How can you tell an Expert from a non-Expert?

As another example of postings which lead you to believe a poster is an expert in his field, consider some of the posts by our friend beachnut. I think we can all agree that, in his general style of posting, he's certainly one of the more pugnacious posters we have. But, when he discusses topics related to piloting and flight, we get this:

Modern compass systems work very well. The plane system must meet check point accuracy and the pilot will not accept more than 4 degrees of error between aircraft systems or ground check points. The compass heading at the end of the flight should be right on. You can check the take off heading to be lined up with the actual runway heading. The FDR should read the exact track of the mag heading for take off.

Runway 30 is 301 magnetic, 291 true, FDR reads 300.2 and 300.6, so the compass on take off was real close to 301 magnetic heading.

The planes top speed was 350KCAS, and the terrorist were doing 463KIAS. The pressure altimeter could be off.

Based on the radar altimeter and the best guess on aircraft location at that point the aircraft atltitude was about 400 feet msl if you take 273 radar reading and add 130 from the ground elevation. The best guess based on the FDR data for the aicraft location is the around the red dot area below, for the last data that JDX has.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/1244745cd092eee417.jpg[/qimg]
Near this red point. There is still 2800 feet to go and no more FDR data. The altimeter here would say 500 feet, but the radar altimeter plus the ground would be 400 feet. Looks like the pressure altimeter is off by 100. You are talking about a system who is +-75 feet in the first place. Here you have a plane going 25 pecent past its top speed. I have no information on what the pitot static system errors are and no one else beside Boeing would know. Some aero majors could make some educated stabs with reasons for errors.



Not as pugnacious, but very detailed and comprehensive. And only one recent example of many of his posts. I'd trust him to fly, based on this sort of thing.

So what is it that tells me to trust him? I'm still deciding that.....
 
Did you miss the "never" in his comment? Caution is almost always a good thing, but is it really impossible to ever determine if someone is an expert in a forum such as this?
I didn't miss "never", but I don't find the qualifier unreasonable. I interpret "unless I truly know who they are" to mean he can validate their credentials.
If that's so, what are we all doing here? What's the point of discussing these topics in a sensible manner, if no one's opinions or analysis are any more trustworthy than anyone else's?

Where do we draw the line between reasonable caution, and just being obstructionist?
That's what I'm trying to determine.
 
Medical Doctors are by definition medical experts. You can not dispute this. It is a verifable fact.

A dermatologist has received further training in skin conditions outside of normal medical doctors. He is even more of an expert on skin conditions but not in other areas of medicine. A dermatoligist must be an MD first before he can go into dermatology.
 
So what is it that tells me to trust him? I'm still deciding that.....



In thinking about it a bit: Is it the almost casual way in which a true expert discusses their knowledge, without having to constantly remind you that they are an expert?

Contrast beachnut to JDX. beachnut has mentioned he's a pilot, but he doesn't harp on it all the time. He allows his analysis stand or fall on its own merits. Meanwhile, JDX constantly reminds you, He's a pilot! "I can anaylyse this data, because I'm a pilot!" He starts a group called "Pilots for Truth", which emphasizes that he's a pilot! He creates a nice little logo that includes pilot's wings! He advertises his film as coming from real pilots! When someone disagrees with him, he dismisses them, because they're not a pilot!

Are there any verifiable examples of widely-accepted experts (in any field) who act like JDX? Or does the confidence that comes from knowing your stuff, and knowing you know it, preclude such antics?
 
I will never accept the legitimacy of an internet poster unless I truly know who they are.

There are no experts on this forum. I am not sure you are aware of what an expert actually is.

Heres an example; A doctor is NOT an expert on medicine. A world leading consultant in say Dermatology IS an expert.
Your own ignorance as a defense for rejecting a professional's expertise in his field: a curious position. All I have to do to be an expert in anything, in our conversations here, is be more expert and educated in the field than you.

If you find my positions unpalatable, find someone whose education and experience in the same field, not another field, exceeds mine, or contradicts mine, and whose reasoning starts from facts and follows a rational path to the position contra.

Beachnut is an expert in airplanes. Deal with it. He is not the only expert on the planet, nor on the forum, but his experience and education and practical application in the field of aviation warrant the appelation "expert," in both the legal sense, and in the relative sense regarding your own demonstrated lack of expertise in the field.

If you want to counter that position, show me what you know about aviation and airplanes. If not, there's the door . . .

DR
 
Are there any verifiable examples of widely-accepted experts (in any field) who act like JDX?

I was once told a joke that mirrors this a bit:

How do you tell who is the architect at a coctail party?





. . .





You don't have to . . . he'll tell you.

In all seriousness, though, I do have one friend who likes to go around introducing himself as an architect, it's usually one of the first things out of his mouth. I guess that it's one of those professions that seems kinda sexy / cool and he likes to make sure people know because he's proud. It makes me cringe, though, (especially when he'll introduce us both like that) and I find it humorous sometimes because he's probably the least qualified to say that among my architect friends. (Unliscensed and currently un-employed)

Perhaps the same is the case for JDX.
 
I was once told a joke that mirrors this a bit:

How do you tell who is the architect at a coctail party?

. . .

You don't have to . . . he'll tell you.


I think we can all agree that using our expert status to hit on chicks is fair game. :)


In all seriousness, though, I do have one friend who likes to go around introducing himself as an architect, it's usually one of the first things out of his mouth. ... I find it humorous sometimes because he's probably the least qualified to say that among my architect friends. (Unliscensed and currently un-employed)

Perhaps the same is the case for JDX.



This may be a very telling thing....Sounds like he's overcompensating for some perceived failure. Do you think this behaviour make people more or less likely to take him seriously?
 
I think one of the problems with tonicblue's analogy is that he/she seems to be confusing "expert" with "specialist". A doctor can be an expert, but not a specialist. There may even be an arguable position that not all specialists are experts (e.g. some of the posters on Pilots for Truth seem very specialized, but I would question their expert status).

One can always provide verifiable credentials (licensing, certifications, etc.) that can be tracked down, but of course then the argument can be made, "Well, I don't believe that the screen name Hokulele matches the person with these certifications."

So to drift off to some conclusion, I would agree that you cannot assume that the person posting is truly an expert, but a good post will contain facts that you can easily confirm through other trusted sources, and use that as a basis to trust the rest of the points in the post. For example, I don't have to believe that gumboot is really an expert on video/audio production, but if I can verify the types of microphones used by various instruments, and I can verify that sounds added to a clip have different properties than sounds present in the original clip, I can trust the rest of his points.

On a side note, I have served as an "expert witness" in a court case, and would be happy to share the process used to verify I was indeed an expert if this would help this thread at all. It is somewhat long and boring, which is why I am refraining unless asked.
 
Are there any verifiable examples of widely-accepted experts (in any field) who act like JDX? Or does the confidence that comes from knowing your stuff, and knowing you know it, preclude such antics?

Sadly, sometimes overconfidence sometimes comes with being good at something. Pseudoscience is rife with examples of otherwise good scientists working outside their fields. Numerous world class athletes have endorsed all sorts of woo as performance enhancing. James Randi's own writing points out that there have been lots of scientists so convinced in their own intelligence that they lose their skepticism in the face of apparent miracles.

In fact, I'd dare say that amongst the oft-ridiculed list of '9/11 Scholars,' there are probably a few sociologists, philosophers etc. who are quite competent in their fields.

Experts, in other words are just a subset of human beings and they suffer from the same kinds of character flaws as non-experts, egotism and arrogance included.
 
I will never accept the legitimacy of an internet poster unless I truly know who they are.

There are no experts on this forum. I am not sure you are aware of what an expert actually is.

Heres an example; A doctor is NOT an expert on medicine. A world leading consultant in say Dermatology IS an expert.

If we take Gumboot as an example. He may well be a film maker, actor, etc but he is NOT an expert in studying audio and video. The people who work for NASA imaging, who Popular Mechanics used for their hit piece ARE experts.

Bolded is your opinion, and you should state it as much, rather as an absolute that will make you sound arrogant and preachy.

The following is my EXPERT opinion on EXPERTESE in Medicine, followed by an extrapolation to Engineering...

As a Family Physician I AM AN EXPERT in a variety of issues, which I will not belabor you with here, but there are many areas in which I am not as qualified as a Dematologist, who is a SPECIALIST in Dermatology. He has spent 4+ years after our medical training to focus just on skin related conditions. He is an EXPERT in Dermatology, no doubt. He is a DOCTOR.

He is not an expert in orthopedics, compared to an orthopedic surgeon, but he is much more of an expert in it that a laymen, and could provide them with a solid opinion, based on common training ALL DOCTORS get, in most any orthopedic problem.

A FAMILY PHYSICIAN is an expert in all areas of medicine, compared to a non-physician, but he does not have the DEGREE OF EXPERTESE that a SPECIALIST would have for any given area.

Similiarly, someone with a regular Bachelors of "XXX" Engineering IS AN EXPERT in that area, and in the area of engineering in general, but is not as much of an expert in "XXX" engineering as someone with a PhD in it.

TAM:)
 
I see Hoku has spoken similar to me earlier...sorry, didnt see it...

TAM:)

Edit: Hoku...done.
 
Last edited:
I see Hoku has spoken similar to me earlier...sorry, didnt see it...

TAM:)


No worries, some points do well by being emphasized, and it comes better from you as a doctor than from me.

Just for the record, I certainly don't mind having my screen name abbreviated, it is a little long, but I would prefer Hoku, or HL, as that is more in the spirit of the Hawaiian word it is representing. Besides, Davidjayjordan has been calling me Hok all along, and I know you would hate having anything in common with him. ;)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom