Health/Wealth Inequality

Uh... no. That isn't what I mean.


So what do you mean?

You have yet to establish what the actual causation is. And you clearly have confused correlation with causation, since you have only demonstrated the former but have claimed the latter.


You could ask about the actual causation even in the case of doctors: Are the sons of medical doctors vaccinated more often because their fathers have easier access to the vaccine? Because they can get it at a discount or maybe entirely free of charge? Or maybe because doctors tend to make so much money that the regular price of the vaccine doesn't really matter anyway?
Fortunately medical professionals in Denmark don't seem to doubt that poverty is the (obvious) reason why boys from poor families aren't vaccinated as often as those from rich families:

Vaccinen koster flere tusinde kroner for drenge, og det gør, at det særligt er drenge i de fattigste familier, der ikke får vaccinen.
Læger og forskere presser på: Giv HPV-vaccinen til de danske drenge - nu!
(Berlingske, June 22, 2017)

(1 DKK = 0.1531 USD)

"The vaccine costs several thousand Danish kroner for boys, and consequently particularly boys in poorest families don’t get the vaccine."
Doctors and researchers urge: Give the HPV vaccine to the Danish boys – now!


By the way, however much you deny it, it is a well-established fact that even life-threatening diseases don't make people go to a doctor for treatment if they know that they can't afford the treatment anyway. That is the reason why education doesn't stop people from going to a witch doctor to be treated for AIDS even when they know about the efficiency of science-based medicine. The witch doctor may be what they can afford.
 
I can't agree. How much is a packet of cigarettes these days, £5? A Big Mac is about £3 just for one meal.

For the same money, you can buy good healthy food to last a week. For example, a loaf of bread, rice, beans, onions, red/green pepper, tomatoes, mushrooms, quorn. Sauce: two spoons of powdered curry mixed in with vinegar and oil and poured into the onion mix: no need to buy expensive sauces.


Really?! Maybe in Moonin Valley you can, but around here, i.e. in the real world, you may be able to afford one good loaf of bread and that's about it. (We are talking full wheat, aren't we? It was supposed to be healthy food, right?!)

But who cares anyway?! Nothing can convince us that poor people aren't poor because they've spent all their money on Carlsberg Special Brew and fags ...
 
Because people eat at hospitals. Sometimes they are also advised about dietary choices at hospitals, and apart from hospitals, food costs money, too.

Food at hospitals is a small part of their budget, and it doesn’t have much effect on life expectancy. And while doctors give dietary advice, people rarely actually take it.

And yes, food costs people money apart from hospitals. But those non-hospital food costs obviously have nothing to do with hospital funding, and providing more hospital funding won’t help people with their non-hospital food costs because duh.
 
Can you make it worse by withholding funds?


The denialism of the people we're up against in this forum is as impenetrable as the stupidity of the U.S. president. They seem to think that poverty and ill health caused by poverty are a question of poor lifestyle choices:

How Being Poor Makes You Sick (The Atlantic, May 21,2014)
Poverty and low income is ’making children sick’, warn paediatricians (The Independent, May 11, 2017)
How poverty and food insecurity make people sick (CBS, Jan. 14, 2014)
 
Last edited:
Food at hospitals is a small part of their budget, and it doesn’t have much effect on life expectancy. And while doctors give dietary advice, people rarely actually take it.

And yes, food costs people money apart from hospitals. But those non-hospital food costs obviously have nothing to do with hospital funding, and providing more hospital funding won’t help people with their non-hospital food costs because duh.


"obviously"? Really?! Could you explain how exactly food costs are exempt from budgetary decisions at hospitals? That would be very interesting.

Hospital chef says budget is too low to make healthy meals for patients
He claimed his hospital spent just £3.50 a day per patient for all three meals, forcing him to cut corners on the ingredients he uses to prepare the food.
(Mirror, July 8, 2018)

I guess he should have asked Vixen for advice. She could have cut costs to £0.70 a day! The patients might have to peel their own potatoes, but that might cut costs for occupational therapy ...
 
Last edited:
Health care is not the primary differentiator in life expectancy in developed countries. Lifestyle is. This isn't a mystery.


It's a mystery to me! Are you sure?! Lifestyle, really?! Could you explain how access to a healthy diet, housing and exercise is all about lifestyle and not related to level of income? In my country it is. Or do you think that poverty is a lifestyle choice?

Smoking, drug abuse, diet, exercise... all these have a lot more to do with how long you are likely to live than how many blood tests you get or any other differentiator in health care provisions.


Yes, they are. I don't think that anybody's claimed that blood tests improve your health. But the treatment that you get or don't get based on those blood tests very often do. And sometimes diets and exercise advice are based on blood tests.
Did you never hear about work-related diseases? Or do you think that work is a lifestyle choice?

The poor tend to make worse lifestyle choices than the rich. This too isn't a mystery. There's all sorts of debate about why exactly they do that, who (if anyone) to blame for it, and most importantly, what to do about it. But lifestyle is the primary differentiator here.


You seem to be saying that this is how it goes: poverty --> bad lifestyle choices --> bad health. So why do you suddenly eliminate poverty from your line of reasoning and make it all about lifestyle choices?!

Take, for example, the issue of obesity. Obesity is a major factor in all sorts of life-shortening health issues (diabetes, cardiovascular disease, etc). In the US, and probably in the UK as well, the poor are more obese than the rich. This isn't because of any difference in health care access.


I'm with you here: It's primarily because of (the lack of) access to proper food, healthy exercise and healthy housing - in general: to a happy, healthy life. Only later, when your deprived life has made you ill, does access to health care become important.

With exceptions so rare as to be lost in the statistical noise, doctors cannot get patients to lose weight.


That is not true. A lot of patients lose weight following doctors' recommendations.

The rich are not less obese because of better health care. They are less obese because of better diet and exercise. Again, there's debate about why that is, but it's pretty damn clear that it isn't because of better health care for the rich.


Well, there are other options for rich people in this respect. I don't know any poor people with personal trainers! And I don't know any poor people who simply go down to the kitchen and tell their personal chef, "This is the diet that my doctor told me to follow. Make sure that the meals that you prepare for me from now on are based on his recommendations."
 
"obviously"? Really?! Could you explain how exactly food costs are exempt from budgetary decisions at hospitals? That would be very interesting.

I didn't say it was immune to budgetary decisions. Your own link supports what I did say, that it's a small part of the budget.
 
It's a mystery to me! Are you sure?! Lifestyle, really?! Could you explain how access to a healthy diet, housing and exercise is all about lifestyle and not related to level of income? In my country it is. Or do you think that poverty is a lifestyle choice?

Are you pretending to be this bad at understanding what I say, or are you honestly this clueless? What exactly do you think the word "lifestyle" even means? Of course diet, housing, and exercise are part of lifestyle. That's basically definitional. And I never said they weren't related to the level of income. In fact, if you spent even one minute thinking seriously about what I said, it would be obvious to you that it's essential to my argument that they ARE related to income level.

And lastly, note that I didn't use "choice" in that first sentence. Some aspects of lifestyle are not choices. You can't choose to live in a mansion if you're poor, you can't choose to dine at expensive restaurants every night if you're poor. Nothing I said suggests otherwise. But there are lots of aspects of the lifestyles of the poor which are choices. It's a choice to smoke cigarettes. It's a choice to drink soda instead of water. It's a choice to sit on the couch and watch TV instead of going for a walk. Poverty seems to be correlated with a number of unhealthy lifestyle choices. You can argue about why that's the case all you want to, and who to blame for that, and several possibilities have already been put forth in this thread. But the cause doesn't matter for the argument I've made here.

You seem to be saying that this is how it goes: poverty --> bad lifestyle choices --> bad health. So why do you suddenly eliminate poverty from your line of reasoning and make it all about lifestyle choices?!

Who said I eliminated it? This is a straw man.

That is not true. A lot of patients lose weight following doctors' recommendations.

A lot of patients who follow their doctor's recommendations lose weight. But not many patients actually follow their doctor's recommendations.

Well, there are other options for rich people in this respect. I don't know any poor people with personal trainers! And I don't know any poor people who simply go down to the kitchen and tell their personal chef, "This is the diet that my doctor told me to follow. Make sure that the meals that you prepare for me from now on are based on his recommendations."

Sure. Funny thing, though: personal trainers and chefs aren't part of the health care system. Increased funding for the health care system isn't going to provide the poor with personal trainers or chefs. Is this difficult to comprehend?
 
Are you pretending to be this bad at understanding what I say, or are you honestly this clueless? What exactly do you think the word "lifestyle" even means? Of course diet, housing, and exercise are part of lifestyle.


Are you pretending to have overlooked the important word "access" in my reference to diet, housing and exercise?!

That's basically definitional. And I never said they weren't related to the level of income. In fact, if you spent even one minute thinking seriously about what I said, it would be obvious to you that it's essential to my argument that they ARE related to income level.


This is why I said: "You seem to be saying that this is how it goes: poverty --> bad lifestyle choices --> bad health. So why do you suddenly eliminate poverty from your line of reasoning and make it all about lifestyle choices?!"

And lastly, note that I didn't use "choice" in that first sentence. Some aspects of lifestyle are not choices. You can't choose to live in a mansion if you're poor, you can't choose to dine at expensive restaurants every night if you're poor.


Sometimes you can't even choose to live in an apartment if you're poor, and you usually can't choose to dine at an expensive restaurant at all. Actually, sometimes you can't even 'choose' to dine at all.

Nothing I said suggests otherwise. But there are lots of aspects of the lifestyles of the poor which are choices.


Yes, there are some aspects of the lifestyle of the poor that are choices, which appears to make the ones that aren't irrelevant to you. Suddenly it's all about lifestyle choices and not at all about the "aspects of the lifestyles of the poor" that aren't. And why is that? Because what you're interested in is the blame game.

It's a choice to smoke cigarettes.


But it's not a choice to smoke a Cohiba after dinner at your mansion or the expensive restaurant instead of 20 Rothmans. (The former may be detrimental to your health but not to the extent that cigarettes are.)

It's a choice to drink soda instead of water.


But it's not a choice to drink an exquisite glass of Chardonnay instead of soda. Sugar is cheap.

It's a choice to sit on the couch and watch TV instead of going for a walk.


But it's not a choice to live in a neighborhood without a view that practically invites you to take a walk in surroundings that you know are safe and secure. And it's not a choice to live in a cardboard box that you have to stay and defend against other poor people instead of taking a nice stroll and enjoying the scenic route.

Poverty seems to be correlated with a number of unhealthy lifestyle choices.


Yes, correlated ... riiiight! Poverty is all about choices for you ... except that poverty really isn't about choices at all. It's about the lack of choices. Poverty is primarily connected with an awful lot of necessities and lack of choices. That's the whole point of poverty: Poor people are eliminated from making the choices that rich people make.

You can argue about why that's the case all you want to, and who to blame for that, and several possibilities have already been put forth in this thread. But the cause doesn't matter for the argument I've made here.


The argument you've made here - from your very first post - is that it's all about lifestyle and choice, which, to you, makes it important to deny the miserable alternatives that are imposed on people by poverty and to demand that they always choose the least health-damaging one of their poor choices. In their otherwise bland lives they shouldn't resort to drinking stuff with a little bit of taste. Otherwise they themselves are to blame for their ailing health. Their choice of a bloody soda is the reason why they're not only poor but also in poor health.

Who said I eliminated it? This is a straw man.


No, it isn't. You eliminated it from your line of reasoning as soon as you'd mentioned it. From then on it was all about choice.

A lot of patients who follow their doctor's recommendations lose weight. But not many patients actually follow their doctor's recommendations.


What you don't want to understand is that the patients are often telling the awful truth when they complain that 'you can't take the soda and fags away from me. It's all I've got.' Even if you and the doctor recommend that they live on water and exercise by pushing the stolen shopping cart with their belongings a little faster so their heart and vascular system are properly exercised.

Sure. Funny thing, though: personal trainers and chefs aren't part of the health care system. Increased funding for the health care system isn't going to provide the poor with personal trainers or chefs. Is this difficult to comprehend?


Not at all! I get the idea: Personal trainers, personal chefs and health care are too good for poor people!
 
I didn't say it was immune to budgetary decisions. Your own link supports what I did say, that it's a small part of the budget.


Yes, it's a small part of the budget but big enough to be cut, apparently.
 
PS

Funny thing, though: personal trainers and chefs aren't part of the health care system. Increased funding for the health care system isn't going to provide the poor with personal trainers or chefs. Is this difficult to comprehend?


I think that you should go back and read the OP again. For some reason you seem to think that this thread is all about "funding for the health care system". It isn't!
 
It would be interesting to see if life expectancy gaps are wider in the US than in Europe. My hypothesis would be that it is wider, because in addition to lifestyle differences between rich and poor, we have a greater gap in our access to health care. (I think)

The link about England said:

Nationally, on average, a boy born in one of the most affluent areas of England will outlive one born in one of the poorest parts by 8.4 years.

US:
https://www.theguardian.com/inequal...y-gap-rich-poor-us-regions-more-than-20-years
Your average life expectancy now varies by more than 20 years depending on where you live in the United States, according to an in-depth study by the University of Washington.


https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/1/9/16860994/life-expectancy-us-income-inequality
They also found that men who were among the top 1 percent of income earners lived 15 years longer than men at the bottom 1 percent.
 
Are you pretending to have overlooked the important word "access" in my reference to diet, housing and exercise?!

God damn, but you're bad at this. I explicitly acknowledged that not everything about lifestyle is a choice, and that poverty restricts lifestyle options. That doesn't change my argument.

This is why I said

I know that. And you're wrong. I haven't eliminated poverty from my line of reasoning. You have clearly failed to grasp my reasoning. It's been such a colossal failure one suspects it may even be intentional.

Sometimes you can't even choose to live in an apartment if you're poor, and you usually can't choose to dine at an expensive restaurant at all. Actually, sometimes you can't even 'choose' to dine at all.

And this contradicts what I said... how?

Oh, that's right: it doesn't.

Yes, there are some aspects of the lifestyle of the poor that are choices, which appears to make the ones that aren't irrelevant to you.

This is a straw man. But even taking the most extreme examples (most poor people are not homeless, most poor people can afford to eat something for dinner) and even considering only the unhealthy aspects of lifestyle which are not choices, guess what? Funding for health care won't fix them. That should be obvious. That should be non-controversial. And yet, when I say it, you have an apoplectic fit that shuts down your ability to think about what I said rationally.

Suddenly it's all about lifestyle choices

Again, you're the one who has exclusively focused on choices, not me. So much so that you basically insert it even where I didn't say it.

But it's not a choice to smoke a Cohiba after dinner at your mansion

Of course it is. Nothing I said even remotely suggests otherwise. Not only is this a straw man, but it's a bizarre, illogical one which doesn't even advance your own position in any coherent way.

But it's not a choice to drink an exquisite glass of Chardonnay instead of soda.

Most straw men at least make sense, in that if the opponent's argument was the straw man, then your own argument has an advantage. This, though... it's so random that it doesn't even make sense as a dishonest argument technique. It makes me suspect that you actually think I'm saying this. Which is troubling. How could you misunderstand me so completely and thoroughly?

Yes, correlated ... riiiight! Poverty is all about choices for you ... except that poverty really isn't about choices at all. It's about the lack of choices. Poverty is primarily connected with an awful lot of necessities and lack of choices. That's the whole point of poverty: Poor people are eliminated from making the choices that rich people make.

Let's take the extreme view that every unhealthy aspect of poverty is involuntary, that poor people have zero control. We know that's not true, but let's assume so for the sake of argument. What, then, changes about what I said? Nothing much, really. Funding for the health care system still won't change that lifestyle. The poor will still die much younger because of that lifestyle.

The argument you've made here - from your very first post - is that it's all about lifestyle and choice

No. It's primarily about lifestyle. Health care differences may have some effect on average longevity, but it's much smaller than lifestyle. That is true regardless of how much of those lifestyle differences are voluntary.

which, to you, makes it important to deny the miserable alternatives that are imposed on people by poverty and to demand that they always choose the least health-damaging one of their poor choices.

So now you're acknowledging that they are making unhealthy choices. Go figure.

But even here, you're still wrong. I haven't argued for denying anyone any choices, regardless of the health consequences. In fact, I haven't argued for any particular course of action at all. I've argued for a particular understanding of the nature of the problem, nothing more. What to do about it is a separate issue. I fully understand that some people will choose activities which may shorten their lives because they enjoy those activities. Hell, I haven't even argued that they are wrong to make such a tradeoff. I have been completely silent on the issue. Which is why your accusation that I've taken a particular position is so absurd.

In their otherwise bland lives they shouldn't resort to drinking stuff with a little bit of taste. Otherwise they themselves are to blame for their ailing health. Their choice of a bloody soda is the reason why they're not only poor but also in poor health.

Choices have consequences, yes. "Blame" attaches moral judgment to those consequences. I have not placed moral judgment on anything in this thread.

Except maybe you for your blatant dishonesty.

What you don't want to understand is that the patients are often telling the awful truth when they complain that 'you can't take the soda and fags away from me. It's all I've got.'

You're putting forth a justification for my observation, but it doesn't change anything. My observation is true. Your justification for it doesn't make it not true.

Even if you and the doctor recommend that they live on water and exercise by pushing the stolen shopping cart with their belongings a little faster so their heart and vascular system are properly exercised.

The statistics on life expectancy for the poor are not dominated by people whose sole belongings are transported in a stolen shopping cart. And I gave no recommendations to anyone.

Not at all! I get the idea: Personal trainers, personal chefs and health care are too good for poor people!

Pathetic straw man once again. It's not an issue of what's too good or not too good. My claim is simply that the health care system won't provide these things. It doesn't provide them to the rich, it doesn't provide them to the poor, and that's not going to change. If you think that the poor should have these things, you'll have to provide them by some means other than the health care system. Just as if you want the poor to get vaccinated, you shouldn't try to do so with food stamps.
 
Funding for health care won't fix them. That should be obvious. That should be non-controversial. And yet, when I say it, you have an apoplectic fit that shuts down your ability to think about what I said rationally.
(...)
My claim is simply that the health care system won't provide these things. It doesn't provide them to the rich, it doesn't provide them to the poor, and that's not going to change.


It's funny that I already answered your funding-for-health-care nonsense before you wrote it:

PS
I think that you should go back and read the OP again. For some reason you seem to think that this thread is all about "funding for the health care system". It isn't!
 
Last edited:
Again, you're the one who has exclusively focused on choices, not me. So much so that you basically insert it even where I didn't say it.


And this one's great, too!

But there are lots of aspects of the lifestyles of the poor which are choices. It's a choice to smoke cigarettes. It's a choice to drink soda instead of water. It's a choice to sit on the couch and watch TV instead of going for a walk. Poverty seems to be correlated with a number of unhealthy lifestyle choices.


'Correlated', yeah right!
 
And this one's great, too!




'Correlated', yeah right!

I made a factual statement. You can get offended till the cows come home, but that won't change the facts. Facts don't care about your feelings.

And yes, there is a correlation. I didn't indicate what the cause of this correlation is because it's not important to my argument, and since there isn't universal agreement about the cause, I'd just as soon not get into that debate since it's not necessary. But again, the existence of this correlation is well established. You certainly haven't disputed it.
 
War is correlated with a lot of people being killed. Is that a fact? Yes, it obviously is!
However, the interesting question is: Why would I back away from the pretty obvious causal effect that wars kill people and instead insist on talking about a correlation?
Because dead people cause wars? Because something else is the cause of both wars and deaths? Because wars and deaths coincidentally happen simultaneously? ('You know, people die in peace time too, and you wouldn't claim that peace kills people, now, would you?')

No, you "didn't indicate what the cause of this correlation is." Not because "it's not important to your argument," but because your argument is that poverty doesn't kill. Instead you would have us all believe that the lifestyle choices of people (who happen to be poor) kill!
That is the reason for your peculiar comment in post 22:
"The children of medical professionals are not getting the vaccine at higher rates than other rich people because of money, but because of something else. Furthermore, the vaccination rate for girls, who get it for free, has apparently plummeted. It's not clear at all that cost is the main driver here."

That the vaccination rate for girls at one point plummeted happened to coincide with (= was caused by!) a HPV-vaccine-scare. In the meantime, health care professionals have managed to educate the media and calm down the mass psychogenic illness among Danish teenage girls, who are now receiving the HPV vaccine again in rising numbers. By the way, even during the vaccine scare girls were vaccinated in much larger numbers than boys because (!) the vaccine was free for girls but not for boys. So it's actually quite clear what cost has to do with the whole thing in spite of your denialism!

All rich people's sons are getting the HPV vaccine at a higher rate than the sons of poor people, and girls, who get it for free, are getting it at a much higher rate than boys whose parents have to pay.
So yes, it's a question of cost, and it's not merely a correlation.

In post 13, you claimed that you "don't know anyone who has ever skipped vaccinations because of the cost," which I described as interesting. I know a lot of parents who can't afford to pay $500 for having a boy vaccinated against HPV.

Those poor people make weird lifestyle choices, don't they?!
 
Last edited:
No, you "didn't indicate what the cause of this correlation is." Not because "it's not important to your argument," but because your argument is that poverty doesn't kill.

This straw man really is the best you can do, isn’t it? That’s just sad.

No, dann, that isn’t my argument at all. My argument is that if you want to increase life expectancy for the poor to a significant degree, you can’t accomplish that through spending more on health care. You have yet to challenge that argument in any way.
 
My argument is that if you want to increase life expectancy for the poor to a significant degree, you can’t accomplish that through spending more on health care. You have yet to challenge that argument in any way.


Your alleged argument is a derail in a thread that is not about health care. The thread is about "Health/Wealth Inequality", of which health care is just a minor part. However, giving boys access to free HPV vaccine will obviously save lives, in particular in Denmark where the incidence of HPV-related throat cancer particularly in men has risen dramatically.

And the difference between the HPV vaccination rate of girls, who don't have to pay for the vaccine, and boys, who do, is very obvious. As obvious as the difference between the vaccination rate of boys from poor and rich families. You know, what you prefer to describe as a "correlation"!
 
Last edited:
Your alleged argument is a derail in a thread that is not about health care.

My alleged argument? Yeah, no. That's not how it works. It's my actual argument. I'm the one who determines what my argument is, not you. And it's not a derail. It's part of the topic of the thread. It isn't the entire extent of the topic, but I didn't claim it was either. If you want to address issues in that topic not covered by my argument, you don't need to attack my argument with straw men and nonsequitors in order to do so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom