Government knew date, targets and method for 9/11 attacks

I do not doubt that there may have been a few people who either worked for a government agency or one of their subcontractors, who knew that terrorists were plotting an attack, maybe a few other people who had some information about methods that could be used, and maybe even a few people who had a vague idea of time frame. However, this does not mean that "The Government" (whatever the heck that is), could have put all of these pieces together in time to do anything about it. The suggestion that government officials at the highest level knew all of the details in advance of the attack and let it happen anyway is simply wishful thinking on the part of the fantasists.

The fact that intelligence gathering has been restructured in the wake of 9/11 certainly indicates that this is something that was investigated, and changes were implemented. Unfortunately, the effectiveness of the new measures is only something that can be disproven in the long run. :(
 
...which were never investigated. I don't think this proves conspiracy. I think it demonstrates the need for a new independent investigation.

So they are whistleblowers on something that was not a conspiracy, but it was a conspiracy because they are whistleblowers who were ignored? But it's not a conspiracy because we just somehow neglected to conduct a proper investigation, but it is a conspiracy because there has been no "independent" investigation?

I think in your efforts to tow the conspiracist line of "we need a new investigation", you forgot that claiming ignorance of something you've already said exists is contradictory...
 
I would wait to see the outcome of a "real investigation" before claiming that this is fact. If you have followed my "neutrality" you should know that I have always been in favor of a new investigation, one with teeth. I think this is just one of the indications that a new investigation is needed. As far as the WTC collapses go, I am still 50/50.


I'm curious about your "new" investigation. As I always ask the other fantasists, how will your investigation proceed in the absence of real engineers, physicists, chemists, demolition experts, flight controllers, avionics techs, military personnel, firefighters, seismologists, forensic examiners, etc? Are you sure you have a sufficient number of theologians, talk radio hosts, and literary theorists to do the job? Remember, once you start adding actual scientists, you simply replicate the findings of all the other investigations. To get the results you desire so desperately, you need the right "researchers."
 
Last edited:
...which were never investigated. I don't think this proves conspiracy. I think it demonstrates the need for a new independent investigation.

I think it demonstrates the need for these "whistleblowers" to present their evidence.

But since you brought it up...who would this investigation be "independent" from?
 
I was wrong about Urich. I claimed that he would reveal himself as a full-blown twoofer after his 500th post. It has taken him 800 posts, although he really didn't hide his intentions very well.

Well golly gee whiz pomeroo! Anyone putting forth anything that might indicate the possibility of a conspiracy must be "lying" or "need help" or wear a "tin hat" or be incredibly stupid or all of the preceding. Your fantasy about me is totally moronic. If you want to know what I think just ask.
 
Well golly gee whiz pomeroo! Anyone putting forth anything that might indicate the possibility of a conspiracy must be "lying" or "need help" or wear a "tin hat" or be incredibly stupid or all of the preceding.
Actually, it's the people who are putting forth nothing (and also lies) and yet claiming we need yet another investigation who are stupid lying tin-hatters.

Know anyone like that GU?
 
I'm curious about your "new" investigation. As I always ask the other fantasists, how will your investigation proceed in the absence of real engineers, physicists, chemists, demolition experts, flight controllers, avionics techs, military personnel, firefighters, seismologists, forensic examiners, etc? Are you sure you have a sufficient number of theologians, talk radio hosts, and literary theorists to do the job? Remember, once you start adding actual scientists, you simply replicate the findings of all the other investigations. To get the results you desire so desperately, you need the right "researchers."

Pure blather. It simply won't have a insider as executive director, will be properly funded, will have enough time, will have unlimited subpoena power and use it, and will be responsive to a citizens oversight group. All things the original commission which "was set up to fail" did not have.
 
Pure blather. It simply won't have a insider as executive director, will be properly funded, will have enough time, will have unlimited subpoena power and use it, and will be responsive to a citizens oversight group. All things the original commission which "was set up to fail" did not have.
When you fell down the rabbit hole of 9/11 truth, did it hurt your engineering side of the brain, or the rational side?

Greg, why have you abandoned the "scientific method" of 9/11 truth, for pure politically biased poppycock?

beachnut, let's keep things civil, please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: jmercer

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pure blather. It simply won't have a insider as executive director, will be properly funded, will have enough time, will have unlimited subpoena power and use it, and will be responsive to a citizens oversight group. All things the original commission which "was set up to fail" did not have.

You do realize that this "unlimited subpoena power" doesn't happen without government involvement...
 
Pure blather. It simply won't have a insider as executive director, will be properly funded, will have enough time, will have unlimited subpoena power and use it, and will be responsive to a citizens oversight group. All things the original commission which "was set up to fail" did not have.

Wasn't that said by the same person that claims "despite this we were ultimately successful?
 
I was wrong about Urich. I claimed that he would reveal himself as a full-blown twoofer after his 500th post. It has taken him 800 posts, although he really didn't hide his intentions very well.
The full-blown twoofer Greg was able to calculate the mass in a way superior to what has been done before. He corrected an old value and there is probably much more to correct. From a debunkers point of view I don't understand the fear of a new full investigation because aren't they convinced that the official story is correct ?
 
Last edited:
The full-blown twoofer Greg was able to calculate the mass in a way superior to what has been done before. He corrected an old value and there is probably much more to correct. From a debunkers point of view I don't understand the fear of a new full investigation because aren't they convinced that the official story is correct ?
Fear? Yes, that's what it is. Nothing to do with the fact a new investigation would cost a ton, arrive at the same conclusions, and ultimately face the same accusations of cover-up the last one did in a pointless attempt to pacify crazy people.
 
The full-blown twoofer Greg was able to calculate the mass in a way superior to what has been done before. He corrected an old value and there is probably much more to correct. From a debunkers point of view I don't understand the fear of a new full investigation because aren't they convinced that the official story is correct ?

Don't be silly einsteen, the facts and evidence are only valid if they support the OCT.
 
OMG, this again.

The truth movement must have bought an new recycler recently...JHC!!!!

I am on the verge of going on a ballistic rant!!!

You were warned!

TAM:)
 
Fear? Yes, that's what it is. Nothing to do with the fact a new investigation would cost a ton, arrive at the same conclusions, and ultimately face the same accusations of cover-up the last one did in a pointless attempt to pacify crazy people.

I agree. Perhaps after spending all that money and arriving at the same conclusions people like gregoryurich and einsteen may finally acquiesce, but we would still be here the very next day having the same old arguments with a dozen of the less rational truthers.

We all know (and that means YOU TOO einsteen and gregory) most truthers would call this new investigation bogus if it didn't point to inside job.

Everybody else, all the REAL experts who already knew that the first investigation was essentially correct, would be scratching their heads wondering what the hell they just spent all their hard-earned tax dollars on.
 
Last edited:
I think with GregoryUlrich it is the case of somebody who hates the Bush Administration ,who wanted to believe that 9/11 was an inside job for some time,but basic ratiionality held them back for a while but at last was overcome and they became full blown truthers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom