Health/Wealth Inequality

Because even if it's free doctors and shots and check ups and colonoscopies are either boring or unpleasant and tacos and bacon never stop being delicious.


Tacos, not so much of a thing over here! But otherwise right, but I'd also add that if you're in an insecure, minimum wage job, don't see any prospects, entertainment options are severely limited, it's dark by five o'clock and it's raining, then cheap alcohol and unhealthy food in front of the telly is an inexpensive way to make yourself feel better, or at least forget you have to go back, for a while.

Not saying it's right, but it's how many people are.
 
You don't?! Interesting …

The children of medical professionals are not getting the vaccine at higher rates than other rich people because of money, but because of something else. Furthermore, the vaccination rate for girls, who get it for free, has apparently plummeted. It's not clear at all that cost is the main driver here.

I am all in favor of free vaccinations for two reasons: 1) it's one of the few preventive care practices which does save money, and 2) it's got huge positive externalities which justify public spending even in an otherwise market setting. But cost still isn't the primary problem we face when trying to increase vaccination rates. Education is. And that doesn't even always follow income levels (google Marin County for a counter-example), though it certainly can.
 
The children of medical professionals are not getting the vaccine at higher rates than other rich people because of money, but because of something else. Furthermore, the vaccination rate for girls, who get it for free, has apparently plummeted. It's not clear at all that cost is the main driver here.

I am all in favor of free vaccinations for two reasons: 1) it's one of the few preventive care practices which does save money, and 2) it's got huge positive externalities which justify public spending even in an otherwise market setting. But cost still isn't the primary problem we face when trying to increase vaccination rates. Education is. And that doesn't even always follow income levels (google Marin County for a counter-example), though it certainly can.

Yes, vaccines specifically are correlated with lower income and lower education. At least in the USA and Canada. The dominant antivaxxer profile in the USA is a six figure income computer engineer who has an MD from Googleversity.

It's not even an 'education' issue IMO so much as a 'expensive well organized misinformation campaign' issue.
 
Not sure you can really use the HPV vaccine as an example of anything. That one has to be administered on separate occasions to work, a certain length of time apart. So it's got added complexity and bother right there, that would discourage those already having access/timing/arrangement issues.
 
Less control of their lives? How?


Well, for one thing, they have less control over where they live. They can only live somewhere they can afford, which means they can't stay in mansions. Cheaper housing means less space, less upkeep from landlords, more noise, and more exposure to industrial land-use.

All of these can contribute to worsening health. People who live near airports, by at least one study, have worse health. Housing near industry will expose people to more air and water pollutants. Bad landlords could fail at mold remediation, radon detection and more. Heck, according to this study, many of America's poorest children are still being exposed to lead paint.

But let's take your example of something a person does have control over - alcohol consumption. It's true that a given person chooses whether to drink or not. But the same given person may not be able to choose whether to be exposed to drunks. So, let's pretend his neighbor gets drunk. I think you'd agree that we have no control over whether our neighbors drink.

In fairly affluent Westchester County, New York, there are about 2,200 people per square mile. (source). In it's poorer neighbor, Bronx County, there are about 33,000 people per square mile - fifteen times as many people. A citizen of Westchester can get fifteen times farther away from an angry drunk than a poorer person (a church-going, tea-totaling, law-abiding poor person) in the Bronx. That person can get fifteen times farther away from his neighbor's cigarette smoke than the same upstanding Bronx resident.

Forget pollution, smog, mold, and all sorts of other things poor people can't control. Population density alone is a huge factor in public health.


* At least one argument in favor of population density is that it brings more people within the range of hospitals and emergency services. This may be true for extremely low-density areas. It becomes fairly silly when considering the difference between Westchester and the Bronx.

ETA: And access to health services, while greater in the UK for the poor, are only a very small part of the problem. It's not about treatment for the sick, it's about the likelihood of not getting sick in the first place.
 
Last edited:
It pretty much starts out as finger wagging.

1. There is a problem.
2. It's someone's fault. Pick one:
a. government
b. individuals

It would be interesting to see if life expectancy gaps are wider in the US than in Europe. My hypothesis would be that it is wider, because in addition to lifestyle differences between rich and poor, we have a greater gap in our access to health care. (I think)

I'd suspect wider, but there is definitely a confounding factor. Black men, especially seem to be much more prone to heart disease. Not sure it's genetic or environmental but even at the ages where violent death is unlikely, black men have fewer years left than white men (and forget about the women).

Let me point out too that it's not like longevity gives you more years in your 20s; it's a decidedly mixed blessing.
 
Tacos, not so much of a thing over here! But otherwise right, but I'd also add that if you're in an insecure, minimum wage job, don't see any prospects, entertainment options are severely limited, it's dark by five o'clock and it's raining, then cheap alcohol and unhealthy food in front of the telly is an inexpensive way to make yourself feel better, or at least forget you have to go back, for a while.

Not saying it's right, but it's how many people are.

I think this is it. Those unhealthy habits are comforting when your life is generally crap.
 
Did nobody notice the OP is about the UK? Where health care (including dental) and preventative treatments (alcohol, smoking and drug addiction) are covered by the NHS? Where there is welfare safety net for all?

Massive amounts of public money goes to health care in the UK. Unlike the US people don’t go broke accessing health services or don’t have to starve after losing their jobs.

Yes all of the above is true but NHS services are far more stretched in poorer areas. Out here in the relatively prosperous countryside, our GPs, hospitals and other healthcare and social services are far less busy. For example, in a city, an NHS dentist is difficult to find and impossible to register with because they are already oversubscribed - in close to 20 years in Bristol I didn't manage to register with one. Here in the country our local NHS dentist still has available capacity, I registered the day we moved.

We do have a welfare safety net, but that safety net is getting smaller all the time (thanks to "austerity") and is also getting increasingly difficult to access. I've recently been applying for various benefits for my father. I've got plenty of time and resources and filling out the complex forms was difficult enough, imagine if I was barely literate. Even if the poor are entitled to benefits, it's quite likely they are not in receipt of their full entitlement and even if they are, they are hardly generous.

The other aspect which is often overlooked is access to healthcare. I have a car and plenty of money. If I need to get to the local GP surgery or hospital, I can be there in a few minutes. If instead I had none of these and also had complex "other" needs either for myself or dependants, simply accessing the health services to which I was entitled could be a major issue. Mrs Don is treasurer and trustee for a local charity which helps out "at risk" families with one or more children under the age of 5. One of the services their volunteers offer is to look after children so that parents can attend doctor or hospital appointments and/or assisting parents to attend with their children. Without the volunteers, the parents and children would likely not attend.

Yes, this is a complex issue, but why is that many poorer people don’t access health services to counter addictions which are shortening their lives?

For the same reason that richer people don't either, but richer people tend to have resources that can mitigate the effects of those addictions. Smoking induced respiratory issues may be less severe if you live in a warn, dry house which isn't riddled with mould. An indoor desk job may be less injurious to health than manual labour.

As you say it's complicated.
 
The children of medical professionals are not getting the vaccine at higher rates than other rich people because of money, but because of something else.


Yes, the children of medical professionals are obviously more likely to be vaccinated because of their parents' education, because of what they know about the cancers in men caused by HPV, but you choose to completely ignore this: "Those who do (get the vaccine) are typically from rich families, …"

Furthermore, the vaccination rate for girls, who get it for free, has apparently plummeted.


Yes, it had plummeted! Due to the mass psychogenic illness and the following HPV-vaccine scare in Denmark! However, now that it's been pretty efficiently contradicted by the experts in an information campaign, the vaccination rate among girls is on the rise again. I've mentioned this case a couple of times in the thread about the outbreak of mass psychogenic illness in the staff of the U.S. embassy in Havana.

It's not clear at all that cost is the main driver here.


Yes, it is: "Those who do are typically from rich families, …"

I am all in favor of free vaccinations for two reasons: 1) it's one of the few preventive care practices which does save money, and 2) it's got huge positive externalities which justify public spending even in an otherwise market setting. But cost still isn't the primary problem we face when trying to increase vaccination rates. Education is. And that doesn't even always follow income levels (google Marin County for a counter-example), though it certainly can.


Why is it so important to you to distinguish between an alleged "primary problem" and an alleged secondary one? If you can't afford it, education doesn't help!

In Denmark HPV vaccinations are free-of-charge for girls, not (yet) for boys! Thus the obvious difference between boys from poor and rich families.
 
For the same reason that richer people don't either, but richer people tend to have resources that can mitigate the effects of those addictions. Smoking induced respiratory issues may be less severe if you live in a warn, dry house which isn't riddled with mould. An indoor desk job may be less injurious to health than manual labour.


A monotonous job that you can't stand is more likely to make you look forward to the next cigarette break. Some residential areas are less likely to make you want to go for a walk or do other kinds of exercise.
 
A monotonous job that you can't stand is more likely to make you look forward to the next cigarette break. Some residential areas are less likely to make you want to go for a walk or do other kinds of exercise.

Indeed, there are a multitude of reasons why being in a bad situation is likely to result in even worse outcomes, and even more likely for people to choose things that are good in the short-term and bad in the long-term. That's pretty much human nature, and psychologists working in behavioral economics have made a number of studies which pretty much confirm the types of things that journalists such as George Orwell knew when he wrote the Road To Wigan Pier:

Would it not be better if they spent more money on wholesome things like oranges and wholemeal bread or if they even, like the writer of the letter to the New Statesman, saved on fuel and ate their carrots raw? Yes, it would, but the point is that no ordinary human being is ever going to do such a thing. The ordinary human being would sooner starve than live on brown bread and raw carrots. And the peculiar evil is this, that the less money you have, the less inclined you feel to spend it on wholesome food. A millionaire may enjoy breakfasting off orange juice and Ryvita biscuits; an unemployed man doesn't. Here the tendency of which I spoke at the end of the last chapter comes into play. When you are unemployed, which is to say when you are underfed, harassed, bored, and miserable, you don't want to eat dull wholesome food. You want something a little bit 'tasty'. There is always some cheaply pleasant thing to tempt you.
 
Indeed, there are a multitude of reasons why being in a bad situation is likely to result in even worse outcomes, and even more likely for people to choose things that are good in the short-term and bad in the long-term. That's pretty much human nature, and psychologists working in behavioral economics have made a number of studies which pretty much confirm the types of things that journalists such as George Orwell knew when he wrote the Road To Wigan Pier:

Good post, even if you outsourced half of it to Orwell.
 
Yes all of the above is true but NHS services are far more stretched in poorer areas. Out here in the relatively prosperous countryside, our GPs, hospitals and other healthcare and social services are far less busy. For example, in a city, an NHS dentist is difficult to find and impossible to register with because they are already oversubscribed - in close to 20 years in Bristol I didn't manage to register with one.

Why doesn't the NHS hire more dentists in urban areas? Or, why don't more dentists open up practices in the city? It seems like there's un-met demand, and I assume the NHS is willing to pay.
 
A monotonous job that you can't stand is more likely to make you look forward to the next cigarette break. Some residential areas are less likely to make you want to go for a walk or do other kinds of exercise.

Or have facilities (or facilities you can afford to use). Similarly, long hours, unsociable or variable hours (when I was on a zero hour contract in a hospitality position I often didn't know what hours I'd be working, between 6:30am and midnight over seven days, until two days before the week began. Team sports, not an option), or a long commute can rob you of the opportunity or will to exercise. Also, I have a weights bench and some other home gym equipment but don't have room to set it up in my house, yeah that's way way down on the list of reasons, but there are a huge number of factors that make a healthy lifestyle easier for the better off, and they add up.

(On a slight sidetrack, if any forumite is in the Bucks/Oxfordshire area and could give a good home to a free stepper machine, PM me.)
 
Why doesn't the NHS hire more dentists in urban areas? Or, why don't more dentists open up practices in the city? It seems like there's un-met demand, and I assume the NHS is willing to pay.

Dentists are unusual in that they are not employed directly by the NHS. Instead they set up their own practices and then decide whether to take NHS patients at NHS rates.

In cities there's enough demand for private dentistry that it seems that NHS clients don't get a look in.
 
It is interesting to note what is not often mentioned when discussing lifestyle choices of those who are pressed economically; namely, that the smoking or drinking as responses to stress and depression, a situation often compounded by a general lack of knowledge and, more subtly, lack of helpful personal histories of prior success to create positive expectations...

... Are the alternative lifestyle responses to going directly for the knife, which speaks damned highly of our fellow men, for all their faults. Damning with faint praise? Hardly; this is homo sapiens sapiens, apex predator, planet Earth, only some several thousand years out the cave; i.e., minutes from the cavern.

Sure, there are bums, a small percentage. But most people want what they might see on TV and do bust their butts with two and three jobs. Imagine that in spite of effort -- often due to having the nearly prescriptive criminal record in the US if black -- you know you get the basics, only the basics, and that's tops. While I lament the health and secondary effects, I find it exceedingly comfortable of others to dismiss the lifestyle choices made by the very poor which, gosh, happen to be surprisingly similar across the globe. There is nothing inherently holy or sinful about being rich or poor.

Perhaps the hard truths about homo sapiens sapiens are a shared trait of every member.
 
Last edited:
A monotonous job that you can't stand is more likely to make you look forward to the next cigarette break. Some residential areas are less likely to make you want to go for a walk or do other kinds of exercise.

Yes, and if you are on a minimum wage, working a 12 hour shift with public transport to and from work and live somewhere with inadequate cooking or refrigeration facilities, which you would struggle to get fixed (due to the cost, the time and the reliance on public Transport), then non-junk food is less accessible.

There are lots of reasons why it's easier to make better choices when one has more choices due to wealth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom