Help with defining a point - light cones

The observer (as in the actual label in the diagram) or "the current spacetime position of the observer".


There is no "symbol, character or math set" that I know of used to commonly represent the hypersurface of the present.
I suggest "hypersurface of the present (HSP)" would be a good definition of a three letter acronym to shorten the phrase.

SRT tends to talk about the observer and the HSP is not relevant in that case. The HSP would be relevant in a gedanken experiment involving multiple observers.
thanks for the clarification.
would it be correect to say:
"all light events can only occur for an observer at t=HSP?"
 
Off topic:

The reason why this is important is that I am going to propose a gedanken that will ask that the time difference between relative t=HSP's be defined between relative v RF's
 
Off topic:

The reason why this is important is that I am going to propose a gedanken that will ask that the time difference between relative t=HSP's be defined between relative v RF's
That gedanken cannot be asked. The HSP does not have a reference frame. Only observers or a coordinate system have a reference frame.
You may ask what the time difference between 2 observers on the HSP is but that may be trivial, e.g. the difference between their time coordinates. If the observers are in different RF's then SRT answers that question.
 
thanks for the clarification.
would it be correect to say:
"all light events can only occur for an observer at t=HSP?"
HSP is the entire surface, i.e. for the coordinates (x,y,z,t), t is constant but the other 3 coordinates change. An observer is at a specific point on the surface. Therefore t is their present time. You do not need to refer to the HSP at all.
 
That gedanken cannot be asked. The HSP does not have a reference frame. Only observers or a coordinate system have a reference frame.
You may ask what the time difference between 2 observers on the HSP is but that may be trivial, e.g. the difference between their time coordinates. If the observers are in different RF's then SRT answers that question.
yes I believed that to be the case, howver I was gouing to add to my post but got interupted by a telephone call...
By being able to clearly distinguish the observers moment as t=hsp
and theerfore clearly state that all light events must be observed at t=hsp one can work up a really terrific gedanken
Given that light emited from a source is also at t=hsp and will always be at t=hsp.....means that t=hsp must be universal and absolute...

5.gif


What the animation attempts to describe, rather badly too I might add, is that regardless of where the photon wave or particle is it must occur at a universal t=hsp
So where ever a photon can be detected it must be at t=hsp universally regardless of velocity of observer.

any ways thats the proposition and maybe one for another thread which I will start once I clarify the approach.
 
Last edited:
When looking at the light cone diagram it suggest that the point I am refering to must occur between past and future, is that correct.

Generally speaking the point that occurs between past and future is referred to as the "present". I'm not sure why that terminology doesn't suit your needs.

ok I will drop the cynicism for a bit and ask:

If the surface is called Steven and it is indicative of the present moment what would that moment in time be called [apart from NOW]

What's wrong with calling it "now"?

If I am not interested in describing an event in the future and I am not interested in describing an event in the past in what way would I do so in mathematics that clearly anchors our point to the present?


If you are not describing the future or the past, then time doesn't enter into the conversation at all.

The red dot on your diagram can refer to any "here and now" of interest. The plane refers to any place other than "here", at this "now". The lower cone represents events that could have contributed to "here and now", and the upper cone represents events that could follow from "here and now".

If you are not interested in past or future, you can simplify your diagram by taking the cones away. What you are left with is a planar surface representing space, with a dot on it. Draw an arrow to the dot. Place the label "You are here" at the start of the arrow.

This is commonly referred to as a "map".
 
HSP is the entire surface, i.e. for the coordinates (x,y,z,t), t is constant but the other 3 coordinates change. An observer is at a specific point on the surface. Therefore t is their present time. You do not need to refer to the HSP at all.
understood thanks
 
Generally speaking the point that occurs between past and future is referred to as the "present". I'm not sure why that terminology doesn't suit your needs.



What's wrong with calling it "now"?




If you are not describing the future or the past, then time doesn't enter into the conversation at all.

The red dot on your diagram can refer to any "here and now" of interest. The plane refers to any place other than "here", at this "now". The lower cone represents events that could have contributed to "here and now", and the upper cone represents events that could follow from "here and now".

If you are not interested in past or future, you can simplify your diagram by taking the cones away. What you are left with is a planar surface representing space, with a dot on it. Draw an arrow to the dot. Place the label "You are here" at the start of the arrow.

This is commonly referred to as a "map".
in the past I have used terminology like; now, present or dynamic now etc and always the response has been SRT does not recognise those terms. So I need to clarify what science uses and so far it appears it fails to see the need to do so, which is understandable as relative time [ t=hsp ] is in vogue and has been for 100 years or so.
 
Last edited:
thanks for the clarification.
would it be correect to say:
"all light events can only occur for an observer at t=HSP?"

You are trying to use a relative definition t=HSP as an absolute definition.

Given that light emited from a source is also at t=hsp and will always be at t=hsp.....means that t=hsp must be universal and absolute...

The t=hsp at emission is not the t=hsp at detection there is a measurable delta t in between. Just as there is a measurable delta t between “now” t=hsp and the “now” t=hsp 5 minutes ago or five minutes in the future, even that delta t (5 minutes) between “now”, “now” then and “now” later is dependent on relative velocity.
 
I think Ozzie is making the mistake of saying that because time t=0 can be arbitrarily applied to any point in time, that means all points in time are the same point.

Ozzie, if this is what you mean, please believe that you are 100% dead wrong.

Saying a particular time is t=0 is just a convention physicists use to divide what comes before that time from what comes after. It ascribes no permanent value to that point in time.

You can't say tsub1=0 and tsub2=0, therefore tsub1=tsub2 (sorry, I don'tknow how to do subscripts. Pedantic moderators may feel free to correct this.)
 
OFF TOPIC POST

You are trying to use a relative definition t=HSP as an absolute definition.



The t=hsp at emission is not the t=hsp at detection there is a measurable delta t in between. Just as there is a measurable delta t between “now” t=hsp and the “now” t=hsp 5 minutes ago or five minutes in the future, even that delta t (5 minutes) between “now”, “now” then and “now” later is dependent on relative velocity.
agreed sort of...
however what the point is :
all light events must be at t=hsp
where 'event' means observable event due to the activity of light.
And of course SRT claims that the t=hsp is relative.
Where as I will argue the case that it is absolute...eventually when a thread is eventually started.
 
I think Ozzie is making the mistake of saying that because time t=0 can be arbitrarily applied to any point in time, that means all points in time are the same point.

Ozzie, if this is what you mean, please believe that you are 100% dead wrong.

Saying a particular time is t=0 is just a convention physicists use to divide what comes before that time from what comes after. It ascribes no permanent value to that point in time.

You can't say tsub1=0 and tsub2=0, therefore tsub1=tsub2 (sorry, I don'tknow how to do subscripts. Pedantic moderators may feel free to correct this.)
Naah I think I got it right...but check any ways igf you can...

t=0 is any arbitary point in time that you choose to make it.
t=hsp is relative t=now according to SRT

it will be argued that t=hsp must in fact be absolute, and in doing so challenge SRT
Note: we are talking about an infinitely small or zero duration, point of time
 
One thing I don't understand, Ozzie. In the OP, you turned to us for clarification on a topic you admittedly don't understand. That is not a sign of weakness. In fact, I applaud it.


However, when told what the answer is, you don't seem to want to believe us. If you've made up your mind ahead of time what you want the answer to be, as appears to be the case, then why have you asked us for help?

I'm not flaming, or trying to insult. This is an honest question.
 
No.

Event 1 occurs at t=hsp1.
Event 2 occurs at t=hsp2
Event 3 occurs at t=hsp3
Etc.

This does not mean that hsp1=hsp2=hsp3.
correct according to SRT.
But as I am saying I will argue that this cannot be so and that SRTmaybe mistaken.

you know nobby , the usual let's throw a gedanken and test SRT's logic and rational type situation, have done hundreds of them ages ago but not with the approach I have in mind and are developing. Test it again I shall I guess [ makes 100+1:)]
 
One thing I don't understand, Ozzie. In the OP, you turned to us for clarification on a topic you admittedly don't understand. That is not a sign of weakness. In fact, I applaud it.


However, when told what the answer is, you don't seem to want to believe us. If you've made up your mind ahead of time what you want the answer to be, as appears to be the case, then why have you asked us for help?

I'm not flaming, or trying to insult. This is an honest question.
I asked for help becasue I didn't know what the exact position was for SRT on the issue of t=0 or t=hsp.

In the gedankens run ages ago it was always fudged and mistaken.
But thanks to your help the issue is much clearer now...
Also all questions are asked for a reason and maybe I make the mistake of showing that reason, as anything other trhan the OP is off topic.
The same question has been raised at 4 other forums to ensure the answers are clear and confirmed. and so far they have been...again thanks....

As to belief, I believe you not a problemo that this is your understanding of how SRT uses the dimension of t.
 
correct according to SRT.
But as I am saying I will argue that this cannot be so and that SRTmaybe mistaken.

you know nobby , the usual let's throw a gedanken and test SRT's logic and rational type situation, have done hundreds of them ages ago but not with the approach I have in mind and are developing. Test it again I shall I guess [ makes 100+1:)]
If you start with the assumption that SRT is wrong then you cannot use SRT to prove that SRT is wrong. Therefore you will have to create a new theory that is not based on SRT's 2 postulates:
  • The Principle of Relativity - The laws by which the states of physical systems undergo change are not affected, whether these changes of state be referred to the one or the other of two systems of inertial coordinates in uniform translatory motion.
  • The Principle of Invariant Light Speed - Light in vacuum propagates with the speed c (a fixed constant) in terms of any system of inertial coordinates, regardless of the state of motion of the light source.
You will either have to throw them away or add more postulates.

In particular you can forget about the diagram in this thread - it is derived from SRT.
 
OFF TOPIC POST
If you start with the assumption that SRT is wrong then you cannot use SRT to prove that SRT is wrong. Therefore you will have to create a new theory that is not based on SRT's 2 postulates:
  • The Principle of Relativity - The laws by which the states of physical systems undergo change are not affected, whether these changes of state be referred to the one or the other of two systems of inertial coordinates in uniform translatory motion.
  • The Principle of Invariant Light Speed - Light in vacuum propagates with the speed c (a fixed constant) in terms of any system of inertial coordinates, regardless of the state of motion of the light source.
You will either have to throw them away or add more postulates.

In particular you can forget about the diagram in this thread - it is derived from SRT.
actually I thought the diagram preceeded SRT....SRT was in fact derived from Minkowski - Einstien Space time....

not that it matters,

To test SRT 's logic I only have to put the gedanken up and the rest happens. I already know that to To falsify or invalidate SRT is impossible until the issue of the travelling photon is resolved thus dah dah dah dh, a full alternative theory would have to be presented...
however when presenting an alternative I will need to know how to approach this issue and the resuts would be beneficial in general.
 
Last edited:
OFF TOPIC POST
The t=hsp at emission is not the t=hsp at detection there is a measurable delta t in between. Just as there is a measurable delta t between “now” t=hsp and the “now” t=hsp 5 minutes ago or five minutes in the future,
this does suggest that you feel the t=hsp is somehow and unchnaging moment when in fact that it is continuously changing.
A lightsource emits a wave of photons t=hsp
as the light travels away the source t=hsp is changing with it but still rretaining the t=hsp.

In philosophical terms the now is in constant change .....
and as discussed in another thread that change is occuring at the rate of 'c'
so in a sense:
the photon is changing location but not time.

as the source travels at the same rate as the photon does though time they are effectively in the same t==hsp that is constantly changing [rate='c']
so I see at least too premises I need to clear up:
1] That the present moment at any time is considerd as [t=hsp] = [ t= what ever you want]
2] The universal change rate of 'c' which confirms that t=hsp is always zero or "now"
 
Last edited:
OFF TOPIC POST

actually I thought the diagram preceeded SRT....SRT was in fact derived from Minkowski - Einstien Space time....

not that it matters,

To test SRT 's logic I only have to put the gedanken up and the rest happens. I already know that to To falsify or invalidate SRT is impossible until the issue of the travelling photon is resolved thus dah dah dah dh, a full alternative theory would have to be presented...
however when presenting an alternative I will need to know how to approach this issue and the resuts would be beneficial in general.
Just make sure that in your gedanken and the mathematics derived from it you do not assume the SRT postulates (after all SRT is wring and so the postulates are probably wrong).
Once you have your replacement for SRT then you can get started on General Relavity (it is also wrong sonce it reduces to SRT which is wrong).
See you in a few decades.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom