Grammatically correct 2nd amendment

I have seen different ideas expressed:

Double barreled musket, with tiny holes drilled between the barrels.
Load barrel #1 with powder, wadding and ball. Then load barrel two with powder, wadding and ball.
Then, load barrel #1 with another round of powder, wadding and ball. Then barrel #2. Maybe do it again, maybe even a 4th time.

Ignite the distal load on barrel #1. It fires the ball out the barrel, some of the charge goes through one of the tiny holes and ignites the distal charge in barrel #2. That shoots the ball out of the barrel, with some of that charge going through another of the little holes and ignites the next layer of powder in barrel #1, which shoots the next ball and ignites the next layer of powder back in barrel #2. And so on, until all layers of powder and ball have been discharged. Less than a second to pop off all layers, real loud and lots of smoke.

Another option would be the Puckle gun

These sorts of things may be what Loesch was describing, I think I saw in this forum. They are counting that as fully automatic. I have seen that used as the argument that the framers totally anticipated fully automatic rifles and would have wanted them freely available in public ownership.


Which is the problematic part coming from the people who derail every conversation where the term "assault' is used in relation to rifles into a long-winded chastisement for the crime of conflating "automatic" and "semi-automatic" weapons.

The Puckle gun was a tripod mounted, long barreled, preferably crew served revolver, of which only a bare handful (possibly as few as two) were ever made, and which were never used in combat.

It isn't even likely that very many (if any) of the "Founding Fathers" ever saw one.

But by that logic a Colt Peacemaker would be an "automatic weapon". This doesn't square very well with the regular arguments tha AR-15s are certainly not "automatics" and aren't 'really' assault rifles.

Now mind you, I happen to agree with the usual distinction between "automatic", "semi-automatic", etc.. But the problem here is that it is the spokescritter for the NRA who is suddenly trying to completely rewrite the definition which they have been the ones so intent on using as a flail against gun control supporters whenever they slip up a bit on nomenclature.

If Dana Roesch, as official representative of the HRA, wants to declare that oversized revolvers are "automatic" weapons that's fine with me.

It's going to change some of the conversations on this subject, though.
 
Now mind you, I happen to agree with the usual distinction between "automatic", "semi-automatic", etc..

It is a fairly recent semantic development, though, isn't it?

When I was learning to shoot there were a few types of shotguns: single shot, double barrel, over under, pump, and automatic.

Similarly there were types of pistols: crack barrels (such as derringers, single shot pistols, and even some triples if I remember correctly) revolvers and automatics.

Rifles were bolt action, lever action, single shot or automatic. (I have an undying fondness for lever action rifles. They just feel so right when you carry them.)

Anything that was truly automatic was considered military grade and generally referred to as a machine gun or sub-machine gun.

The terms "auto" and "automatic" universally referred to what we are now instructed to call "semi-automatic" weapons.

Is my experience in this regard unique?
 
The terms "auto" and "automatic" universally referred to what we are now instructed to call "semi-automatic" weapons.

Is my experience in this regard unique?

That was my experience also. These days it seems like an unforgivable sin, used to dismiss a person's point of view. Not so long ago, however, "automatic" meant semi-auto. Full-auto was usually just referred to as a "machine gun", even if it didn't meet the current definition of sustained automatic fire.

In a previous thread, I quoted from a Mike Hammer book which was using the word "automatic" to refer to what were clearly semi-auto pistols.

Here's one.

Here's another.

The thing about Mike Hammer, is that if you disagree with him, he'll just shoot you in the leg.

ETA: This is one of the semi-auto pistols that is referred to as an "automatic" in the Mike Hammer books.
 
Last edited:
.... a long-winded chastisement for the crime of conflating "automatic" and "semi-automatic" weapons.

I think I'm going to start calling that the "Mike Hammer Fallacy".

With the added bonus that if an offender constantly hammers on people for conflating "automatic" with "semi-automatic", Mike Hammer will show up and shoot them in the leg with his favorite .25 automatic, which is semi-automatic. Mike doesn't take kindly to people nitpicking his gun terminology.
 
How does this help communication?

If I say that people have the right to own and carry automatic weapons, people here will understand I mean semi-automatic rifles and pistols, and dispute me on that basis? I won't catch a lot of grief for advocating a right to bear heavy machine guns?
 
It is a fairly recent semantic development, though, isn't it?

When I was learning to shoot there were a few types of shotguns: single shot, double barrel, over under, pump, and automatic.

Similarly there were types of pistols: crack barrels (such as derringers, single shot pistols, and even some triples if I remember correctly) revolvers and automatics.

Rifles were bolt action, lever action, single shot or automatic. (I have an undying fondness for lever action rifles. They just feel so right when you carry them.)

Anything that was truly automatic was considered military grade and generally referred to as a machine gun or sub-machine gun.

The terms "auto" and "automatic" universally referred to what we are now instructed to call "semi-automatic" weapons.

Is my experience in this regard unique?



Perhaps I should have said "the current usual distinction".

You're managing to miss the point entirely, which just proves the effectiveness of the NRA crowds efforts to obfuscate the debate through nit-picking terminology.

The point is that even while trying to derail the conversation by going on interminably about things like the distinction between "fully automatic" and "semi-automatic", which they insist is verging on criminal ignorance to refer to simply as "automatic", the NRA's own professional representative cannot be bothered to conform to such distinctions herself, claiming that such things as revolvers are "automatic" weapons.

Keep them honest. Next time an NRA groupie starts up about AR-15s not being assault rifles because they aren't "automatics", ask them to explain why their own leaders like to claim that revolvers are.
 
Perhaps I should have said "the current usual distinction".

You're managing to miss the point entirely, which just proves the effectiveness of the NRA crowds efforts to obfuscate the debate through nit-picking terminology.

The point is that even while trying to derail the conversation by going on interminably about things like the distinction between "fully automatic" and "semi-automatic", which they insist is verging on criminal ignorance to refer to simply as "automatic", the NRA's own professional representative cannot be bothered to conform to such distinctions herself, claiming that such things as revolvers are "automatic" weapons.

Keep them honest. Next time an NRA groupie starts up about AR-15s not being assault rifles because they aren't "automatics", ask them to explain why their own leaders like to claim that revolvers are.
This seems to be more about scoring a gotcha than about fostering good communication.
 
This seems to be more about scoring a gotcha than about fostering good communication.


I agree that the NRA groupies are certainly trying to score a "gotcha" every time they inevitably try to derail a conversation into schooling someone about the difference between "automatic" and "semi-automatic" weapons.

I don't see why asking them to be consistent in their definitions when they do that is a "gotcha". They were the ones that brought it up in the first place.
 
It is a fairly recent semantic development, though, isn't it?

When I was learning to shoot there were a few types of shotguns: single shot, double barrel, over under, pump, and automatic.

Similarly there were types of pistols: crack barrels (such as derringers, single shot pistols, and even some triples if I remember correctly) revolvers and automatics.

Rifles were bolt action, lever action, single shot or automatic. (I have an undying fondness for lever action rifles. They just feel so right when you carry them.)

Anything that was truly automatic was considered military grade and generally referred to as a machine gun or sub-machine gun.

The terms "auto" and "automatic" universally referred to what we are now instructed to call "semi-automatic" weapons.

Is my experience in this regard unique?

Same here, but we often called semis autoloaders, and made the distinction for single-action revolvers (cap and ball percussion).
 
How does this help communication?

If I say that people have the right to own and carry automatic weapons, people here will understand I mean semi-automatic rifles and pistols, and dispute me on that basis? I won't catch a lot of grief for advocating a right to bear heavy machine guns?



Formal debates define terms before the bunfight. It might be useful in these instances.

I've never really thought of it as particularly tricky though, that said I might just be plain out wrong, but the difference between a manual, a semi automatic and an automatic weapon seem to be really, really, really obvious to me and I know next to jack about guns.

I've probably got it wrong.
 
Formal debates define terms before the bunfight. It might be useful in these instances.

I've never really thought of it as particularly tricky though, that said I might just be plain out wrong, but the difference between a manual, a semi automatic and an automatic weapon seem to be really, really, really obvious to me and I know next to jack about guns.

I've probably got it wrong.


It seems to depend on who you ask, or perhaps more accurately, when.

At one time, and for many years, as has been pointed out just recently in this thread, the term "automatic" could refer to automatically loading weapons, which still required a trigger pull for each round fired.

More recently the NRA and its fan club have been quite pointed about schooling (and even ridiculing) anyone with the temerity to refer to a weapon which doesn't not automatically fire as well as load as an automatic, even though this distinction was at one time made by using the the phrase "fully automatic".

It is rare that a conversation about gun control where, when someone commits the apparently heinous faux pas of referring to a semi-automatic weapon as an "automatic", they are not quickly taken to task for such a display of profound ignorance, and it is implied that any other statement they might make can be casually dismissed on the basis of this transgression alone.

Which is why, when their very own mouthpiece made the claim that there were "automatic" weapons in 1776, a statement based, it would seem, on the existence of a massively oversized revolver which didn't work well enough to justify more than a handful of copies, it seems only fair to question their earlier rigid adherence to those other, more specific definitions they champion.
 
Which is why, when their very own mouthpiece made the claim that there were "automatic" weapons in 1776, a statement based, it would seem, on the existence of a massively oversized revolver which didn't work well enough to justify more than a handful of copies, it seems only fair to question their earlier rigid adherence to those other, more specific definitions they champion.

I am not sure if anyone if referring to Puckle guns as automatic. I think I saw that somewhere, but can't find it now.

The other thing I mentioned though is Superposed Load. Full auto, of a sort. Once it starts firing, you can't stop it until it runs through all the ammo, and very slow to load. I would guess pretty finicky to get right. Like volley guns, they always seemed to be novelties that were more likely to injure the person holding the gun rather than the target.

ETA: Okay, disregard my first paragraph. Apparently Ms Loesch described the Puckle gun as an example of a fully automatic gun available at the time of the crafting of the bill of rights. She got her facts wrong, it is semi-auto (ETA: I keep giving her too much credit - it was not even semi-auto, it was a fully manual operation. And unrifled barrel, not a rifle. It was a manually operated musket, which she referred to as a fully automatic rifle. Gadzooks, she was not even anywhere close to the truth - right there in front of those kids who had seen their friends shot down just a few days before. Are people still suggesting we need to treat that organization with respect?)

Loesch also referred to the Belton Rifle, a type of Superposed load design. The Belton Rifle never existed - it was designed but never built. She fails on both fact-checking points. There might have been superposed load guns around back then, but not the one that was never made.
 
Last edited:
I agree that the NRA groupies are certainly trying to score a "gotcha" every time they inevitably try to derail a conversation into schooling someone about the difference between "automatic" and "semi-automatic" weapons.

I don't see why asking them to be consistent in their definitions when they do that is a "gotcha". They were the ones that brought it up in the first place.

That isn't what I asked, and you know it. But whatever. Am I allowed to look for clarity and consistency of terms, here in this discussion, without being dismissed as an "NRA groupie", and without being called upon to defend their language?
 
I have lost track of a thing or two here, including exactly what point the prestige is trying to make and which side he takes on what are nowadays called "automatic" weapons, but I will add that when I was growing, up, indeed the terminology then was to classify an "auto-loading" weapon that would now be called "semi-automatic," as "automatic." What is now considered fully automatic would, I think, have been called a machine gun.

I inherited my mom's Hi Standard pistol, which was throughout my youth called an automatic, though it is indeed semi automatic. It's a nice machine, by the way, though I have only used it once to make sure it operated after a repair, and it's never kept loaded. Back in the long ago times, when we lived way out in the country, she kept it for varmints and the like, and practiced by putting a magazine cover of Joe McCarthy on a tree and trying to get him between the eyes.
 
I have lost track of a thing or two here, including exactly what point the prestige is trying to make and which side he takes on what are nowadays called "automatic" weapons, but I will add that when I was growing, up, indeed the terminology then was to classify an "auto-loading" weapon that would now be called "semi-automatic," as "automatic." What is now considered fully automatic would, I think, have been called a machine gun.
I would like to have a discussion about gun control that managed to acknowledge and account for important technical distinctions without getting bogged down in a terminology slapfight. And also without having to deal with "NRA groupies" and other counterproductive name-calling.

If quadraginta wants to call me an "NRA groupie", let him do so, and we can proceed accordingly. But if he doesn't, he can take his beef with the NRA to wherever their "groupies" actually hang out, and try his luck with his actual intended audience. Meanwhile we here could have a civil discussion about gun control.
 
How does this help communication?

If I say that people have the right to own and carry automatic weapons, people here will understand I mean semi-automatic rifles and pistols, and dispute me on that basis? I won't catch a lot of grief for advocating a right to bear heavy machine guns?

I'm not going to jump either way, but yes, there does seem to be a subset of posters that take the view that every term being used must be precise before moving to the point being discussed. As this is the "grammatically correct 2nd amendment" thread I assumed this was the best place to air my grammatical frustrations with this debate.

If we are limited to just the bad grammar in the second amendment, then it is a short thread: remove the extraneous comma. The other problems with the amendment are not grammatical in nature.
 
That isn't what I asked, and you know it.


I don't know anything of the sort. Not least because I was unaware that you had actually asked a question in the post of yours to which I responded.

This seems to be more about scoring a gotcha than about fostering good communication.

By all appearances it is a simple declarative sentence. If you intended it as an interrogative perhaps you should have phrased it differently.

But whatever. Am I allowed to look for clarity and consistency of terms, here in this discussion,


Certainly. In fact it is to be preferred. In case you overlooked the point I was making in your haste to disagree, consistency is exactly what I was looking for.

without being dismissed as an "NRA groupie", and without being called upon to defend their language?


It isn't clear to me that I ever suggested you to be, much less "dismissed" you as an NRA groupie. In fact, until this outburst I would have viewed your post #126 as placing you in the category I am trying to encourage. I had thought you were agreeing.

Now, I confess, I am no longer quite so confident regarding that.
 
So I appreciate the idea that we should be speaking the same language and have some basic appreciation of how things differ, and thus for the purpose of our discussion, why don't we start by trying to agree on what the distinctions actually are and what they mean, and while we're at it to discard and disregard attempts by those who really are NRA groupies to muddy that distinction or to pretend things that are one thing are really the other.

To that end, I would propose that we begin by adopting for this discussion the terminology which I think most people would consider currently standard, which is that a weapon that loads its next shot automatically but does not fire it without both releasing and re-activating the trigger will be called "semi-automatic," and a weapon that both loads its next shot automatically and fires it without first releasing the trigger is "automatic." A weapon that requires recocking with a bolt, pullback of hammer, or pump, would be a non automatic multiple shot one, and one which does not have any magazine at all and requires that each bullet be inserted by hand would be a single shot one.
 
I would like to have a discussion about gun control that managed to acknowledge and account for important technical distinctions without getting bogged down in a terminology slapfight.


Exactly. This is a stance you should endeavour to take up with those parties who are the most frequent and regular transgressors of such a policy.

Which isn't me. I didn't even address the topic until Dana Roesch's effort (as NRA spokescritter) to change the NRA's own definitions* to fit her most immediate protestations of moral superiority.

(*; You know, the ones they've spent the last decade or two browbeating everyone else into accepting?)

And also without having to deal with "NRA groupies" and other counterproductive name-calling.

If quadraginta wants to call me an "NRA groupie", let him do so, and we can proceed accordingly.

<snip>


Methinks he doth protest too much.

It isn't clear to me why you so eagerly assumed the mantle of wounded party.

I don't believe I have made any statements which imply that you personally would fall into the category of NRA groupie.

It appears that you are somewhat oversensitive on this subject, and rather over-quick to take offense where none has been offered.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom