How are aspects of American History taught outside America?

Is it possible we've found a glaring factual error that Tokie can't tap-dance around? I guess this one's pretty hard to gloss over, as it's so blatantly incorrect - not even open to a question of interpretation.

Now, in my world, a mensch would step up and say, "Yeah, that was dumb, I made a mistake." I'm kinda not expecting that, though.
 
It must have been the other South Vietnam. The one we don't know about.

I took it that Tokie was in such mid rant that he couldn'y physically stop himself to correct an obvious slip. :)

It is a while since I have seen the "we wuz robbed" communist conspiracy rant. I thought it had been retired.

In terms of serious High School studying I was taught Scottish History, British History, from the Union onwards, and a lot of European History from 1789 onwards - (essentially modern political history). Prior to High School we covered the Romans, Greeks, Egyptians and were essentially given a grounding in key dates in world history like Julius Ceaser invading Britain, Viking raids, Norman Conquest, American and French revolutions, US Civil War and WW1 and WW2. The latter 5 were covered in more depth in High School and we also looked at the Age of Empire in Europe. The US was not really a major international player until the 20th century so it is perhaps understandable that US History is not covered in great depth except where it interfaced with global issues, such as the slave trade. Those who did more work on modern history from 1900 onwards would, of course, deal with the US far more.
 
I never know which word to use - I know the Scots and the Welsh won't stand for being called "English," but "British" is okay? And are the English okay with being called "British" or do they prefer "English"? And what about the northern Irish (in Ulster)?

How do the home rule/independence factions in Wales and Scotland feel about being part of "Great Britain"?

British is fine for all but the most loony fringes of nationalist groups in any nation, providing the context it is used in makes sense. For instance the original post referred to WWII. Britain, collectively, was involved in that war so it makes sense to use the word "British". Decisions were made by a British government, not an English one. To talk of "England" being forced to submit due to a blockade makes no more sense than to talk of Texas being responsible for providing the support - it is only one part of a larger whole and decisions were taken for the whole, not any individual part.

In terms of asking people what nationality they are, things are a bit trickier.

You are more likely to find an English person describing themselves as British (about half do), than a Welsh person (about a third) or a Scottish person (a quarter). (NB the question allowed multiple answers so you could select both British & English, meaning the figures will not all add to 100%).

http://www.statistics.gov.uk/lib2001/viewerChart4920.html

For more info:

http://www.statistics.gov.uk/lib2001/Section3658.html
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom