Homeopathic licensing alarms doctors

Blue Wode

Graduate Poster
Joined
Feb 17, 2006
Messages
1,306
It's finally happened:

Packaging on homeopathic products will be allowed to describe the illnesses they claim to be able to treat under a controversial licensing scheme introduced by the government today.

-snip-

Michael Baum, emeritus professor of surgery at University College London said: "This is like licensing a witches' brew as a medicine so long as the bat wings are sterile."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/medicine/story/0,,1862554,00.html

More here:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/5303080.stm
 
I think a campaign is in order. In the UK we can lodge complaints with the Advertising Standards Authority for any advertising that makes unproven claims.

http://www.asa.org.uk/asa/
 
Last edited:
Agreed.
What a farce. How does the MHRA justify this?

On the BBC this am I heard Dr Fitzpatrick and our homeopath friend John Saxon having a "debate".
Fitzpatrick is right - "we now have a Kite mark for the Emperor's new clothes, or rather the Prince of Wales' new clothes"

ETA - looks like we missed the boat on this one when it first was proposed, chaps. The MHRA opened their proposals to public consultation in the summer, and part of their justification for allowing the new regulations seems to be that there was a favourable public response.
The response summary can be linked to from here. There were only 32 responses!
We could have easily done something about this, but it is now too late.
Shame on us.
 
Last edited:
I think a campaign is in order. In the UK we can lodge complaints with the Advertising Standards Authority for any advertising that makes unproven claims.

http://www.asa.org.uk/asa/

I had a quick look and am not sure that they will have any power. If a "medicine" is licensed and allowed to make certain claims I doubt the ASA will be able to stop them including it in their advertising.

Wonderfully the MHRA website under about us states:

"Welcome to the About us section.

The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) is the government agency which is responsible for ensuring that medicines and medical devices work, and are acceptably safe.

No product is risk-free. Underpinning all our work lie robust and fact-based judgements to ensure that the benefits to patients and the public justify the risks.

We keep watch over medicines and devices, and we take any necessary action to protect the public promptly if there is a problem.

We aim to make as much information as possible publicly available.

We enable greater access to products, and the timely introduction of innovative treatments and technologies that benefit patients and the public. "

Looks like they need to update this:

No need to demonstrate that anything works, so we can strike that.

Remove the bit about "robust and fact-based judgements" - no need to bother with awkward things like facts. Also need to remove that problematic bit about benefits in case anybody asks what they are and how we judged them in the absence of any evidence.

Need to remove the bit about protecting the public.

Also think the bit about information needs changed - allowing unsubstantiated claims to be made is not the same as providing information.

Again that annoying bit about benefits to patients needs to go.
 
Where are the BMA, the Royal College of Nursing and Royal Pharmaceutical Society?

Do they really have nothing to say on this subject?

Maybe those involved with the MHRA on its various advisory committees should make it very clear that they are unwilling to continue to be associated with a body that is willing to license unproven "medicines"?
 
ETA - looks like we missed the boat on this one when it first was proposed, chaps. The MHRA opened their proposals to public consultation in the summer, and part of their justification for allowing the new regulations seems to be that there was a favourable public response.
The response summary can be linked to from here. There were only 32 responses!
We could have easily done something about this, but it is now too late.
Shame on us.
In all fairness, from what I'm reading it looks like every effort was made by the MHRA to slip this in under the wire with as little opportunity as possible for parliament, professional organizations or the public to interfere. The very line "opened their proposals to public consultation in the summer" is a good indicator of that; who's paying attention to government business in the summer? In the words of Douglas Adams, "the plans were on display [...] in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the leopard'."
 
The press release by the MHRA is a cracker. This bit had me creased up laughing

“The MHRA is the government agency that is responsible for ensuring that medicines and medical devices work”

When I compose my self a letter may be in the offing asking for a full list of the homeopathic medicines they have licensed that they have ensured work. .
 
The press release by the MHRA is a cracker. This bit had me creased up laughing

“The MHRA is the government agency that is responsible for ensuring that medicines and medical devices work”

When I compose my self a letter may be in the offing asking for a full list of the homeopathic medicines they have licensed that they have ensured work. .

I thought the last line was better.

"Underpinning all our work lie robust and fact-based judgements to ensure the benefits to patients and the public justify the risks."

Maybe your letter should ask what "fact-based judgement" they make in considering the benefits of a homeopathic "remedy" when they are never presented with any facts on which to make a judgement or any indication that there is any benefit.
 
In the words of Douglas Adams, "the plans were on display [...] in the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying 'Beware of the leopard'."

Well said Euromutt! Another bureaucratic stitch-up.

I heard Michael Baum having it out with an apologist for homeopathy on the Today programme this morning. Baum was excellent, every bit as scathing as homeopathy deserves: but the hoeopath refused to deal with the real issue of the total uselessness of the product, hiding behind a claim that this was just a minor administrative issue. John Humphries (supposedly one of Britain's toughest journalists) let him get away with it :mad:
 
The clasical homeopaths will be haveing a fit.
 
It seems that the homoeos are alowed to make claims even for effects which have been actively disproved. The woman in this video clip (sorry, it's a realplayer file) is delighted that instead of just "Arnica" on the bottle they can now write "Arnica - for bruising". All this despite a paper showing arnica to be ineffective for bruising.

If claims of efficacy don't have to be substantiated, what is to stop any action or effect being attributed to any (or every) remedy; disciplinary action from the Society of Homoeopaths?... I think not.

What if someone uses arnica to treat bruising and it doesn't work, what if someone uses Oscillococcinum for a cough that is actually the early stages of lung cancer and proper treatment is delayed; will these new claims mean that consumers now have recourse to compensation under the trades description act?

Yuri
 
I think a campaign is in order. In the UK we can lodge complaints with the Advertising Standards Authority for any advertising that makes unproven claims.

http://www.asa.org.uk/asa/
Unfortunately they don't deal with claims made on packaging. You need your local trading standards department for that, and the burden of proof would be on them to prove that the claim was false.
 
The only was I can see out of this mess would be to sue the manufacturers that the products don't work as advertised.
That, or get NICE and the BMA sufficiently outraged by writing 1000's of complaint letters.
 
Lothian said:
The press release by the MHRA is a cracker. This bit had me creased up laughing

“The MHRA is the government agency that is responsible for ensuring that medicines and medical devices work”

When I compose my self a letter may be in the offing asking for a full list of the homeopathic medicines they have licensed that they have ensured work.
I thought the last line was better.

"Underpinning all our work lie robust and fact-based judgements to ensure the benefits to patients and the public justify the risks."
I liked the bit about including it in the Yellow Card Scheme:
All homeopathic medicines fall within the scope of the Yellow Card Scheme, which will allow patients and healthcare professionals to report suspected side effects to the MHRA.

...

Adverse effects associated with the use of homeopathic medicines should be reported to the MHRA using the Yellow Card Reporting Scheme.
Does this include aggravations?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom