2. Do you require that all concrete is destroyed uniformly, and during the collapse? If so, this is also wrong. Even Dr. Steven Jones has remarked on this for years, noting that at best only a small fraction of the concrete was actually turned to dust, and even of the dust much of it is quite coarse. You could make a more rigorous mass estimate by looking at the dust study by Lioy et. al. and looking at the mass fraction relative to, say, dust from drywall, assume that most or all of that was turned to dust, and treat the rest of the concrete as uncrushed. Also, what concrete is ground up does not have to be ground up during the collapse. If it hits the ground with some leftover kinetic energy, this energy also contributes to grinding of materials. Furthermore, concrete exposed to fire (i.e. the fire floors, and practically everything in the Pile) will spall, and this will allow grinding with hardly any kinetic energy expenditure. In summary, the amount of concrete turned to dust during the collapse is small.
No. There is no requirement for uniform destruction of all concrete.
The concrete crush energy sink can be switched off entirely, or either of two distinct selectable methods can be applied:
1) A user specifiable constant energy usage (in joules) for the crushing of concrete. Applied per-floor.
or
2) A user specifiable particle scale range (top to bottom) (in microns) applied on a floor-by-floor linear ramped scale, with a current limit of up to 500 micron (although of course this can be easily extended by the user. It's a linear energy usage scale)
The first method does not relate to concrete volume at all, only energy consumed per floor, and so is a fully specifiable constant allowing the user to use a value equivalent to the crushing of zero concrete thru to all concrete, and using their own external methods for determining the amount of energy required to do so.
Mechanically the second method does apply to the full concrete volume of each impacted floor, but again, the scale of the crush can be changed as described above. Many sources state an 'average' concrete crush scale well below the current maximum of 500 micron, which is why the limit was set as such. It could easily be extended to a maximum of say 1m if the user chose to.
If it hits the ground with some leftover kinetic energy, this energy also contributes to grinding of materials.
In this situation the KE should be removed from the system via mass loss. Applying it's energy to post-descent material destruction is erronious.
Furthermore, concrete exposed to fire (i.e. the fire floors, and practically everything in the Pile) will spall, and this will allow grinding with hardly any kinetic energy expenditure.
The model does not include energy sink for any concrete in the cap, only for the impacted floors below. Your point is redundant within the model.
I assume that by 'pile' you mean the descending mass I refer to as the 'cap' ? (As in pile-driving mass)
In summary, the amount of concrete turned to dust during the collapse is small.
This is a much discussed point of contention within 9/11 debates, and does not belong here.
Further extension of the model will include the ability to specify mass loss on a per-floor basis for each possible material.
This extension will allow per-floor specification of the concrete volume crushed and per-floor max/min crush scale.
Additional energy sinks will also be included for the crushing of other materials, which are currently not included.
At this point, only the crush energy for concrete is included (if non zero). Crush energy required for dry wall, furnishings, fittings and a wealth of other required crush 'bodies' will also be included.