleration profile was entered into the simulation in order to reproduce the collapse, i.e. that this result is not the output of the simulation, but the input.

Using that same approach and a physics engine, I've made my own animation. Here are the results (warning: 12 MB GIF animated image):

http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/penthouse-animation-vs-video.gif

I used this video for the comparison: https://archive.org/download/nsia-CBSNetNISTDub5/CBS-Net Dub5 24.avi and rotated it 2.46° CCW. Note the tilting, apparently induced by the east side starting to fall earlier than the west, refuting the "simultaneous failure of all columns" meme. For an object with that mass, this tilting was pretty significant. Not so noticeably, as the collapse progresses this tilting reverts in direction, probably due to the resistance of the still intact columns as they meet the already collapsed part.

If you can't see the difference that this tilting makes, here's a comparison with the same thing without tilting:

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/frame-229-without-rotation.png[/qimg]

This should settle the question of whether the building tilted during the collapse: yes it did, and Dr. Hulsey's animation does not represent this tilting.

Observe also the wedge that forms between the EPH and the screen wall while the EPH falls, not visible in Hulsey's simulation. I situated the pivot point at the base of the penthouse. In Hulsey's simulation, the penthouse appears to pivot around the rooftop's corner, impeding the wedge to form. Therefore, Hulsey's animation is less accurate with regards to the penthouse.

The animation, without the video background:

[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/penthouse-animation-solid.gif[/qimg]

Now one question that may arise: since my animation is more precise than Hulsey's and NIST's, does it mean it's of superior quality than any of these?

It's definitely of better quality than Hulsey's, because being based on the same approach of forcing it to follow the actual collapse, it does so with better precision. Unlike Hulsey's, it's able to exhibit the pivot point of the penthouse accurately as well as the tilting of the building. That's quite an accomplishment for it to be using a 2D physics engine!

And what about NIST's? NO, it's not of superior quality than NIST's. In fact, like Hulsey's, it's CRAP compared to NIST's, because NIST's animation is the output of the simulation, rather than the input. NIST did not just enter the positions where the video should be at specific frames, to produce the desired visual effect; instead, they performed a dynamic finite element analysis whose input was the initial conditions necessary for the collapse to start, and whose output was the animation they produced. Having it resemble the actual chaotic collapse to even some extent is quite an achievement.

In fact all evidence points to the building falling over on itself, as it did in 2005 when Dr. Steven E Jone proposed it was a CD.
Nothing has really changed since 2005 Hulsey's physics are the same as Jones's essentially worthless.
 
Anything interesting going on, on the Hulsey front?

No. Interest in the Hulsey Report - from both sides - seems to have petered out after about a month with almost no substantive contributions from the pro-Hulsey side. It seems unlikely they will make their $320k back in additional fundraising. But I could be wrong.
 
No. Interest in the Hulsey Report - from both sides - seems to have petered out after about a month with almost no substantive contributions from the pro-Hulsey side. It seems unlikely they will make their $320k back in additional fundraising. But I could be wrong.

They have been morally bankrupt for Quite some time let's hope financial Bankrupcy also embrasses them.
 
...
Chris Sarns AKA "Christpher 7" or "C7" is engaging with Mick West and other members over on Metabunk. Members may recall that C7, a core member of Gage's AE911 team, was a regular poster here some years back. Usually in episodic "spurts" of activity tag-teaming with other AE911 high profilers such as Tony Szamboti.

My cynical interpretation of his role is unchanged. His purpose is to drag out debate as per the aE911 agenda. I've judged him - with a bit of reluctant admiration - as a clever troll. His technique is to engage in rational debate including occasionally yielding on an issue or two under debate. Thereby convincing members that he is a serious debater. I cannot recall any other truther side troll who was clever enough to play that sort of "game".
...

A week ago, C7 hinted that representatives of Hulsey's sponsor, AE911Truth, are unhappy with the obviously unphysical models Hulsey has presented in his draft report:
https://www.metabunk.org/posts/235339/
I checked out the video and it appears that you are right. I notified the AE911Truth team of this and our mutual concerns about the unrealistic collapse models. The info has been forwarded to Dr. Hulsey. There will be a response to these and other questions/criticisms but it may take a while. Thank you for your observations. They will help Dr. Hulsey make these things clear.
 
A week ago, C7 hinted that representatives of Hulsey's sponsor, AE911Truth, are unhappy with the obviously unphysical models Hulsey has presented in his draft report:
https://www.metabunk.org/posts/235339/
Just recognise the point I made. C7's history of participation on this forum shows that many members were persuaded that he was engaging in reasoned rational debate. His most persuasive ploy was that he would occasionally agree with debunker critiques and or yield a point in debate. IMNSHO - and cynical assessment - a clever, devious and successful ploy.

Also don't overlook another strategic initiative on AE911 - the Chandler Coste led "push" to support plane at Pentagon. The pair who preach how committed they are to scientific method to support their pro-plane at Pentagon position. But no sign whatsoever of then retro-fitting scientific method reasoning to their CD at WTC claims.

Both strategies - C7's and Chandler/Coste's are yielding a debunker counter-claim point. To win support. Or rather to make them look more credible to debunkers. AND without the least change of position on their main themes. "Come in you debunker suckers - we will give you a couple of little points to distract you from the reality that we are set fast on our main points."

Now how long - how often - can they get away with it. Maybe another 10 years???? Maybe less? What is Gage's target horizon for his income security and ego tripping "job"?? Most truth leaders must know they lost the battle. Way back before the WTC 7 report. Since then their strategy has - de facto - been "play for time...keep the truther suckers fooled...no need to make arguments rigorous enough to defeat debunking counter claims...play for time....play for time...)
 
Last edited:
Just recognise the point I made. C7's history of participation on this forum shows that many members were persuaded that he was engaging in reasoned rational debate. His most persuasive ploy was that he would occasionally agree with debunker critiques and or yield a point in debate. IMNSHO - and cynical assessment - a clever, devious and successful ploy.

Also don't overlook another strategic initiative on AE911 - the Chandler Coste led "push" to support plane at Pentagon. The pair who preach how committed they are to scientific method to support their pro-plane at Pentagon position. But no sign whatsoever of then retro-fitting scientific method reasoning to their CD at WTC claims.

Both strategies - C7's and Chandler/Coste's are yielding a debunker counter-claim point. To win support. Or rather to make them look more credible to debunkers. AND without the least change of position on their main themes. "Come in you debunker suckers - we will give you a couple of little points to distract you from the reality that we are set fast on our main points."

Now how long - how often - can they get away with it. Maybe another 10 years???? Maybe less? What is Gage's target horizon for his income security and ego tripping "job"?? Most truth leaders must know they lost the battle. Way back before the WTC 7 report. Since then their strategy has - de facto - been "play for time...keep the truther suckers fooled...no need to make arguments rigorous enough to defeat debunking counter claims...play for time....play for time...)
They have nothing else left to them all the Science is in they are only fooling the gullible.
 
Just recognise the point I made.
I did recognize the point you made by linking to and quoting the latest example of what you described :)

...
Both strategies - C7's and Chandler/Coste's are yielding a debunker counter-claim point. To win support. Or rather to make them look more credible to debunkers. ...

I am not sure they are both doing it specifically with debunkers in mind. At least Coste, I believe, is seriously into it for credibility with the general population. He mostly avoids engaging debunkers.
He confesses to one conversion - from one who thought the Pentagon no-plane claims to be at least plausible. I suspect he has faint inklings that other beliefs may be false, too, and shuts his eyes and ears (and blocks me from his groups on Facebook :D) to avoid having to write off his last 10+ years of toil and ridicule.
 
I did recognize the point you made by linking to and quoting the latest example of what you described :)
My post was a bit too blunt. :o

At least Coste, I believe, is seriously into it for credibility with the general population. He mostly avoids engaging debunkers.
You are probaly correct - I have less experience of assessing Coste. And in one experience that we shared I deliberately did not take him "on" as a direct target for critique. I saw him as the far better guy than McKee.
 
I actually encountered Coste who set up a table to pass out AE911T at an event help at I believe John J College with speakers about fire catastrophes. I recall meeting Sally Regenhard whose sun was a young fire fighter who died on 9/11.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sally_Regenhard

There were some investigators from NIST who spoke too. It was informative and not focused on 9/11 as much a response to fire disasters...

Pushing 9/11 swill was, in my opinion, at that talk entirely inappropriate.

I think my car was towed or I got a ticket so it stays in my memory.
 
Mr. Jowenko gave a professionally related opinion.

He supports the Hulsey Report through his conviction that WTC7 absolutely could not have collapsed the way it did as a result of fire.

You do know he is dead right. For a few years now

And I am always amazed at truthers. Because for some reason, he is right about WTC7, but he is mistaken about WTC1 and 2.

But I guess everything is alowed to give any credit to the Hulsey report, which is getting no traction in the scientific comunity
 
Not much new in the debate of technical details.

Meanwhile AE911 has resuscitated J Bermas to work on a documentary... Preceded by the usual expected hyperbolic hoopla.

So - my summary - beating a dead horse.

And they asked the community $20.000 to make this movie, I guess truth has a price, because before they did it at own expenses

I am sure thats the reason, that he is broke and needs cash
 
And they asked the community $20.000 to make this movie, I guess truth has a price, because before they did it at own expenses

I am sure thats the reason, that he is broke and needs cash

Yes 9/11Truth is the giant Nothing Burger that keeps on giving nothing.
 
AE911Truth today has announced (vaguely) "that the final report of the University of Alaska Fairbanks computer modeling study on World Trade Center Building 7 will be published early next year".

https://www.ae911truth.org/news/631...y-2020-kicking-off-year-of-intensive-outreach

They do not say what "early next year" means. The first days of January? Before July 1st?

So far, they had said that the final report was expected to be released before the end of this year.
 
AE911Truth today has announced (vaguely) "that the final report of the University of Alaska Fairbanks computer modeling study on World Trade Center Building 7 will be published early next year".

https://www.ae911truth.org/news/631...y-2020-kicking-off-year-of-intensive-outreach

They do not say what "early next year" means. The first days of January? Before July 1st?

So far, they had said that the final report was expected to be released before the end of this year.

I just read that Message from them. I wonder who commented on the report, and if they, like NIST, will show the comments. Although I only think truthers will comment on this "report".

Its all just to help truthers sleep better at night.
 
I just read that Message from them. I wonder who commented on the report, and if they, like NIST, will show the comments. Although I only think truthers will comment on this "report".

Its all just to help truthers sleep better at night.

I am pretty sure they received serious critique. There should be at least two comments that rip the draft report apart.

Yes, I wonder, too, if they'll faithfully publish all received comments without censorship
 
I am pretty sure they received serious critique. There should be at least two comments that rip the draft report apart.

Yes, I wonder, too, if they'll faithfully publish all received comments without censorship

No they never published mine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom