How are aspects of American History taught outside America?

With the fierce fighting at Hue and the reports from members of the media embedded with the troops helped to turn the opinion of Tet in the US not as a decisive US victory, but as a decisive NVA victory. In a way it's sort of what happened with Hezbollah in the last Israel-Lebanon conflict (except that it was a ceasefire). Depending on who you listened to the media helped to fuel the opinion that it was a victory for Hezbollah (although some said Israel).
It all comes down to how one defines victory it seems to me. There's military victory and then there's a public relations victory; there's tactical victory and then there's strategic victory. You can have a tactical victory but a strategic defeat for example.
 
Geez, all of my public High School and private Elementary School history teachers were inhuman taskmasters.
We had to cover Sumeria, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Rome, The Ottomans, Greece, the Normans, the Saxons, the Gael, Inca, Aztec, China, India, the Mongols, Japan, Ethiopia, Nubia, exploration of the American West, The Civil War, Mexican independence from France, World War I, II, Vietnam, The Cold War, the Falklands war, Banana republics and US interventionism, The Philippines, and South African Apartheid. Also The Dark Ages, the Renaissance, and the New England Witch Hunts. For each topic section, I wrote a five page report. I had to do three dioramas of historical events in High School. Got 3 new sets of shoes out of the deal. Wanna see an Inca sports stadium in a Reebok box?
I either had the best teachers ever or worst teachers ever. At the time I figured it was the latter.
 
It all comes down to how one defines victory it seems to me. There's military victory and then there's a public relations victory; there's tactical victory and then there's strategic victory. You can have a tactical victory but a strategic defeat for example.

True.

Like most things it seems that it is all how we classify something.
 
Geez, all of my public High School and private Elementary School history teachers were inhuman taskmasters.
We had to cover Sumeria, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Rome, The Ottomans, Greece, the Normans, the Saxons, the Gael, Inca, Aztec, China, India, the Mongols, Japan, Ethiopia, Nubia, exploration of the American West, The Civil War, Mexican independence from France, World War I, II, Vietnam, The Cold War, the Falklands war, Banana republics and US interventionism, The Philippines, and South African Apartheid. Also The Dark Ages, the Renaissance, and the New England Witch Hunts. For each topic section, I wrote a five page report. I had to do three dioramas of historical events in High School. Got 3 new sets of shoes out of the deal. Wanna see an Inca sports stadium in a Reebok box?
I either had the best teachers ever or worst teachers ever. At the time I figured it was the latter.

Actually that sounds a lot like my own High School experience. Frankly I'm grateful for it because it really helped me in school after that.
 
Hmm....no idea why you would think that.

The NVA generals said, after the war, that we'd completely crushed them at Tet; VC were wiped out and the North had no way to get materiel into the South...on top of that, they went to the peace talks only after Tet.

They said they knew their only hope was to delay long enough to rebuild their supply capability, and to let the American press do its job.

Which they did.

And the rest is history.

BTW: your being woefully ignorant of something and ignorantly happy to believe the propaganda does not make that something so. It just makes you woefully ignorant and ignorantly happy.


Tokie

Erm, no. The US/South Vietnam did not win the war at the Tet offensive. They virtually wiped out the attacking force, but they did not win the war. It continued for several more years, by which time the US and Australia had left, and South Vietnam no longer had the strength to defend itself. The north won.
 
Erm, no. The US/South Vietnam did not win the war at the Tet offensive. They virtually wiped out the attacking force, but they did not win the war. It continued for several more years, by which time the US and Australia had left, and South Vietnam no longer had the strength to defend itself. The north won.

Don't forget that the DRVN broke the Paris Peace Accord as well.
 
My point is that the matter was much more complicated than simply "freeing the slaves."
No, actually, it wasn't. Slightly more, perhaps. But make no mistake: this war was fought because the South wanted to be able to have slaves, and THAT was mostly about profit, pure and simple.


Nope, cause. Of course, American history books teach it in a softer, less offensive way, so that the people who still live in the traitor states don't have to feel so bad that their forefathers committed treason to maintain their right to own other people.
:rolleyes:

Quite the contrary: American history books portray it as harshly and extremely and offensively as possible, in yet another of seemingly endless efforts to keep heaping on the white guilt - esp on the people who still have the audacity to live in the "traitor states" (those bastages! I can't believe there are people alive today who won't take responsibility for the crimes of those who turned to dust well over 100+ years ago).

Sorry for any offense, but frankly I find it unbelievably absurd to place blame on people (or attempt to make them feel guilty) for things they had absolutely nothing to do with.

And this goes to people in both the North AND South: slavery, as well as the Civil War, have been over for a pretty long time now. Get OVER it already.



It all comes down to how one defines victory it seems to me. There's military victory and then there's a public relations victory; there's tactical victory and then there's strategic victory. You can have a tactical victory but a strategic defeat for example.
Well said.
 
Last edited:
Erm, no. The US/South Vietnam did not win the war at the Tet offensive. They virtually wiped out the attacking force, but they did not win the war. It continued for several more years, by which time the US and Australia had left, and South Vietnam no longer had the strength to defend itself. The north won.

Oh...gee, thanks for that history lesson.

Sheesh.

The war was won for the Allies (South Vietnam, US, Aus and a few others) at Tet, when Allied forces utterly crushed the VC (Viet Cong), drove the NVAR(North Vietnames Army Regulars) completely out of the South and utterly destroyed the NVA's (North Viet. Army) ability to continue supplying any surviving VC.

North Vietnam came to the peace talks then, after refusing for several years; NVA generals interviewed and writing after the war admitted that the war was lost (for them) due to the overwhelming victory of the Allies at Tet.

The only thing the South (and their allies, mostly China) could hope for then, was that the US media and communist sympathizers in the US government would help them to force the Allies to snatch defeat from the upper GI tract of victory.

Enter, Uncle Walter, "the most trusted man in America," to whom nearly every American with a TV turned every evening for "news." He stood, walked to a wall map, pointed at Vietnam, looked into the camera and lied himself blue in the face.

Pushed by communists and communist sympathizers in the permanent gov't and the Congess, the war was, shortly after, defunded by the Democrats who held a majority in Congress at that time, and then, yes, indeed...the war that had been won, was lost.

It's a bit more involved, I think, than your ignorant thumbnail suggests.

Tokie
 
Geez, all of my public High School and private Elementary School history teachers were inhuman taskmasters.
We had to cover Sumeria, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Rome, The Ottomans, Greece, the Normans, the Saxons, the Gael, Inca, Aztec, China, India, the Mongols, Japan, Ethiopia, Nubia, exploration of the American West, The Civil War, Mexican independence from France, World War I, II, Vietnam, The Cold War, the Falklands war, Banana republics and US interventionism, The Philippines, and South African Apartheid. Also The Dark Ages, the Renaissance, and the New England Witch Hunts. For each topic section, I wrote a five page report. I had to do three dioramas of historical events in High School. Got 3 new sets of shoes out of the deal. Wanna see an Inca sports stadium in a Reebok box?
I either had the best teachers ever or worst teachers ever. At the time I figured it was the latter.

LOL!

My daughters were horrified when they discovered in their 10th grade Honors English class that they, like you, would be required to make dioramas and collages.

I guess YOU din't figger out at that age that you were no longer a little boy with blunt-tip scissors, one of Mommy's old Look magazines and some paste.

Maybe you ate too much paste before high school?

MY kids figured it out and the one daughter told me, tearfully, "I feel like we (she and her sis) are getting dumber and dumber every day we are there."

Looks like it worked with you if you think your teachers were harsh taskmasters assigning shoebox dioramas in the 12 grade.

Tokie
 
Well, Tokie, I can see from your well-thought-out and well-considered response to my post regarding the learning of Chinese history that you're definitely someone to be taken quite seriously. You clearly are a paragon of critical thinking and sharp acumen.

EDIT:

Sorry guys, I was still a bit muddled from my visit to the mirror universe. Gotta say though, Darat with a goatee? Awesome. And yet, no where near as good as Lisa Simpson's. Terry's was pretty sexy too.
 
Last edited:
Whig Interpretation was Good Enough for America's Founders

Only 5%, Black and White, of the South owned slaves. The semi-false elite. Not until 1815 did Virginia enact the law making it illegal for a Black to own a White slave, and it should be noted that in Oglethorpe's Georgia Charter slavery (Rome was "the Wall Street of slavery" for 2,000 years) was illegal.

Even before Roman Catholics assassinated Meriwether Lewis and Lincoln, built Standard Oil (Rockefeller became the Vatican's correspondent bank) on unredressed murder and arson, foisted upon us the unconstitutional Fed and IRS, financed Hitler and the Holocaust, killed Kennedy and King to send us to die in Vietnam, and committed 9-11 for their BIG OIL, heroin, the Saudis and a corrupt faction of false Jews in the State of Israel remaining silent about Rome's proven guilt for Hitler/Divini Redemptoris-Kristallnacht/Holocaust: Viz. "A Moral Reckoning," Goldhagen, America's Whig Founders knew History unfolds as the result of the conflict between Rome, and everyone else: Whig Analysis of History.

A year before his death, Thomas Jefferson wrote:

Draft Declaration and Protest of the Commonwealth of
Virginia, on the Principles of the Constitution of the
United States of America, and on the Violations of them
December 1825

This Draft Declaration was suppressed at the time, just as is the proof that Bush committed 9-11 and that his father helped kill John Kennedy...by the same Fifth Column faction.

etext(dot)virginia(dot)edu/etcbin/toccer-new2?id=JefPapr.sgm&images=images/modeng&data=/texts/english/modeng/parsed&tag=public&part=17&division=div1

Read it yourselves. He, and his countrymen realized Roman corruption - grounded in a demographic shaped by the greedy "needing" cheap labor being pushed by the Pope to balance the ballot box from Ireland, Germany and Italy, as Rome is promoting illegal immigration today to "take back" America, while their coffers empty from pedophile priest judgments and the disaffected), was usurping the Republic (Scorcese touched on it in "Gangs of New York), foresaw civil war and sought resolution.

There were virtually no Roman Catholics in the South (per: RCC census of 1855). Roman Catholics got off the boats, learned the truth of Whig Jeffersonianism (The Confederate Battle Flag's operative symbol: the Cross of St. Andrew, signifies "Protestantism Overseas," and Jews came to fight on the side of the South from all over the world as they knew the North was Roman and anti-Semitic), stopped enabling the pedophiles, and never sent for priests. Rome's pedophilia creates blood-thirsty killers to prove they're "men," got their Sherman and the foreigners as cannon-fodder, and took it over, using the "Italian Solution" on Lincoln as soon as he gave orders to Grant to "let them up easy" at Appomattox.

America is the Land of Promise...Rome's been messing with our history but the truth will out...and rid us of them.

Apologies to all peoples of the world suffering at the hands of the Anti-Christ's Fifth Column now running America. G-d Willing the American People will get things back in order, try them, and show them hanging from nooses after fair trials and righteous judgment.
 
[tongue in cheek]Perhaps a few extra geography lessons would have established that "England" is a very strange term to use in this context[/tongue in cheek]

I never know which word to use - I know the Scots and the Welsh won't stand for being called "English," but "British" is okay? And are the English okay with being called "British" or do they prefer "English"? And what about the northern Irish (in Ulster)?

How do the home rule/independence factions in Wales and Scotland feel about being part of "Great Britain"?


In the US we are just taught the Civil War was fought to "free the slaves."

Very noble thing to do, so that is how the government wants you to hear it.

Um, nope, that's not how it was taught in any of my classes. I was taught that the Civil War was about the question of the rights of states to secede from the Union. Granted that the reason the South wanted to secede was to protect the institution of slavery, but the greater issue was preservation of the Union.

"My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing any slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that. What I do about slavery, and the colored race, I do because I believe it helps to save the Union; and what I forbear, I forbear because I do not believe it would help to save the Union. I shall do less whenever I shall believe what I am doing hurts the cause, and I shall do more whenever I shall believe doing more will help the cause." The Collected Works of Abraham Lincoln edited by Roy P. Basler, Volume V, "Letter to Horace Greeley" (August 22, 1862), p. 388. http://home.att.net/~rjnorton/Lincoln78.html


Geez, all of my public High School and private Elementary School history teachers were inhuman taskmasters.
We had to cover Sumeria, Mesopotamia, Egypt, Rome, The Ottomans, Greece, the Normans, the Saxons, the Gael, Inca, Aztec, China, India, the Mongols, Japan, Ethiopia, Nubia, exploration of the American West, The Civil War, Mexican independence from France, World War I, II, Vietnam, The Cold War, the Falklands war, Banana republics and US interventionism, The Philippines, and South African Apartheid. Also The Dark Ages, the Renaissance, and the New England Witch Hunts. For each topic section, I wrote a five page report. I had to do three dioramas of historical events in High School. Got 3 new sets of shoes out of the deal. Wanna see an Inca sports stadium in a Reebok box?
I either had the best teachers ever or worst teachers ever. At the time I figured it was the latter.

Actually that sounds a lot like my own High School experience. Frankly I'm grateful for it because it really helped me in school after that.

Yep, me too, starting in elementary school. In junior high school we studied Georgia history (this was in Georgia; I believe it's a pretty common practice in most U.S. states to devote one year to the state's history), and we had world history and American history in high school. Then in college, besides world history and U.S. history (again!), I got a lot of history in my upper-level Spanish classes.
 
I never know

Yep, me too, starting in elementary school. In junior high school we studied Georgia history (this was in Georgia; I believe it's a pretty common practice in most U.S. states to devote one year to the state's history), and we had world history and American history in high school. Then in college, besides world history and U.S. history (again!), I got a lot of history in my upper-level Spanish classes.


What grade did your graduate thesis diorama get you?

Tokie
 
Enter, Uncle Walter, "the most trusted man in America," to whom nearly every American with a TV turned every evening for "news." He stood, walked to a wall map, pointed at Vietnam, looked into the camera and lied himself blue in the face.

Pushed by communists and communist sympathizers in the permanent gov't and the Congess, the war was, shortly after, defunded by the Democrats who held a majority in Congress at that time, and then, yes, indeed...the war that had been won, was lost.


Doesn't this belong in the Conspiracy Theories forum?
 
Last edited:
Even before Roman Catholics assassinated Meriwether Lewis and Lincoln, built Standard Oil (Rockefeller became the Vatican's correspondent bank) on unredressed murder and arson, foisted upon us the unconstitutional Fed and IRS, [ ... snip ... ]


The U.S. Supreme Court disagrees with you on that "unconstitutional" claim.
 
Should we re-fight, or mostly re-write, history (wars) in this thread?

Or should we stick to solid facts backed up with first-hand evidence?

If at one time a textbook contained slanted or false information, that's no reason to assume the text cannot be correctly refined.

There are countless history texts. Some of them, partly or wholly, contain fiction mislabeled inadvertently (and sometimes advertently).
 
Oh...gee, thanks for that history lesson.

Sheesh.

The war was won for the Allies (South Vietnam, US, Aus and a few others) at Tet, when Allied forces utterly crushed the VC (Viet Cong), drove the NVAR(North Vietnames Army Regulars) completely out of the South and utterly destroyed the NVA's (North Viet. Army) ability to continue supplying any surviving VC.

North Vietnam came to the peace talks then, after refusing for several years; NVA generals interviewed and writing after the war admitted that the war was lost (for them) due to the overwhelming victory of the Allies at Tet.

The only thing the South (and their allies, mostly China) could hope for then, was that the US media and communist sympathizers in the US government would help them to force the Allies to snatch defeat from the upper GI tract of victory.

Enter, Uncle Walter, "the most trusted man in America," to whom nearly every American with a TV turned every evening for "news." He stood, walked to a wall map, pointed at Vietnam, looked into the camera and lied himself blue in the face.

Pushed by communists and communist sympathizers in the permanent gov't and the Congess, the war was, shortly after, defunded by the Democrats who held a majority in Congress at that time, and then, yes, indeed...the war that had been won, was lost.

It's a bit more involved, I think, than your ignorant thumbnail suggests.

Tokie



Tokie, your diatribes (attacking the argument, not the arguer) are becoming less and less tolerable, frankly. Your rants cease to entertain. Your response to ChaoticLimbs is just plain nasty and ill-tempered. If you're incapable of making a point civilly, perhaps you should find a more vitriolic board to troll at. I know many radically conservative individuals who are able to make their points without such rancor. It is not necessary to be the nastiest crayfish in the swamp just because you have differing opinions.

As to the above.... Commies and com-symps in Congress and the government? Wow, things get better and better in Bizarro World! Would you care to cite us a list of the communists in congress at that time? I, for one, would be really interested in seeing the list. I can imagine that Rush Limbaugh would be, too. How come we haven't seen this list, yet?

Twisty History Lesson No. 7: Did all the NVA generals really say after the war that they were defeated after the Tet Offensive? Or did one such officer make that comment, perhaps giving face to the westerners. There was no overwhelming "victory" at Tet. There were huge "losses" by the NVA and VC, and possibly irrecoverable losses, at that. But, the best analysis I've ever heard was that the NVA could have been defeated at that juncture, had the South and the Americans had the backbone to pursue it.

What did the generals say when you asked them about why they went to the peace talks and did nothing for almost a year? Was it because they were cowering at the overwhelming US and ARVN might? Or was it because they knew that all they had to do was stall while the NLF rebuilt and while American public opinion continued to sour?

And I didn't know that "nearly every American" tuned into the CBS Evening News in 1968. I kinda thought it was like other years, with CBS leading but by a percentage point or two (having just taken over the lead from Huntley/Brinkley on NBC a year or so earlier).

I guess that's why ABC and NBC closed down - they had no viewers, what with "nearly every American" watching CBS, how could they sell soap flakes? What? You mean ABC and NBC are still out there? Still doing new reports? Oh, then one of us is likely mistaken.



And just so you know you're not the rantingest conservative, I give you, above.... (iamerican.... Wow! Now, that's some paranoid ***t, man!)
 
Last edited:
Wait! Did I miss that.....?????


....the South (and their allies, mostly China)

Tokie! Bubbie! Where do you get this stuff? 1968? 1969? Just when did the Chinese ally themselves with South Viet Nam? I'm pretty sure I read most of the papers in those years (except for that week that I was rioting in Chicago during the DNC, so maybe it happened then..) and I cannot, for the life of me, recall Chinese support of the side that America was allied with.
 
Tokie! Bubbie! Where do you get this stuff? 1968? 1969? Just when did the Chinese ally themselves with South Viet Nam? I'm pretty sure I read most of the papers in those years (except for that week that I was rioting in Chicago during the DNC, so maybe it happened then..) and I cannot, for the life of me, recall Chinese support of the side that America was allied with.

It must have been the other South Vietnam. The one we don't know about.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom