How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, so those transactions which go USD-BTC-USD-stuff.

Can you see how the BTC is a bit superfluous there? And how there's not really anything tying it to any specific value? That is the problem. That is why it isn't a currency, but at best a store of value for things that are currencies.
I am actually not sure what you mean here, but let me explain how it works in a hypothetical case.

Assume in a alternate universe people have two currencies, one is inflationary and the other is deflationary. Each has various advantages and disadvantages over the other. At some point, an equilibrium will be reached and the two currencies will each have some share of the overall market. But these shares may be in wildly different markets and market segments.

Does not matter really how things look when the dust settles. There is no such thing as one of the two currencies being 'superfluous'.

As noted in Hyack's essay, giving consumers a choice of currencies has nothing but good benefits, in the extreme it eliminates the massive human suffering and starvation that has been seen to accompany hyperinflationary events. This is clearly nothing to take lightly.

If Bitcoin is so widely accepted, why are escrow agents needed?

A) For your statement 'accepted' has some relation to presence or absence of escrow, I do not see any connection.

In the case of the seller of the sbux cards in question, I have delt with him before and do not need escrow. But it is built into the auction site. I may have bought some cards from him direct, also.
 
Last edited:
I know virtually nothing about bitcoin but I'm not sure how buying a pizza and a Starbucks card shows how useful it is.
 
Where YYY =/= Starbucks. Funny how you omitted that.

Mhaze, you really didn't answer this. Your Bitcoin payment didn't go to Starbucks. Starbucks doesn't accept Bitcoins in any way, shape or form. They accept USD from Coingig.

And I found this in Coingig's FAQs:

To start selling on Coingig it is very easy, you just need to sign up as a seller if you are a new user. If you have signed up as a buyer previously, you are able to become a seller easily by just providing the required seller information in the settings section and voilà you’re a seller! On Coingig we only work with a fixed-price model so each item listed will have to include it’s final price.

What do you suppose the "final price" is denominated in? Hint: Not BTC.
 
I know virtually nothing about bitcoin but I'm not sure how buying a pizza and a Starbucks card shows how useful it is.
Good question, but we've got Remirol posting in this thread that has refused to believe, and who has repeatedly called me a liar for six months that pizzas / hulu subscriptions/starbucks cards etc could be bought with bitcoin.

A move from denial of reality to questioning the merits of said reality would be a definite step forward.
 
But we already knew you could buy drugs with bitcoin. Starbucks cards being used to lauder credit card fraud doesn't seem like much of an improvement.

So scamming and buying drugs is unique to bitcoin now? :rolleyes:

There are plenty of flaws with bitcoin and crypto-currencies in general that need to be solved, but it's really hard to understand this reactionary nonsense going on in this thread.

You have provided evidence of buying things through intermediaries who accept Bitcoin. That's all well and good, but it is NOT evidence that the end sellers accept Bitcoin. The end sellers are accepting the USD that they get from the intermediary, not Bitcoins.

I really can't make this any simpler for you.

Are you suggesting that there aren't any vendors that accept bitcoin as payment? Because, on the previous page, I provided a list of vendors that allegedly do. It's transaction from a wallet (to temporary wallets) to a wallet (that's just the first bitcoin API hit I got when googling it).
 
Mhaze, you really didn't answer this. Your Bitcoin payment didn't go to Starbucks. Starbucks doesn't accept Bitcoins in any way, shape or form. They accept USD from Coingig.

And I found this in Coingig's FAQs:

What do you suppose the "final price" is denominated in? Hint: Not BTC.
No, Coingig has nothing to do with Starbucks. Coingig is an auction site.

Next issue, I am dealing with 'buy it now'. Here....

Someone lists sbux card for sale on coingig. The card originates from and has value measured in some currency - usd, euro, whatever. That is how we call it out. "I am buying 100usd sbux for 39usd equivalent", etc.

The transaction is at the moment of hitting the final click, that amount of value in bitcoin moved from buyer's address to escrow address in the blockchain, plus a return for the 'spare change' from the originating address. Some time later, after escrow clears, that amount goes from the escrow address in the blockchain to the seller, plus a return for the 'spare change' of the escrow agent's bitcoin.

It's not complicated, really.

Here's another interesting auction item.

http://coingig.com/CoinTrade/100-To-your-PayPal-through-Bitcoin-with-Escrow-6416

So scamming and buying drugs is unique to bitcoin now? :rolleyes:

There are plenty of flaws with bitcoin and crypto-currencies in general that need to be solved, but it's really hard to understand this reactionary nonsense going on in this thread.

Are you suggesting that there aren't any vendors that accept bitcoin as payment? Because, on the previous page, I provided a list of vendors that allegedly do. It's transaction from a wallet (to temporary wallets) to a wallet (that's just the first bitcoin API hit I got when googling it).

I guess it's fine to think in terms of wallet to wallet. Maybe I should not have said it as in the bolded section above. But these people seem confused about when and how conversions between currency and bitcoin occur...
 
Last edited:
So scamming and buying drugs is unique to bitcoin now? :rolleyes:

There are plenty of flaws with bitcoin and crypto-currencies in general that need to be solved, but it's really hard to understand this reactionary nonsense going on in this thread.



Are you suggesting that there aren't any vendors that accept bitcoin as payment? Because, on the previous page, I provided a list of vendors that allegedly do. It's transaction from a wallet (to temporary wallets) to a wallet (that's just the first bitcoin API hit I got when googling it).

The map shows 115 businesses worldwide.

And the list isn't very impressive, really, and it gets less impressive when you take out the sites selling stuff to mine BTC and BTC exchanges.
 
No, Coingig has nothing to do with Starbucks. Coingig is an auction site.

Next issue, I am dealing with 'buy it now'. Here....

Someone lists sbux card for sale on coingig. The card originates from and has value measured in some currency - usd, euro, whatever. That is how we call it out. "I am buying 100usd sbux for 39usd equivalent", etc.

The transaction is at the moment of hitting the final click, that amount of value in bitcoin moved from buyer's address to escrow address in the blockchain, plus a return for the 'spare change' from the originating address. Some time later, after escrow clears, that amount in USD goes from the escrow address in the blockchain to the seller, plus a return for the 'spare change' of the escrow agent's bitcoin.

It's not complicated, really.

You left the bolded part out.
 
Mhaze, you really didn't answer this. Your Bitcoin payment didn't go to Starbucks. Starbucks doesn't accept Bitcoins in any way, shape or form. They accept USD from Coingig.

And I found this in Coingig's FAQs:

I really have no idea what Starbucks accepts, but does Coingig deal in USDs?

Because I found this in the FAQ:
Sellers

<snip>

How do I receive a payment from Coingig?

<snip>

Please make sure that the wallet address entered when signing up is the correct wallet address, we will be sending all payments to this address, to view or change address visit the settings page in the account panel.
 
The map shows 115 businesses worldwide.

And the list isn't very impressive, really, and it gets less impressive when you take out the sites selling stuff to mine BTC and BTC exchanges.

Well, I wasn't trying to impress you, just curious what's your point. There's a growing list of vendors accepting bitcoin, that's a fact. Certainly not an impressive list, but no-one claimed every vendor is accepting bictoins (that's the battle bitcoin enthusiasts are fighting right now). Heck, some vendors don't accept debit/credit cards either.
 
Well, I wasn't trying to impress you, just curious what's your point. There's a growing list of vendors accepting bitcoin, that's a fact. Certainly not an impressive list, but no-one claimed every vendor is accepting bictoins (that's the battle bitcoin enthusiasts are fighting right now). Heck, some vendors don't accept debit/credit cards either.

But the list of bitcoin accepters is horribly tiny (compared to those who don't), as is the number of vendors who don't accept debit/credit cards (compared to those who do).
 
You left the bolded part out.

Blockchains don't carry USDs. ETA: Well blockchain is essentially just a log, it's more accurate to say that there're no USD transactions possible between bitcoin wallets/addresses, which is the type of transaction we are talking about. What you have in that process that mhaze described is purely crypto-currency, from the beginning to the end. A quick google seems to suggest that Starbucks doesn't accept bitcoins, so the actual seller in the described scenario perhaps isn't Starbucks. (might be wrong here)
 
Last edited:
But the list of bitcoin accepters is horribly tiny (compared to those who don't), as is the number of vendors who don't accept debit/credit cards (compared to those who do).

Certainly. I, for one, would like to see more vendors accept bitcoins. Right now, bitcoin as a currency is indeed practically useless to me. I don't expect a change in the financial world happen overnight, but one might hope we will gradually get there.
 
The map shows 115 businesses worldwide.

And the list isn't very impressive, really, and it gets less impressive when you take out the sites selling stuff to mine BTC and BTC exchanges.

No, that map is not at all accurate. There has been recently a discussion on the Bitcoin Foundation blog, which is not public access. It is about how to gather and maintain a list of businesses that take bitcoin.

LOL...obviously nobody wants to do the work...some kind of automatic aggregation should work, though...

I really have no idea what Starbucks accepts, but does Coingig deal in USDs?

Because I found this in the FAQ:
I think it's right that from beginning to end on Coingig, there is no currency moving around, or mc/visa, or paypal.....just bitcoin.

Would not matter to me if they did dual or triple mode, just trying to answer the question.
 
Last edited:
They certainly occur before the seller accepts the transaction.

ETA: When you can go here:

http://www.starbucks.com/

and pay with Bitcoins, I'll concede your point.
ahh....you'd be conceding a different point, then...I guess. But do not be surprised if Sbux picks up on a trendy nerdy thing like bitcoin.

And I'd rather get the sbux cards on the cheap through the auction site, than pay full retail with btc, usd or whatever.
 
I think it's right that from beginning to end on Coingig, there is no currency moving around, or mc/visa, or paypal.....just bitcoin.

Would not matter to me if they did dual or triple mode, just trying to answer the question.

Sure. And in the end, each of us individually will use whatever form of payment is available, cheaper or easier anyway. I was making an observation that jhunter1163, while quoting one part of the FAQ might have not read the other relevant part of the FAQ. (ie Starbucks indeed doesn't accept bitcoins but Coingig doesn't pay in USDs (to anyone).)
 
Last edited:
I am actually not sure what you mean here, but let me explain how it works in a hypothetical case.

Assume in a alternate universe people have two currencies, one is inflationary and the other is deflationary. Each has various advantages and disadvantages over the other. At some point, an equilibrium will be reached and the two currencies will each have some share of the overall market. But these shares may be in wildly different markets and market segments.

Does not matter really how things look when the dust settles. There is no such thing as one of the two currencies being 'superfluous'.

As noted in Hyack's essay, giving consumers a choice of currencies has nothing but good benefits, in the extreme it eliminates the massive human suffering and starvation that has been seen to accompany hyperinflationary events. This is clearly nothing to take lightly.

Bitcoin is not a currency. It has no market of its own with which to "settle" against the dollar, so your paper isn't even applicable. No one is accepting bitcoin for anything unless its getting turned into an actual currency first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom