Government knew date, targets and method for 9/11 attacks

The decision rendered in United States v. Johnson, 546 F.2d 1225, 1227 (5th Cir. 1977) was done by at least a three judge panel, not an individual. Furthermore, the case carries precedent, it is cited in decisions by appellate courts in other jurisdictions like this one: http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/200113624.opn.pdf

Moreover, the US Supreme Court said misprision of a felony "require both knowledge of a crime and some affirmative act of concealment or participation.” Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665, 696 n.36 (1972)

You did not claim this:

"There is a federal statute compelling disclosure of knowledge of violent felonies".

You claimed this:

"U.S. citizens, regardless of standing, are legally obligated to report knowledge of violent felonies. Not doing so is a felony itself."

Your claim is false. US Courts have ruled that it is false in terms of Federal law and the Cash case proves it is false with respect to State law.

You like playing semantical games. This is a perfect example of an impotent woo.
 
What about you? Do you what to admit that Mince was wrong yet?


Mince's statement, as quoted by you, is not wrong. The statute remains on the books, and people can be prosecuted for it.


And on a side note, Pats-haters are sooooo cute when they are jealous. ;)

(If anyone really cares about my reaction to Spygate, there are two perfectly good threads, one in Community and one in Sports, about this. My thoughts are already posted there.)
 
"Jersey Girl" Patty Casazza tells of meeting with whistleblowers who said the government knew the date, targets and methods of the attacks prior to 9/11.


In the first section (NORAD) of the film In Their Own Words, Patty Casazza makes the following specific claims:

These planes were not thought to be errant, they were known to be hijacked quite early on.

This is false. According to FAA protocol on 9/11 an aircraft was not to be considered hijacked unless Air Traffic Controllers received and confirmed a Mode 3/A 7500 transponder code. None of the aircraft hijacked on 9/11 gave a 7500 code.

Further, the FAA did not even suspect AA11 was a hijacked until 10 minutes after it was hijacked, and 22 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect UA175 was a hijack until 14 minutes after it was hijacked and 8 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect AA77 was a hijack until 27 minutes after it was hijacked and 16 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect UA93 was a hijack until 4 minutes after it was hijacked and 33 minutes before it crashed.



Supposedly at 08:46 the FAA set up a phone bridge; with the Secret Service, with NORAD...

This, again, is false. No official communication between the FAA and military was established during the attack. While the NMCC established a tele conference after the Pentagon was attacked, both they and the White House had great difficulty including the FAA who kept dropping off it.

Prior to 0903 no one thought that there was any serious threat underway requiring the coordination of multiple government agencies.


With the Secret Service in on that at 08:46 in the morning, they would have also, by standard protocol and procedure, have to have told the National Security Advisor, who is also there in protection of the President; she is to inform him of all National Security threats.

Again, false. No one was aware that suicide hijackings were under way until 0903 at the very earliest. Neither an airliner crashing nor an airliner being hijacked are national security matters.



Again, it seems impossible that she [the National Security Advisor] was not aware of the terrorist attacks; the fact that these were hijacked planes. These were not errant planes or pilot error.

No one was aware that terrorist attacks were under way until 0903.



He [Vice President Cheney] claims to have only heard the attacks at 09:30 when the Secret Service came in and said that the nation's under attack and that he had to be put some place safe. And yet there are photographer accounts and Richard Clark's account that in fact Vice President Cheney was informed around 9 o'clock. Why didn't Vice President Cheney then ensure that the right steps were being taken by the Department of Defense, when then wouldn't they evaculate perhaps DC buildings? There was a whole chain of events and maybe the Pentagon wouldn't have - well maybe it still would have got hit but maybe not as many people would have lost their lives. How is it that the Secretary of Defense Rumsfield, the then-acting Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Myers were totally unaware then, after this chain of command in interrupted, why they then weren't activated in some way shape or form to at least protect the President, protect the Vice President.

This needs breaking up:

He [Vice President Cheney] claims to have only heard the attacks at 09:30 when the Secret Service came in and said that the nation's under attack and that he had to be put some place safe.

The video itself contradicts this claim. Immediately prior to her claim it shows a video of Cheney in which he explains that he at the time the USSS evacuated him he was getting updates on the TV and beginning to work out what should be done about the attacks. He is clearly saying he was not only aware of the attacks but was working to address them. His statement regarding 09:30 is that this is when he was notified of the direct threat to him (i.e. the White House). This is entirely consistent with what happened on 9/11. Cheney also claims in the same clip that was shown prior to her claim, that all the USSS said to him was "we have to leave now".



And yet there are photographer accounts

There is one photographer account that Cheney was evacuated sooner. The claim is not supported by evidence, and is refuted by others.


and Richard Clark's account that in fact Vice President Cheney was informed around 9 o'clock.

At 0900 no one knew there was an attack underway. Richard Clark's accounts are incredibly shakey and many of his timelines conflict with other people.



Why didn't Vice President Cheney then ensure that the right steps were being taken by the Department of Defense, when then wouldn't they evaculate perhaps DC buildings?

Yes that's right, upon learning that some sort of aircraft (size unknown) has (presumably) accidentally flown into the WTC, Cheney should have immediately ordered the military to evacuate Washington DC. Apparently.



There was a whole chain of events and maybe the Pentagon wouldn't have - well maybe it still would have got hit but maybe not as many people would have lost their lives.

One of the Pentagon's primary evacuation gathering points is on the open grass field beside the helicopter pad. Had they evacuated the Pentagon prior to impact thousands of people would have been directly in the aircraft's path with nothing between them and the resultant fireball, blast, and debris. Hundreds and hundreds more people would have been killed.


How is it that the Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld, the then-acting Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Myers were totally unaware

Both claim to have known about the first impact in short order. According to various accounts Rumsfeld was in a meeting in the morning, and they were informed about the first impact between 08:50 and 09:00 at which point the meeting as adjourned and Rumsfeld went to a CIA briefing, during which he was informed about the second impact. He directed his staff to begin setting things up to manage the crisis while he went to his intelligence briefing.

Myers was apparantly in the first meeting with Rumsfeld and learned of the first impact then. He then went to a meeting at Capitol Hill and learned of the second impact when that meeting ended, shortly before the Pentagon was hit.


then, after this chain of command in interrupted, why they then weren't activated in some way shape or form to at least protect the President, protect the Vice President.

Neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense has the responsibility of protecting the President or Vice President, neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense had reason to suspect the President or Vice President needed protecting, and neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense was capable of providing protection to the President or Vice President.



We find that, according to his [Donald Rumsfield's] accounts, he was unaware of the attacks until the Pentagon got hit, and then apparently he rushes out to help victims of the attack.

Rumsfeld's own accounts directly contradict this claim. And he did not "apparently" head outside the Pentagon to help victims - it's a categorical fact - there's ample news footage of him actually doing it.



Here we have two totally different accounts; this is not a partisan issue, this is something that if you'd pulled the tapes we could have nailed the facts then and there: who was there and who was not there?

Which is precisely what the 9/11 Commission did. In their report they provided a thorough account of Richard Clark's teleconference, based on the evidence they had. It started at 09:25, the FAA and CIA did not join until 09:40. Even Clark himself does not claim it started at 08:46 - he claims it started at 09:10.

Clark's account of who was present in the teleconference at 09:10 is conflicted by cross-collaborating accounts from others such as Myers, Senators, Rumsfeld, all their staff, and so forth. So either Clark is right, and dozens of other people both lied and faked evidence (including, presumably, the news networks that showed the evacuation of the White House at about 09:30), or Clark got his times wrong.

So there we have an idea of Patty Casazza's reliability. She has no credibility whatsoever. Personally I'm not going to take her word for it that there are FBI agents who knew the precise date, targets and methods of the 9/11 attacks in advance - especially given that the FBI agents specifically tasked with tracking Al Qaeda deny this allegation (and they, unlike Casazza's whistleblowers, are willing to talk about it on the record).
 
I'm impressed that anyone in the FBI knew the exact date, method, etc of the attacks in advance considering that John O'Neill's counter terrorism unit, which was specifically tasked with tracking Al Qaeda, didn't know it was coming.
If he did he picked an odd place to be that morning...
 
I would wait to see the outcome of a "real investigation" before claiming that this is fact. If you have followed my "neutrality" you should know that I have always been in favor of a new investigation, one with teeth. I think this is just one of the indications that a new investigation is needed. As far as the WTC collapses go, I am still 50/50.
I've resurrected a thread for you:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=92411

I'd be interested to see your thoughts.

Are you interested in being more specific about what an investigation would actually investigate, GregoryUrich?

Here is the first post from the thread I mentioned above:

I suppose this is a variation on the "What should an investigation be carried out?" question; but, for the sake of an intellectual exercise I'm proposing that we forget about a lot of the practical obstacles to a new investigation.

Imagine that you are in charge of a new investigation. You can call any witness you like, ask for expert testimony from anybody you want, examine all the physical evidence and records that you like. All questioning would be under oath.

There are some limitations:

1. All witness have the same constitutional rights as they would in a courtroom (including those provided by the Fifth Amendment).

2. You have no special powers to tell if a witness is lying or not.

3. There is nothing currently kept secret that would instantly and explicitly prove an inside job (for example, the unreleased Pentagon video tapes; or some memo that tells the whole story and has been suppressed). For the purposes of this exercise, we have to assume that anything obvious has been kept completely secret and shared only between a small number of conspirators. As soon as orders are passed to a large number of people (NIST, NORAD, the FDNY, field officers of the CIA and FBI, etc) they would have to be constructed in such a way as to not make those people suspicious that they were participating in a terrorist attack against their own people. The same must apply to any information they are made privy to. We have to assume that the number of people who really knew what was happening was small enough to ensure that nobody spilled the beans and that they all had a very good reason for conspiring.

4. You are trying to build a case which will become the basis for a prosecution. Therefore, you can expect all your witnesses to be cross-examined and all your expert testimony to be challenged by other experts. The case that you build will have to convince a jury in the face of the best defence lawyers that money can buy. I don't want to get too far into imagining an actual trial here, but imagine that you would have to use this investigation to produce a report to a prosecutor that would convince them it was worth going to trial.

So, what witnesses do you call? What questions would you ask? What would ask your investigators and experts to look at?

After all that, what do you imagine your case for the prosecution would look like?

I'd be interested in any details you can supply. Please reply in the other thread:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=92411
 
OK, I guess I have mixed in Sibel Edmonds situation with the other alleged whistleblowers. Correction: Sibel Edmonds has a gag-order so hopefully we won't need to argue about that. The others would only be subject to reprisals at their place of employment.

If I had evidence pointing to the most massive government crime in all of American history, I'd certainly risk my job to tell it.

In fact, I'd probably quit my job. That way, I'd have more time to go on Oprah and promote my new best-selling book.

You think that a job would keep people from talking? When history is full of people who gave their freedom, and even their lives?

What kind of coward are you?

Regardless of how courts have ruled, the claim is not false. The statute compels U.S. citizens to report violent felonies, regardless how that statute may be interpreted by any given jurisdiction. Of course jurisdictions have ruled against it, but jurisdictions have also ruled in favor of it.

But, again, regardless of case law, there is a federal statute which exists (U.S.C. Title 18, Part I, Chapter 1, Sec. 4),that legally obligates a U.S. citizen to disclose knowledge of a violent felony. You're speaking as if it is absolute that the court will rule in favor of the defendant every time. That is not true. A judge may also rule against the defendant based on the statute.

Compulsive legislation does exist. I guess you'd have to take a year or two of law school to understand the nuance. One jurisdiction ruling against the statute does not mean the statute disappears. Clearly, and even according to your own Wiki link, the statute is still "on the books" and still applies.

I think I agree with you, but want to be sure I understand this. Is this like saying, just because the judge let you off for going 65 in a 40 mph zone, doesn't mean that everybody everywhere can ignore the speed limit?

That's the impression I'm getting. Is this a coorect analogy?
 
I'm going to ask you one question and it should be the ONLY question asked of you by anyone here. Gregory, if the whistleblowers can't go public with the information, why do you claim to know what it is? I mean this is about as stupid as claiming the Masons are a secret group that everyone knows exists.
 
I think I agree with you, but want to be sure I understand this. Is this like saying, just because the judge let you off for going 65 in a 40 mph zone, doesn't mean that everybody everywhere can ignore the speed limit?

That's the impression I'm getting. Is this a coorect analogy?


Yes, Nob, that is a pretty good analogy. Most legislation is written intentionally vague with room for interpretation by relevant bodies of law...for a very good reason. To continue your "speed limit" analogy:

Pretend that legislation was absolute, with no room for interpretation by a judge. And pretend your jurisdiction just legislated a 50 mph speed zone on a particular road with punishment being a fine of $1000. Let's also pretend you were stopped for traveling 65 mph on that road and fined accordingly (a fine which you are unable to pay within the legal time-frame, thus risking further legal action). You go to court and argue that you were speeding to the hospital because your friend was experiencing extreme difficulty breathing and agonzing chest pains. The judge dismisses your argument because the statute is absolute; if you speed, regardless of the circumstances, you must, under the rule of law, be punished accordingly.

This is an extreme analogy, of course, but I think it demonstrates well the tragedy of absolute legislation. This is why most legislation is written vaguely with often times much room for interpretation.

Given the interpretive nature of legislation, it's not surprising that many laws are interpreted differently in different jurisdictions. But, if one piece of legislation, as in bofor's cited Cash case, is overruled in a particular jurisdiction, that decision does not invalidate that legislation for all jurisdictions. Thusly, the federal Misprision of Felony statute remains valid for all other jurisdictions that wish to recognize it. Consequently, Misprision of Felony does require reporting knowledge of a violent felony and compels all citizens under its jurisdiction to do same.

Mind you, I am not a lawyer. I did get a bachelor's degree in Paralegal Studies and did attend 1+ years of law school, but, as any legal scholar can tell you, my legal education is very cursory. I say this because my interpretation of the Misprision of Felony legislation and the operation of the legal system overall may be mistaken also, or alternately interpreted.
 
Last edited:
I just came upon this story about Sibel Edmonds.

Treason in the State Department

It mentions nothing about 9/11 though.
No, I'm not aware of a connection to her and any foreknowledge or cover-up of the 9/11 attacks. I hope this story is investigated as if true, though. The Bush administration just moved to make sales of nuclear technology to Turkey legal (the Clinton admin. had done the same, but that was blocked by Congress). The timing is certainly interesting.
 
In the first section (NORAD) of the film In Their Own Words, Patty Casazza makes the following specific claims:

This is false. According to FAA protocol on 9/11 an aircraft was not to be considered hijacked unless Air Traffic Controllers received and confirmed a Mode 3/A 7500 transponder code. None of the aircraft hijacked on 9/11 gave a 7500 code.

Further, the FAA did not even suspect AA11 was a hijacked until 10 minutes after it was hijacked, and 22 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect UA175 was a hijack until 14 minutes after it was hijacked and 8 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect AA77 was a hijack until 27 minutes after it was hijacked and 16 minutes before it crashed. The FAA did not even suspect UA93 was a hijack until 4 minutes after it was hijacked and 33 minutes before it crashed.

This, again, is false. No official communication between the FAA and military was established during the attack. While the NMCC established a tele conference after the Pentagon was attacked, both they and the White House had great difficulty including the FAA who kept dropping off it.

Prior to 0903 no one thought that there was any serious threat underway requiring the coordination of multiple government agencies.

Again, false. No one was aware that suicide hijackings were under way until 0903 at the very earliest. Neither an airliner crashing nor an airliner being hijacked are national security matters.

No one was aware that terrorist attacks were under way until 0903.

This needs breaking up:

The video itself contradicts this claim. Immediately prior to her claim it shows a video of Cheney in which he explains that he at the time the USSS evacuated him he was getting updates on the TV and beginning to work out what should be done about the attacks. He is clearly saying he was not only aware of the attacks but was working to address them. His statement regarding 09:30 is that this is when he was notified of the direct threat to him (i.e. the White House). This is entirely consistent with what happened on 9/11. Cheney also claims in the same clip that was shown prior to her claim, that all the USSS said to him was "we have to leave now".

There is one photographer account that Cheney was evacuated sooner. The claim is not supported by evidence, and is refuted by others.

At 0900 no one knew there was an attack underway. Richard Clark's accounts are incredibly shakey and many of his timelines conflict with other people.

Yes that's right, upon learning that some sort of aircraft (size unknown) has (presumably) accidentally flown into the WTC, Cheney should have immediately ordered the military to evacuate Washington DC. Apparently.

One of the Pentagon's primary evacuation gathering points is on the open grass field beside the helicopter pad. Had they evacuated the Pentagon prior to impact thousands of people would have been directly in the aircraft's path with nothing between them and the resultant fireball, blast, and debris. Hundreds and hundreds more people would have been killed.

Both claim to have known about the first impact in short order. According to various accounts Rumsfeld was in a meeting in the morning, and they were informed about the first impact between 08:50 and 09:00 at which point the meeting as adjourned and Rumsfeld went to a CIA briefing, during which he was informed about the second impact. He directed his staff to begin setting things up to manage the crisis while he went to his intelligence briefing.

Myers was apparantly in the first meeting with Rumsfeld and learned of the first impact then. He then went to a meeting at Capitol Hill and learned of the second impact when that meeting ended, shortly before the Pentagon was hit.

Neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense has the responsibility of protecting the President or Vice President, neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense had reason to suspect the President or Vice President needed protecting, and neither the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff nor the Secretary of Defense was capable of providing protection to the President or Vice President.

Rumsfeld's own accounts directly contradict this claim. And he did not "apparently" head outside the Pentagon to help victims - it's a categorical fact - there's ample news footage of him actually doing it.

Which is precisely what the 9/11 Commission did. In their report they provided a thorough account of Richard Clark's teleconference, based on the evidence they had. It started at 09:25, the FAA and CIA did not join until 09:40. Even Clark himself does not claim it started at 08:46 - he claims it started at 09:10.

Clark's account of who was present in the teleconference at 09:10 is conflicted by cross-collaborating accounts from others such as Myers, Senators, Rumsfeld, all their staff, and so forth. So either Clark is right, and dozens of other people both lied and faked evidence (including, presumably, the news networks that showed the evacuation of the White House at about 09:30), or Clark got his times wrong.

So there we have an idea of Patty Casazza's reliability. She has no credibility whatsoever. Personally I'm not going to take her word for it that there are FBI agents who knew the precise date, targets and methods of the 9/11 attacks in advance - especially given that the FBI agents specifically tasked with tracking Al Qaeda deny this allegation (and they, unlike Casazza's whistleblowers, are willing to talk about it on the record).
So when are you guys invading so you can take over NORAD as your nations new colonial NORAD boss! The colony of North America!

It would be cool if this was a debate as you blast Greg, and we see the caught in the headlight look fade to the look of "ignorance on 9/11".

Looks good
 
That's a link to a couple of news articles. It is not a link to a "gag order".

How about providing a link to a court order that supports the contention that she is forbidden from speaking to the media about allegations of wrongdoing in connection with the attacks of 9/11?

How about providing a link to a court order that precludes her from publicly accusing people of complicity in those attacks?

The referenced "State's Secret Gag orders" are actually the invocation of the State's Secret Privilege and only to prevent giving sensitive testimony during legal proceedings in open court.

I've seen nothing to suggest that the use of the State Secret Privilege in a court case also restrains a person's First Amendment rights, outside of the court room.

What's more, gag order or not, if Sibel Edmonds (or anyone) had reliable info that directly implicated the current Administration in the execution or cover-up of the 9/11 attacks then there is no way the same Administration would then get away with prosecuting her for revealing this fact.

Arthur
 
What's more, gag order or not, if Sibel Edmonds (or anyone) had reliable info that directly implicated the current Administration in the execution or cover-up of the 9/11 attacks then there is no way the same Administration would then get away with prosecuting her for revealing this fact.

This no-brainer appears lost on some folks however.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom