Government knew date, targets and method for 9/11 attacks

Dude, you're arguing that you didn't eat the chocolate cake...with chocolate cake all over your face and fingers. Admit you are wrong...that there is a federal statute compelling disclosure of knowledge of violent felonies, regardless of an individual judge's decision and move on.

The decision rendered in United States v. Johnson, 546 F.2d 1225, 1227 (5th Cir. 1977) was done by at least a three judge panel, not an individual. Furthermore, the case carries precedent, it is cited in decisions by appellate courts in other jurisdictions like this one: http://www.ca11.uscourts.gov/opinions/ops/200113624.opn.pdf

Moreover, the US Supreme Court said misprision of a felony "require both knowledge of a crime and some affirmative act of concealment or participation.” Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665, 696 n.36 (1972)

You did not claim this:

"There is a federal statute compelling disclosure of knowledge of violent felonies".

You claimed this:

"U.S. citizens, regardless of standing, are legally obligated to report knowledge of violent felonies. Not doing so is a felony itself."


Your claim is false. US Courts have ruled that it is false in terms of Federal law and the Cash case proves it is false with respect to State law.
 
Anyway, bofors, the whole "it's a crime not to report a crime" thing was an aside and not necessarily relevant to the thread. In response to GregoryUrich's claim that FBI employees are bound by law not to talk (a point later conceded), I insisted he was mistaken and it actually was quite the opposite...as we have seen. I don't know how it turned into a raging brushfire, but the idea is really only germaine to that one post.
 
You did not claim this:

"There is a federal statute compelling disclosure of knowledge of violent felonies".

You claimed this:

"U.S. citizens, regardless of standing, are legally obligated to report knowledge of violent felonies. Not doing so is a felony itself."

Your claim is false. US Courts have ruled that it is false in terms of Federal law and the Cash case proves it is false with respect to State law.



Regardless of how courts have ruled, the claim is not false. The statute compels U.S. citizens to report violent felonies, regardless how that statute may be interpreted by any given jurisdiction. Of course jurisdictions have ruled against it, but jurisdictions have also ruled in favor of it.

But, again, regardless of case law, there is a federal statute which exists (U.S.C. Title 18, Part I, Chapter 1, Sec. 4),that legally obligates a U.S. citizen to disclose knowledge of a violent felony. You're speaking as if it is absolute that the court will rule in favor of the defendant every time. That is not true. A judge may also rule against the defendant based on the statute.

Compulsive legislation does exist. I guess you'd have to take a year or two of law school to understand the nuance. One jurisdiction ruling against the statute does not mean the statute disappears. Clearly, and even according to your own Wiki link, the statute is still "on the books" and still applies.
 
Last edited:
I hear you guys saying time and again, "where are all the whistleblowers?," OP shows you a few and predictably you say naaah.
Also id like to point out the Patriots had far from a "perfect season,"
how soon you forget they were caught cheating a few weeks into the
season.:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I don't recall "where are all the whistleblowers?". Please provide references.

Christ on a bicycle. Do Truthers even try?

ETA: and with regard to the Patriots (may their late grandmothers sneeze in their pantyhose) ... They won, didn't they? So far quite perfect, as much as I hate to admit it. No one says they are nice. They just win.
 
Last edited:
I hear you guys saying time and again, "where are all the whistleblowers?," OP shows you a few and predictably you say naaah.


I have not said "naaah". However, I do say "I see no whistleblowers. I've heard reports of whistleblowers but I've seen absolutely no evidence of them.", and I ask "where are these whistleblowers?" and "how long have they known what the OP claims they know and why did they keep it secret for so long, considering the importance to the victims' families and the country?".

If I'm correct, you are implying that all of us here would readily dismiss any whistleblowers because it is contrary to our position. I think I can speak for many here when I say, "Nonsense." If there are actual whistleblowers (still waiting) and what they say is true and can be verified empirically, then I'll be the first and last to admit I was mistaken (although my position was logically sound at the time), apologize, and, unlike almost ALL of the truthers, I wouldn't let such knowledge go to waste on radio shows and message boards.




Also id like to point out the Patriots had far from a "perfect season,"
how soon you forget they were caught cheating a few weeks into the
season.:rolleyes:

I'd buy this argument had they not got caught in week one and then went on to utterly destoy every other team, including the team they got caught against, from week 2 to week 17 and beyond. They got caught in week one, do you really think they were cheating after week one?
 
Last edited:
Spygate doesn't cast much doubt about the Patriots accomplishments this season because they did get caught so early in the season, but what's disturbing is that they'd done it before this season too. They were reprimanded by the league three or four times last season for doing it. The Green Bay Packers and Detroit Lions were two teams that we know they did it to because those teams reported them to the league. The Lions even had their radio communications mucked up during the game at Gillette. But it only became public this year because Mangini went to the press directly about it, probably knowing that contacting the league would result in nothing happening as per usual. In the past, a league official would reprimand them on-site and then that was that. What Spygate does do is call into question the validity of certain victories in past seasons. Peronsally, my biggest problem with the way the Pats handled Spygate was that they didn't have the decency to just admit that they did something they knew to be illegal and apologize. Instead they pretended it was some meaningless mistake and then spent their whole season trying to get revenge on everyone because they did something wrong and got caught.
 
Also id like to point out the Patriots had far from a "perfect season,"
how soon you forget they were caught cheating a few weeks into the
season.:rolleyes:

That's the only rational thing i've seen from you on this board. DOWN WITH THE PATRIOTS!
 
Oh and they got caught the first game of the season. But how long they've been doing it is the part i'd like to know.
 
No decent person would be stopped by the threat of jail.

End of story.

Agreed. If I had facts or evidence implicating people in the deaths of 3000 people, but for some reason thought that there was a risk of being jailed as a result of providing my facts and evidence to law enforcement, I would take appropriate steps to retain a lawyer, set out my facts and evidence in an excruciatingly detailed affidavit, and have my lawyer accompany me to the appropriate law enforcement agency to provide that evidence. I would also instruct my lawyer that in the event that I am incarcerated as a result of providing those facts and evidence to the authorities, copies of my affidavit are to be released to the world wide media along with the information that I have been incarcerated for providing same. Further, I would have also left several copies of my affidavit with trusted family members and friends for distribution to other law enforcement agencies and world wide media, in the unlikely event that my lawyer was in on the plot, too, and failed to do so.

But, bottom line is that if I honestly believed that I had valuable information implicating persons complicit in the murder of thousands, there is no way that I would refrain from ensuring that the information found its way into the hands of those who could do something about it, just to spare myself the discomfort of a jail cell for a while.

However, I digress. Edmonds has no evidence of any such thing. It appears that, at best, she's got some dirt on a co-worker that perhaps should have been investigated further than it was by her employer of 6 months. I'm not defending the FBI but it is not at all surprising that allegations of nefarious and serious wrongdoing made by a newbie employee against co-workers are often not taken as seriously as they might otherwise be. That doesn't make it right, of course, but it puts into perspective why she was viewed by her employer as disruptive and not credible.



Unfortunately, people are usually very practical when it comes to their own self interests. I find that to be much more likely than Patty Casazza making all this up.

With regard to the bolded portion above [my bolding]: Why?

Is it, as it appears, just credulity on your part or is there something more than that that leads you that conclusion?

And, as an aside, GregoryUrich, why do you call these anonymous people "whistleblowers" when they have, by all accounts, not blown any whistles?

And why do you call an alleged conversation at the side of a road with anonymous individuals "testimony"?


The history of the world is FULL of people risking imprisonment, or their very lives, to support a cause they felt was right. Are you telling us that instead of either doing it themselves or at least contacting somebody who is willing to take the risks for them with all their evidence, they are just giving bits and pieces of it out on the internet?

Somewhere there is a journalist who longs for the Pulitzer Prize who would love to get his hands on solid evidence of an inside job. Somewhere there is a member of a foreign government who would love to strike a blow against the US government with solid evidence of an inside job.

This silence really makes me wonder. It should make you wonder too.

Indeed.

So many twoofers make unsupported accusations but they never manage to actually do anything about their accusations. Just look at all of the twoofers who - without manufacturing a perceived threat of jail or citing even minor inconvenience, for that matter - proclaim that certain people were criminally negligent or complicit in the attacks, but lack the fortitude to do a damned thing about their unsupported accusations except blather about them on the Internet.

I hear you guys saying time and again, "where are all the whistleblowers?," OP shows you a few and predictably you say naaah.


The OP hasn't established the existence of any "whistleblowers" at all. See above.
 

That's a link to a couple of news articles. It is not a link to a "gag order".

How about providing a link to a court order that supports the contention that she is forbidden from speaking to the media about allegations of wrongdoing in connection with the attacks of 9/11?

How about providing a link to a court order that precludes her from publicly accusing people of complicity in those attacks?
 
And how many other teams didn't get caught is another part I'd like to know.

Bott line is the Patriots are THE standard for the word classless. Mike Vrabel intentionally trying to trip Phil Rivers in the title game comes to mind. Should've been a penalty nullifying an interception.

Tom Brady being a TERRIBLE role model by leaving his babys moma and well, the baby.

Randy Moss smacking women up and should have an asterisk next to his record.

The list goes on and on.....

This will soon be out of this thread tho.
 
How Dick Cheney talked them into taking the fall for it is the part I'd like to know.

All I want to know is... In the Ravens game on NE's final drive... How in the hell is the ref gonna call pass interference on that CB when Randy Moss basically tackled him!??!? I mean Welker (IIRC) already had the first down! Why add insult to injury!??! Matter of fact, the ref didn't even call out the dude's number!!! He just said "Pass interference on the dude Randy Moss just tackled." It was wrong!!1 WRONG I TELLS YA!!!!
 
The whistleblowers work for the FBI. They can be prosecuted for "talking" unless they are subpoenaed. Have you heard of Sibel Edmonds and her "gag-order"?


I'm impressed that anyone in the FBI knew the exact date, method, etc of the attacks in advance considering that John O'Neill's counter terrorism unit, which was specifically tasked with tracking Al Qaeda, didn't know it was coming.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom