How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Only if by "unique" you mean "generally accepted".

Fiat Money: money without intrinsic value.

I use "Fiat Money" to mean money as a financial instrument (asset/liability) that, as such, derives value because of a contractual relationship. It is money without intrinsic value.

Under this definition Bitcoin is certainly fiat money.

"Fiat money has been defined variously as:
any money declared by a government to be legal tender.[1]
state-issued money which is neither convertible by law to any other thing, nor fixed in value in terms of any objective standard.[2]
money without intrinsic value.[3][4]"
(wiki)

Fiat money, when discussing bitcoin, is primarly used in the meaning that it is state-issued and declared by government to be legal tender. Your definition, while technically true (and false), is just confusing. Did the inclusion of 'fiat' serve a specific purpose in the point you are making?
 
Are you saying that the text could say exchange rate guaranteed during checkout process...... even if the web page being linked to is about pink unicorns?

Did you read what BBB (Bitcoin Best Bid) is? It occurs during the checkout process. That is the guaranteed exchange rate they are talking about all over that page linked and which is also stated in the link description. The fact that the checkout process comment is on another page doesn't change the fact that they are both describing the BBB feature. I was simply consolidating the information because it related to the 15 minute Tiger Direct limitation on closing out Bitcoin purchases. Now who is making a dogs breakfast out of nothing.
 
Last edited:
Fiat Money: money without intrinsic value.


From your link:
While gold- or silver-backed representative money entails the legal requirement that the bank of issue redeem it in fixed weights of gold or silver, fiat money's value is unrelated to the value of any physical quantity. Even a coin containing valuable metal may be considered fiat currency if its face value is defined by law as different from its market value as metal.
If by "intrinsic value" you mean "market value" then there is definitely a market for bitcoin so it fails your definition of "fiat".

In any case, everybody else uses the first 2 definitions in your link:
  • any money declared by a government to be legal tender.
  • state-issued money which is neither convertible by law to any other thing, nor fixed in value in terms of any objective standard.
 
If by "intrinsic value" you mean "market value"

No, "intrinsic value" has a very specific meaning, and "market value" is not it. This has been discussed before.

In any case, everybody else uses the first 2 definitions in your link:
However, this is true. "Fiat money", in common usage (and especially in these forums), refers to reserve currency that isn't backed by any particular commodity or thing. Nitpicking that "bitcoin is fiat by this definition" doesn't really say anything at all, it's just wordplay to score Internet Points.

I'm sort of tired of watching that go on by -everyone-, TBH -- the ridiculous sideline about whether BitPay is a flippin' payment processor, which everyone knew that it was, for example, was a bunch of mind-numbingly stupid ****-waving.
 
Fiat money, when discussing bitcoin, is primarly used in the meaning that it is state-issued and declared by government to be legal tender.

I cannot believe that to be the case.

If there actually were people arguing that Bitcoin was state-issued legal tender, I could understand why most usage of "fiat money", in such discussions, would signify "a state-issued money, declared by a government to be legal tender".
But nobody argues this.

I apologize for any confusion.
My intent was to stimulate thought.

Did the inclusion of 'fiat' serve a specific purpose in the point you are making?

Yes, to counter claims that Bitcoin is "the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era."
To show that it is nothing new, that it is a financial (monetary) instrument like government money.
 
Yes, to counter claims that Bitcoin is (??) "the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era."
How about "bitcoin could be the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of an era where only governments issue money".

Can you twist that?

BTW why did you misquote me?
 
Last edited:
If by "intrinsic value" you mean "market value" then there is definitely a market for bitcoin so it fails your definition of "fiat".

I do NOT mean "market value".
In the context of money, "intrinsic value" is the value derived from the physical qualities or characteristics of its material form.
In the case of a coin, "intrinsic value" is the value of the metal from which it is made.
 
However, this is true. "Fiat money", in common usage (and especially in these forums), refers to reserve currency that isn't backed by any particular commodity or thing. Nitpicking that "bitcoin is fiat by this definition" doesn't really say anything at all, it's just wordplay to score Internet Points.

I disagree.
It counters the claim that Bitcoin is "the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era".
 
How about "bitcoin could be the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of an era where only governments issue money".

Can you twist that?

Private "monies" are nothing new, company scrip, arcade tokens, etc.
As long as government money is required to pay taxes it will always have some value/demand.

BTW why did you misquote me?

Honest mistake, maybe subconscious?
Never-the-less, I apologize.
 
Private "monies" are nothing new, company scrip, arcade tokens, etc.
As long as government money is required to pay taxes it will always have some value/demand.
That much is true. However, these forms of money all share the characteristic that they can be created at will by the issuer.

OTOH Nobody can create bitcoins and this is a significant difference. I'm not saying that because of this difference, government/privately created monies will be displaced. Crypto currencies may not even have a significant role in the future at all. It is just a possibility.
 
"Additional" seems like an overstatement since most of the issues raised in that link have been discussed at length in this thread.

Actually there are only two valid concerns raised by the article: the inelasticity of the supply of bitcoins and the fact that individuals are "on their own" when it comes to the security of their holdings or transactions. Little needs to be added to those topics at this stage.

The rest of the article is mostly anti-bitcoin propaganda. When they say that "The price of bitcoins will drop dramatically in the future. Why and when this will happen is anybody’s guess and is irrelevant" without any justification whatsoever then you need to take the article with a grain of salt.
 
That much is true. However, these forms of money all share the characteristic that they can be created at will by the issuer.

OTOH Nobody can create bitcoins and this is a significant difference.y.

Good point.
It makes me think that Bitcoins aren't even a monetary instrument but a commodity.
All monetary/financial instruments give rise to both a financial asset (of the bearer) & a corresponding liability (of the issuer).
No liability, no financial asset.
In the case of Bitcoin we have an asset but, unless I'm mistaken, no liability.
That would make Bitcoins a real asset, a commodity.
 
I cannot believe that to be the case.

If there actually were people arguing that Bitcoin was state-issued legal tender, I could understand why most usage of "fiat money", in such discussions, would signify "a state-issued money, declared by a government to be legal tender".
But nobody argues this.

I apologize for any confusion.
My intent was to stimulate thought.

The point is that bitcoin is not "a state-issued money, declared by a government to be legal tender", hence bitcoin is not fiat money. The debates all over the net is basically fiat money vs cryptocurrencies.

As I understand all you meant was that bitcoin is not commodity money. Sure, and neither are the mainstream currencies it is compared to.

All in all, no need to apologize ;)

Yes, to counter claims that Bitcoin is "the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era."
To show that it is nothing new, that it is a financial (monetary) instrument like government money.

Alright, but that wasn't even the claim, never mind the quote mining.
And yes, it is something new in the currency landscape. Whether it survives is another matter. I see it has potential, and obviously so do many others.
 
Good point.
It makes me think that Bitcoins aren't even a monetary instrument but a commodity.
All monetary/financial instruments give rise to both a financial asset (of the bearer) & a corresponding liability (of the issuer).
No liability, no financial asset.
In the case of Bitcoin we have an asset but, unless I'm mistaken, no liability.
That would make Bitcoins a real asset, a commodity.

There has been much discussion on weather Bitcoin is a commodity or a currency. I think the truth lies not in definitions, but in how it behaves. And for now at least it is behaving like a commodity. I personally think it can and may jump the gap, or it may simply blur the lines and define its own category. A commodency, maybe?
 
And yes, it is something new in the currency landscape. Whether it survives is another matter. I see it has potential, and obviously so do many others.

I've started a new thread, here, about future developments of Bitcoin and/or other cryptocurrencies, for those of us that would like to focus more deeply on the technology, where it is heading, potential future uses, etc.

And we can leave discussion of bitcoin price movements, exchanges, and whether it is a currency, a commodity, a dessert topping or a floor wax, financial ideologies, and those other delightful exchanges that have kept this thread going for so long right here where they belong :)

Thanks to remirol for the suggestion.

I hope some of you will join me there.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=272868
 
And for now at least it is behaving like a commodity. I personally think it can and may jump the gap, or it may simply blur the lines and define its own category. A commodency, maybe?

I think you're right.
Until it has an issuer Bitcoin will behave like a commodity, as a real not financial asset.
To be a monetary instrument the creation of Bitcoins must give rise to both a financial asset (of the bearer) & corresponding liability (of the issuer).
There needs to be a Bitcoin issuer of which Bitcoins are a liability (to accept back bitcoins at face value in payments - to create & destroy them)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom