I don't mean to interrupt such a charming interrogation, but...
Are gold bugs really worse than stock pickers in general? If you believe the
efficient market hypothesis, then any form of speculation is just a gamble. In other words, gold bugs are nutty, but isn't Jim Kramer just as crazy?
Sorry, I don't believe in that silly theory. It's trivial to find counterexamples. But, that does not bear (too much) in this. The EMH certainly does not say that
everything will acquire value at the same rate. My Honda is depreciating, my gold (if I had any) more or less follows inflation, my stocks appreciate satisfactory (in the sense that Ben Graham uses the term).
The argument against using gold as an
investment (as opposed to preservation of capital), is that when you buy stocks, you are buying a part of a business that is out there producing things. They are
creating wealth (I think a lot of gold bugs might disagree with the concept of creating wealth, but I digress - that is econ 101). Hence, it makes sense to invest in them, in exactly the same way it makes sense to start your own business - you do work to create value for your customers, some of which they then share with you. If you feel the market is efficient, buying an index fund in a broad index will still give you wealth creation, and is a sound
investment.
Gold, on the other hand, just sits there. It's price will rise and fall, certainly, but there is no wealth creation. In the
long term, it just floats along with inflation, tipppit's short term performance non-withstanding. There's no reason for it to acquire value above and beyond that, and it doesn't. If you believe you can predict macro economic events, then it may make sense to buy gold, but I've never seen evidence, or a theoretical framework, for doing so. There is no reason for it to match or exceed the Dow.
As with any argument, this one comes with premises. The premises here are: efficient market theory is nonsense (
some stocks are efficiently priced, I grant, but some are not), value can be identified in stocks (in some cases, not any stock at any time), companies create wealth, gold does not. I'd be happy to discuss (not debate - too tedious, I'm here for fun) the first 2 in a different thread. The latter 2 are covered in any econ 101 text, and in this thread.