Hardfire: Physics of 9/11

My apologies, I see what you are getting at now.

NIST couldn't account for 7 damaged columns in their model :rolleyes:

Maybe they didn't account for the plate thickness or grade of steel, maybe the fuel distribution was a little off, maybe they didn't account for the effect of the siding adding to the penetrating depth (as a hypothetical, the siding may have acted as a lubricant as the wing tip penetrated the column, maybe there was moisture between the siding and the column, maybe there was insulation, maybe there was bird crap...)

You seriously question the validity of the NIST report and the outcome of what happened that day because NIST can't account for 6 or 7 severed columns? You're one tough cookie. While I applaud your attention to detail, it might be better suited in precision machining and not accident recreation.

I don't know what to tell you Bardamu. It's a model. NIST made a scientific estimate of what could have happened, and obviously didn't account for everything. That's how these things go. There's about 100 things they could have overlooked that may have accounted for this. Or you could scream gross negligence at some 100 professional engineers.

Six or seven columns per wing is almost half the broken columns. This is worse than gross negligence.
 
Six or seven columns per wing is almost half the broken columns. This is worse than gross negligence.

You either can't count or are lying. There's 4 on the starboard wing, and 2 or 3 on the port.

Your opinion on what is or isn't negligent is impotent. You have neither the skills nor the authority to make such an observation. You have yet to even demonstrate the capacity to acquire the skills necessary to make these accusations.

This is the reason you hide behind a monitor and do nothing. You know that in real life people will laugh in your face. This is the Truth.

Good Luck with your investigation. Please let us know how it turns out.
 
Six or seven columns per wing is almost half the broken columns. This is worse than gross negligence.

Again, then it should be EASY to prove.

Provide your engineering proofs that NIST is wrong. Get it peer reviewed and you can be the first truther to provide the FIRST peer reviewed engineering refutation of part of NIST.

Please provide it.

I know that I (and many others) eagerly await your thesis.

Come on twoof... man up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom