Homeopathic licensing alarms doctors

I would be careful if I were you. You might well get your fingers burnt if you play!!

If they have done this, then I am sure they will be ready to deal with any fallout that ensues!!
You need not asume that any of this has been properly thought out. What kind of digital incineration do you envisage?
 
I am on Colourful Radio:confused: tomorrow morning and will have a few points to make!

You mean this......?
Show: Colourful Morning
Presenter: Karen Morgan
09:00 - 12:00
Email | Website | Share |
Info: A lively mix of news, interviews, and trivia which is sure to put a smile on your face. Colourful Mornings is just what you need to get your day off to a good start.
Were you in the trivia section?
 
Were you in the trivia section?
When invited I expressed some reservations but a reliable third party said the station has a good audience. But it's hardly `Today in Parliament' I have to admit.
 
Only joking! ;)
That was in no way a comment intended to diminish your valued contribution to the debate. (I only wish I had the abilities to do what you have been doing for the cause!)
 
When invited I expressed some reservations but a reliable third party said the station has a good audience. But it's hardly `Today in Parliament' I have to admit.

While 'Today in Parliament' possibly gets an audience that could do something about it, Colourful Radio has the potential to inform parts of the population who might otherwise be unaware that homeopathy is controversial, so it's all good :)
 
for #3 they cannot show what the qualiitative and quantitative compositin of the product is.

According to the first page linked:
Class 1 is the most critical, for example serious mislabelling, microbial contamination or incorrect ingredients


Many homeopathic remedies must fail this test, since they claim to contain X but demonstrably don't.
 
According to the first page linked:



Many homeopathic remedies must fail this test, since they claim to contain X but demonstrably don't.
Do they have incorrect ingredients?

A bottle containing pills with c30 dilution of a substance would have the expected amount of the substance in it. Perhaps the problem is in failing to list as an ingredient C30 dilutions of every other substance on the planet !
 
Deetee said:
for #3 they cannot show what the qualiitative and quantitative compositin of the product is.

According to the first page linked:
Class 1 is the most critical, for example serious mislabelling, microbial contamination or incorrect ingredients
Many homeopathic remedies must fail this test, since they claim to contain X but demonstrably don't.
I'm not sure, but I think homoeopathic remedies tend to list their ingredients as just lactose, or whatever the medium is. See for example this post from Rolfe.
 
Today’s Guardian has published an unbelieveably shoddy piece from a practicising osteopath and educator:

“The name-calling that greeted this month's ruling on the labelling of homeopathic remedies was unconstructive and predictable”

Ironically, one of the few areas that a large-scale trial has been done is the area that started this current row. Homeopathic medicine is indeed controversial, as in order for a homeopath to treat a patient, the person's individual symptoms have to be taken into account in order to make an individualised prescription. This means that homeopathy does not perform exceptionally well in random controlled trials - where one group of people are all given the same medicine and another group are given a placebo.

When homeopathic trials are based upon individualised prescriptions we see a very different picture. At the end of 2005, the results of a large six-year study of 6,500 patients at Bristol Homeopathic Hospital reported 75% improvement in their health.

The sad thing about arguments such as this is that both sides of the medical divide could work at their best together.

Earlier this year, a report commissioned by Prince Charles (OK, bear with me - he didn't write it) said that patients using the "big five" complementary therapies - osteopathy, chiropractic, acupuncture, homeopathy and herbal medicine - would greatly benefit from their treatment, while the NHS would reap economic rewards.

The report was written by Christopher Smallwood, who commented at the time: "The weight of evidence we have examined suggests that complementary and alternative medicines could play a larger role in the delivery of healthcare, and help to fill recognised gaps in healthcare provision."

He went on to call for the NHS's drugs watchdog to assess the cost-effectiveness of complementary therapies and he asked the government to boost funding for the therapies on the NHS.

Such support is welcome, even if the basis is economics not health, and the new rules on homeopathic treatment are a small step in the direction of bringing complementary medicines into the mainstream - a journey already made by physiotherapists, after all. But while snide asides about eye of newt and wing of bat continue to emerge from those in the medical profession who forget why we use the word complementary in preference to alternative (it is alongside, not instead of), it will be a struggle. And the real losers will be the patients.

http://society.guardian.co.uk/health/comment/0,,1864592,00.html
Obviously, she knows nothing about the background to the Bristol Homeopathic Hospital trial, nor the unwillingness of the Dept. of Health to refer CAMs to NICE.
 
"When homeopathic trials are based upon individualised prescriptions we see a very different picture. At the end of 2005, the results of a large six-year study of 6,500 patients at Bristol Homeopathic Hospital reported 75% improvement in their health. "

If it wasn't so serious, it would be funny how widespread is the failure to understand the basic scientific concept of needing a control group as a comparator in any experiment where a causal effect is being claimed. Sadly, too many people really are this stupid and it extends to professionals who have been through a full scientific medical education.
 
Homeopathic medicine is indeed controversial, as in order for a homeopath to treat a patient, the person's individual symptoms have to be taken into account in order to make an individualised prescription.
Indeed, if homeopaths are to be believed.

Why then the homeopaths' delight at the "licensing" of over the counter remedies for various minor conditions, when by their own admission, the nostrums will be ineffective unless individualised? Why are they being allowed to get away with having their cake and eating it too?
 
Why then the homeopaths' delight at the "licensing" of over the counter remedies for various minor conditions, when by their own admission, the nostrums will be ineffective unless individualised?
They'll be just as effective as remedies used in individualised homoeopathic treatment. ;)
 
"When homeopathic trials are based upon individualised prescriptions we see a very different picture. At the end of 2005, the results of a large six-year study of 6,500 patients at Bristol Homeopathic Hospital reported 75% improvement in their health."
It didn't report that, in any case. It didn't even report that 75% of patients had an improvement in their health (which is not the same thing).

It actually reported that:
A total of 6544 consecutive follow-up patients were given outcome scores. Of the patients 70.7% (n = 4627) reported positive health changes, with 50.7% (n = 3318) recording their improvement as better (+2) or much better (+3).
The figure of 75% was reported as the percentage of children with asthma who said they felt 'better' or 'much better'.

I wonder if Ms. Sturzaker bothered to read the paper (or even an abstract) before commenting on it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom