How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm commenting on the ongoing trend here, which is ridiculous. You're making claims and get defensive when asked to provide evidence. Even though you say you don't have a horse in this race, it seems mightily biased.

The first post I made was based on checking the Bitcoin payment option on TigerDirect and noticing that they used Bitpay and then reading carefully what TigerDirect had in it's bitcoin payment process. I was pretty sure that I had previously checked that Bitpay was an intermediary but I didn't verify that.

Since TigerDirect only allows 15 minutes for the transaction to be closed, I pretty much believe that they are not transferring to their wallet, instead, they are using Bitpay to cash out as described on the Bitpay site.

I think that the big fuss being made here is on the part of the bitcoin supporters, anyone else could tell what I could, TigerDirect isn't taking bitcoin and holding them. You don't even believe they are. I mean isn't it obvious that it's better not to take the risk of a loss and let the intermediary do that since that is really what they are for right now?
 
:sdl: You're not very good at this are you?

Actually you should look around a bit more.

The second mentioned link is actually titled "Bitcoin Exchange Rates" and (surprise surprise) the words "checkout" and "guaranteed" don't appear once on that page.

I will let you find these on the Bitpay site. Porkie anyone?
 

Attachments

  • bitpay.jpg
    bitpay.jpg
    19.1 KB · Views: 8
  • bitpay1.jpg
    bitpay1.jpg
    19.8 KB · Views: 8
Actually you should look around a bit more.



I will let you find these on the Bitpay site. Porkie anyone?
Considering that the screenshot you posted is of a different web page to the one you linked to (with the false title) I think I will leave that honour with you.
 
Since TigerDirect only allows 15 minutes for the transaction to be closed, I pretty much believe that they are not transferring to their wallet, instead, they are using Bitpay to cash out as described on the Bitpay site.

How does that follow? The time limit is probably implemented by BitPay API to protect against price volatility (both for the merchant and the customer). Whether it's USD or bitoins received by TigerDirect, either way the transaction first goes through BitPay's temporary wallets (at least that's how CoinBase does it AFAIK). The time limit doesn't seem to indicate anything regarding the form of payment TigerDirect receives.

I think that the big fuss being made here is on the part of the bitcoin supporters, anyone else could tell what I could, TigerDirect isn't taking bitcoin and holding them. You don't even believe they are. I mean isn't it obvious that it's better not to take the risk of a loss and let the intermediary do that since that is really what they are for right now?

Yes I personally don't believe they are taking bitcoins, mostly because that might bring complications regarding taxation, but I may be grossly mistaken here (I know nothing about US tax laws).
 
Last edited:
Considering that the screenshot you posted is of a different web page to the one you linked to (with the false title) I think I will leave that honour with you.

Like I said, your nitpicking simply demonstrates the lack of substance in your complaint. I don't see how the text that I include in the link is required to be in the web page pointed to. The text in the link was an expansion of what was pointed to (BBB process). You just keep whining and nitpicking, it really helps your case.
 
How does that follow? The time limit is probably implemented by BitPay API to protect against price volatility (both for the merchant and the customer). Whether it's USD or bitoins received by TigerDirect, either way the transaction first goes through BitPay's temporary wallets (at least that's how CoinBase does it AFAIK). The time limit doesn't seem to indicate anything regarding the form of payment TigerDirect receives.


I think I pretty clearly stated this is what I believe. Ergo, my conclusion based on the evidence available. Doesn't have to be the same conclusion you draw.
 
Yes TigerDirect is using BitPay to process its payments.

Yes, BitPay is a “middleman”, which offers merchants the option of keeping their bitcoins or having other currency deposited into their account daily, weekly, monthly, or on demand.

https://bitpay.com/faq

But here is the problem meg, those bitcoins need to be converted to cash because Tiger Direct isn't really taking bitcoins directly anymore than any other merchant is right now. That puts the onus of producing cash for the bitcoins on the bitcoin middle man.

Which, unless BitPay is hoarding all the bitcoins gathered from the 15,000+ merchants they provide service to, is already happening, and has been since BitPay started in 2011. These coins are in the exchanges now. They are moving now. And they are getting the cash which is going into merchant accounts now.

https://bitpay.com/bitcoin-exchange-rates

If the middle man dumps them into the exchange, money has to be provided to the middle man and that crimps the fake price games being played on the exchanges.

Or your assumption that the exchanges are run by “fake price games” is false. Or your assumption that a middleman service liquidating bitcoins on the exchanges somehow “crimps” the price is false.

TigerDirect only allows you 15 minutes to pay with Bitcoin. It's obvious that the volatility is a problem and they are dumping bitcoins as soon as they get them. I think that if bitcoin is priced somewhere between $15 and $150 that it will be more likely to stabilize. Of course that means that the real value of bitcoin is far less than bitcoin promoters would like to see. It also means that a bitcoin economy is tiny.

By using a service to exchange the bitcoins to cash, TigerDirect has solved its problem with volatility. Apparently it is not as monumental of a problem as you think. As I've said before, if bitcoin were the only currency around, its volatility would be a problem. It's not, though. It's an option. And apparently it's not so volatile within 15 minute increments that the risk is unmanageable.

And no. You saying that you think if bitcoin were at X price it would be stable is meaningless and unsupported. Your statement does not then “of course that means” anything at all.

Bank of America strategists estimate that the “real value” of bitcoin at around $1300.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/samanth...f-america-puts-a-price-on-the-virtual-tender/

The only way for the bitcoin economy to grow is if the price of bitcoin in $ escalates and even then, you have the problem that now it's a buy and hold thing which limits the utility of bitcoin as a currency.

And yet the merchants accepting bitcoin, and the volume of transactions they process in bitcoin grows steadily every day. The amount of people selling, trading and shopping grows every day. Obviously, not everyone is holding.
 
I don't see how the text that I include in the link is required to be in the web page pointed to.
The problem is that some people might actually click on the link and find that it is completely different to what your text says it is. Some posters might not want to destroy their credibility this way.

You could have just posted something like, "TigerDirect doesn't collect bitcoins directly but uses Bitpay as a middle man which very likely converts at least some of the bitcoins into cash before paying TigerDirect" and you wouldn't have a credibility problem.
 
Just heard on the BBC that "The Department of Justice said Robert Faiella, known as BTCKing, and Charlie Shrem from BitInstant.com have both been charged with money laundering." Something to do with the closure of Silk Road.

link

Might be old news ... dunno
 
Last edited:
Just heard on the BBC that "The Department of Justice said Robert Faiella, known as BTCKing, and Charlie Shrem from BitInstant.com have both been charged with money laundering." Something to do with the closure of Silk Road.

link

Might be old news ... dunno



This is not much of a surprise. BitInstant has been shut down since last July. There have been class action lawsuits filed against them for poor service. The rumor mill's been running that they've been under investigation for a long time.
 
The problem is that some people might actually click on the link and find that it is completely different to what your text says it is. Some posters might not want to destroy their credibility this way.

Are you saying that the text in the link isn't factual?


You could have just posted something like, "TigerDirect doesn't collect bitcoins directly but uses Bitpay as a middle man which very likely converts at least some of the bitcoins into cash before paying TigerDirect" and you wouldn't have a credibility problem.

Actually I think maybe my "credibility" is only in question with you and the bitcoin supporters. I have made the post completely clear now so even you should be happy.
 
I think I pretty clearly stated this is what I believe. Ergo, my conclusion based on the evidence available. Doesn't have to be the same conclusion you draw.

I understand it's what you believe. I'm curious of your thought process, ie how the conclusion follows from the premise.
 
Or your assumption that the exchanges are run by “fake price games” is false.

The fact that MtGox is 25% higher than the lowest quote tells me the price is fake, at least on that exchange.


Or your assumption that a middleman service liquidating bitcoins on the exchanges somehow “crimps” the price is false.

Apparently TigerDirect did $500,000 in three days and except for a couple of pumps, the price has been falling. In fact, that 2hr 200ma was a wall against the pumpers, they failed and now the price is back below both the 2hr 50ma and the 50dma. Now you can read into the latest govt announcement whatever you want.


By using a service to exchange the bitcoins to cash, TigerDirect has solved its problem with volatility. Apparently it is not as monumental of a problem as you think. As I've said before, if bitcoin were the only currency around, its volatility would be a problem. It's not, though. It's an option. And apparently it's not so volatile within 15 minute increments that the risk is unmanageable.

As long as Bitpay takes the risk it's all good for TigerDirect. The thing is, I would think that a two way business could be had between TigerDirect and AMD. If AMD took bitcoin then they could sell more GPUs I bet. Course I bet the profit margins are still pretty good on those chips so they may not want bitcoin.

And yet the merchants accepting bitcoin, and the volume of transactions they process in bitcoin grows steadily every day. The amount of people selling, trading and shopping grows every day. Obviously, not everyone is holding.

That is what bitcoin needs but it also needs that cash in there to liquidate it until prices are posted in bitcoin. In the meantime, it needs a pretty stable $ price. I think you have to get people paid in bitcoin for their actual work for it to really take hold. It's not going to work with merchants taking it unless they can ultimately spend it. Employees seems the most likely place for them to do that. Hmm, wonder how the IRS would treat bitcoin payments.
 
It's not going to work with merchants taking it unless they can ultimately spend it. Employees seems the most likely place for them to do that. Hmm, wonder how the IRS would treat bitcoin payments.

It's old news, but:

Kentucky Police Chief’s Salary Paid in Bitcoin

This approval paved the way for the city’s transaction with Vaughn today, which would make it the first instance of a US government entity paying an employee via cryptocurrency.

According to Cummings, Vaughn’s salary would have federal and state taxes deducted before being converted to bitcoin at the prevailing rate. This would be done on a month-by-month basis.
 
Last edited:
Hmm, wonder how the IRS would treat bitcoin payments.


Apparently the IRS is still undecided on how to treat bitcoin for taxation purposes:
The U.S. Internal Revenue Service should give taxpayers clear rules on how it will handle transactions involving Bitcoin and other digital currencies, Nina Olson, the National Taxpayer Advocate, said today. (10 Jan)

.................................

The IRS today reiterated a statement it issued in December.

“The IRS is aware of the potential tax compliance risks posed by virtual currencies,” it said in the statement. “The IRS continues to study virtual currencies and intends to provide some guidance on the tax consequences of virtual currency transactions.”

According to Olson’s report, a big distinction for the IRS to make is whether Bitcoin is property, in which case capital gains rules would apply with a top basic rate of 20 percent. If it’s treated like a “nonfunctional currency,” ordinary income tax rates would apply with a top rate of 39.6 percent.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-01-09/clear-bitcoin-tax-rules-needed-taxpayer-advocate-says.html
 
I don't know whether to post :dl: or to ask you how the government spends bitcoin into existence.

The problem is that you have a very unique definition of "fiat".

Only if by "unique" you mean "generally accepted".

Fiat Money: money without intrinsic value.

I use "Fiat Money" to mean money as a financial instrument (asset/liability) that, as such, derives value because of a contractual relationship. It is money without intrinsic value.

Under this definition Bitcoin is certainly fiat money.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom