Help with defining a point - light cones

OFF TOPIC POST

this does suggest that you feel the t=hsp is somehow and unchnaging moment when in fact that it is continuously changing.
A lightsource emits a wave of photons t=hsp
as the light travels away the source t=hsp is changing with it but still rretaining the t=hsp.
Well, that's one way of putting it. The value for t is bounded by a function of (x,y,z) together describing a specific four-dimensional hypersurface - the light cone.

In philosophical terms the now is in constant change .....
Well, yeah.

and as discussed in another thread that change is occuring at the rate of 'c'
Information propagates at a rate no greater than c.

so in a sense:
the photon is changing location but not time.
In what frame?

as the source travels at the same rate as the photon does though time they are effectively in the same t==hsp that is constantly changing [rate='c']
No. Not at all

The source remains within the bounds of its own light cone - this is always true - but it need not be (cannot be, for any massive object) on the surface of the light cone.

so I see at least too premises I need to clear up:
1] That the present moment at any time is considerd as [t=hsp] = [ t= what ever you want]
This doesn't mean anything.

[2] The universal change rate of 'c' which confirms that t=hsp is always zero or "now"
This doesn't mean anything either.
 
Last edited:
I think Ozzie is making the mistake of saying that because time t=0 can be arbitrarily applied to any point in time, that means all points in time are the same point.

Ozzie, if this is what you mean, please believe that you are 100% dead wrong.

Saying a particular time is t=0 is just a convention physicists use to divide what comes before that time from what comes after. It ascribes no permanent value to that point in time.

You can't say tsub1=0 and tsub2=0, therefore tsub1=tsub2 (sorry, I don'tknow how to do subscripts. Pedantic moderators may feel free to correct this.)


It is {SUB} {/SUB} for subscript and {SUP} {/SUP} for superscript of course use "[]" intead of "{}"
 
OFF TOPIC POST

this does suggest that you feel the t=hsp is somehow and unchnaging moment when in fact that it is continuously changing.
A lightsource emits a wave of photons t=hsp
as the light travels away the source t=hsp is changing with it but still rretaining the t=hsp.

No it simply indicates that it is a reference point. You can continually change your current reference point if you want but it gains you noting and makes relationships harder to calculate. Try telling time with a clock that continually changes its current reference back to 12:00; such a clock requires no moving parts.



In philosophical terms the now is in constant change .....
and as discussed in another thread that change is occuring at the rate of 'c'
so in a sense:
the photon is changing location but not time.

In scientific terms changes requires the passage of time, in fact that is how we define change, different with the passage of time, and consistency, the same with the passage of time. Constant change just means the rate of change does not vary over time, without time there is no change.



as the source travels at the same rate as the photon does though time they are effectively in the same t==hsp that is constantly changing [rate='c']
so I see at least too premises I need to clear up:
1] That the present moment at any time is considerd as [t=hsp] = [ t= what ever you want]
2] The universal change rate of 'c' which confirms that t=hsp is always zero or "now"

No it is ‘c’ that confirms the units of time and space are interchangeable, specifically the consistency of ‘c’. Just as we measure time in seconds and distance in meters we also measure time in meters traveled by light and distance as the seconds required for light to travel.
 
Last edited:
Wow. Similar thread as mine Ozziemate.

Ya know, it doesn't appear that you've got an answer just like I didn't:p
I'm simply trying to get the fools to elaborate on their explanations... Would seem that when posing a question they rely on the theory and not the questions being presented.
 
In order to attempt to critique a mathematical theory, one must use mathematical equations.
Philosophising at maths will not prevent said maths from being correct.
 
Wow. Similar thread as mine Ozziemate.

Ya know, it doesn't appear that you've got an answer just like I didn't:p
I'm simply trying to get the fools to elaborate on their explanations... Would seem that when posing a question they rely on the theory and not the questions being presented.
You presented a question about a very specific (one could even call it "Special") mathematical theory.
Your questions were answered in the specific language of that theory (and of basic math), yet you claimed to be dissatisfied.
I am sorry if basic definitions are not your strong suit. I apologize if the detailed answers to your questions were insufficient.
I am very, very sorry that you think that philosophy has any relevance to reality.
Do the math.
Get back to us.
 
Wow. Similar thread as mine Ozziemate.

Ya know, it doesn't appear that you've got an answer just like I didn't:p
I'm simply trying to get the fools to elaborate on their explanations... Would seem that when posing a question they rely on the theory and not the questions being presented.

Not getting an answer and not understanding an answer are two very different things.
 
This entire thread is a perfect example of why I didn't study physics at school :) It hurts my head.
 
This entire thread is a perfect example of why I didn't study physics at school :) It hurts my head.
Very little in this thread has anything to do with physics. If you would like a real headache sometime, read a few pages of this. :)
 
Last edited:
The cone is only a visualization tool. If you are at that point, it's now but you cannot know the cones. If you're not at that point, you have no idea about the time and you still cannot know the cones. It's a bit like asking what a tesseract of copper weighs - a fun exercise, but don't take it too literally.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom