Crazy Chainsaw
Philosopher
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2006
- Messages
- 8,339
Now let's revisit the animation that Dr. Hulsey presents to defend his claim that the simultaneous disappearance ("failure", using his words) of ALL core columns for 8 floors is what best reproduces the observed collapse. He gives no explanation as to how these columns would suddenly disappear out of the way. And he offers this animation as a proof that it reproduces the collapse better.
We now know, from the published data, that the acceleration profile was entered into the simulation in order to reproduce the collapse, i.e. that this result is not the output of the simulation, but the input.
Using that same approach and a physics engine, I've made my own animation. Here are the results (warning: 12 MB GIF animated image):
http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/penthouse-animation-vs-video.gif
I used this video for the comparison: https://archive.org/download/nsia-CBSNetNISTDub5/CBS-Net Dub5 24.avi and rotated it 2.46° CCW. Note the tilting, apparently induced by the east side starting to fall earlier than the west, refuting the "simultaneous failure of all columns" meme. For an object with that mass, this tilting was pretty significant. Not so noticeably, as the collapse progresses this tilting reverts in direction, probably due to the resistance of the still intact columns as they meet the already collapsed part.
If you can't see the difference that this tilting makes, here's a comparison with the same thing without tilting:
[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/frame-229-without-rotation.png[/qimg]
This should settle the question of whether the building tilted during the collapse: yes it did, and Dr. Hulsey's animation does not represent this tilting.
Observe also the wedge that forms between the EPH and the screen wall while the EPH falls, not visible in Hulsey's simulation. I situated the pivot point at the base of the penthouse. In Hulsey's simulation, the penthouse appears to pivot around the rooftop's corner, impeding the wedge to form. Therefore, Hulsey's animation is less accurate with regards to the penthouse.
The animation, without the video background:
[qimg]http://www.formauri.es/personal/pgimeno/xfiles/11-s/penthouse-animation-solid.gif[/qimg]
Now one question that may arise: since my animation is more precise than Hulsey's and NIST's, does it mean it's of superior quality than any of these?
It's definitely of better quality than Hulsey's, because being based on the same approach of forcing it to follow the actual collapse, it does so with better precision. Unlike Hulsey's, it's able to exhibit the pivot point of the penthouse accurately as well as the tilting of the building. That's quite an accomplishment for it to be using a 2D physics engine!
And what about NIST's? NO, it's not of superior quality than NIST's. In fact, like Hulsey's, it's CRAP compared to NIST's, because NIST's animation is the output of the simulation, rather than the input. NIST did not just enter the positions where the video should be at specific frames, to produce the desired visual effect; instead, they performed a dynamic finite element analysis whose input was the initial conditions necessary for the collapse to start, and whose output was the animation they produced. Having it resemble the actual chaotic collapse to even some extent is quite an achievement.
In fact all evidence points to the building falling over on itself, as it did in 2005 when Dr. Steven E Jone proposed it was a CD.
Nothing has really changed since 2005 Hulsey's physics are the same as Jones's essentially worthless.