Grammatically correct 2nd amendment

US constitutional amendments are not made by national referendum.

Typically, two-thirds of both Houses of Congress must pass the amendment and then three-quarters of state legislatures have to ratify the amendment.

This currently has an extremely small chance of success.

Depends on how you look at it. There have been nine amendments passed in the last century. Two others were passed by Congress, but were not ratified by the necessary number of states.
 
The first half of the amendment is just explaining their reasoning. This example is not original with me, but I do find it pretty interesting. Suppose one of the amendments to the constitution said as follows: "A well-educated Congress being necessary for the governance of a free state, the right of the people to keep and read books shall not be infringed." Would anybody see that as saying that only members of Congress can keep and read books?

No, but that's not a good analogy nor a valid response. Suppose, for example, we found ourselves in a world where the majority of knowledge was disseminated not by books, but by some other medium. Would it not become more important that access to that other medium was protected? Might it even become irrelevant that the right to keep and read books be protected? If the statement of the justification of the imperative statement becomes obsolete, it seems reasonable to re-examine whether the imperative is still appropriate.

Dave
 
The courts have established a clear standard for infringement of rights under the constitution:

There must be a compelling government interest in solving the problem. The proposed solution must be narrowly tailored to that problem. The proposed solution must be the least restrictive solution that meets the first two requirements.

So you can't just say the solution is to "infringe" a little more. You'll have to identify a specific problem, describe a specific solution to that problem, and show that there's no less-restrictive solution to the problem.

So. I think we can stipulate that school shootings are a serious problem, and that the government has a compelling interest in solving it, even if it means infringing on constitutional rights. Meeting the other two requirements is left as an exercise for the reader.

I was referring to the fact that 2nd AD has been infringed before quite successfully - the full canopy of military gear is not available to the US buyer which it should be if the 18th century meaning of the phase was to be met.

I suspect that in time further infringement will occur.
 
No, just “the people”.

Otherwise, you are postulating that intention of the second amendment is to prevent the state from disarming the state.


That seems like a perfectly reasonable goal in view of the conflict they had been engaged in only a few years before they drafted it.

The first actual battle of the American Revolutionary War was fought to prevent British soldiers from seizing militia arms stored at Concord.

That alone suggests to me that the section about "A well regulated militia" was far more than superfluous.
 
At some point, discussing it should involve actual discussion. Even reinventing the wheel at some point must progress beyond people saying "hey, has anybody ever thought about reinventing the wheel?"
<snip>


And so it has. The wheel gets reinvented all the time, in many different applications.

Just look at the history of the automobile over the last century. The wheels on the cars you ride in now have gone through a constant process of reinvention.

And it continues today.
 
The courts have established a clear standard for infringement of rights under the constitution:

There must be a compelling government interest in solving the problem. The proposed solution must be narrowly tailored to that problem. The proposed solution must be the least restrictive solution that meets the first two requirements.

So you can't just say the solution is to "infringe" a little more. You'll have to identify a specific problem, describe a specific solution to that problem, and show that there's no less-restrictive solution to the problem.

So. I think we can stipulate that school shootings are a serious problem, and that the government has a compelling interest in solving it, even if it means infringing on constitutional rights. Meeting the other two requirements is left as an exercise for the reader.

Yes, that responsibility lies with the reader, not their representatives in the US government.

Less sarcastically: requiring a license to purchase or posses firearms passes that test pretty easily so long as the requirements to obtain that license are not onerous or discriminatory.

The problem is political, not legal.
 
Yes, that responsibility lies with the reader, not their representatives in the US government.

Less sarcastically: requiring a license to purchase or posses firearms passes that test pretty easily so long as the requirements to obtain that license are not onerous or discriminatory.

The problem is political, not legal.
Why the sarcasm? I seriously consider it a fundamental principle that the responsibility for formulating and understanding policy is first and foremost an individual responsibility of each and every citizen.

Even if the authority to decide matters of law is ultimately delegated to elected representatives and appointed judges, citizens still owe it to themselves and to each other to be able to follow along with such decisions, and confidently present their own agreement or dissent with such decisions. Nobody with sincere concerns about the issue should blindly leave it up to the legislature and the courts to decide these questions, without having already done their own reasoning about them.

As for your proposed solution: What specific problem does it aim to solve? Is it narrowly tailored to that problem? Is it the least restrictive solution to that problem?

I agree that it's a political problem, mainly in the sense that people are more interested in political shenanigans than legal solutions.
 
As for your proposed solution: What specific problem does it aim to solve? Is it narrowly tailored to that problem? Is it the least restrictive solution to that problem?

Unsuitable people having access to firearms. There are red flags that surround most people who use firearms illegally. A better system to review those red flags BEFORE selling the firearm would be a narrowly tailored approach to that problem.

Side benefit: once the license is obtained it is a quick check to see if it is still valid. So the requirement could be extended to personal transactions.

Assuming it's not guns that kill people, it must be people. So, lets focus on the people. And which ones get to own guns.

I agree that it's a political problem, mainly in the sense that people are more interested in political shenanigans than legal solutions.

Agreed.
 
So it is with the Second Amendment. We want a well-regulated militia (again, drawn from the populace). Making guns available to everyone will help in that goal (because at least we will have people who are familiar with firearms and can shoot well).

I thought you said we could ignore the first clause entirely, and all that is left is the right to bear arms? Probably my mistake - it's late here - so accept my apologies if it wasn't you.

eta: Ah ...

Brainster: "The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. The other clause is superfluous. "
 
Last edited:
That seems like a perfectly reasonable goal in view of the conflict they had been engaged in only a few years before they drafted it.

The first actual battle of the American Revolutionary War was fought to prevent British soldiers from seizing militia arms stored at Concord.

That alone suggests to me that the section about "A well regulated militia" was far more than superfluous.

I'm not sure that the Minutemen would have been seen as part of the British State.

"Minutemen were civilian colonists who independently organized to form well-prepared militia companies self-trained in weaponry, tactics, and military strategies"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minutemen

The minutemen were closer to being "The People" than a "National Guard" equivalent.
 
True, but as some of us have seen, the results of a referendum can provide a major motivator to legislators to execute what has clearly been stated as the will of the people.

Dave

Or not depending upon the result. One thing to look at would be polling figures on this issue.

Perhaps a better tactic for those who want to amend the second amendment would be to have grassroots candidates in state legislatures and running for Congress on the platform.
 
Depends on how you look at it. There have been nine amendments passed in the last century. Two others were passed by Congress, but were not ratified by the necessary number of states.

I mean, specifically, amending the second amendment has little chance of success right now.
 
I'm not sure that the Minutemen would have been seen as part of the British State.

"Minutemen were civilian colonists who independently organized to form well-prepared militia companies self-trained in weaponry, tactics, and military strategies"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minutemen

The minutemen were closer to being "The People" than a "National Guard" equivalent.


I think you are trying too hard.

From your link;

In the British colony of Massachusetts Bay, all able-bodied men between the ages of 16 and 60 were required to participate in their local militia.[2] As early as 1645 in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, some men were selected from the general ranks of town-based "training bands" to be ready for rapid deployment. Men so selected were designated as minutemen.

That sounds like "the state" to me. The colonies were governed by authority of the British Crown. Under that authority they were required to establish and maintain militias.

In other words, "the state"

There was a militia. It was formed for the defense of the residents and the Crown by the residents, at the behest of the Crown. "The state", AKA the British, mandated militia groups as a ready source of recruits for military actions. The British tried to disarm the militia at Concord in the lead-up to the war by confiscating the arms in their militia armory.

They weren't trying to take the weapons out of individual homes.

This was a simple, straightforward example of the state trying to disarm the state, and one of the key incidents of the beginning of full-out war between the Colonies and the British home rule.

I'm not surprised in the least that the writers of the Bill of Rights made a point of not only including the protections of the 2nd Amendment, but also made a point of connecting that protection to militias, since they had already been burned that way.
 
Last edited:
The first half of the amendment is just explaining their reasoning. This example is not original with me, but I do find it pretty interesting. Suppose one of the amendments to the constitution said as follows: "A well-educated Congress being necessary for the governance of a free state, the right of the people to keep and read books shall not be infringed." Would anybody see that as saying that only members of Congress can keep and read books? (I guarantee a few "skeptics" will say yes, but they are being obstinate).

No, the plain reading of that amendment would be that since we want a well-educated Congress, and since the Congress is drawn from the populace at large, we also need a well-educated populace, and making books available to everyone will help in that goal. And an even plainer reading is that the first clause is superfluous.

So it is with the Second Amendment. We want a well-regulated militia (again, drawn from the populace). Making guns available to everyone will help in that goal (because at least we will have people who are familiar with firearms and can shoot well).


That would seem to be an argument for the abolition of the second amendment? It's purpose, as stated in the document, is no longer in play. A well regulated militia is now no longer necessary for the security of a free state.
 
Unsuitable people having access to firearms. There are red flags that surround most people who use firearms illegally. A better system to review those red flags BEFORE selling the firearm would be a narrowly tailored approach to that problem.

Or we can accept that political violence(terrorism) is a feature of our constitutional right to arms and not a bug.

"I Disapprove of Who You Shoot, But I Will Defend to the Death Your Right to Shoot Them"
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom