How can you tell an Expert from a non-Expert?

No disrespect intended again, but if that video of the explosion were ever being used in court, would you be called as the audio expert or would it be some serious professor guy?


Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702. Testimony by Experts
If scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will assist the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue, a witness qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education, may testify thereto in the form of an opinion or otherwise, if (1) the testimony is based upon sufficient facts or data, (2) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods, and (3) the witness has applied the principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case.

Most states in the US have requirements that duplicate these requirements, or are at least extremely close. It is not necessary to call 'some serious professor guy' in most instances, as long as the witness has "training, education, or experience" that will assist the jury in understanding the evidence.

A car mechanic is a perfectly acceptable witness, and his testmony, according to the subject, may be as valuable or more valuable than a professional engineer with a bevy of degrees. What also counts is whether the methodology is considered reliable -- which usually means is the generally accepted method (in the field at issue) or one that allows repeatability, etc.

Yes, I am a trial attorney. You don't have to accept my expertise, of course, but searches on the above Federal Rule and decisions regarding expert/opinion testimony will verify what I am saying. So yes, it appears from the above that gumboot would probably qualify to testify regarding the issues raised.
 
Do you think this behaviour make people more or less likely to take him seriously?

Actually, it's probably the wookie impersonations he likes to do that make people take him less seriously. However, in my observational experience, it seems to carry more weight with people who were already interested in what you had to say, and less with people who weren't.

For instance, we go to a lot of art gallery show openings (free beer / wine and snacks, you know) so a lot of the people we meet are creative types: artists and the like. They tend to be more interested in architecture, so finding out that you're an architect can actually lead to some pleasant and interesting conversations. Here's an excerpt from one we had recently at a multi-artist show:

Julie: So, Pat, do you have anything on display here tonight?
Patrick: Oh, no. I'm not an artist, I'm just a no-talent hack.
Julie: What? Oh, what do you do?
Patrick: I'm an Architect.
Julie: Oh, that - that doesn't make you a no-talent hack!
Me: You haven't seen his buildings . . .
Julie: Oh! Well, I . . . I . . .
Patrick: . . .
Me: Don't feel bad, though, nobody else has, either.

Maybe that one wasn't the best example, he usually does better than that. After that particular exchange I was informed that he no longer needed my assistance, for some reason. :rolleyes:

Whereas walking up to a table full of 20-something year old chicks at Llewellyn's Pub, who didn't want to meet you in the first place, and saying, "Hi, My name's Patrick, I'm an architect" doesn't seem to elicit the same response, probably because it's not as appropriate to the situation.
 
Experts

You know, when I was training I worked with an architect who was an acknowledged expert in his field. Interestingly, he never described himself as such as when it was once put to him in these terms he responded "I'm not an expert, you all just know bugger all".

An expert is, as others have pointed out, someone who through education and training has a suitably robust and comprehensive depth of knowledge in his field. I'm a qualified architect and hence an expert in buildings.

Within any field, we have specialists. These are people who have additional education or experience in a certain sub-topic. I specialise in tall buildings (well, by UK standards), and in general commercial work. I have a colleague who specialises in historic building conservation.

One of the interesting things thanks to the OJEU bidding procedures for consultancy work is that one sometimes comes up against other architects who have managed to get to an advanced stage in the selection process through effective b*llsh*t or marketing (same thing, surely). These people are experts in building, but not in tall buildings. It is usually fairly easy to suss this out within a few minutes, because their lack of understanding tends to be very evident even in peer-peer conversation.

One of the things I find most amusing about CTers is their failure to understand expertise when they see it. Most of us sceptics have been through higher education. We know real experts when we see them. So why not the CTers? Bloody-mindedness? Lack of education? Who knows.

I have one loon over at Urban75 who thinks that yield point and tensile strength are much the same thing; Nist got it wrong, I got it wrong, everyone got it wrong except him! Now what kind of person would seriously disregard a broad range of expert views on the basis of 10 minutes on Google?

Aye, it's a funny old game (as Jimmy Greaves would say).
 
One of the things I find most amusing about CTers is their failure to understand expertise when they see it. Most of us sceptics have been through higher education. We know real experts when we see them. So why not the CTers? Bloody-mindedness? Lack of education? Who knows.

I have one loon over at Urban75 who thinks that yield point and tensile strength are much the same thing; Nist got it wrong, I got it wrong, everyone got it wrong except him! Now what kind of person would seriously disregard a broad range of expert views on the basis of 10 minutes on Google?

Aye, it's a funny old game (as Jimmy Greaves would say).



It's this failure to recognize expertise that I'm interested in. What is it about certain posters that leads you to accept their opinions as being "expert" opinions, and why don't the twoofers see the same things?



Perhaps the twoofers here could look at it from the other direction: Other than just contrariness and general principle, why don't you accept people like Gumboot and Architect as experts? Do you consider yourself (or would others consider you) to be an "expert" in any field? It doesn't have to be CT-related.
 
Just to clarify, I have no intention of claiming the "expert" title, in any field (except perhaps the field of my own writing, in which I am irrefutably the world expert...;))

However it was asked that there be a professional analysis, and I am a professional. I do this for a living. :)

(Not analysing CT videos, but Film Production Services, including analysis).

I also contend that the level of analysis required to determine the fakery of the specific video in question does not require any significant level of expertise - certainly it doesn't require one to be a leading expert.

There have been other CT videos similar to this one, which my analysis has not found to be suspect, thus until an expert with greater expertise than me determines they are fake, I continue to assume they are genuine.

-Gumboot
 
Oh, don't be so modest!

But actually, it may not even be a question of "expertise", but one of basic "competence". How many of the twoofers are those people who just aren't very good at anything?
 
Gumboot let me clarify my position.

Before I will accept this accusation that the video is fake and a truther faked it, I want documented expert analysis.
 
Gumboot let me clarify my position.

Before I will accept this accusation that the video is fake and a truther faked it, I want documented expert analysis.



Hang on what's this "that a truther faked it"?

How can anyone possibly know who faked it?

-Gumboot
 
Gumboot let me clarify my position.

Before I will accept this accusation that the video is fake and a truther faked it, I want documented expert analysis.

hehe, I think this is funny when I compare it to my position. I generally assume things AREN'T true until I find cooberating evidence and sufficent understand to know that they are.
 
Gumboot let me clarify my position.

Before I will accept this accusation that the video is fake and a truther faked it, I want documented expert analysis.
You can want in one hand and defacate in the other. Which one do you think will fill up first?

What you want is irrelevant. What you offer to the conversation on a forum is facts, evidence, and reason backed up by whatever wit you bring to the table. In your case, the latter isn't much. It isn't about what you want, it is about what you offer.

Your demands on others are pretentious, childish rubbish.

DR
 
Just to clarify, I have no intention of claiming the "expert" title, in any field (except perhaps the field of my own writing, in which I am irrefutably the world expert...;))

However it was asked that there be a professional analysis, and I am a professional. I do this for a living. :)

(Not analysing CT videos, but Film Production Services, including analysis).

In case I was not clear, my post was limited to the question regarding "expert" testimony in court.

Of course, we've had a change of subject since then, and I no longer seem to see the goalposts. I could have sworn they were right in front of me a minute ago . . . .
 
Really where?

Here

Another of firemen at a phone booth with the added stero explosion supposedly of WTC7.

That sort of thing.

In a lot of cases, the reason I knew these were fake straight away was I'd seen the original videos without the explosions, so I know they had been added.

I think these are a case of CTers fabricating evidence. 9/11 was the most documented event in World History. And yet there's not a single video recording that captured a single explosion. That's a problem for Conspiracy Theorists. I think some of the more dishonest ones sought to address that problem, and the rest fell for it because they wanted to believe.
 
You claimed a member of the truth movement faked it.


Care to cite where I said that?

I've spoken generally of conspiracy theorists faking these sorts of videos, and I jokingly suggested a Truther might have taken the explosion from a movie (in ref. to the music at the beginning), and I have specifically stated that I don't know who faked it (proposing in that same post that it could have been the documentary makers, or the person who shot the footage, or even a Government Agent).

I have never claimed in seriousness that a Conspiracy Theorist faked the video.

-Gumboot
 
Care to cite where I said that?

I've spoken generally of conspiracy theorists faking these sorts of videos, and I jokingly suggested a Truther might have taken the explosion from a movie (in ref. to the music at the beginning), and I have specifically stated that I don't know who faked it (proposing in that same post that it could have been the documentary makers, or the person who shot the footage, or even a Government Agent).

I have never claimed in seriousness that a Conspiracy Theorist faked the video.

-Gumboot

Here is what you said:

Another of firemen at a phone booth with the added stero explosion supposedly of WTC7.

That sort of thing.

In a lot of cases, the reason I knew these were fake straight away was I'd seen the original videos without the explosions, so I know they had been added.

I think these are a case of CTers fabricating evidence. 9/11 was the most documented event in World History. And yet there's not a single video recording that captured a single explosion. That's a problem for Conspiracy Theorists. I think some of the more dishonest ones sought to address that problem, and the rest fell for it because they wanted to believe.

By the way, could you give me one example of where you saw a video without explosions and then saw one with them added?
 
By the way, could you give me one example of where you saw a video without explosions and then saw one with them added?
Go to youtube or google video. Look up all the 9/11 videos and you will find one with explosions done within a year, and the original without the added explosions.

A truther or a truther liar teaser made it. They are pushing it knowingly or unknowingly as a video of explosive sounds. If you are CT minded the fake one will have lots of wonderful lies to help you feel better. If you know the WTC was hit by a plane, burned and fell you will be disgusted people are dumb enough to believe lies made up to mislead other who are too dumb to understand.

It was posted on JREF before; you could find it if you search. Maybe someone will tell you where some are. Someone has posted a video and sound references for your study. But you can find your own. It should only take an hour.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom