Gold

I got out of tech in Feb of 2000, and started investing in a diversified precious metals portfolio soon after. My average basis in physical gold is $270/oz, and I owned Bema before it was acquired by KGC. I have similar low bases in Harmony, Newmont, et al. I'm in silver at about $4/oz, and platinum at $550. Once the manipulation in the spot gold market is overwith, I will have exorbitant gains in both physical, ETF, mining shares, and depository certificates. I've beaten the DJIA by some 1400% annualized over the past seven years. Is that good enough?

Liar
 
bull.

1700% annualized would turn $10 into $6,122,200,30 in seven years. I haven't seen your name in the fortune 500.
 
Tippit is either lying or cannot do simple math. You decide.

Anybody expecting Dash to return? Back last winter that guy was peddling some of the most bizarre economic woo involving precious metals I have seen.
 
Sloppy, can't believe you sold out before 10 March, and didn't go limit-short that day. You will never make it big in lying investing.

Why bother. He's already, by his own announcement, a multi-trillionaire. Why does he need more money when he already owns more than the Forbes 400 put together?
 
bull.

1700% annualized would turn $10 into $6,122,200,30 in seven years. I haven't seen your name in the fortune 500.

I meant to say 1400% per annum, not annualized. I have generated returns in excess of 14 times what the Dow has returned each year, for the past 7 years.
 
Per annum vice annualized. Oh dear me. Same thing in this context.

Some years the Dow was negative. you made 14x a negative return? That would be total loss of capital, given 2002's return was -16.76%.

Now, if you are claiming that you made 14x the total return on the dow in the last 7 years I'd believe you, given that the dow opened at 10786 in 2001, and is now at 10825, for a 0.36% total return. 14x makes that 5% total over 7 years. Is that what you are bragging about?

I doubt it. So what are you saying? Please use commonly used finance terms, or just tell us your return, total or annualized.

No matter how you slice it, comparing your performance against the recent DJIA is pretty pointless, given it has been flat.
 
Lol. You guys are pathetic.

You're right.

It is pathetic that we take your statements seriously enough to point out that they're obviously lies.

So what's your spin now? Roger just did a pretty thorough hatchet job on all the ways he could think of to interpret your original statement, and they all make you look like either a liar, a fool, or a clueless poseur.

Not that I think that those are mutually exclusive in your case.
 
I don't mean to interrupt such a charming interrogation, but...

Are gold bugs really worse than stock pickers in general? If you believe the efficient market hypothesis, then any form of speculation is just a gamble. In other words, gold bugs are nutty, but isn't Jim Kramer just as crazy?

On the apocalypse issue - why prepare with economic considerations? Basic disaster preparedness makes sense, but it there's a reason people look at bunker builders as crazy.
 
Last edited:
Now, if you are claiming that you made 14x the total return on the dow in the last 7 years I'd believe you, given that the dow opened at 10786 in 2001, and is now at 10825, for a 0.36% total return. 14x makes that 5% total over 7 years. Is that what you are bragging about?

The 14x figure was from a while ago, it's even more now as the Dow has since retreated.

My annualized rate of return on spot gold is 15%, for a cumulative return of 229% over about 8.7 years.

Meanwhile the Dow over roughly the same period of time (week ending Feb 14, 2000 to date) has returned a whopping .7% annualized - it's moved up about 600 points in nearly nine years.

My annualized return in spot gold has beaten the annualized Dow return by 20.43 times, or 2043%.

I doubt it. So what are you saying? Please use commonly used finance terms, or just tell us your return, total or annualized.

See above. Also note that this is simply the spot price of gold I'm talking about. My total return is higher because I have a diversified portfolio including ETFs, mining shares, and other metals. For example, my average cost basis in KGC is only $2.67 a share, a 550% gain. That's destroyed the Dow too.

No matter how you slice it, comparing your performance against the recent DJIA is pretty pointless, given it has been flat.

In fact, it's not pointless. Why not compare it to the Dow, when the idea is to beat the market with less risk? You can pick a broader based index if you want, the difference is going to be similar. The point is, investing in an inert metal over the past 8.7 years has smoked an index of 30 industrial stocks.
 
Last edited:
I own gold. But the actual taels, not a certificate. I pick it up from time to time, when prices are lower and I have spare change.

I don't consider it an investment I consider it a safety net.

I have been to more than a few places at more than a few times where things were getting close to barter system...never actually got that bad, but have been in places where US was accepted but local notes were trash.

I look at what gold I have the same way I look at the small stack of US notes I have in the safe. Its anti investment really...part of an emergency cash cushion as it were.
 
Bought some at $250 Aus. a while ago, love the stuff. Think it may go to $4000 yet. But what happens when the world de-populates. Silver now has two prices, one for paper and a higher price for the real stuff. Shortage of silver, pay the money and wait, the mint in West Australia can't supply enough.
 
Are gold bugs really worse than stock pickers in general? If you believe the efficient market hypothesis, then any form of speculation is just a gamble. In other words, gold bugs are nutty, but isn't Jim Kramer just as crazy?

Yes, Jim Cramer is crazy. I would not listen to any investment advice from him.

However, what seperates him from the common gold bug is that at least he is crazy within the confines of a sane, real world. Gold bugs invent some crazy, fantasy world, and they are crazy even there.

While I wouldn't take investment advice from him, as far as I know, he doesn't spin loony conspiracy theories about the Federal Reserve printing counterfeit money.
 
I don't mean to interrupt such a charming interrogation, but...

Are gold bugs really worse than stock pickers in general? If you believe the efficient market hypothesis, then any form of speculation is just a gamble. In other words, gold bugs are nutty, but isn't Jim Kramer just as crazy?
Sorry, I don't believe in that silly theory. It's trivial to find counterexamples. But, that does not bear (too much) in this. The EMH certainly does not say that everything will acquire value at the same rate. My Honda is depreciating, my gold (if I had any) more or less follows inflation, my stocks appreciate satisfactory (in the sense that Ben Graham uses the term).

The argument against using gold as an investment (as opposed to preservation of capital), is that when you buy stocks, you are buying a part of a business that is out there producing things. They are creating wealth (I think a lot of gold bugs might disagree with the concept of creating wealth, but I digress - that is econ 101). Hence, it makes sense to invest in them, in exactly the same way it makes sense to start your own business - you do work to create value for your customers, some of which they then share with you. If you feel the market is efficient, buying an index fund in a broad index will still give you wealth creation, and is a sound investment.

Gold, on the other hand, just sits there. It's price will rise and fall, certainly, but there is no wealth creation. In the long term, it just floats along with inflation, tipppit's short term performance non-withstanding. There's no reason for it to acquire value above and beyond that, and it doesn't. If you believe you can predict macro economic events, then it may make sense to buy gold, but I've never seen evidence, or a theoretical framework, for doing so. There is no reason for it to match or exceed the Dow.

As with any argument, this one comes with premises. The premises here are: efficient market theory is nonsense (some stocks are efficiently priced, I grant, but some are not), value can be identified in stocks (in some cases, not any stock at any time), companies create wealth, gold does not. I'd be happy to discuss (not debate - too tedious, I'm here for fun) the first 2 in a different thread. The latter 2 are covered in any econ 101 text, and in this thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom