Hardfire: Physics of 9/11

I say he's a sucker for even trying, but hey, that's what he wants so I respect it. (plus you have to pity him, he has a very weak palette, he probably prefers whites to reds but isn't willing to admit it) :D

It's "palate," but well played nonetheless. :D Now back to topic...
 
what the nass was the topic again?

The bastardization of French terminology through English interpretation :D

Most recently is was the interpretation of the fuel slug model as it pertains to energy, column damage and observation. Bardamu seems inclined to believe that the fuel slug model holds no bearing on the discussion because it doesn't adequately describe observation.

His argument stems from the fact that the wing tips represented a very small portion of the concentrated energy available to sever the columns.

What he's saying is that the model predicts a very large hole in the building, but not a hole in the shape of a plane.

What he fails to consider is that Ryan's model never intended to account for the plane shaped cutout on the exterior. Ryan has graciously left that to NIST, which did a wonderful job covering in their extensive 10 000 page report.
 
yeah,bardamu's problem with the fuel slug model seems to be a case of looking for something to complain about.

I mean,I understand it and I went to public school.
 
yeah,bardamu's problem with the fuel slug model seems to be a case of looking for something to complain about.

I mean,I understand it and I went to public school.

Bard doesn't even understand that slug is the unit of mass.
 
Bard doesn't even understand that slug is the unit of mass.

As the person that brought this bit of trivia to this forum, I have to follow-up with the admission that I was wrong in how Mackey used the word. When I posted my message I hadn't seen Mackey's powerpoint files which made his use clear.
 
Only because your logic doesn't seem to follow from observation. You keep jumping from the fuel slug model to this empty wing couldn't penetrate theory. From observation, the wing, empty or full, penetrated the exterior. So either way you are wrong.

If you're going to defer to the videos, there's no point in designing a model in the first place.


That's on top of the fact you have yet to show the energy of the fuel slug alone wasn't enough to penetrate the exterior columns. All you've pointed out is the fuel slug couldn't penetrate the columns exactly as was observed.

I'm accepting for the sake of argument that the fuel slug was enough to penetrate the few exterior columns that could have been hit by fuel. I'm disputing the leap of logic used to reach the conclusion that "the effect that we see, that the plane sliced right through the building, is really the only thing we could expect to see".


I think we all agree that a slug of fuel in the exact shape of the tanks couldn't have created the pattern observed. There's obviously more at work here than just the fuel. What you fail to realize is that this isn't about the pattern, it's about the energy.

Like I've already said, anvils would have the energy, but if the columns couldn't have been hit by anvils, there's no point in modelling them.


All you've shown is that this simplified model is simple.

R Mackey: "What a model is, it's a simplified, practical way to replicate what happened in real life, or what you think might happen in real life."


The bastardization of French terminology through English interpretation :D

Most recently is was the interpretation of the fuel slug model as it pertains to energy, column damage and observation. Bardamu seems inclined to believe that the fuel slug model holds no bearing on the discussion because it doesn't adequately describe observation.

His argument stems from the fact that the wing tips represented a very small portion of the concentrated energy available to sever the columns.

What he's saying is that the model predicts a very large hole in the building, but not a hole in the shape of a plane.

What he fails to consider is that Ryan's model never intended to account for the plane shaped cutout on the exterior. Ryan has graciously left that to NIST, which did a wonderful job covering in their extensive 10 000 page report.

Your use of the term "wing tips" here is a bastardization of English terminology through deception. There was no fuel outboard of rib 18, which is around half way between the fuselage and the wing tip, yet several columns were broken by that section of wing.
 
what the nass was the topic again?

Answer my questions without dodging and you''ll be on topic.


yeah,bardamu's problem with the fuel slug model seems to be a case of looking for something to complain about.

R Mackey: "Science demands review. It demands revision".


I mean,I understand it and I went to public school.

If you understand it, you should be able to explain to me how the model predicts that the empty fuel tanks will slice through the perimeter columns.


Bard doesn't even understand that slug is the unit of mass.

How would you calculate or estimate the mass of the fuel if it had no dimensions?


As the person that brought this bit of trivia to this forum, I have to follow-up with the admission that I was wrong in how Mackey used the word. When I posted my message I hadn't seen Mackey's powerpoint files which made his use clear.

I recommend becoming familiar with an argument before you leap to its defence, but better late than never...
 
Answer my questions without dodging and you''ll be on topic.
Much like you can explain how a SIMPLIFIED MODEL must EXACTLY match what we see in the videos.

R Mackey: "Science demands review. It demands revision".

Then show the science is wrong. You quibble about the ends of the wing tips which you claim were empty (NIST has 3 different indepth models they used, and you are choosing one... and you want to talk about double talk?)

If you understand it, you should be able to explain to me how the model predicts that the empty fuel tanks will slice through the perimeter columns.

Again and again, what part of SIMPLIFIED MODEL do you not understand? the Simp? Lif? ied? mod? or the el?

using the SIMPLIFIED MODEL we can see that there was enough impulse, mass and momentum (all terms you need to review along with symmetrical, uniform and gradual) to slice through the perimeter and core columns.

So you are just quibbling about the fact that it is too simplified and they are making over generalizations? Is that all you have? semantic word games? ROFLMAO.

How would you calculate or estimate the mass of the fuel if it had no dimensions?

I don't need to. NIST did it. R. Mackey (who has owned you repeatedly, man it must hurt to get so anally raped) was doing a SIMPLIFIED MODEL to show a quick and dirty explaination of the physics behind what we saw.

what about that is soooooo hard for you to understand?
 
Answer my questions without dodging and you''ll be on topic. (snip)
You do understand that if the plane was made of balsa wood the result would have been pretty much the same?

Things traveling that fast striking a stationary object are going to **** **** up.

Now please prove WHY the plane couldn't penetrate (which you haven't) to prove the thousands of people who worked on the problem were wrong.

HOW can they make a punchout like that while the fireball is still burning? Thousands witnessed the first hit and I would guess millions witnessed the second with their own eyes. Both hits had similar craft and similar results. Where is the mistake, Bard? What did we miss?
 
I know tri (if I'm not mistaken) brought up this one a week or two ago:

Again, it's a reminder that we're concerned more with mass and velocity of the moving object than the material or what the object actually is. But with no planers it's more than an issue of them being unable to interpret physics; in their minds if you don't produce names then the 'witnesses' to the event are either non-existent, or NWO plants. I've never gotten a rational response from no planers, and I don't expect I ever will.

You'll notice that the steel plate used at the back of that car is 1-inch thick steel and it was folded into a pretzel by the force of that impact. There's practically nothing left of the car they used. You figure the steel used in the WTC is about 1/4 thick and they were hit at high speed, by something with MORE MASS than the sled used in that experiment. It speaks volumes.

Mackey can simplify everything as much as he wants and there will still be people who can't interpret it. He understands that first hand :\
 
Last edited:
I'm accepting for the sake of argument that the fuel slug was enough to penetrate the few exterior columns that could have been hit by fuel. I'm disputing the leap of logic used to reach the conclusion that "the effect that we see, that the plane sliced right through the building, is really the only thing we could expect to see".

Bardamu, listen, you've got to put your thoughts together here and say what you mean. The above just doesn't make any sense. Maybe you could draw out what damage you expect to see then post it here? Totally remove the plane an imagine the mass of fuel impacting the building. Then consider the fuselage. What's the hole look like now? Then add the tail section and engines. At this point you should have a 3 layered image of what would happen if there were no wings on the plane.

You don't even need to do any math here. Just draw the three pictures and post them. I don't think your debate comes from the fuel slug, it comes from the wings being able to penetrate the exterior columns.


Like I've already said, anvils would have the energy, but if the columns couldn't have been hit by anvils, there's no point in modelling them.

Ok, you are correct. The fuel couldn't have hit the exterior on the outboard sides of the wings past the fuel tanks. That's not what the model is about. The model is about punching a hole out of the side in the shape of the tanks and the fuselage, then hypothetically still having enough energy left over to sever the rest of the columns.


Your use of the term "wing tips" here is a bastardization of English terminology through deception. There was no fuel outboard of rib 18, which is around half way between the fuselage and the wing tip, yet several columns were broken by that section of wing.

Yep. That's what an aluminum wing traveling at 500 mph will do. You want proof? That's not a problem. At least to show a bulk of the damage caused by the empty wing section impacting the exterior columns. NIST did it. I think several people did it independently of NIST as well (I think Bazant and then there was a college computer simulation)

Heck, you could work the fuel slug model and create a fuselage model. You'd need the wing dimensions and approximate density.

Why not draw the pictures like I said, then we can work out how much energy is needed to go from what you think and what was observed?
 
If you understand it, you should be able to explain to me how the model predicts that the empty fuel tanks will slice through the perimeter columns.

Even trained engineers sometimes make mistakes based on personal incredulity. Unless I miss my guess, you are not trained in any way and so are far more likely to make such a mistake.

After the shuttle Columbia broke up, many NASA engineers swore up and down that there was no WAY a piece of foam from the external tank could break a hole in the shuttle's protective covering. They couldn't imagine such a thing, even though it took only a BOE calculation to show that it was possible.

Then they all attended an outdoor simulation, and watched it happen.

Oops.
 
Bardamu, listen, you've got to put your thoughts together here and say what you mean. The above just doesn't make any sense. Maybe you could draw out what damage you expect to see then post it here? Totally remove the plane an imagine the mass of fuel impacting the building. Then consider the fuselage. What's the hole look like now? Then add the tail section and engines. At this point you should have a 3 layered image of what would happen if there were no wings on the plane.

You don't even need to do any math here. Just draw the three pictures and post them. I don't think your debate comes from the fuel slug, it comes from the wings being able to penetrate the exterior columns.


Ok, you are correct. The fuel couldn't have hit the exterior on the outboard sides of the wings past the fuel tanks. That's not what the model is about. The model is about punching a hole out of the side in the shape of the tanks and the fuselage, then hypothetically still having enough energy left over to sever the rest of the columns.


Yep. That's what an aluminum wing traveling at 500 mph will do. You want proof? That's not a problem. At least to show a bulk of the damage caused by the empty wing section impacting the exterior columns. NIST did it. I think several people did it independently of NIST as well (I think Bazant and then there was a college computer simulation)

Heck, you could work the fuel slug model and create a fuselage model. You'd need the wing dimensions and approximate density.

Why not draw the pictures like I said, then we can work out how much energy is needed to go from what you think and what was observed?

NIST have already drawn the pictures and done the maths. They modelled the wing with and without the fuel. The wing with the fuel broke the perimeter columns. The wing without the fuel was shredded without breaking the columns. Their diagrams of the observed damage don't match the modelling when you compare the fuel distribution at the time of impact to the damage to the columns.
 
NIST have already drawn the pictures and done the maths. They modelled the wing with and without the fuel. The wing with the fuel broke the perimeter columns. The wing without the fuel was shredded without breaking the columns. Their diagrams of the observed damage don't match the modelling when you compare the fuel distribution at the time of impact to the damage to the columns.
So bardamu, tell us what you think this means. This is how intelligent people get to the bottom of things. Dancing around an perceived anomaly proves absolutely nothing.

Please for the love of God, GET TO THE POINT. (I am assuming you have one)
 
So bardamu, tell us what you think this means. This is how intelligent people get to the bottom of things. Dancing around an perceived anomaly proves absolutely nothing.

Please for the love of God, GET TO THE POINT. (I am assuming you have one)
Without supporting evidence, why should a skeptic share your assumption?
 
If you're going to defer to the videos, there's no point in designing a model in the first place.




I'm accepting for the sake of argument that the fuel slug was enough to penetrate the few exterior columns that could have been hit by fuel. I'm disputing the leap of logic used to reach the conclusion that "the effect that we see, that the plane sliced right through the building, is really the only thing we could expect to see".




Like I've already said, anvils would have the energy, but if the columns couldn't have been hit by anvils, there's no point in modelling them.




R Mackey: "What a model is, it's a simplified, practical way to replicate what happened in real life, or what you think might happen in real life."




Your use of the term "wing tips" here is a bastardization of English terminology through deception. There was no fuel outboard of rib 18, which is around half way between the fuselage and the wing tip, yet several columns were broken by that section of wing.

Dancing and prancing all around the facts.
 
NIST have already drawn the pictures and done the maths. They modelled the wing with and without the fuel. The wing with the fuel broke the perimeter columns. The wing without the fuel was shredded without breaking the columns. Their diagrams of the observed damage don't match the modelling when you compare the fuel distribution at the time of impact to the damage to the columns.

My apologies, I see what you are getting at now.

NIST couldn't account for 7 damaged columns in their model :rolleyes:

Maybe they didn't account for the plate thickness or grade of steel, maybe the fuel distribution was a little off, maybe they didn't account for the effect of the siding adding to the penetrating depth (as a hypothetical, the siding may have acted as a lubricant as the wing tip penetrated the column, maybe there was moisture between the siding and the column, maybe there was insulation, maybe there was bird crap...)

You seriously question the validity of the NIST report and the outcome of what happened that day because NIST can't account for 6 or 7 severed columns? You're one tough cookie. While I applaud your attention to detail, it might be better suited in precision machining and not accident recreation.

I don't know what to tell you Bardamu. It's a model. NIST made a scientific estimate of what could have happened, and obviously didn't account for everything. That's how these things go. There's about 100 things they could have overlooked that may have accounted for this. Or you could scream gross negligence at some 100 professional engineers.
 
NIST have already drawn the pictures and done the maths. They modelled the wing with and without the fuel. The wing with the fuel broke the perimeter columns. The wing without the fuel was shredded without breaking the columns. Their diagrams of the observed damage don't match the modelling when you compare the fuel distribution at the time of impact to the damage to the columns.

GREAT.

Then you finally have something which can be completed, modeled, and published in a real peer reviewed engineering journal.

Get cracking... that would be the 1st paper by a twoof which says that NIST is wrong...

I eagerly await your thesis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom