Has anyone ever heard of a thing called COINTELPRO?

Or perhaps he's a COCOINTELPRO agent, trying to disrupt our COINTELPRO organization, distracting us just long enough for the Truthiness Movement to get reorganized and back on track. Little does he know, our COINTELPRO organization also employs COCOCOINTELPRO agents, so his efforts are being wasted.

I, for one, am cuckoo for COCOINTELPRO. Just thought I'd share.
 
Scooby, I was wondering if you might answer a question that's been bugging me since the whole disinfo/cointelpro/government shill thing started a few months ago.

How do you know if someone is cointelpro? What criteria do you use to determine this, and how is that criteria objective?

Let me give you a quick rundown of what I've gleaned so far:
  1. Disinfo agents have views that are radically different from those of the truth movement.
  2. The views of disinfo agents are preposterous when compared with those of other members of the truth movement.
  3. Disinfo agents are supposed to seed discord and disagreement within the movement in order to fracture it.
That's pretty much been the response I've gotten thus far. The problem with those three criteria is that they are entirely subjective in nature. For a movement that already has radically different views than those of the majority of the scientific community or of the general public, it seems odd to classify someone under item #1. You all have radical views, but you have decided that some views are too radical to be true. Speaking as a skeptic, Judy Wood's beam weapons are no more preposterous than any of the controlled demolition theories.

Item #3 also has a lot to do with how the truth movement sees themselves against how outsiders see them. It has always appeared to us that the truth movement was primarily comprised of ego hounds and people who are in it for the money. When egos clash, it is natural to assume that people will split off from the group.

Compare the truth movement to the skeptics. We've all analyzed the same data and come to the same conclusion. Our arguments compliment each other, rather than contradict each other (Wood, Fetzer and Jones all are guilty of contradicting the others). Is this result because we've all looked at the data analytically?
 
Compare the truth movement to the skeptics. We've all analyzed the same data and come to the same conclusion. Our arguments compliment each other, rather than contradict each other (Wood, Fetzer and Jones all are guilty of contradicting the others). Is this result because we've all looked at the data analytically?

Also, when some of our conclusions do contradict, which always happens in science (and ... in life, basically) we always welcome discussion to figure out a possible explanation, which I can't say the same of the Truth Movement.
 
Scooby, never, ever post that picture again!

If you think that's bad, check out the SONG he linked.

After you do, you'll wish you hadn't, but if you don't the curiosity will eat at you for days...

ETA: Scooby, could you indulge me just a little and tell me:

1. What evidence or turn of events would convince you that you are wrong about the whole COINTELPRO thing and that it's really just a bunch of people disagreeing?

2. What evidence would convince you that you and/or the entire truth movement are wrong about 9/11, and that it really hid happen pretty much as described by the 9/11 Commission report?

You know, just for kicks.
 
Last edited:
Well, now I've set the scene, I can lay out the big picture.

COINTELPRO in the 60's and 70's.

Which brings us back to Scholars for 911 Truth,

Jim Fetzer
Steve Jones
Judy Woods
www.acebaker.com/
Jim Hoffman.
David Ray Griffin
You have listed the biggest nuts in the nut case truth movement!

There is no COINTELPRO here, it is just a parade of dolts who truth movement lemmings follow and show their terminal stupidity as they pick their favorite lies to support and parrot.

Not one person in the truth movement has any facts. Never did, never will. So there is no need or danger from this movement but for dumb people who buy LC video, and DavidRayGriffin books.

Silly old men and real dumb young men make up the truth movement.
 
Well, scooby it's an epic post which I'm sure you put alot of effort in, but ultimately the bickering between 'truthers' is your problem not ours.

Maybe you should post this over on LCF. They might care.

According to the Hitch-hiker's guide to the Galaxy

Blog·ging - Blogging is the act of regularly updating your website with some humdrum information about your life or a link to something you just read on the internet in the mistaken belief that anyone actually cares.

It is the 21st century equivalent of hanging around railway stations, writing pithy but erudite descriptions of the passing trains. To take part in "blogging" or to use the appropriate terminology "to join the blogosphere" there are a couple of things you need to do. Firstly, you'll need to increase the size of your ego. Without a swollen ego you simply cannot achieve the levels of solipsism required by a modern blog. This necessary step is often missed by new bloggers, yet without it, you won't believe that anyone is remotely interested in what you've had for lunch today, how cute your cat Mittens is, or whether or not you designed some tedious internet protocol.

In fact blogging without a nova-sized ego can actually be dangerous. If you start using words like blogosphere there is a very real possibility that your own major intestine will leap straight up through your neck and throttle your brain in an attempt to preserve civilization. Fortunately there are various forms of medication to increase the size of your ego, many offering a money back guarantee that you will be at least twice as obnoxious in four weeks or less.

Until you are sufficiently obnoxious, you might feel the need to explain or at the very least describe the things you leap to. Experienced bloggers know that they are so important that readers will blindly follow their links. After all, a few seconds of one blogger's time is clearly more valuable than all the time spent by people discovering they really didn't care. The other thing you should do to become a successful blogger, is change your website to use dotted lines and unreadable tiny fonts, wherever possible.
 
Still waiting, scooby.

You just now claimed there were all kinds of important questions that hadn't been "adequately dealt with." I'm still waiting for even a single valid question.

Let's hear your best.

You jest?
 
Scooby, I was wondering if you might answer a question that's been bugging me since the whole disinfo/cointelpro/government shill thing started a few months ago.

How do you know if someone is cointelpro? What criteria do you use to determine this, and how is that criteria objective?

Let me give you a quick rundown of what I've gleaned so far

Yeah I read your rundown I wasn't too impressed with what you've gleaned to be honest. I've answered your key question several times already, but the answer is only short so I don't mind a recap. It's this.

You don't need to.

Let me give you an example - pretend you're on holiday in the UK, you're in London to see the sights - "hallo matey! God save the Queen!" - and you're in the Underground waiting for a train and it's crowded. There are people all around you, and someone is standing on your foot.

How do you know who is standing on your foot Almond? Maybe you are politically active back in the states - how do you know it's not the COINTELPRO - maybe you were discussing something political, and now you've been distracted by this 'foot'. Do you ring the ACLU? Or do you politely withdraw your foot and continue with what you were saying?

Can you see it now?
 
How do you know who is standing on your foot Almond? Maybe you are politically active back in the states - how do you know it's not the COINTELPRO - maybe you were discussing something political, and now you've been distracted by this 'foot'. Do you ring the ACLU? Or do you politely withdraw your foot and continue with what you were saying?

Can you see it now?
Ah...it is clear now. The criteria you use is a gut feeling. I'll be...it is scientific and logical after all...
 
If you think that's bad, check out the SONG he linked.

After you do, you'll wish you hadn't, but if you don't the curiosity will eat at you for days...

ETA: Scooby, could you indulge me just a little and tell me:

1. What evidence or turn of events would convince you that you are wrong about the whole COINTELPRO thing and that it's really just a bunch of people disagreeing?

2. What evidence would convince you that you and/or the entire truth movement are wrong about 9/11, and that it really hid happen pretty much as described by the 9/11 Commission report?

You know, just for kicks.

I don't believe I've made any bold claims about COINTELPRO, other than to describe it's history and methods, and point out that similar operations have been conducted against antiwar groups recently.

As for Fetzer being deliberately disruptive, I would suggest that he is, based on this show alone ... http://www.911podcasts.com/files/audio/JimFetzer-StevenJones_20070117.mp3 but people should make their own minds up.

As for Judy Woods 'research' being nonsense, I would suggest that it is, because it plainly as, but would also urge people to view this interview where she is questioned about it ... http://video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=-558096240694803017 and again, make their own minds up.

Seen Griffins new book btw, he's a scrapper ...

debunkingdebunking.gif
 
David Ray Grffin states:



Another feature of controlled demolition is the production of a lot of dust, because explosives powerful enough to slice steel will pulverize concrete and most other non-metallic substances into tiny particles


But in his mini-nuke rebuttal, Steven Jones states:


As we examined the WTC-debris sample, we found largechunks of concrete (irregular in shape and size, one wasapproximately 5cm X 3 cm X 3cm) as well as medium-sized piecesof wall-board (with the binding paper still attached). Thus, thepulverization was in fact NOT to fine dust, and it is a falsepremise to start with near-complete pulverization to fine powder(as might be expected from a mini-nuke or a “star-wars” beamdestroying the Towers). Indeed, much of the mass of theMacKinlay sample was clearly in substantial pieces of concreteand wall-board rather than in fine-dust form.


So, Scooby, David Ray Griffin - kook or spook?
 

~enigma~ and scooby - keep the personal insults out of your exchanges, or further action will be taken based on your membership agreement regarding civility. Stick to the topic of the debate.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer
 
If you think that's bad, check out the SONG he linked.

After you do, you'll wish you hadn't, but if you don't the curiosity will eat at you for days...

Damned if you do, damned if you don't. I didn't. It's taken me six months of intensive exposure to Led Zeppelin and the Who to get the LIHOP/MIHOP song out of my head. I don't want to have to go through that again.

And if I ever see that pic of Judy Wood again, I'll report the poster on GP (general principles).

Carry on.
 
Damned if you do, damned if you don't. I didn't. It's taken me six months of intensive exposure to Led Zeppelin and the Who to get the LIHOP/MIHOP song out of my head. I don't want to have to go through that again.

And if I ever see that pic of Judy Wood again, I'll report the poster on GP (general principles).

Carry on.

Altogether now!

Oh whether it's LIHOP
Or whether it's MIHOP
We need to know the Truth
and make this war stop.
 
See Mr Hunter, I helped you with the diet and now you are getting exercise. Who said the internet makes people unhealthy?
 
David Ray Grffin states:

Quote:
Another feature of controlled demolition is the production of a lot of dust, because explosives powerful enough to slice steel will pulverize concrete and most other non-metallic substances into tiny particles


But in his mini-nuke rebuttal, Steven Jones states:

Quote:
As we examined the WTC-debris sample, we found largechunks of concrete (irregular in shape and size, one wasapproximately 5cm X 3 cm X 3cm) as well as medium-sized piecesof wall-board (with the binding paper still attached). Thus, thepulverization was in fact NOT to fine dust, and it is a falsepremise to start with near-complete pulverization to fine powder(as might be expected from a mini-nuke or a “star-wars” beamdestroying the Towers). Indeed, much of the mass of theMacKinlay sample was clearly in substantial pieces of concreteand wall-board rather than in fine-dust form.


So, Scooby, David Ray Griffin - kook or spook?

The simple answer would be neither.

I think I see where you've gone wrong - a clue is in the composition of your question.

You've taken a statement from one argument, and stitched it to a rebuttal from another different argument - and this was where the magic happened, add a bit of skeptic's powder and voila - Frankenstein.

They are talking about different things - this is explained in Steve Jones' work, there are precise gradings behind terms like 'fine' dust, 'ultra-fine' etc. The grading of the dust found at ground zero supports the use of explosives in a controlled demolition as described by Griffin above, but no significant presence of the 'fine dust' as required for the mini-nuke space-beam weapon has been found. I can't remember the exact gradings, he talks about this in the interview I posted earlier, briefly. I think he says that about 98% of the dust was controlled demolition type dust and less than 2% was Star Wars.
 
The grading of the dust found at ground zero supports the use of explosives in a controlled demolition as described by Griffin above, but no significant presence of the 'fine dust' as required for the mini-nuke space-beam weapon has been found. I can't remember the exact gradings, he talks about this in the interview I posted earlier, briefly. I think he says that about 98% of the dust was controlled demolition type dust and less than 2% was Star Wars.
Explain how these numbers were calculated, explain how a standard CD produces such dust, explain how the dust was collected, measured, and identified.
 
Explain how these numbers were calculated, explain how a standard CD produces such dust, explain how the dust was collected, measured, and identified.

Originally Posted by scooby
The grading of the dust found at ground zero supports the use of explosives in a controlled demolition as described by Griffin above, but no significant presence of the 'fine dust' as required for the mini-nuke space-beam weapon has been found. I can't remember the exact gradings, he talks about this in the interview I posted earlier, briefly. I think he says that about 98% of the dust was controlled demolition type dust and less than 2% was Star Wars.

Explain the problem with his explanation.
Explain it to him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom