How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
A look at the pictures you keep posting suggests that the oscillations are dying down and the BTC price is settling in the $800s while the market takes a breather.

For BTC to go up significantly, someone's going to need to buy in somewhere. The problem is that buying in at this price isn't rational, and the supply of suckers has been temporarily exhausted.

The stacks have evened out volume-wise at the moment (see spoiler tag, pasted from bitcoinwisdom and market bitstamp) but it's still trending slightly downwards. I think the blobs at 870+ and 835- are going to stay there for awhile and it'll piddle around there while people poke at it with sticks. There'll have to be some new good news for BTC to spike significantly again, and I don't see where that'll come from -- most recent news has been about external forces slamming the brakes onto BTC because of the regulatory issues and requirements it presents.


"asks"
875 435
870 414
865 309
860 139
855 78
850 38



"bids"
850 8
845 25
840 400
835 506
830 513



 
For BTC to go up significantly, someone's going to need to buy in somewhere.....

Meanwhile, in the real world, I am buying a couple more Hulu+ subscriptions for Chrismas presents. And a couple hundred dollars of Starbucks cards. For Chrismas presents. Maybe a few other things. But only if they are seriously good deals.

And I'm buying them with bitcoin at huge discounts over what could be done on a service like Ebay, using Paypal.

Then, since I like to own bitcoins, I'll repurchase the same amount of coins - probably about 0.6 btc - at Coinbase. Easy and convenient.

And while the Jrats use the psychological tactic of Denial to ignore this, I will be simply using bitcoin to get good deals.

Cheers!

Merry Chrismas!
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, in the real world, I am buying a couple more Hulu+ subscriptions for Chrismas presents. And a couple hundred dollars of Starbucks cards. For Chrismas presents.

And I'm buying them with bitcoin at huge discounts over what could be done on a service like Ebay, using Paypal.

No, you aren't. You /think/ you are.
 
I disagree with the bitcoiners in that I don't believe bitcoin is a currency at the moment, for any reasonable definition of the word. What it is, is a speculative digital asset which makes it relatively easy and cost effective to transfer wealth across borders and subvert capital controls. Its value is mostly just liquidity premium, as well as speculation that it may function as a popular global medium of exchange at some time in the future. Bitcoin as a speculative investment has its limits, and at some point in the future its price will stabilize. It is at this moment that it will begin to function more like a currency as other assets, as well as consumer goods and services will begin to look relatively attractive, and strong bitcoin hands will be more liable to exchange them for other things. It's also possible that some technical or legal problem will cause the price to plummet. But the rate of deflation in things typically priced in BTC (ie: mostly USD and other fiat currencies at the moment) will slow as bitcoins themselves slow to appreciate. The fact that people are willing to sell bitcoins even given such substantial gains and the prospects for future gains, is reflective of the fact that some people, at some points in time, are willing to part with valuable assets, even in exchange for consumer goods. Moderate deflation is not a bad thing as you seem to imply, although there is nothing moderate about bitcoin at the moment.



Who benefits from the inflation and the newly created altcoins? Or would it be miners as a function of the difficulty? And why would people choose to accept a depreciating crypto-currency when they could instead accept, and save in, an appreciating crypto-currency instead? The reason that bitcoin has caught on like wildfire, is because that it is scarce, which most intelligent people recognize is a property of value. It also promises some future utility as a medium of exchange, not just the (volatile) store of value that it as a digital asset represents now.

Bitcoin holders will not continue to enjoy several thousand percent a year capital gains in perpetuity, and when this time comes, any utility it has as a medium of exchange will be realized, but not so much before then, despite whether or not you can buy the odd pizza or car with it now. And I know first hand from a friend who has a large stake in BTC that the infrastructure to do just that is being built up around bitcoin, at this very moment. The rabid bitcoin skeptics are either ignorant of, or in denial of this.
You're preaching Someday. That's fine, we all need a Someday. But I'm not certain that day will come on its own. See, bitcoin is still a very niche product. It really, truly hasn't caught on like wildfire in any sense of the word. At all. The slightest bit of attention from the external world causes huge fluctuations in price. The price *had* stabilized, as of a month or two ago. Then Baidu decided to adopt it as a method of payment, and it shot up 10x practically overnight. Then Baidu stopped taking it as payment, and it's been gradually relaxing back down. The price will never stabilize without a large enough volume of actual trade, not speculative exchange, and you'll never get a large volume of trade until the price stabilizes. But Someday, sure, the general utility might outweigh its deflationary promise.

In the meantime, Someday may be accelerated somewhat by an inflationary currency that would have actual utility as actual currency. The mined coins would go to the miners, of course, which is why I'd prefer an ASIC-hostile solution, but the important thing is the inflation itself. With a large but stable rate, liquid coinage would start burning a hole in people's pockets. They'd want to spend them, to give them to people who will also want to spend them, because they do you no good devaluing in your wallet. That's a little more like how this whole economy thing works, rather than waiting for the arbitrary trading value to stop fluctuating before you actually trade it for something of value.
 
No, you aren't. You /think/ you are.

Yes, I am.

...Someday may be accelerated somewhat by an inflationary currency that would have actual utility as actual currency. The mined coins would go to the miners, of course, which is why I'd prefer an ASIC-hostile solution, but the important thing is the inflation itself. With a large but stable rate, liquid coinage would start burning a hole in people's pockets. They'd want to spend them, to give them to people who will also want to spend them, because they do you no good devaluing in your wallet. That's a little more like how this whole economy thing works, rather than waiting for the arbitrary trading value to stop fluctuating before you actually trade it for something of value.

This would be correct in the case of a single currency, but is incorrect when consumers have several currencies freely available to them use, exchange and purchase with.
 
Last edited:
This would be correct in the case of a single currency, but is incorrect when consumers have several currencies freely available to them use, exchange and purchase with.
Do you mean "bitcoin and the current host of bitcoin clones," or "bitcoin and this new coin?"
 
So no margin trading means even less liquidity is available. What we've got is a few Bitwhales passing coins between each other's wallets to keep the "bid" high, and siphoning the cash off from the suckers who join the party late. I guess if you don't get greedy and dump a whole bunch of BTC at once, you could do this for a while. Sooner or later though, the new money will stop coming in, at least not in meaningful amounts. That's when you'll see the bubble pop.

Well, yeah. You wouldn't actually stop doing it until you stop seeing your own numbers go up by any appreciable amount. That's when there's no new money coming in, and then you start trying to get out as gradually as you can -- the goal is to sell the vast majority of yours off before anyone realizes what's happening, so that you're on the leading edge of the pulse and everyone else is boned.

The risk of course is that the hypothetical 'you' in this case is not the only person doing this, by a long shot. Adversarial partnerships-of-circumstance such as the one we see here are far from unusual, but they aren't going to be talking on the phone/via email to each other and arranging it -- so whenever one decides to 'defect'*, all the other players have to spot it right away and choose for themselves whether to pick up his slack or follow his lead. The crash will come when enough of them follow the leader.

And I thought it was the bitwhales and their coin shuffling that set the price. Where are they now?

This was mentioned previously; see above.
 
This was mentioned previously; see above.

So how do you differentiate between 'someone buying in' and bitwhale manipulation? Honest question. I'm daytrading various crypto-currencies, small amounts and just for fun.

Well, yeah. You wouldn't actually stop doing it until you stop seeing your own numbers go up by any appreciable amount.

The amount being?

Your speculation, while plausible, seems to be based on no actual evidence, and in fact could be substituted with 'someone somewhere buying in', which has exactly the same amount of explanatory value sans the conspiracy factor.
 
Do you mean "bitcoin and the current host of bitcoin clones," or "bitcoin and this new coin?"
Neither. I mean an individual having ready access, like in my example, usd, euros, australian dollars, bitcoin....

more generally, i mean a fiat currency which is relatively stable, and the bitcoin. (So called 'bitcoin clones' can for now be disregarded.)

For a full explanation of the impact of multiple currencies in the hands of consumers, I suggest Hyack's paper "Choice of Currency" available for download various places on the web, example Mises website.
 
Last edited:
No, you aren't. You /think/ you are.

So....moving forward against the wall of irrationality and psychological denial, first thing is to choose a auction site to work with. I'll use coingig.com. Typing starbucks into the search bar...

http://coingig.com/httnbitmit/100-Starbucks-eGift-card--4225

This is 'buy it now' $39 for $100 starbucks gift card, numbers transmitted digitally. I want the buy it now option, having no interest in playing the auction game (that's just me, I'm the same way on ebay).

Next, to check the exchange rate. MtGox is 898.62, coingig currently is 904.99. Close enough. Finally, to check the seller's trust status. 5 stars, certainly acceptable.

I am ready to buy at this time, so I bring up a wallet window....using coinbase, for this example. Login, wait for secondary authorization to phone sms. Done. Access to my bitcoins at this point. Well, the few that are in this hot wallet. Select a 'send bitcoin public address'. For grins I pick a new address, clipboard it. If I was paying with the phone, it would be just read the square barcode. That's the cool way...but I'm on a mac.

Back to auction site. Select 'buy it now', authorize, then enter sending public address previously clipped. Site says the usual "are you sure you want to send xxx btc to yyy". Double check, click okay. Done.

Next thing will be an automated receive of message with the sbux card 16 digit number and 8 digit pin. That'll be another Jrats post, I have other stuff to do now.

I hope this explanation helps to clear up some of the gross misunderstandings present on this forum. The thing to remember is very simple:

Why is he buying the sbux card with bitcoins?

BECAUSE IT'S CHEAPER THAT WAY!!!
 
Last edited:
It's coming from trader chat boxes. Of course MtGox comes to mind as one where no one gets their money out, only BTC can leave and I have documented that thoroughly up the thread.
Ridiculous and false. You've documented nothing really, except woo things. Like reading tea leaves, chicken bones, market price charts.

You have documented woo. Quite nicely, really.
 
So these Starbucks gift cards aren't activated? They'll send you the code and PIN via e-mail? You're a trusting soul, aren't you?

This transaction seems like the virtual equivalent of buying something off the back of a truck. Maybe it's legit, and you'll get your Starbucks cards, and the users won't find out they're spoofed or whatever.

Maybe.
 
Ridiculous and false. You've documented nothing really, except woo things. Like reading tea leaves, chicken bones, market price charts.

You have documented woo. Quite nicely, really.

Neither ridiculous or false, you apparently don't even read the links I have posted about Gox. So what I will say is that you need to go read Gox's own site where they admit to being at least three weeks behind in processing withdrawal requests. Then you can go read other links where multiple individuals are complaining about not being able to get their requests even submitted. Gox is kaput and so are all the exchanges. Price increasing by an order of magnitude without money coming in to the exchanges ensured this situation. It's a bubble and they are trying to let the air out slowly.
 
It's coming from trader chat boxes. Of course MtGox comes to mind as one where no one gets their money out, only BTC can leave and I have documented that thoroughly up the thread.

Trader chat boxes, otherwise known as troll boxes, as they call them. Not really a reliable source. Or by not getting your money out, did you by chance mean it takes uncomfortably long to receive your funds?

If there are documented cases of MtGox or other bitcoin exchanges keeping your money or profits, I'd certainly like to know about it.
 
Neither ridiculous or false, you apparently don't even read the links I have posted about Gox. So what I will say is that you need to go read Gox's own site where they admit to being at least three weeks behind in processing withdrawal requests. Then you can go read other links where multiple individuals are complaining about not being able to get their requests even submitted. Gox is kaput and so are all the exchanges. Price increasing by an order of magnitude without money coming in to the exchanges ensured this situation. It's a bubble and they are trying to let the air out slowly.

Oh ok. You actually didn't mean what you said. Just more hyperbole. I get it now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom